join two closely related independent clauses with a semicolon, with or without a conjunctive adverb, and explain why that choice is stronger than a period or a comma in a specific analytical sentence.
Instruction
Analytical writing has a characteristic sentence shape, and it is not the one most students bring from middle school. Analysis constantly holds two ideas in one breath: a claim and its consequence, an observation and its complication, a move and what it costs. This unit is full of things that cut two ways — Occom’s restraint protects him and hides his case; Apess praises his audience’s founders in order to indict their descendants — and you cannot write about a thing that cuts two ways in sentences that carry one idea each.
The mark built for that job is the semicolon.
An independent clause has a subject and a verb and could stand alone. Occom itemizes his pay. The itemizing is the argument. Four ways to join them, not interchangeable:
- A period. Occom itemizes his pay. The itemizing is the argument. Correct, and it presents the two as unrelated. The reader supplies the connection you were supposed to make.
- A comma plus a coordinating conjunction (and, but, or, nor, for, so, yet). Occom itemizes his pay, and the itemizing is the argument. Correct, and loose.
- A semicolon. Occom itemizes his pay; the itemizing is the argument. Correct, and it asserts that the clauses belong together without spelling out how. The reader feels the link. This is the sentence of analysis.
- A comma alone. Occom itemizes his pay, the itemizing is the argument. A comma splice, and an error — the commonest mechanical mistake in ninth-grade analytical writing.
A conjunctive adverb — however, therefore, moreover, nevertheless, consequently, indeed, instead — names the relationship precisely. But it is not a conjunction and cannot hold two independent clauses together alone. Semicolon in front, comma after:
Apess praises the Pilgrims’ courage at length; however, every virtue he grants them becomes a standard he then measures their descendants against.
The test is mechanical: cover the connector. If what is on each side could stand alone, you need a semicolon.
One more rule you will need immediately. Introduce a quotation with a full independent clause and use a colon. If the quotation completes your own sentence grammatically, use no punctuation at all: Occom concludes that the reason is simply that he is “a poor Indian.” Over-punctuating quotations is the tell of a writer who has not yet learned to embed them.
Reading: Mentor sentences: the semicolon and the conjunctive adverb in Occom and Apess
Samson Occom, A Short Narrative of My Life (1768); William Apess, The Experiences of Five Christian Indians of the Pequod Tribe (Boston, 1833) | Text: https://teachingamericanhistory.org/document/a-short-narrative-of-my-life/; https://archive.org/download/experiencesoffiv00apes/experiencesoffiv00apes_djvu.txt · SLS original; quoted passages are public domain (Occom, 1768; Apess, 1833)
Do each test yourself before you read the key: cover the connector and see if both sides could be a sentence.
The lab teaches one mark and one relationship between clauses, and the mentors are sentences by Native writers who used it in print: Samson Occom (Mohegan) and William Apess (Pequot). In each mentor the semicolon sits between two clauses that could each stand alone. Cover the connector and test them.
Mentor sentences
Mentor 1
I had near 30 scholars this winter; I had an evening school too for those that could not attend the day school
Samson Occom (Mohegan), A Short Narrative of My Life (1768), on the school at Montauk
Mentor 2
I concluded with prayer; I generally heard my evening scholars 3 times round, and as they go out the school, every one that can spell is obliged to spell a word, and to go out leisurely one after another.
Occom, A Short Narrative of My Life (1768), on how he ran the school
Mentor 3
Another reason is because they have no education to take care of themselves; if they had, I would risk them to take care of their own property.
William Apess (Pequot), “An Indian’s Looking-Glass for the White Man” (1833)
Mentor 4
What then is the matter now; is not religion the same now under a colored skin as it ever was?
Apess, “An Indian’s Looking-Glass for the White Man” (1833)
Mentor 5
Some say, their crimes are punished here; indeed, this is a new doctrine
Apess, “An Indian’s Looking-Glass for the White Man” (1833), on how his contemporaries answered the charge of crime
Mentor 6
I commenced exhorting them to flee the wrath to come — there was an old veteran of the woods, who despised all that was said to her upon the subject of salvation, and would use very bad language in her way, being not able to speak plain English; however, the Lord reached her heart, and many others, and there was a work of God amongst us.
Apess, A Son of the Forest, in The Experiences of Five Christian Indians of the Pequot Tribe (1833 and 1837), on a revival
What the mentors show
- Mentors 1 and 2 (Occom). Each clause is a full report of work: I had near 30 scholars this winter and I had an evening school too. The semicolon presents them as parts of one ledger. A period would make two separate facts, and a comma would splice them.
- Mentor 3 (Apess). The second clause begins with if they had, but it finishes as an independent clause (I would risk them to take care of their own property), so the semicolon is legitimate. The clauses are a claim and its condition.
- Mentor 4 (Apess). The second clause is a question. A semicolon can join a statement to a question that presses on it.
- Mentors 5 and 6 (Apess). Both use a conjunctive adverb, indeed in Mentor 5 and however in Mentor 6, that names the relationship: semicolon in front, comma after. Cover it in each and the clauses on both sides still stand alone, which is how you know a semicolon is required.
Worked key for the lab (SLS original)
Test every join the same way: cover the connector and ask whether each side could stand alone as a sentence.
| Pair | Combined sentence | What the punctuation makes the reader see |
|---|---|---|
| (a) Occom raised £12,000 in England. The college it founded educated almost no Native students. | Occom raised £12,000 in England; however, the college it founded educated almost no Native students. | The adverb names the relationship, a reversal, which a period would leave the reader to guess. Both halves keep the same weight, so the sentence reads as a fact set against a fact. |
| (b) Apess praises the Pilgrims’ courage. He uses that praise as a standard. | Apess praises the Pilgrims’ courage; he uses that praise as a standard. | No connector is needed. The semicolon asserts that the second clause follows from the first, and the reader feels the praise turning into a demand. |
| (c) The narrative was never printed in his lifetime. It is addressed to a reader on every page. | The narrative was never printed in his lifetime; it is addressed to a reader on every page. | The semicolon holds a puzzle: a text nobody read is written to be read. A period would separate the two facts and lose the tension. |
The comma splice test. Occom itemizes his pay, the itemizing is the argument fails the test. Both sides stand alone and only a comma joins them. Repair it with a semicolon, a period, or a comma plus and.
Introducing a quotation. Complete sentence, then colon: Occom ends his accounting with a plain statement of cause: “I believe it is because I am a poor Indian.” If the quotation finishes your own sentence, use no punctuation before it: Occom concludes that the reason is that he is “a poor Indian.”
Sources
Occom: modernized transcription of the 1768 manuscript, Dartmouth Occom Circle, as reproduced at teachingamericanhistory.org (retrieved 2026-09-26). Apess: The Experiences of Five Christian Indians of the Pequod Tribe (Boston, 1833; second edition 1837), Internet Archive copy “experiencesoffiv00apes” (retrieved 2026-09-26); the space before the semicolon, question mark and colon in the printed text is closed up here. Numbers and paraphrase in the key are SLS original.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you, and your teacher, whether the standard below has landed yet.
Which sentence is punctuated correctly?
A semicolon can attach a dependent clause, such as “because his livelihood depended on them”, to a main clause.
Occom never states the grievance he lists the facts and lets the reader assemble it, and the technique has a name demonstration rather than assertion.
Rewrite these three choppy pairs as single analytical sentences, using a semicolon in at least two and a conjunctive adverb in at least one. (a) Occom raised £12,000 in England. The college it founded educated almost no Native students. (b) Apess praises the Pilgrims’ courage. He uses that praise as a standard. (c) The narrative was never printed in his lifetime. It is addressed to a reader on every page. After each, add one sentence explaining what the punctuation makes the reader see that a period would not.
How confident are you that you can test any sentence for a comma splice by covering the connector and asking whether both sides could stand alone?