THE VR SCHOOL
  • Schools & Districts
    • License the academy
    • Free program for your students
    • Request a demo
  • Catalog
    • AI & Data
    • Cybersecurity & Web
    • Programming
    • Health Science
    • All Guilds
    • All courses
  • Families
  • Accreditation
  • Log In
  • Request a demo
  • Home
  • Courses

English 9A — The Written Word and the Rights of Nations

Curriculum

  • 4 Sections
  • 28 Lessons
  • 10 Weeks
Expand all sectionsCollapse all sections
  • Unit 1: The Native Public Voice, 1768–1836
    7
    • 1.1
      Introduction
      2 mins
    • 1.2
      Samson Occom and the Account That Was Not Printed
      45 mins
    • 1.3
      Language Lab — Semicolons, Conjunctive Adverbs and the Analytical Sentence
      40 mins
    • 1.4
      Seminar — Apess’s Looking-Glass: Who Is the Argument For?
      50 mins
    • 1.5
      Writing Workshop — Thesis, Topic Sentence and the Embedded Quotation
      50 mins
    • 1.6
      Key Assignment — Rhetorical Authority Analytical Essay
      150 mins
    • 1.7
      Occom’s Voice: A Mohegan Minister Writes His Own Record
      15 mins
  • Unit 2: Literacy as a Sovereign Act
    7
    • 2.1
      Introduction
      2 mins
    • 2.2
      A Nation Invents a Writing System
      45 mins
    • 2.3
      Language Lab — The Language of Law
      45 mins
    • 2.4
      Listening Lab — Boudinot, Ross, and the Editor Who Was Removed
      50 mins
    • 2.5
      Writing Workshop — Claim, Counterclaim and the Concession Paragraph
      50 mins
    • 2.6
      Key Assignment — Sovereignty Argument Essay
      150 mins
    • 2.7
      A Nation Writes Itself: Sequoyah, New Echota and the Constitution
      15 mins
  • Unit 3: Testimony, Evidence and the Courts
    7
    • 3.1
      Introduction
      2 mins
    • 3.2
      Sarah Winnemucca and the Book as Evidence
      45 mins
    • 3.3
      Language Lab — Parallel Structure, Antithesis and Public Cadence
      45 mins
    • 3.4
      Listening Lab — Standing Bear Before the Court
      50 mins
    • 3.5
      Writing Workshop — The Four-Sentence Rhetorical Precis
      50 mins
    • 3.6
      Key Assignment — Rhetorical Analysis and Audience Rewrite
      150 mins
    • 3.7
      The Book as Evidence: Winnemucca in the Great Basin and the Courtroom
      15 mins
  • Unit 4: Synthesis — Satire, the Report and the Record
    7
    • 4.1
      Introduction
      2 mins
    • 4.2
      Satire and the Record — Posey’s Fus Fixico Letters
      45 mins
    • 4.3
      Research Lab — Sources, Signal Phrases and Citing Community Knowledge
      50 mins
    • 4.4
      Media Lab — One Policy, Different Records
      50 mins
    • 4.5
      Writing Workshop — Synthesis as Braiding, Not Reporting
      50 mins
    • 4.6
      Key Assignment — Synthesis Research Paper and Digital Presentation
      200 mins
    • 4.7
      The Fire Circle and the Federal Record: Satire, Reports and Photographs
      15 mins

Language Lab — Parallel Structure, Antithesis and Public Cadence

Unit 3  ·  Rhetoric & Language Lab  ·  Lesson 12 of 20

Language Lab — Parallel Structure, Antithesis and Public Cadence

L.9-10.1.aENG9A-BIE
By the end of this lesson I can…

use parallel structure correctly in my own sentences, identify antithesis and anaphora in a speech, and explain what the grammar does that the content alone would not.

Instruction

In a late 19th-century American courtroom, a Ponca chief (Standing Bear) stands with dignity, raising his hand to address a sympathetic but stern white judge

Parallel structure means items doing the same grammatical job take the same grammatical form. It is a rule of correctness and, in speech, a source of power — which is why the CCSS treats it as a language standard and why the texts in this unit are full of it.

Correctness first.

  • Faulty: Winnemucca records names, dates, and that rations were withheld.
  • Parallel: Winnemucca records names, dates, and withheld rations.

Two nouns and a clause cannot share a list. The same rule governs paired constructions — not only… but also…, either… or… — which must join equivalent forms on each side.

Now the power. Parallelism makes a sentence predictable in form, which lowers the effort of following the content and makes any break in the pattern land like a change of key.

Antithesis sets opposed ideas in parallel form so the grammar performs the contrast. Standing Bear, in the passage you will read in the next lesson, holds up his hand and says: “That hand is not the color of yours, but if I prick it, the blood will flow, and I shall feel pain. The blood is of the same color as yours. God made me, and I am a man.”

Look at what the structure does. Not the color of yours — a concession, granted first. But if I prick it… the blood will flow… I shall feel pain — three parallel consequences. The blood is of the same color as yours — the contrast completed, in the same grammatical frame as the concession. The argument is carried by the symmetry: he grants the visible difference in order to make the invisible sameness undeniable.

Rewrite it unbalanced — although our skin color differs, we are physiologically the same and I am human — and the claim survives while the force does not. And notice something else: the balanced version can be spoken to a judge in a courtroom in 1879. The unbalanced version is a sentence from a textbook.

Anaphora is parallelism plus repetition at the head of successive clauses. Winnemucca: “You have taken our land; you have driven us from place to place…” Each repetition costs the audience nothing to process, so attention moves to the new material inside the frame, and the returning phrase accumulates weight.

Tricolon is the three-part parallel series — the smallest number that establishes a pattern and completes it in one breath.

The analytical move this lesson trains, and it connects to RI.9-10.5: do not stop at naming the device. Standing Bear uses antithesis to emphasize his point could be written by someone who had not read it. Ask instead: what does the structure let the speaker do that a plain statement could not? Here, it lets him concede the thing his listeners can see and use the concession as the ground for the claim they cannot dispute.

Reading: Mentor sentences for parallel structure, antithesis and anaphora, with a worked key

On the edge of an open plain in the late 1800s, a small circle of Northern Paiute women, including an elder, sit around a large outdoor fire at dusk

Standing Bear (Ponca), speech of 1879 (Tibbles, in The New York Times, 27 May 1906); William Apess (Pequot), Eulogy on King Philip (1836) and Indian Nullification (1835); Sarah Winnemucca Hopkins, Life Among the Piutes (1883); Thomas H. Tibbles, The Ponca Chiefs (1879); Elias Boudinot, An Address to the Whites (1826) | Text: https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/The_New_York_Times/1906/5/27/One_Case_Where_Carl_Schurz_Was_Not_on_the_Side_of_Human_Liberty; https://archive.org/download/eulogyonking00apesrich/eulogyonking00apesrich_djvu.txt; https://archive.org/download/lifeamongpiutes00manngoog/lifeamongpiutes00manngoog_djvu.txt; https://archive.org/download/poncchiefsanindi00tibbrich/poncchiefsanindi00tibbrich_djvu.txt; Project Gutenberg 12486; https://archive.org/download/addressto00boud/addressto00boud_djvu.txt · SLS original; quoted passages are public domain (Standing Bear via Tibbles, 1879 and 1906; Apess, 1835 and 1836; Winnemucca Hopkins, 1883; Boudinot, 1826)

Read each mentor aloud first. Then do exercise (a) to (c) before you read the worked key.

The lab teaches one structure, parallelism, in three strengths: correct parallel form in a series, antithesis, and anaphora. The mentors below are sentences by Native speakers and writers who used them in print (Standing Bear, Apess, Winnemucca, the Marshpee tribe, Boudinot). Read each aloud before you read the note under it. The exercise sentences (a) to (c) are in the lesson; the worked key follows the mentors.

Mentor sentences

A sequence of three vignettes shows a Pequot orator (William Apess) at a busy 1830s New England gathering, delivering a public speech from an elevated wooden platform M1: Standing Bear (Ponca), to Judge Elmer Dundy in Omaha, 1879, as Thomas H. Tibbles reported it (The New York Times, 27 May 1906)

That hand is not the color of yours, but if I prick it, the blood will flow and I shall feel pain. The blood is of the same color as yours. God made me, and I am a man.

Antithesis with the concession first. He grants the visible difference, and the next two sentences put the shared fact in the same frame.

M2: William Apess (Pequot), Eulogy on King Philip (Boston, 1836)

Look at the disgraceful laws, disfranchising us as citizens. Look at the treaties made by Congress, all broken. Look at the deep-rooted plans laid, when a territory becomes a State, that after so many years, the laws shall be extended over the Indians that live within their boundaries.

Anaphora: three sentences begin Look at the. The first two are short and the third runs long, so the pile-up is built into the sentence lengths.

M3: Sarah Winnemucca Hopkins (Northern Paiute), Life Among the Piutes (1883), chapter 1: the old women answering a prophecy about the coming of white people

We shall [no] longer be a happy people, as we now are; we shall no longer go here and there as of old; we shall no longer build our big fires as a signal to our friends, for we shall always be afraid of being seen by those bad people.

A tricolon with anaphora and negation. Each clause has the shape we shall no longer plus a verb phrase, and each names something lost. (The bracket marks a scan misprint in the source text, “po”.)

M4: Standing Bear (Ponca), refusing the order to leave the Niobrara, as reported in Thomas H. Tibbles, The Ponca Chiefs (Boston, 1879)

We have harmed no man. We have kept our treaty. We have learned to work.

Three short parallel sentences, each We have plus a past participle. The frame carries the claim, and it takes only nine words.

M5: The Marshpee tribe, resolutions adopted 21 May 1833, as printed in William Apess, Indian Nullification (1835)

Resolved, That we will rule our own tribe and make choice of whom we please for our preacher. Resolved, That we will have our own meeting house, and place in the pulpit whom we please to preach to us. Resolved, That we will publish this to the world;

Parallel clauses in a legal frame: Resolved, That we will plus a different verb phrase each time. Parallelism is what lets a list of promises read as one act.

M6: William Apess (Pequot), Indian Nullification of the Unconstitutional Laws of Massachusetts (1835)

Let them put our white neighbors in Barnstable County under the guardianship of a Board of Overseers, and give them no privileges other than have been allowed to the poor, despised Indians. Let them inflict upon the said whites a preacher whom they neither love nor respect, and do not wish to hear. Let them, in short, be treated just as the Marshpee tribe have been, I think there will soon be a declension of morals and population.

Anaphora as a thought experiment. Let them comes three times, and each time the white neighbors take the Marshpee’s place. The structure is the argument.

M7: Elias Boudinot (Cherokee), An Address to the Whites (Philadelphia, 1826)

Need I spend one moment in arguments, in favour of such an institution; need I speak one word of the utility, of the necessity, of an institution of learning; need I do more than simply to ask the patronage of benevolent hearts, to obtain that patronage.

Parallel rhetorical questions that shrink: one moment, one word, more than simply to ask. The reader is walked to the conclusion that no argument is needed.

Worked key for the exercise (SLS original)

Test. List the items, then ask what each one has to be. In (a) the items are all predicates that need a past-tense verb. In (b) they are all passive verbs. In (c) they are all things Standing Bear asked for, and each needs the same form after it.

Faulty sentenceRepairWhy it is faulty, and what the repair does
(a) Winnemucca lectured, wrote a book, and that she sold it at the lectures.Winnemucca lectured, wrote a book, and sold it at the lectures.A that-clause cannot share a list with two bare verbs. The repair makes three past-tense verbs, so the reader can see three things she did in order.
(b) The petition was signed, delivered, and Congress passed a bill.The petition was signed, delivered, and answered by a bill.Two passive verbs and then a full clause with a new subject break the pattern. Three passives keep the petition as the subject all the way through.
(c) Standing Bear asked for the right to bury his son, to return to his homeland, and that he be recognized as a person.Standing Bear asked for the right to bury his son, to return to his homeland, and to be recognized as a person.Two infinitives and a that-clause do not match. Three infinitives make three requests of the same kind, and the last one is the largest.

Anaphora rewrite of (a), with what it adds. Winnemucca lectured in the East; Winnemucca wrote a book; Winnemucca sold it at every lecture. The repeated subject puts her, and not the events, at the head of each clause. It adds an accumulating effort: three acts by the same actor, and the reader hears the effort repeat.

A device analysis that says what the structure does (SLS original)

Weak: Apess uses anaphora to emphasize his point. That sentence could be written about a speech nobody has read. Strong: In “Look at the disgraceful laws… Look at the treaties… Look at the deep-rooted plans,” Apess (M2) repeats the same command three times and lengthens each item, so that a Boston audience is told to inspect, one after another, the very documents its own government wrote. The repetition turns his listeners into the ones who must look. The strong version names the words, says what the structure does in this text, and names the audience.

Checklist for your own repairs

  1. List the items in the series.
  2. Say each one aloud after the same lead-in words.
  3. Rewrite the one that sounds wrong until it matches the others.
  4. Ask whether a repeated opening (anaphora) would help, and say what it adds.

Sources

M1: The New York Times, 27 May 1906, quoting Thomas H. Tibbles, on Wikisource. Tibbles reported the speech after it was interpreted, so it is a report and not a transcript. M2 and M7: Internet Archive copies of the 1836 and 1826 printings, retrieved 2026-09-26. M3: Internet Archive copy of the 1883 edition. M4: Internet Archive copy of the 1879 edition. M5 and M6: Project Gutenberg ebook 12486. Worked key, notes and device analysis SLS original.

Vocabulary in context

  • parallel structure — Items doing the same grammatical job take the same grammatical form.
  • antithesis — Opposed ideas in parallel form so the grammar performs the contrast.
  • anaphora — Repetition of the same words at the beginning of successive clauses.
  • tricolon — A three-part parallel series.
  • cadence — The rhythm a sentence’s structure produces when spoken.

Formative check

Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you, and your teacher, whether the standard below has landed yet.

+50 XP

Which sentence uses parallel structure correctly?

Every item in a series takes the same grammatical form. Read each aloud and listen for where the pattern breaks.
+50 XP

“That hand is not the color of yours, but if I prick it, the blood will flow, and I shall feel pain.” What does the balanced construction accomplish that a plain statement could not?

Look at what is conceded and where. The structure puts the undeniable claim in the same grammatical frame as the concession.
Myth or Fact?

Writing “Winnemucca uses anaphora to emphasize her point” is adequate analysis of the repeated “You have” construction.

Myth. That sentence could be written about any speech by someone who had not read this one. RI.9-10.5 asks how a particular construction develops the claim: here the repeated frame puts the audience in the grammatical subject position of every accusation.

Repair these for parallel structure, then rewrite one using anaphora and say what the repetition adds: (a) Winnemucca lectured, wrote a book, and that she sold it at the lectures. (b) The petition was signed, delivered, and Congress passed a bill. (c) Standing Bear asked for the right to bury his son, to return to his homeland, and that he be recognized as a person.

0 words
Quick self-check

How confident are you that you can hear a broken parallel in my own writing and repair it without being told which item is wrong?

Not yetVery confident

CCSS addressed in this lesson: L.9-10.1.a, RI.9-10.5, L.9-10.5.a, W.9-10.4

Essential Understandings addressed: EU6

Instructional pillar: Command of conventions in service of persuasive writing

Up NextComplete & Continue →

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Sarah Winnemucca and the Book as Evidence
Prev
Listening Lab — Standing Bear Before the Court
Next

© 2026 The VR School | Career content by Wiley | Powered by Sejal Learning Systems.

Join free · Accreditation · Privacy Policy · Terms of Service

Modal title

Main Content