
complete and revise a trompe l’oeil colored-pencil painting, defend a position on the value of illusion, and review my sustained investigation at its first checkpoint.
Instruction
This task completes the unit and marks the first checkpoint of your sustained investigation.
What you submit for the unit. The finished trompe l’oeil painting; your reference photograph and gridded transfer; a revision note; and a 250-350-word position statement on whether illusion is enough to make a painting good, which answers the strongest opposing view you met in Lesson 1.3 and refers to at least one historical work and to your own.
The two-distance self-critique. Put the work away for a day, then look at it in two passes with the critique sheet in the brief. A family member or another adult may look too; write down what they say. From six feet: does the illusion hold? Which object looks most real and which looks painted on, and why (shadow, value, edge)? From arm’s length: which surface details convince and which break the spell? You then revise. Typical revisions: darkening and sharpening the cast shadow nearest each object’s edge; pushing the value range at the brightest highlight; adding one or two small specific details (a nail head, a torn fiber); and unifying the backing so objects sit on it.
Investigation checkpoint 1. Bring two works or substantial studies from your sustained investigation (your trompe l’oeil may count as one if you designed it to address your question) and your investigation log. Hold a written self-conference: answer in writing, What is your question now? What did these works teach you? What will the next work test? The next day, reread your answers as a reviewer would and revise your plan in writing. It is normal, and good, for the question to sharpen or shift at this stage.
Defending the work. Record a short artist talk (about three minutes) presenting the painting and your position. Standard VA:Cr3A.III asks you to refine work considering both traditional criteria and your personal vision. Say which traditional trompe l’oeil strategy you used most, and where your own vision departed from it.
Presenting the work. Trompe l’oeil depends on how it is shown. Display the finished painting unframed or in a simple frame at eye level, lit from the same side as the light in your reference photograph, so that real and painted shadows agree. If the light comes from the wrong side, the illusion weakens at once.
Scoring. The rubric scores the unit work; the investigation checkpoint is scored separately in the investigation log.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
After a day away, you look from six feet and your pinned photograph looks “pasted on.” What revision is most likely to fix it?
Write the question your sustained investigation is asking now, and explain how it has changed since your midyear proposal.
How confident are you that you can complete and revise a trompe l’oeil painting and review my investigation at its first checkpoint?
Unit 1 checkpoint
Do this before you start the task. It covers the whole unit and tells you what to review first.
In Pliny’s story, why did Zeuxis concede to Parrhasius?
Photorealism, like trompe l’oeil, usually tries to make you mistake the painting for the real object.
The strongest single cue that an object stands in front of a surface is a crisp shadow.
Which museum holds Peto’s Books on a Table?
Why should early colored-pencil layers be at pressure 1-2?
Black pressed hard is the best way to make deep, living darks in colored pencil.
What did Alfred Frankenstein’s 1953 research reveal?
An image or object that reminds viewers of mortality is called a memento .
A print is 5 x 7 inches with a 1-inch grid and the drawing will be 15 x 21 inches. What grid goes on the paper?
With a lamp 40 degrees off the board’s normal (factor 0.84), how far does the shadow shift for an object 1/2 inch off the board?
You should photograph your arrangement straight on, with the camera parallel to the board, to avoid perspective distortion.
Submit: Trompe l’oeil colored-pencil painting, position statement and investigation checkpoint 1
Task: Complete a life-size trompe l’oeil colored-pencil painting from your own photograph of a shallow arrangement, revise it after a two-distance self-critique, defend a position on the value of illusion, and review two investigation works in a written self-conference.
Submission workflow
- Stage 1 — Plan. Arrangement, lit reference photograph, scale calculation and gridded transfer, checked against the arrangement specification in the technique sheet.
- Stage 2 — Critiqued work in progress. Painting at two-thirds complete, self-critiqued after a day away from six feet and from arm’s length (an adult viewer optional); feedback recorded.
- Stage 3 — Revised final. Finished painting with revision note, the 250-350-word position statement, and two investigation works with the log.
- Stage 4 — Defense. A recorded artist talk on the painting and position, and the written investigation self-conference.
How it is scored
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Illusion and design (VA:Cr1B.III) | Shallow space, life-size scale and convincing cast shadows make objects appear to sit on or before the surface. |
| Colored-pencil technique (VA:Cr2A.II) | Layered color, controlled pressure, full value range and purposeful burnishing; clean surface. |
| Revision (VA:Cr3A.III) | Specific changes after the two-distance self-critique, explained against traditional criteria and personal vision. |
| Originality (VA:Cr2A.III) | The arrangement is the student’s own and carries meaning; any broken convention is deliberate and explained. |
| Position statement (VA:Re9A.III) | A clear position supported by a historical work and the student’s own; answers an opposing view. |
Portfolio Task 5 Brief: Criteria, an Exemplar Position Statement, Revision Note and Critique Sheets
SLS original assignment brief and constructed exemplars; works cited checked against Cleveland Museum of Art and Art Institute of Chicago open-access records, retrieved Sept. 26, 2026 · SLS original
Why this reading. The task names five things to submit but the rubric alone does not show what a strong entry looks like. This is the full brief: the assignment, four-level criteria, a complete exemplar position statement with commentary, a revision-note exemplar, the two-distance self-critique sheet and the investigation self-conference sheet. Everything here is an SLS original. The exemplar was written for this course; it is not by a real student, artist or museum. The works it cites are real and are checked in the reading “Five Trompe l’Oeil Paintings and Pliny’s Story” (Cleveland Museum of Art 1965.235; Art Institute of Chicago 1956.125).
The assignment
Submit (1) a colored-pencil trompe l’oeil painting, life size, from your own photograph of a shallow arrangement; (2) the reference photograph, scale calculation and gridded transfer; (3) a revision note; (4) a 250–350-word position statement on whether illusion is enough to make a painting good, referring to at least one historical work and to your own and answering the strongest opposing view met in Lesson 1.3; (5) two works or studies from your sustained investigation with your log and a revised plan. Materials, grid arithmetic and the six-period plan are in the technique sheet for Lesson 1.4.
Criteria, four levels
| Criterion | 4 Exceeds | 3 Meets | 2 Approaching | 1 Beginning |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Illusion and design | From six feet every object appears to sit in front of or on the surface; shadows agree in direction and vary from thin at contact to wider where objects lift | Most objects convince from six feet; one or two shadows are weak or too soft | Shadows are present but pale; objects look pasted on from a distance | No consistent light direction; scale not life size |
| Colored-pencil technique | Layered color with the tooth still visible before burnish; five or more values; burnishing used only on glossy areas | Layered, mostly smooth, four values; burnish mostly appropriate | Waxy heavy first layers, white paper specks, three values | One heavy layer; flat; no value range |
| Revision | At least two specific changes made after the critique, each tied to a comment and to a criterion, with a before/after note | Two changes made and explained | One change or changes unexplained | No visible revision |
| Originality and meaning | The arrangement is the student’s own and says something; any broken convention is deliberate and explained in one sentence | Own arrangement with a theme sentence | Arrangement mostly generic | Copied from another image or includes currency or documents |
| Position statement | Clear position; names criteria; uses a historical work with museum and accession number and the student’s own; answers the strongest opposing point | Clear position; one historical work and own work; answers an opposing view | Position stated but evidence vague | No position or no work cited |
Exemplar position statement (SLS original, about 315 words; constructed, not a real student)
“Illusion is not enough to make a painting good, but it is a fair test of skill. When Pliny tells the story of Zeuxis, the painter is proud that birds pecked his grapes and then admits he painted the grapes better than the child holding them, because a truly convincing child would have frightened the birds. I take that as an early answer to my question: deceiving one kind of viewer proves one kind of skill.
William Harnett’s Memento Mori, ‘To This Favour’ (1879, Cleveland Museum of Art, 1965.235) shows what illusion can do when it serves a meaning. The skull, the empty hourglass and the extinguished candle are painted so precisely that they feel present, and that precision is what makes the Hamlet quotation on the tattered book cover at the front hit hard: everyone comes to this. The museum points out that the word ‘paint’ in that line also jokes about the painting itself. On the other side, John Peto’s Lights of Other Days (1906, Art Institute of Chicago, 1956.125) softens its edges on purpose and loses some of the trick, yet it feels more like memory. The strongest argument against me is the one Pliny’s story itself makes: Parrhasius fooled another artist, which is a higher bar than any moral, so a painting that fools an expert does not need a message. I answer that being fooled lasts a second, and the paintings I go back to are the ones that reward looking after I know the trick.
My own painting is a corkboard with a bus pass, a key on a string and a note in my grandmother’s handwriting. The cast shadow of the curling note does most of the work from six feet. Up close, the pencil grain in the cork is the detail that convinces. The illusion gets you to the board; the note, which I chose to leave half legible, is why you stay.”
Why this is strong. It states a position in the first sentence; it uses Pliny, a named museum work with accession number, and a contrasting work; it names the criterion it is applying (what the illusion serves); it states and answers an opposing view; it ends on the student’s own painting with two observable features (the note’s shadow; the cork grain). Weaker versions say “illusion is good because it is realistic” and never leave the general.
Exemplar revision note (SLS original)
“After a day away, from six feet, the bus pass looked pasted on, and my aunt saw the same thing. Cause: its shadow was as light as the cork behind it. Change: I layered blue-violet and burnt umber along the pass’s lower and right edges, darkest where it touches the board (about 1/16 in. wide) and 1/8 in. wide at the far corner where it lifts, then I sharpened the shadow’s outer edge. Result: at six feet the pass now sits above the cork. Still to fix: the key’s shadow is the wrong side; the light comes from the upper left.”
Two-distance self-critique sheet (fill in after a day away; an adult viewer may add answers)
- From six feet. Which object looks most real? Why (shadow, value, edge)? Which looks painted on? Why?
- From arm’s length. Which surface detail convinces? Where does the illusion break?
- Do all shadows fall from the same direction? Y / N. Which object is inconsistent?
- One change that would help most. One thing to leave alone.
Investigation checkpoint 1: self-conference sheet
Lay out two works or studies and your log. Answer in writing: (a) My question, in one sentence. (b) What did each work teach me? (c) What will the next work test? (d) What has changed since the midyear proposal? The next day, reread your answers as a reviewer would, then rewrite the plan in three to five sentences.
Sources: Cleveland Museum of Art Open Access, Memento Mori, “To This Favour” (1965.235) (clevelandart.org); Art Institute of Chicago, Lights of Other Days (1956.125) (artic.edu)