produce a 750-1,000 word analysis of how one writer constructs authority for an audience that does not grant it, with four embedded MLA-cited quotations and a paragraph handling evidence against my own claim.
Instruction
This is the unit’s summative assessment and the first of the semester’s four formal essays. Read the whole page before drafting; the stages are scored separately and a strong final draft cannot recover Stage 1 points.
The prompt. Choose Occom or Apess. How does the writer construct authority for an audience that does not grant it in advance — and what does that construction cost the writing? Take a position on whether the method succeeds on its own terms.
What the essay must contain. 750-1,000 words. An introduction ending in an arguable thesis that names a choice and asserts its effect. Three to four body paragraphs, each opening with a topic sentence that advances the claim rather than reporting events. At least four quotations embedded in your own syntax and cited by section or paragraph. At least one paragraph that takes seriously a passage cutting against your thesis — for Apess, most often a moment where he appeals to his audience’s Christianity in terms that sit uneasily now; for Occom, the plainness that can be read as deference rather than strategy. A conclusion that states what the reading lets a reader see that they would otherwise miss. A Works Cited entry naming the edition.
One thing this essay must not do. Do not write that your author expresses “the Native perspective” or speaks for Native people. Occom was Mohegan in 1768; Apess was Pequot in 1836; the leader Apess eulogises was Wampanoag. Three nations, three positions, one speech. An essay that flattens them has failed the thing this course is most concerned with, and the rubric says so.
The oral component. After Stage 3, record a sixty-second defense: your claim, your strongest evidence, and the objection you found hardest. A written transcript earns equal credit.
Academic honesty. The analysis must be yours. The assigned texts are the only ones you may reproduce, marked and cited. Analysis produced by a language model removes the one thing this assignment measures.
Reading: Key passages, rubric and model for the Rhetorical Authority essay
Samson Occom, A Short Narrative of My Life (1768); William Apess, Eulogy on King Philip (1836); SLS original rubric and model | Text: https://teachingamericanhistory.org/document/a-short-narrative-of-my-life/; https://archive.org/download/eulogyonking00apesrich/eulogyonking00apesrich_djvu.txt · SLS original; quoted passages are public domain (Occom, 1768; Apess, 1836)
Cite by passage number. Your thesis must differ from the model thesis.
Everything the Rhetorical Authority essay needs is in Units 1.1, 1.3 and 1.4 and here. The essay is 750 to 1,000 words and takes Occom or Apess as its subject. Cite by passage number: (Occom, passage 5) or (Apess, Eulogy, E3). If you want to read the whole of either work, the editions are named at the end; you are not required to.
The prompt
Choose Occom or Apess. How does the writer construct authority for an audience that does not grant it in advance, and what does that construction cost the writing? Take a position on whether the method succeeds on its own terms. Name the writer’s nation (Occom, Mohegan; Apess, Pequot; Metacom, whom Apess eulogizes, Wampanoag) and do not write that either speaks for “the Native perspective.”
Where the evidence is
| If you choose | Core passages | A passage that complicates your reading |
|---|---|---|
| Occom | Lesson 1.1, passages 3 to 7 (the work, the pay, the ending) | Passage 8 below, and the phrase “for which I am very thankful” in passage 4: plainness that can be read as deference. |
| Apess | Lesson 1.3, E2 to E6 and L1 to L3 | E7 and E8 below: praise in terms a modern reader may find uncomfortable, and an appeal to Christian mercy that also accepts the audience’s frame. |
Two more passages to use
Occom, passage 8 (his first meeting with Eleazar Wheelock)
So I went up, thinking I should be back again in a few days; when I got up there, he received me with kindness and compassion and instead of staying a fortnight or three weeks, I spent 4 years with him.
Apess, Eulogy, E7
so will every patriot, especially in this enlightened age, respect the rude yet all-accomplished son of the forest, that died a martyr to his cause, though unsuccessful, yet as glorious as the American Revolution.
Apess, Eulogy, E8
It is said that in the Christian’s guide, that God is merciful, and they that are his followers are like him. How much mercy do you think has been shown towards Indians, their wives and their children? Not much, we think.
Rubric (four levels)
| Criterion | Advanced (4) | Proficient (3) | Approaching (2) | Beginning (1) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Thesis | Arguable, names a choice and its effect, and the essay complicates it honestly. | Arguable, names a choice and its effect, and holds throughout. | Names a topic or a feeling, or drifts. | A fact or a summary. |
| Textual evidence | Five or more quotations woven into the writer’s own syntax and analyzed. | Four quotations woven and analyzed. | Four quotations, some dropped or unanalyzed. | Fewer than four. |
| Counter-evidence | A passage that cuts against the claim changes or qualifies it. | Engages such a passage and explains why the reading survives. | Mentions it without answering. | Absent. |
| Nations named | Precise throughout, with the writer’s nation and the nation he writes about kept distinct. | Names the writer’s nation, no generalizing. | Names once, generalizes elsewhere. | “The Native perspective.” |
| Conventions and MLA | No comma splices; semicolons and colons precise; citations and Works Cited exact. | Minor slips only. | Repeated comma splices or citation gaps. | Conventions impede reading. |
| Recursive process | Revision note traces a substantial change to specific peer feedback. | Names one change and the feedback behind it. | A general statement of revision. | No note. |
A model thesis and outline (SLS original)
Thesis. Occom constructs authority from the only ground no one can dispute, the record of his own labor and pay, and the method both protects him from the charge of ingratitude and forces him to leave his grievance unnamed until a single sentence at the end.
- Introduction: Occom in 1768 (Mohegan, a minister, writing to answer rumors); the thesis.
- Body 1: the itemized work and living conditions (passages 2 and 3) make him a witness on matters no one else can testify to.
- Body 2: the two-sum comparison (passages 4 and 5) turns pay into an argument by ratio, with no adjectives.
- Body 3 (counter-evidence): passages 4 and 8 thank the commissioners and Wheelock. Answer: deference is a cost of the method, and the story of the boy in passage 6 breaks it.
- Body 4: passage 7 states the cause for the first time, in the same sentence that concedes he cannot change it. Cost and success together.
- Conclusion: what the reading lets a reader see (a writer who could not accuse builds a case that must be answered as arithmetic).
Oral defense, 60 seconds: your claim, your strongest passage number, and the objection you found hardest. A typed transcript earns equal credit.
Editions
Occom: modernized transcription of the 1768 manuscript, Dartmouth Occom Circle, via teachingamericanhistory.org. Apess: Eulogy on King Philip (Boston, 1836; Internet Archive “eulogyonking00apesrich”) and The Experiences of Five Christian Indians of the Pequod Tribe (Boston, 1833; “experiencesoffiv00apes”), retrieved 2026-09-26.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you, and your teacher, whether the standard below has landed yet.
restraint
Tap to revealWithholding expected intensity so the reader supplies the judgment.
consistency argument
Tap to revealGranting a principle and demanding it be applied evenly.
ethos
Tap to revealThe appeal from a writer’s credibility, constructed inside the text.
rhetorical situation
Tap to revealSpeaker, audience, purpose and occasion together.
eulogy
Tap to revealA formal speech of praise for the dead.
Your Stage 2 draft comes back with a peer comment: “Your third paragraph just retells the war.” What is the correct revision?
How confident are you that you can write a body paragraph whose topic sentence advances an argument and whose quotations are embedded rather than dropped?
Submit: Rhetorical Authority Analytical Essay (750-1,000 words)
Prompt: Choose Occom or Apess. How does the writer construct authority for an audience that does not grant it, and what does that construction cost the writing? Argue whether the method succeeds on its own terms.
Each stage opens only after the previous one is submitted. Stages are scored separately.
Submission workflow
- Stage 1 — Thesis & evidence organizer. From Lesson 1.4: thesis, four cited quotations with notes, one counter-quotation, four topic sentences. Scored for the arguability of the thesis and the range of evidence.
- Stage 2 — Peer-reviewed rough draft (600+ words). Upload, complete the peer-review rubric for two classmates, then submit a revision note naming what you changed and which piece of peer feedback caused it. The revision note is scored.
- Stage 3 — Final revised essay (750-1,000 words) + Works Cited. Submit as PDF with MLA formatting.
- Stage 4 — Recorded thesis defense (60 seconds). Claim, strongest evidence, hardest objection. A typed transcript earns equal credit.
How it is scored
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Thesis (W.9-10.2, W.9-10.4) | Arguable, names an authorial choice and asserts its effect, and holds across the essay rather than drifting. |
| Textual evidence (RI.9-10.1) | Four or more quotations embedded in the writer’s own syntax, each analyzed rather than left to speak for itself. |
| Handling of counter-evidence (RI.9-10.3) | Engages a passage that genuinely complicates the claim and explains why the reading survives it. |
| Nations named precisely (EU1, EU2) | Names the writer’s nation and does not present one writer as speaking for Native people generally. An essay that says ‘the Native perspective’ cannot reach proficient on this line. |
| Conventions & MLA (L.9-10.2.a, L.9-10.3.a) | No comma splices; quotations punctuated correctly; citations and Works Cited in MLA form. |
| Recursive process (W.9-10.5) | Stage 2 revision note shows a specific, substantive change traceable to peer feedback. |