
distinguish political, narrative, descriptive and symbolic strategies in art from several cultures, analyze how experiencing an image changes my own understanding of a time or place, and assess how particular artists affected what their societies saw and believed.
Instruction
The record introduces artists “whose work was political, narrative, descriptive, symbolic,” naming Andy Warhol, Keith Haring and Diego Rivera, and asks for an international survey that draws on many cultures, including your own if you choose. The four words are strategies, and many works use more than one. This lesson defines each and studies examples.
Descriptive: bearing witness. Descriptive art records what happened or what is. Honoré Daumier’s lithograph Rue Transnonain, on April 15, 1834 (1834, Art Institute of Chicago) shows the aftermath of a massacre: during unrest in Paris, government troops killed residents of a building on the rue Transnonain. Daumier shows a dead man in his nightclothes on the floor of a bedroom, with other bodies in the shadows. There is no hero and no explanation, only the evidence. The print was published as a lithograph, a medium that could be reproduced for a wide audience, and its plain, close description is its argument.
Political: taking a position. Francisco Goya made the eighty-some etchings of The Disasters of War in the years of war in Spain after Napoleon’s invasion, but they were published only in 1863, long after his death. Plate 30, Ravages of war (1810/11, published 1863), shows civilians among the ruins; plate 79, Truth has died (1815/20, published 1863), turns to allegory. Goya names no side as glorious. The prints argue that war itself is the disaster.
Narrative: telling a story. The Persian epic Shahnama (Book of Kings) was illustrated for rulers who saw themselves in its stories of kingship. The folio “The Feast of Sada” from the Shahnama made for Shah Tahmasp (c. 1525, The Metropolitan Museum of Art) shows an episode about the origins of a festival of fire. Narrative art asks you to read in sequence and to know, or learn, the story.
Symbolic: standing for something. Akan artists in what is now Ghana cast small brass weights, such as this geometric gold weight (18th-19th century, The Metropolitan Museum of Art), to weigh gold dust in trade. Many Akan weights are figurative and are associated with proverbs; geometric ones like this carry patterns rather than figures, and their meanings are harder for outsiders to read. Symbols compress meaning into a form a community can read.
Art for a wide public. José Guadalupe Posada’s broadsides, such as ¡Terrible y verdadera noticia! (1910, Art Institute of Chicago) and The Skeleton of the Buses (c. 1900-10, Cleveland Museum of Art), combined image and text so that news and satire reached workers, many of whom, the Cleveland Museum notes, could not read. In the Cleveland print a streetcar delivers passengers to the figure of Death, a comment on the danger of Mexico City’s new electric trams. Käthe Kollwitz chose printmaking because, in the museum’s words, she saw it as a democratic medium; her Working Woman with Blue Shawl (1903) shows a Berlin worker with a direct gaze that gives her dignity.
The record’s twentieth-century artists, whose work is under copyright and studied by description: Diego Rivera (1886-1957) painted public murals of labor and history in Mexico and the United States, including the Detroit Industry frescoes (1932-33). Andy Warhol (1928-1987) repeated images of consumer products, celebrities and news photographs, such as his 1962 paintings of Campbell’s soup cans, raising questions about mass production and fame. Keith Haring (1958-1990) drew in New York subway stations and painted public murals, including work on the AIDS crisis and drug addiction.
Narrative and political, in Missouri. George Caleb Bingham (1811-1879) painted The Verdict of the People (1854-55, oil on canvas, 46 x 55 in., Saint Louis Art Museum, 45:2001). In the museum’s description, crowds gather around a courthouse to hear voting results: farmers, laborers, merchants, children, politicians, immigrants, veterans, women and enslaved African Americans, with responses that range from elated to dejected. Bingham was a politician himself, and the museum explains that he drew on his own experience in the Missouri legislature for his three-part “Election Series”; the other two paintings, Stump Speaking and The County Election, show campaigning and the casting of votes. The museum also points out what the crowd leaves out: the women on the balcony and the African American man in the left foreground stand for people who had no vote at the time. The painting tells a story in stages, like the Shahnama folio, and it carries an argument about who takes part in public life. It is a work of history, not of today’s politics; study it for how it shows an event, not for any side.
Images and your own understanding. Experiencing an image can change what you think you know. Before looking, write one sentence about what you imagine an election in 1850s Missouri was like. Then look closely at Bingham’s painting for five minutes and write again. Most viewers notice something they did not expect: how crowded and noisy it is, who is celebrating, who is shut out. Name the detail that changed your picture of that time. The same question applies to every work here: what did Daumier’s print teach you about 1834 Paris that a sentence in a textbook would not?
Impact. Standard VA:Cn11A.III asks you to assess an artist’s impact on a society’s beliefs and behaviors. Posada, the Cleveland Museum notes, was admired by many twentieth-century Mexican artists; that influence is one kind of evidence of impact.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Daumier’s Rue Transnonain shows the aftermath of a massacre with no hero or explanation. Which strategy dominates?
Goya’s Disasters of War were published during his lifetime to rally support for the war.
Daumier, Rue Transnonain (1834)
Tap to revealDescriptive witness to a massacre; lithograph for wide circulation.
Goya, Disasters of War
Tap to revealPolitical; war itself as disaster; published 1863.
Shahnama folio (c. 1525)
Tap to revealNarrative; episode from the Persian Book of Kings.
Akan gold weight
Tap to revealSymbolic; brass weight for gold dust; many linked to proverbs.
Posada
Tap to revealImage and text for a wide public, including readers and non-readers.
Kollwitz
Tap to revealPrintmaking as a democratic medium; dignity of working people.
Bingham, The Verdict of the People (1854-55)
Tap to revealNarrative and political; a Missouri election crowd, including people with no vote; Saint Louis Art Museum.
Missouri standard: VA:Re7B.I
Choose one work from this lesson, such as Bingham’s The Verdict of the People. (a) What did you understand about that time or place after looking closely that you did not understand before, and which detail in the image caused the change? (b) Make one claim about the artist’s impact on what a society saw or believed, and give one piece of evidence.
How confident are you that you can distinguish political, narrative, descriptive and symbolic strategies and assess an artist’s impact?
Practice
Work these on paper or in your notebook, then open Check your answer. Aim for all of Fluency and Application; try at least one Challenge.
Printable version: this unit’s practice workbook (PDF)
Fluency
Build speed and accuracy with the core skill.
- Define the four strategies: descriptive, political, narrative and symbolic art.
Check your answer
Answer: Descriptive: records what happened or what exists, often as witness. Political: takes a position on power, conflict or public life. Narrative: tells a story, often read in sequence. Symbolic: forms stand for ideas, values or identities a community can read.Many works use more than one strategy. - Match each work to its main strategy: (a) Daumier, Rue Transnonain; (b) Goya, The Disasters of War; (c) the Shahnama folio “The Feast of Sada”; (d) the Akan geometric gold weight.
Check your answer
Answer: (a) descriptive; (b) political; (c) narrative; (d) symbolic.These are the lesson’s own examples of each strategy. - Define allegory and genre painting, with the lesson’s example of each.
Check your answer
Answer: Allegory: an image in which figures represent abstract ideas, such as Truth or Justice (Goya’s plate 79, Truth has died). Genre painting: a painting of everyday life and ordinary people (Bingham’s scenes of Missouri elections and river life).Glossary terms from the lesson.
Application
Use the skill in context. Show your reasoning.
- Why does the lesson say the plain, close description in Daumier’s Rue Transnonain “is its argument”? How did the medium help?
Check your answer
Answer: By showing only the evidence (a dead man in nightclothes on a bedroom floor, other bodies in shadow) with no hero or explanation, the print lets the facts accuse the government troops. As a lithograph, it could be reproduced for a wide audience.Descriptive art can be persuasive because it bears witness. - Goya made the Disasters of War etchings during the war in Spain after Napoleon’s invasion, but they were published in 1863. Goya died in 1828. How many years after his death were they published, and what does the series argue?
Check your answer
Answer: 35 years after his death. The prints name no side as glorious; they argue that war itself is the disaster.1863 – 1828 = 35. - In Bingham’s The Verdict of the People (1854-55), who in the crowd had no vote, according to the Saint Louis Art Museum, and how does that make the painting both narrative and political?
Check your answer
Answer: The women on the balcony and the African American man in the left foreground stand for people who had no vote. It is narrative because it tells an election story in stages (the Election Series), and political because it carries an argument about who takes part in public life.It is a work of history, studied for how it shows an event, not for any side. - Posada’s broadsides and Kollwitz’s prints were both made for wide audiences. What does each museum say about why the medium suited the audience?
Check your answer
Answer: Posada combined image and text so news and satire reached workers, many of whom, the Cleveland Museum notes, could not read. Kollwitz chose printmaking because she saw it as a democratic medium; her Working Woman with Blue Shawl gives a Berlin worker dignity through her direct gaze.Both chose reproducible media to reach many people.
Challenge
Stretch problems. Expect to think before you write.
- Make one claim about Posada’s impact on what a society saw or believed, as Cn11.HSIII requires, and give two pieces of evidence from the lesson.
Check your answer
Answer: Model: “Posada shaped how ordinary Mexicans saw the news and modern danger.” Evidence: (1) his broadsides combined image and text so news and satire reached workers who could not read, for example The Skeleton of the Buses commenting on the danger of Mexico City’s new electric trams; (2) the Cleveland Museum notes he was admired by many twentieth-century Mexican artists.Influence on later artists is one kind of evidence; circulation to a wide public is another.
Review
Keep earlier skills sharp.
- Review (Lesson 2.1): Bingham’s Raftsmen Playing Cards and The Verdict of the People both carry arguments. State each argument as the Saint Louis Art Museum reads it.
Check your answer
Answer: Raftsmen: clean, collegial river workers present Missouri as trustworthy, and the snag and sandbar argue for clearing the rivers with federal funds. Verdict: the election crowd shows who takes part in public life, and who is left out (women and enslaved African Americans who had no vote).Both are genre paintings that are also political.
Eight Works That Speak: Records, Descriptions and a Worked Strategy Chart (Daumier, Goya, Shahnama, Akan, Posada, Kollwitz)
Museum open-access records retrieved Sept. 26, 2026: AIC 1953.530, 1920.1335, 1920.1384, 1959.526; Met 1970.301.2, 1994.312.2; Cleveland 2000.97, 1932.320 · Public domain (the artworks; museum records under CC0), with SLS original descriptions and worked chart. Art Institute description text quoted briefly under CC BY 4.0; Cleveland text is CC0.
Why this reading. Your chart classifies six works by strategy, audience and medium and asks for one claim about impact with one piece of evidence. That needs the works. Here are eight, with museum records, a description of what is printed or painted on each, what the museum says about it, and a worked chart row. Museum links are conveniences only. Twentieth-century artists named in the lesson (Rivera, Warhol, Haring, Baca) are still under copyright; the lesson describes them and they are not reproduced. Records retrieved Sept. 26, 2026 from the museums’ open-access data.
The four strategies, briefly
Descriptive records what happened or what is. Political takes a position on power or public life. Narrative tells a story, often in sequence. Symbolic uses forms that stand for ideas a community can read. Most works use more than one; choose the one that dominates and name the second.
Eight works
| Work | Museum record |
|---|---|
| Honoré Daumier, Rue Transnonain, on April 15, 1834, plate 24 from L’Association mensuelle | Lithograph in black; image 28.6 × 44.2 cm; Art Institute of Chicago, 1953.530; public domain |
| Francisco Goya, Ravages of war (Estragos de la guerra), plate 30 of The Disasters of War | 1810/11, published 1863; etching, drypoint, burin and burnishing; image 12.8 × 15.7 cm; AIC 1920.1335 |
| Goya, Truth has died (Murió la Verdad), plate 79 | 1815/20, published 1863; etching and burnishing; image 14.5 × 18.2 cm; AIC 1920.1384 |
| Folio 22v, “The Feast of Sada,” from the Shahnama (Book of Kings) of Shah Tahmasp; text by Firdausi; painting attributed to Sultan Muhammad | ca. 1525; opaque watercolor, ink, silver and gold on paper; painting 24.1 × 23 cm; page 47 × 31.8 cm; The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 1970.301.2; public domain |
| Akan artist, geometric gold weight | 18th–19th century; brass; 1.6 × 4.8 × 4.8 cm; The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 1994.312.2; public domain |
| José Guadalupe Posada, ¡Terrible y verdadera noticia! | 1910; relief engraving or photo relief etching on tan paper; image 24.8 × 16.2 cm; AIC 1959.526 |
| Posada, The Skeleton of the Buses (La calavera de los camiones) | c. 1900–10; relief etching and letterpress; sheet 39.4 × 29.3 cm; Cleveland Museum of Art, 2000.97; CC0 |
| Käthe Kollwitz, Working Woman with Blue Shawl | 1903; color lithograph; Cleveland Museum of Art, 1932.320; CC0 (no dimensions in the open-access record) |
What is on each
Daumier. A man in a nightshirt and cap lies on his back on a bedroom floor, one leg bent, the other stretched toward us, his head against a rumpled bed; a small body lies partly hidden beneath his arm; another figure lies at the left in the dark and another head appears at the lower right; dark stains spread on the floor and a chair is overturned. The caption reads “Rue Transnonain, le 15 Avril 1834.” The room is lit from the upper right; the darkest areas are the corners. There is no attacker, no hero and no text of explanation. The Art Institute says Daumier used “partially exposed corpses to make a political statement,” criticizing the French government’s “excessive response to a lower class riot.” (CC BY 4.0.)
Goya, plate 30. A ruined interior under crossed beams; a figure tumbles headfirst from above; below lie a heap of bodies, women’s and children’s among them, at the base of the collapsed structure. The handwritten title is “Estragos de la guerra.” Plate 79. A woman’s shining body lies in the foreground, light radiating from her; behind her stands a dense crowd, including figures in hoods and a mitred hat under a dark cross; at right, a seated female figure hides her face. The handwritten title is “Murió la Verdad.” The Art Institute describes the corpse as Truth, “about to be buried,” and Justice at right, “clasping her scales in her left hand,” covering her face; it says that by ending the series so, Goya shows that “the final blow of war is that truth is dead and justice despondent.” Both plates were published in 1863, decades after Goya’s death in 1828.
Shahnama folio. A small square painting set into a page of Persian text in four columns below and a few lines above: a figure in orange sits on a carpet at the center of a green, rocky hillside; a fire burns in the lower middle; groups of figures sit and converse around it, and animals and hunters fill the bottom; flowering trees in pink, purple and blue rise around the edges, and a deer stands at the top. The rulers who commissioned the book saw themselves in its kings; the picture needs the story to be read.
Akan gold weight. A square brass block; a raised border of small parallel bars runs along the top and bottom edges; within the frame, an openwork design of two large concentric circles side by side, each crossed by a horizontal bar, with half-circles above and below at the center. It is a geometric weight, not a figure, so its meaning is carried by pattern.
Posada, ¡Terrible y verdadera noticia! The sheet has two halves: on the right, a woodcut-style picture across the top of a violent scene, a bold headline “¡Terrible y verdadera noticia!” (“Terrible and true news!”), a subhead and two columns of dense text; on the left, more text and a moral poem in two columns. The imprint at the foot names the printer Antonio Vanegas Arroyo, Mexico City, 1910. The whole page is a broadside: news, warning and verse. The Skeleton of the Buses. The title fills the top in large capitals; below it a huge skeleton at left gestures toward a sea of skulls, and at right a streetcar full of passengers drives toward a cemetery gate; verse in columns fills the bottom. The Cleveland Museum says Posada “combined image and text in his depictions of social and political issues so that they were accessible to workers, many of whom were illiterate” and that this print is part of a series using skeletons to comment humorously on events, such as “the danger of electric trams in Mexico City.” It adds that “a number of 20th-century Mexican artists admired” him.
Kollwitz. Head and shoulders of a woman against a very dark blue-green ground; her head is lowered and turned, the light catching her cheek, nose and hair, which is drawn in fine dark strokes; a blue shawl covers her shoulders. Cleveland says she favored printmaking as “a democratic medium, affordable and capable of reaching all social classes,” that she “depicted Berlin’s most disenfranchised inhabitants,” and that the sitter’s “direct gaze and exhausted pose” suggest both hard conditions and dignity. Test that: on the museum’s photograph her eyes look down and to our right. Decide what the evidence supports.
Worked chart row (SLS original)
| Work | Strategy (dominant, then second) | Audience | Medium and why it fits | Impact claim and evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Posada, The Skeleton of the Buses (Cleveland 2000.97) | Political humor, with symbolic skeletons | Working people in Mexico City, including readers and non-readers | Cheap relief etching and letterpress, so many copies at low price | Claim: it influenced later artists. Evidence: Cleveland notes 20th-century Mexican artists admired Posada. |
| Goya, Truth has died (AIC 1920.1384) | Political, with allegory | Print buyers after 1863, decades after the events | Etching, small plate, viewed close | Claim: it changes what viewers think war means. Evidence: the AIC reading of its ending; publication in 1863 shows its message outlived the war. |
Fill six rows using your own choices. In a claim about impact, separate what the work shows from what you can document that people did or thought because of it.
Sources: Art Institute of Chicago open-access API: 1953.530, 1920.1335, 1920.1384, 1959.526 (artic.edu); The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Open Access: 1970.301.2 and 1994.312.2 (metmuseum.org); Cleveland Museum of Art Open Access: 2000.97 and 1932.320 (clevelandart.org)