
evaluate how effectively an image influences a specific audience, and compare how different media cover the same art exhibition.
Instruction
This lab has two parts, both about images reaching audiences. The first analyzes how a poster persuades. The second follows the record’s assignment to compare how different media cover the same art exhibition.
Part 1: A poster that worked. Henri de Toulouse-Lautrec’s color lithograph Moulin Rouge, La Goulue (1891, Art Institute of Chicago) was, the museum explains, his first commissioned poster, made to advertise the dancer La Goulue and Valentin le Désossé, who danced with her, at the Montmartre dance hall. Thousands of copies were pasted around Paris and it made his name. Analyze it as a persuasive image:
- Audience. Parisians walking past walls crowded with posters. The image must be read in seconds, from a distance.
- Dominance. The dancer is the brightest, most detailed shape. The crowd behind her is a flat black silhouette, and the male dancer in the foreground is a dark gray silhouette, so she is framed on both sides.
- Text. The venue’s name is repeated in large capitals across the top, so a passer-by learns where to go even without reading the rest.
- Simplification. Flat areas of color, bold contour and cropped figures, learned partly from Japanese woodblock prints, make the image legible at a glance.
The museum also points out that the composition seems to trap the dancer between the stage lights, the anonymous crowd and the male dancer. A persuasive image can carry a second, more critical meaning.
Evaluating effectiveness. Standard VA:Re7B.II asks you to evaluate how effectively an image influences the ideas, feelings and behaviors of a specific audience. Ask: Who is the audience? What does the image want them to think, feel or do? What evidence is there that it worked? For the poster, the evidence is its circulation and the commissions it brought. For a contemporary image, evidence might be attendance, responses, or your own test with viewers.
Part 2: One exhibition, several reports. You need one exhibition and two or three accounts of it from different media. Choose one route. All three earn full credit, all three give you the same comparison to make, and all three end in the same 300-400 word write-up.
Option A — a show you can follow now. Pick any exhibition at a museum or gallery that publishes its own exhibition pages. In Missouri, the Saint Louis Art Museum and Laumeier Sculpture Park post press releases in their press rooms, and the Nelson-Atkins Museum of Art, the Kemper Museum of Contemporary Art and the Pulitzer Arts Foundation publish exhibition pages; so do most university and city galleries. Take the institution’s own page or press release as one account, a review in a newspaper or arts magazine as a second, and a broadcast, podcast, video walkthrough or the museum’s own social post as a third.
Option B — the press of its day. The International Exhibition of Modern Art, known as the Armory Show, opened at the 69th Regiment Armory in New York on 17 February 1913 and later traveled to the Art Institute of Chicago and to Boston. It was covered by newspapers across the country, much of it hostile, and Marcel Duchamp’s Nude Descending a Staircase, No. 2 became the story the papers kept returning to. U.S. newspapers of 1913 are in the public domain and are free to search, page by page, in Chronicling America at the Library of Congress (loc.gov). Search February and March 1913 for the exhibition and gather three accounts from different papers or different kinds of coverage: a straight news notice, a review, and a humor or editorial piece. The organizers’ own exhibition catalog is digitized too, so you have the institution’s voice as well. Compare them by the same five questions.
Option C — the account set printed below, which needs no internet. Three accounts of one exhibition are given at the end of this lesson. They were written for this course, and both the show and the venue are invented, so nothing in them can be looked up; that is deliberate, because it forces the comparison to rest on the language rather than on what you already know. Compare them by the same five questions.
Whichever route you take, compare the accounts on these five points:
- Purpose. Is the account promoting, informing, or judging?
- Selection. Which works are named or pictured? Which are left out?
- Language. Which art vocabulary is used? Is the tone expert, enthusiastic, skeptical?
- Judgment. Does it evaluate the show? By which criteria?
- Presentation. Standard VA:Pr5A.I asks you to analyze the reasons and ways an exhibition is presented. What do the accounts say about how the show is installed, and why?
A museum press release and a critic’s review usually describe the same show very differently: the release tells you why to come, and the review tells you whether it succeeds. Neither is the whole truth. Write a comparison of 300-400 words, ending with your own judgment of what a reader would understand about the exhibition from each account.
The account set for Option C
All three of the accounts below were written for this course. The exhibition, the artists and the venue are invented. Read them as writing samples, not as reporting.
1. The venue’s own press release. “Rivermouth Arts Center is proud to present Ground Water, a landmark exhibition bringing together six river-town artists working at the edge of the flood. Spanning three galleries and the courtyard, Ground Water features new commissions in ceramic, textile and video, including Alma Rios’s twelve-foot river-gauge sculpture, shown publicly for the first time. Visitors will find an exhibition of rare urgency and beauty, grounded in the lived experience of the communities it portrays. Free admission every first Sunday. Supported by the Rivermouth Foundation.”
2. A newspaper review. “Ground Water is at its strongest when it stops explaining itself. Alma Rios’s river gauge, hung so that visitors walk beneath it, does more in silence than the four wall texts around it manage between them. The video gallery is another matter: three works, each over twenty minutes, are installed on benches too shallow to sit through, and the effect is that nobody sees any of them whole. Six artists in three rooms is one or two artists too many. The show is worth the drive for the ceramics; the curating has not yet caught up with the work.”
3. A local radio segment, transcribed. “We are standing in what used to be the loading dock, and there is a sound in here I cannot place — sort of a low knocking. It is coming from the sculpture, which is an actual steel river gauge, and you feel it in your feet before you hear it. I brought my daughter, who is nine, and she went straight past the paintings to the textile piece with the dried river mud on it. The place was busy for a Tuesday. If you go, go early, because parking is on the street and the courtyard closes at four.”
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
In Moulin Rouge, La Goulue, why are the crowd and the male dancer shown as dark silhouettes?
A museum press release calls an exhibition “groundbreaking,” while a newspaper critic calls it uneven. What is the best conclusion?
Name the route you took (A, a show you can follow now; B, the Armory Show of 1913 in the newspapers of its day; C, the three accounts printed in this lesson) and the exhibition you worked on. Then answer: what does one of your accounts say, or leave out, about how the show is installed and why?
How confident are you that you can evaluate how an image persuades an audience and compare media coverage of one exhibition?
Practice
Work these on paper or in your notebook, then open Check your answer. Aim for all of Fluency and Application; try at least one Challenge.
Printable version: this unit’s practice workbook (PDF)
Fluency
Build speed and accuracy with the core skill.
- List the four features of Toulouse-Lautrec’s Moulin Rouge, La Goulue (1891) that the lesson uses to analyze it as a persuasive image.
Check your answer
Answer: Audience (Parisians passing crowded poster walls; read in seconds, from a distance); dominance (the dancer is the brightest, most detailed shape, framed by silhouettes); text (the venue’s name repeated in large capitals across the top); simplification (flat color, bold contour, cropped figures, learned partly from Japanese woodblock prints).The museum also notes a second, more critical meaning: the dancer seems trapped. - Define press release and review, and state how their purposes usually differ.
Check your answer
Answer: A press release is a statement an institution issues to announce and promote an event; a review is a published critical evaluation. The release tells you why to come; the review tells you whether the show succeeds.Neither is the whole truth. - Name the five points on which you compare media accounts of an exhibition.
Check your answer
Answer: Purpose; selection; language; judgment; presentation.Presentation connects to standard VA:Pr5A.I: the reasons and ways an exhibition is presented.
Application
Use the skill in context. Show your reasoning.
- Compare the Option C press release and newspaper review of Ground Water on purpose and judgment.
Check your answer
Answer: The press release promotes: it calls the show “landmark” and of “rare urgency and beauty” and gives admission details, with no criticism. The review judges: it praises Rios’s river gauge and the ceramics but criticizes the video installation (works over twenty minutes on benches too shallow to sit through) and says six artists in three rooms is too many.The review names its criteria (how well the curating serves the work); the release offers enthusiasm, not evaluation. - What does each Option C account say, or leave out, about how the show is installed (presentation, Pr5.HSI)?
Check your answer
Answer: Release: three galleries and the courtyard, new commissions, Rios’s twelve-foot river-gauge sculpture; nothing on how works are hung. Review: the gauge is hung so visitors walk beneath it; the video gallery’s benches are too shallow. Radio: they are in the old loading dock; the gauge makes a low knocking felt in the feet; the courtyard closes at four. None explains why the curators chose these arrangements.Answers should cite details from the accounts as printed; the show is invented, so nothing can be looked up. - What evidence does the lesson give that Lautrec’s poster worked on its audience? Suggest one kind of evidence you could gather for a contemporary image.
Check your answer
Answer: Thousands of copies were pasted around Paris, it was his first commissioned poster, and it made his name (circulation and the commissions it brought). For a contemporary image: attendance, viewers’ responses, or your own test with viewers.Standard Re7.2.HSII asks how effectively an image influences a specific audience’s ideas, feelings and behaviors. - The radio segment mentions a nine-year-old who went straight to the textile piece with dried river mud. What kind of account is this, compared with the other two, and what does it offer that they do not?
Check your answer
Answer: It is informal, first-person description: neither promotion nor formal evaluation. It offers the felt experience of the space (the sound felt in the feet, a busy Tuesday) and practical details (parking, closing time), plus one visitor’s response as evidence of what draws attention.Different media serve different purposes; compare their evidence before judging.
Review
Keep earlier skills sharp.
- Review (Lesson 3.1): Lautrec’s poster and Posada’s broadsides both reached a wide public. What did each combine to be read quickly?
Check your answer
Answer: Lautrec: a dominant, simplified image of the dancer with the venue’s name in large capitals. Posada: image and text together on cheap broadsides, so even workers who could not read got the news and satire.Both combine image and text for a public that reads in passing.
How Posters Persuade: Lautrec and Three WPA Posters, with Full Text, Layout, Records and a Worked Analysis
Art Institute of Chicago 1954.1193 (open-access API); Library of Congress items 98518428, 98516354, 98518521, Work Projects Administration Poster Collection; retrieved Sept. 26, 2026 · Public domain (Lautrec 1891 lithograph; WPA posters, no known restrictions on publication per the Library of Congress), with SLS original descriptions and worked analysis. Art Institute description quoted briefly under CC BY 4.0.
Why this reading. Part 1 of the lab asks you to judge how well an image persuades a specific audience. The lesson supplies a Toulouse-Lautrec poster; this reading prints its full text, layout and the museum’s evidence, then adds three public-domain posters from the Works Progress Administration (WPA) collection at the Library of Congress so you can compare a commercial poster with public-health and workplace-safety posters, and a worked analysis and analysis sheet. Part 2 (press coverage of one exhibition) is served by Option C in the lesson itself. Records retrieved Sept. 26, 2026.
Toulouse-Lautrec, Moulin Rouge, La Goulue (1891)
Color lithograph on tan paper; image 189 × 115.7 cm (about 6 ft 2 in. by 3 ft 9 in.); Art Institute of Chicago, 1954.1193; public domain. Layout. The paper is pale yellow-green. Across the top, in pink-red capitals, the words MOULIN ROUGE are printed three times in a stack, the first letter M drawn much taller than the rest, down the left edge; at the upper right, in black, CONCERT / BAL / TOUS LES SOIRS (“every night”); centered below in black, LA GOULUE. Across the middle a band of black silhouettes of a crowd in top hats and feathered hats spans the whole width, with three pale yellow lamps above them. In front of the crowd, a dancer with orange-blond hair, a pink polka-dot bodice and a huge white ruffled skirt kicks one leg toward the right. At the right, in the foreground, a tall flat gray silhouette of a man in a top hat, seen in profile with one hand raised (the museum names him Valentin le Désossé); at the left a large bright yellow curve fills the edge. Below, the floorboards recede in thin perspective lines, with MOULIN ROUGE again in red at left, “les Mercredis et Samedis” in red script and BAL MASQUÉ in large red capitals across the bottom right. The lower edge carries the printer’s name, CH. LEVY, 10 Rue Martel, Paris. Museum’s evidence of effect (CC BY 4.0). It was Toulouse-Lautrec’s first commissioned poster; “thousands of copies” were pasted around Paris and it was “an instant success, propelling Toulouse-Lautrec into the artistic limelight and attracting numerous commissions.” The museum adds that the composition “traps La Goulue in her spectacle: between the bright yellow stage lights, the anonymous silhouetted crowd, and the provocatively posed Valentin.”
Three WPA posters (all “no known restrictions on publication,” Library of Congress)
| Poster | Library of Congress record |
|---|---|
| Failure here may mean death below: Safety first | Woodcut, color; WPA Federal Art Project, Pennsylvania, [1936 or 1937]; call number POS – WPA – PA .N37, no. 2a; item 98518428 |
| Tuberculosis: Don’t kiss me! Your kiss of affection, the germ of infection | Silkscreen, color; WPA Federal Art Project, District 4, [New York], between 1936 and 1941; for the Town of Hempstead, W. H. Runcie, M.D., Health Officer; call number POS – WPA – NY .D03, no. 4; item 98516354 |
| Don’t fear cancer fight it! | Silkscreen, color; WPA Federal Art Project, New York City, between 1936 and 1938; initialed JR; call number POS – WPA – NY .R68, no. 16; item 98518521 |
Safety first. A square picture with a black border on a pale gray ground shows a steel I-beam being hoisted by a crane: a pulley block and a dark ball weight hang from the top, and a chain sling holds the beam, which slants diagonally down to the lower left, its faces shaded light and dark blue-gray. Below the frame, three lines of large capitals: FAILURE HERE MAY / MEAN DEATH BELOW in pale blue-gray, and SAFETY FIRST in black, heavier and wider. Audience: construction workers. Only one thing is dark and heavy: the beam, hanging on a single cable above the reader’s head.
Tuberculosis. A headline TUBERCULOSIS in black capitals across the top of a cream card; a green circle holds a baby with orange hair and pink cheeks in a pink bib on which is lettered, in a child’s hand, “DON’T KISS ME!”; below, in green capitals, YOUR KISS OF AFFECTION / THE GERM OF INFECTION; at the bottom in small capitals the health officer’s name and the WPA credit. Audience: families with babies in the town of Hempstead. The baby “speaks,” and the rhyme of affection and infection is easy to remember.
Cancer. A light blue ground; DON’T FEAR at the top in black, the word CANCER arched across the middle in crimson capitals, FIGHT IT! in black beneath; a stylized figure in white profile with a blue drape holds an upright sword in one raised hand and an unrolled scroll in the other; at the foot, FURTHER INFORMATION MAY BE SECURED FROM the United States Public Health Service, Washington, D.C., and the American Society for the Control of Cancer, 1250 Sixth Avenue, New York. Audience: the general public in New York, 1936–38. The scale of type sets the order: CANCER first, then the sword and figure, then the instruction, then the agencies.
Five questions and a worked analysis (SLS original)
- Audience. Who exactly, and where will they see it?
- Ask. What should they think, feel or do?
- Attention. What is the most dominant element, and what makes it dominant (size, contrast, position, color)?
- Appeal. Is it using fear, humor, authority, empathy or a rule to remember?
- Evidence. What shows that it worked?
Worked analysis of the safety poster. (1) Workers on a site, who will see it from a few steps away. (2) Be careful under loads. (3) The steel beam: it is the largest form, has the strongest diagonal and is the only shape with both very light and very dark faces; the headline is set below in large letters. (4) Fear, made concrete: the image does not show an injury; it shows the cause hanging from one cable, and the words finish the thought. (5) The Library record contains no evidence about its effect; you can only say what it would take to know: accident counts on the sites where it was posted before and after. Comparison. Lautrec’s poster has evidence (thousands of copies, new commissions); the WPA records have none. That is a real finding: an image can be well designed and its effect still unknown.
Legibility test you can run
Print or draw your poster’s headline at final size. Stand ten feet away; if you cannot read the top level in one second, enlarge it. Squint: what is still visible is your true hierarchy.
Sources: Art Institute of Chicago, Toulouse-Lautrec, Moulin Rouge, La Goulue (1954.1193) (artic.edu); Library of Congress, Failure here may mean death below: Safety first (item 98518428) (loc.gov); Library of Congress, Tuberculosis: Don’t kiss me! (item 98516354) (loc.gov); Library of Congress, Don’t fear cancer fight it! (item 98518521) (loc.gov)