write a thesis that a reasonable reader could dispute, build topic sentences that advance it rather than summarize events, and embed a quotation inside my own sentence with an MLA citation.
Instruction
This lesson produces Stage 1 of the unit’s key assignment. By the end you will have a thesis, four pieces of evidence and a plan — not a finished essay, and deliberately so.
A thesis is a claim someone could argue with. Apply the test ruthlessly:
- Apess argues that Native people were treated unjustly. Nobody disputes this. It is a summary.
- Occom was a remarkable man who overcame great obstacles. Also undisputed, and it is about a person rather than a text.
- Apess withholds his own accusation until he has spent two-thirds of the Eulogy establishing his audience’s virtues, which converts every compliment into a debt they have to pay before he asks for anything. Now there is an argument. A reasonable reader could disagree.
Notice what the third has: it names a choice the writer made and asserts an effect. That is the grammar of a literary thesis — because the author does X, the reader experiences Y. Keep the author in the sentence. “Occom was underpaid” is a fact about a life; “Occom itemizes the underpayment and declines to characterize it” is a claim about a text, and a text is a thing you can produce evidence about.
A topic sentence advances the claim; it does not report events. Compare: In the Eulogy, Apess describes the events of King Philip’s War. That is summary. Now: The war narrative is delivered almost entirely in dates and place names taken from colonial histories, so the audience cannot dispute the record without disputing their own historians. The second tells the reader what the paragraph will prove.
Embedding a quotation means the quoted words work inside your own grammar. Three levels, worst to best:
- Dropped. “Apess is angry. ‘O Christians, can you answer for those beings that have been destroyed by your hostilities?’ This shows his anger.” The quotation sits with no sentence around it. Avoid entirely.
- Signal phrase. As Apess asks, “O Christians, can you answer for those beings that have been destroyed by your hostilities?” Acceptable.
- Woven. Apess does not accuse his audience; he puts them in the position of a witness under oath, asking whether they “can answer for those beings that have been destroyed by your hostilities” — a question that presumes the destruction and disputes only the accounting. This is what proficient looks like.
MLA for this unit. These texts have no stable pagination across editions, so cite by paragraph or section: (Apess, Eulogy, pt. 1). Punctuation outside the parenthesis. Name your edition in the Works Cited.
And the point of a recursive workshop. Your thesis is a hypothesis. If the evidence contradicts it, that is the most useful thing that will happen today. Change the thesis to the one the evidence supports.
Reading: Mentor paragraph, model thesis and Stage 1 criteria
William Apess, Eulogy on King Philip (1836); Samson Occom, A Short Narrative of My Life (1768); SLS original models | Text: https://archive.org/download/eulogyonking00apesrich/eulogyonking00apesrich_djvu.txt · SLS original; quoted passages are public domain (Apess, 1836; Occom, 1768)
The model thesis is about Occom. Your own thesis must be about the writer you choose and must not copy this one.
This workshop produces Stage 1 of the Rhetorical Authority essay. The reading gives you a mentor paragraph from a Native writer, a model thesis and paragraph about Occom, a before-and-after revision, and the criteria Stage 1 is scored against. Cite from the unit’s numbered passages: (Occom, passage 5) for the Occom narrative in Lesson 1.1, and (Apess, Eulogy, E4) for the Eulogy passages in Lesson 1.3.
A mentor paragraph: a claim first, then the evidence for it
William Apess (Pequot), Eulogy on King Philip (1836), passage E4
We may look upon this move of Philip’s to be equal, if not superior to that of Washington crossing the Delaware. For while Washington was assisted by all the knowledge that art and science could give, together with all the instruments of defence, and edged tools to prepare rafts, and the like helps for safety across the river, Philip was naked as to any of these things, possessing only what nature, his mother had bestowed upon him; and yet makes his escape with equal praise.
Look at how it is built. The first sentence makes the claim (Philip’s retreat matches Washington’s crossing of the Delaware). The next sentences give the evidence (Washington had “all the knowledge that art and science could give”; Philip was “naked as to any of these things”). The last clause returns to the claim (“equal praise”). Nothing in it is summary.
Three levels of quotation, applied to Apess
- Dropped (avoid): Apess is angry. “Oh, Christians, can you answer for those beings that have been destroyed by your hostilities” This shows his anger.
- Signal phrase (acceptable): As Apess asks, “Oh, Christians, can you answer for those beings that have been destroyed by your hostilities” (Apess, Eulogy, E3).
- Woven (proficient): Apess does not accuse his audience; he puts them in the position of a witness, asking whether they “can answer for those beings that have been destroyed by your hostilities” (Apess, Eulogy, E3), a question that presumes the destruction and disputes only the accounting.
A model thesis and paragraph (SLS original)
Thesis. Occom builds his case out of his own labor and pay, a method that protects him from the charge of ingratitude and leaves the conclusion to his reader, which is exactly why his one plain sentence of cause lands so hard.
Topic sentence and paragraph. Occom sets a number beside a number and lets the reader do the subtraction. He reports that the commissioners “gave me £180 for 12 years’ service, which they gave for one year’s services in another mission” (Occom, passage 5), and he adds only that he was “my own interpreter” and both “schoolmaster and minister.” The sentence has no adjective in it. Its force is in the ratio, which he leaves for the reader to find. That restraint is a choice: a writer whose income depended on the same commissioners could be dismissed for complaint, but not easily for arithmetic.
Before and after: fixing a summary topic sentence (SLS original)
| Before (a summary) | After (a claim) |
|---|---|
| In his narrative, Occom describes how much he was paid and how much other missionaries were paid. | Occom never calls his pay unjust; he reports the pay of a young missionary beside his own and makes the reader conclude the rest. |
| In the Eulogy, Apess describes the events of King Philip’s War. | Apess narrates the war almost entirely from colonial sources and colonial dates, so a listener who wants to dispute the record has to dispute his own historians. |
The “after” sentences each name a choice the writer made and assert an effect on a reader. The “before” sentences only say what the text contains. Note that the second “after” sentence is a hypothesis you would test against the Eulogy before you used it.
Criteria for the Stage 1 organizer (four levels)
| Criterion | Proficient (3) | Not yet (1 to 2) |
|---|---|---|
| Thesis | One sentence, disputable, names an authorial choice and its effect on a reader. | A fact about a life, a summary, or an announcement (“This essay will…”). |
| Evidence | Four quotations, each with a citation by passage number and a one-sentence note on what it proves. | Fewer than four, unnumbered, or with no note on what each proves. |
| Counter-quotation | One quotation that complicates the thesis, with a plan for handling it. | None, or one that does not actually complicate. |
| Topic sentences | Four, each advancing the claim, none starting “In the Eulogy” or “In his narrative.” | Summaries of events, or the same sentence four times. |
Advanced (4) means the thesis is precise enough that a classmate could argue against it, and the counter-quotation genuinely forces a change to the thesis or a qualification of it.
Source
Apess, Eulogy on King Philip (Boston, 1836; Internet Archive “eulogyonking00apesrich”), retrieved 2026-09-26; Occom passage as in Lesson 1.1. Other text SLS original.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you, and your teacher, whether the standard below has landed yet.
Which of these is a workable thesis for the unit essay?
If the evidence you gather contradicts your starting thesis, you should look for different evidence.
Apess asks whether his listeners “can answer for those beings that have been destroyed” Apess, Eulogy, pt. 1 , a question that presumes the destruction and disputes only the accounting.
Submit your Stage 1 organizer: (1) your thesis in one sentence, naming a choice the writer made and the effect it has; (2) four quotations with citations, each with a one-sentence note on what it proves; (3) one quotation that complicates your thesis, with a note on how you will handle it; (4) four topic sentences, none of which may begin with “In the Eulogy” or “In his narrative”.
How confident are you that you can tell the difference between a thesis and a summary, and fix a summary by naming an authorial choice and its effect?