assess a source for authority, purpose and currency, integrate it with a signal phrase and an MLA citation, and apply the different rules that govern citing community knowledge.
Instruction
Two questions govern this lesson: should I use this source, and how do I put it in my paragraph without stealing it. The second question has an extra part in this course.
Vetting a source. “Is it reliable?” is too blunt. Four narrower questions.
- Authority. Who wrote it, and what puts them in a position to know? Authority is domain-specific: a historian of federal policy is an authority on the Dawes Act and not on what a particular nation did in response.
- Purpose. What was it written to do? The Meriam Report was commissioned by the federal government to evaluate federal policy — which makes it unusually strong evidence, because its findings run against its sponsor’s interest.
- Currency. Does the date matter for this claim? For a 1928 audit of 1928 conditions, 1928 is the point. For a claim about what a nation thinks now, a 1928 source is evidence of 1928 and nothing else — and a great deal of writing about Native nations is written in a permanent past tense that the third Essential Understanding exists to correct.
- Corroboration. Does an independent source say the same thing?
Good places to look: the Internet Archive and HathiTrust for period documents; the National Archives and the Oklahoma Historical Society for federal and territorial records; DOAJ and university repositories for current scholarship; and tribal college and tribal nation websites, which are often the best available source on a nation’s own history and are routinely overlooked because they are not indexed like journals.
Integrating a source. Signal phrase naming the source and framing its stance, then the material, then your analysis — which must be longer than the borrowing.
MLA mechanics. Parenthetical author-page, punctuation outside: (Meriam 348). If the signal phrase names the source, the parenthesis carries the page only. Spell names correctly; a misspelt name in a citation is a citation failure.
Now the part that is specific to this research. Community knowledge is not cited the way a book is. Three rules:
- Attribute to a person and a nation, with their permission and in the form they chose. “An elder said” is not a citation; it erases the person. If they asked not to be named, say that a knowledge holder of the nation asked not to be named — which is itself accurate attribution.
- Ask before you record, and ask separately before you quote. Permission to hear something is not permission to write it down, and permission to write it down is not permission to publish it.
- Some knowledge is not for a paper. If you are told that, the answer is complete and you write around it. “This is held by the community and was not shared for this assignment” is an honest sentence and you will not be marked down for it.
None of this is red tape. It is the same principle as every citation rule: say where the knowledge came from, and do not take what was not given.
One line about language models. Generated text is not a source: it has no author in a position to know and no accountability for error. It is also, specifically, unreliable about tribal history and will state confident falsehoods about nations, treaties and events. Use it to help you understand a passage if you like; its sentences may not appear in your paper.
Reading: Vetting cards, a citation key and the rules for community knowledge, with Meriam Report passages to practice on
Lewis Meriam and staff, The Problem of Indian Administration (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins Press for the Institute for Government Research, 1928); SLS original vetting cards and citation key | Text: https://archive.org/download/ldpd_11418459_000/ldpd_11418459_000_djvu.txt · SLS original; quoted passages are public domain (Meriam et al., 1928)
Practice on R1 to R5 before you work with your own two sources.
The lab asks you to decide whether a source is fit for your claim, to work a quotation into your own sentence with a signal phrase and a correct MLA citation, and to cite community knowledge by rules that differ from the rules for a book. The passages below are from the 1928 Meriam Report, one of the sources for the unit. They are labeled R1 to R5 so you can practice on them. The worked vetting cards, the citation key, and the templates for community knowledge follow.
Practice passages from the Meriam Report
R1: the letter of transmittal
Sir: I have the honor to transmit herewith the report of the survey of the economic and social condition of the American Indians, made by the Institute for Government Research in accordance with your request of June 12, 1926.
Lewis Meriam and staff, The Problem of Indian Administration (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins Press for the Institute for Government Research, 1928)
R2: the general condition (page 3)
An overwhelming majority of the Indians are poor, even extremely poor, and they are not adjusted to the economic and social system of the dominant white civilization.
Same report
R3: health (page 3)
The health of the Indians as compared with that of the general population is bad.
Same report
R4: allotment (page 41)
The policy of individual allotment should be followed with extreme conservatism. Not accompanied by adequate instruction in the use of property, it has largely failed in the accomplishment of what was expected of it. It has resulted in much loss of land and an enormous increase in the details of administration without a compensating advance in the economic ability of the Indians.
Same report
R5: boarding schools (page 11)
The survey staff finds itself obliged to say frankly and unequivocally that the provisions for the care of the Indian children in boarding schools are grossly inadequate.
Same report
Page numbers come from the running heads of the 1928 printing, which sit on even pages only, so each is a count and not a printed number on the page itself. The quotation in R4 runs onto page 42.
Vetting: four questions, four worked cards (SLS original)
| Source | Authority | Purpose | Currency | Corroboration |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Problem of Indian Administration (1928) | Written by Lewis Meriam and a staff of specialists for the Institute for Government Research. | Made at the request of the Secretary of the Interior (R1), and it criticizes the programs of the office that requested it. That direction of travel makes its findings hard to dismiss. | Evidence of 1928 and of the policy period before it. It cannot speak for what any nation thinks now. | Ask whether tribal records, newspapers of the time, or the letters in Lesson 4.1 say the same thing. |
| The Ponca Chiefs (Tibbles, 1879) | The author was at the hearing and prints the record and the judge’s opinion. | Advocacy: the book was written to win support for the Ponca. It is strong evidence of what a supporter wanted the public to read. | Evidence of 1879. Later law has moved. | The opinion can be compared with the official report of the case. |
| Life Among the Piutes (1883) | Sarah Winnemucca Hopkins was present as interpreter and witness to what she reports. | To raise support for a petition; she sold the book at her lectures. | Evidence of 1883 events, seen from one witness. | The officers’ letters printed in the appendix support her account of her role. |
| The Poems of Alexander Lawrence Posey (1910) | Collected and arranged by Mrs. Minnie H. Posey, with a memoir by William Elsey Connelley. | A memorial volume after Posey’s death. The memoir is a tribute and gives its own view of his family. | Published two years after his death; the memoir reflects its date. | Check its biographical claims against records made in his lifetime. |
Two-sentence annotation, model (SLS original)
Meriam, Lewis, and Associates. The Problem of Indian Administration. Johns Hopkins P, 1928. This report gives a survey-based account of federal Indian administration in 1928, and its findings on allotment and on boarding schools come from a study the Secretary of the Interior requested. Its authority is strong on the conditions the survey counted and its date is a limit, because it is evidence of 1928 and says nothing about what nations think now.
Each annotation has exactly two sentences: what the source contributes, and where its authority, purpose or currency limits it. “There are no limitations” is never correct.
Integrating a source: the pattern and a key (SLS original)
Pattern: a signal phrase that names the source and frames its stance, then the quoted words, then the parenthetical citation, then your own analysis, which must be longer than the borrowing. MLA form gives the author and page with no comma and the period after the parenthesis.
| Exercise | Worked answer | What the answer teaches |
|---|---|---|
| Use R4 with a signal phrase that names the source. | The Meriam Report concludes that individual allotment “has largely failed in the accomplishment of what was expected of it” (41). | The signal phrase names the source, so the parenthesis carries the page alone. |
| Use R4 with no signal phrase. | Individual allotment “has resulted in much loss of land” (Meriam et al. 41). | With no signal phrase, the parenthesis names the source and the page. Punctuation goes after the parenthesis. |
| Use R2 and shorten the quotation. | The survey staff found that “an overwhelming majority of the Indians are poor” (Meriam et al. 3). | A short quoted clause worked into your own grammar keeps your sentence as the main sentence. |
| Paraphrase R3 and cite it. | The survey reported that the health of Indians was worse than that of the general population, with high death rates and widespread tuberculosis (Meriam et al. 3). | A paraphrase is cited too. |
| Quote R5 and change one word. | The staff called the care of children in boarding schools “grossly inadequate” (Meriam et al. 11). | A quoted phrase from a longer sentence needs no bracket if your sentence takes the words as they stand. |
Works Cited entry for this report: Meriam, Lewis, and Associates. The Problem of Indian Administration. Johns Hopkins P, 1928. Spell every name exactly as it appears, because a misspelled name in a citation is a citation failure.
Community knowledge is cited by different rules (SLS original)
- Attribute to a person and a nation, with their permission and in the form they chose. Template: (Last name, First name, [Nation], interview, date; used with permission).
- If the person asked not to be named, write: A knowledge holder of the [Nation] asked not to be named. That is accurate attribution.
- If you were told it is not for a paper, write around it: This knowledge is held by the community and was not shared for this assignment.
| Do not write | Why | Write instead |
|---|---|---|
| An elder told me that… | It erases the person and the nation. | Use template 1 or template 2. |
| A paraphrase of something you were asked not to publish. | Permission to hear is not permission to publish. | Template 3, and leave the content out. |
| Something you got from a language model. | Generated text has no author in a position to know, and it is unreliable about tribal history. | A source you found, read and cited. |
Ask before you record and ask separately before you quote. None of this is red tape: it is the same principle as every citation rule. Say where the knowledge came from and do not take what was not given.
Where to look for open-access sources
- The Internet Archive and HathiTrust for period documents.
- The National Archives (archives.gov) and the Oklahoma Historical Society for federal and territorial records.
- The Directory of Open Access Journals and university repositories for current scholarship.
- Tribal nation and tribal college websites, which are often the best source on a nation’s own history.
Sources
The Meriam Report: Lewis Meriam and staff, The Problem of Indian Administration (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins Press, 1928), Internet Archive copy ldpd_11418459_000, retrieved 2026-09-26. Vetting cards, annotation, citation key and community-knowledge templates SLS original.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you, and your teacher, whether the standard below has landed yet.
Why is the Meriam Report unusually strong evidence about the failure of federal Indian policy?
“An elder told me that…” is an acceptable citation for community knowledge.
A knowledge holder shares something with your class and then says it should not go in a written paper. What do you do?
When the signal phrase already names the source, the parenthetical citation carries the page alone the Report finds that allotment “has largely failed in the accomplishment of what was expected of it” 41.
Find two open-access secondary sources for your research question, at least one of them from a tribal nation or tribal college site. For each write an annotation of exactly two sentences: what it contributes, and where its authority, purpose or currency limits it. Then write one paragraph using one of them — signal phrase, borrowed material, your own analysis, with the analysis longer than the borrowing.
How confident are you that you can explain the difference between citing a book and citing knowledge a person shared with me?