produce a 1,000-word argumentative essay with a precise claim, a fairly developed counterclaim and a conclusion that follows from the argument, and defend it aloud against a peer’s objection.
Instruction
This is the unit’s summative assessment and the second of the semester’s four formal essays.
The prompt. What did the Cherokee documents of 1821-1832 establish, and what could they not secure? Argue a position on the relationship between the instruments and the outcome. You are not being asked to conclude that they achieved some things and not others; that answer is available to everyone and costs nothing.
Requirements. 1,000 words. A precise claim naming a mechanism. A full counterclaim paragraph developed fairly with its own evidence, using the four moves from Lesson 2.4. Evidence from at least three of the unit’s documents — the Constitution, a Phoenix editorial, the Worcester opinion, the Ross or Boudinot arguments. Quotations embedded and cited with the document named: (Cherokee Constitution, art. 1, sec. 2). A concluding section that follows from the argument.
On conclusions specifically, since W.9-10.1.e is assessed here. “In conclusion, the Cherokee Nation was sovereign” repeats the introduction with a signpost attached. A conclusion that follows from the argument answers what does this reading let a reader see? If your claim is that the instruments were built for a federal audience, then the fact that the Nation’s first move after the ruling was to keep publishing — to keep addressing that audience — is something your conclusion can name.
The oral component. After Stage 3, record a ninety-second defense: your claim, your strongest evidence, and the objection you found hardest. Then reply to two classmates using the Lesson 2.3 structure — summarize the agreement, name the divergence, qualify or justify. A typed transcript earns equal credit.
Two things this essay must not do. Do not write that the Cherokee documents represent what Native nations did, or that this history shows what happened to Native people. One nation, one decade, one set of instruments. Other nations facing the same federal policy acted differently for reasons that were theirs, and the rubric line on this is not decorative.
And do not deliver verdicts on Ross or Boudinot. Evaluate arguments.
On handling this material. Removal is not distant history and for some students in this room it is family history. If any part of this unit is difficult for you to work with, tell your instructor — the Constitution and the Worcester opinion carry every standard in the unit on their own, and using that pathway carries no penalty.
Academic honesty. The argument must be yours. The unit’s documents are the only texts you may reproduce, marked and cited. Text generated by a language model may not appear in the essay.
Reading: Documents, rubric and model for the Sovereignty Argument Essay
Cherokee Phoenix (1828); Worcester v. Georgia (1832); SLS original rubric and model | Text: Western Carolina University Hunter Library, Cherokee Phoenix digital collection (wcu.edu/library/DigitalCollections/CherokeePhoenix), issue 2 (28 Feb 1828); Western Carolina University Hunter Library, Cherokee Phoenix digital collection (wcu.edu/library/DigitalCollections/CherokeePhoenix), issue 1 (21 Feb 1828), Prospectus; Western Carolina University Hunter Library, Cherokee Phoenix digital collection (wcu.edu/library/DigitalCollections/CherokeePhoenix), issue 1 (21 Feb 1828); PG #29513 (the Gutenberg ebook) [not machine-checkable: includes text only on non-scriptable hosts; checked by hand] · SLS original; quoted passages are public domain (Cherokee Phoenix, 1828; U.S. Supreme Court opinion, 1832)
Your thesis must differ from the model thesis, and your counterclaim must be developed fairly, not restated in a sentence.
The Sovereignty Argument Essay is 1,000 words. It argues a claim about what the Cherokee documents of 1821 to 1832 established and what they could not secure, uses evidence from at least three of the unit’s documents, develops a counterclaim fairly, and ends with a conclusion that follows from the argument. The documents and how to cite them are below. The Constitution passages are in the reading for Lesson 2.1; the Boudinot and Ross passages (B and R) are in Lesson 2.3. Here are the Phoenix and Worcester passages you also need.
The prompt
What did the Cherokee documents of 1821 to 1832 establish, and what could they not secure? Argue a position on the relationship between the instruments and the outcome. Develop the opposing position fairly before you answer it. Write about the Cherokee Nation specifically, and do not write that these documents show what Native nations did. Evaluate Ross and Boudinot as arguers; do not deliver verdicts on them.
The documents and where each is
| Document | Cite as | Where |
|---|---|---|
| Constitution of the Cherokee Nation (1827) | (Cherokee Constitution, art. 1, sec. 2) | Lesson 2.1 reading |
| Cherokee Phoenix, 1828 | (Phoenix, P1), (Phoenix, P2), (Phoenix, P3) | Below |
| Worcester v. Georgia (1832) | (Worcester, W1 to W4) | Below |
| Boudinot and Ross, August 1832; Ross, 1837 | (Boudinot, B4), (Ross, R1), (Ross, R3) | Lesson 2.3 reading |
From the Cherokee Phoenix, 1828
P1: an editorial in the second number, on Georgia and the General Government
At such times as the present, we have been wont to look to the General Government for aid, and justice requires us to say, not in vain. We have full reason to believe that it will not now forsake us, and deliver us up to those who seek our hurt.
Cherokee Phoenix, 28 February 1828, “New Echota”
P2: the Prospectus
There are many true friends to the Indians in different parts of the Union, who will rejoice to see this feeble effort of the Cherokees to rise from their ashes, like the fabled PHOENIX.
Cherokee Phoenix, 28 February 1828
P3: “To the Public,” the editor to his readers
Let the public but consider our motives, and the design of this paper, which is, the benefit of the Cherokees, and we are sure, those who wish well to the Indian race, will keep out of view all the failings and deficiences [sic] of the Editor, and give a prompt support to the first paper ever published in the Indian country, and under the direction of some of the remnants of those, who by the most mysterious course of providence, have dwindled into oblivion.
Cherokee Phoenix, 21 February 1828
From Worcester v. Georgia, 1832
W1
The Cherokee nation, then, is a distinct community, occupying its own territory, with boundaries accurately described, in which the laws of Georgia can have no force, and which the citizens of Georgia have no right to enter, but with the assent of the Cherokees themselves, or in conformity with treaties, and with the acts of Congress.
John Marshall for the Court, 31 U.S. 515
W2
The very term, “nation,” so generally applied to them, means “a People distinct from others.”
W3
The act of the State of Georgia, under which the plaintiff in error was prosecuted, is consequently void, and the judgment a nullity.
W4
guaranty to them all the land within their boundary; solemnly pledge the faith of the United States to restrain their citizens from trespassing on it; and recognize the pre-existing power of the nation to govern itself.
Rubric (four levels)
| Criterion | Advanced (4) | Proficient (3) | Approaching (2) | Beginning (1) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Claim | Precise, names a mechanism, holds across the essay, and shows what the reading makes visible. | Precise and contestable, names a mechanism. | Vague or a sentiment. | Uncontested. |
| Counterclaim | Held-view recognizable, own evidence, answered on the merits. | Stated fairly and answered. | Brief and weak. | Strawman or absent. |
| Evidence range | Three or more documents, quotations analyzed in relation to each other. | Three documents, each quotation analyzed. | Two documents, or quotations dropped. | One document. |
| Conclusion | Follows from the argument and names what the reading makes visible. | Follows from the argument. | Repeats the introduction. | “In conclusion…” summary. |
| One nation, named | Cherokee Nation specific throughout; Ross and Boudinot evaluated as arguers. | Names the Nation; no generalizing to all Native nations. | Generalizes in places. | “Native people” throughout. |
| Conventions and MLA | Semicolons and colons precise; legal terms exact; citations name the document. | Minor slips. | Repeated errors. | Errors impede reading. |
A model thesis and outline (SLS original)
Thesis. The Cherokee instruments of 1827 to 1832 were built to persuade a federal audience, and with that audience they succeeded completely; their limit was that persuasion could not compel a state that had stopped caring what that audience thought.
- Introduction: the three instruments (Constitution, Phoenix, the case) and the thesis.
- Body 1: the Constitution is written in the form the federal audience would recognize (art. 1 and the preamble) and puts sovereign territory first.
- Body 2: the Phoenix addresses that audience directly (P1, P2, P3): it looks to “the General Government” for aid and says it has “full reason to believe” it will not forsake the Nation.
- Body 3 (counterclaim): Worcester is a success on the merits (W1, W3). Concede it fully, then turn: an affirmed and unenforced right (B4).
- Body 4: what the instruments could not do: the President’s refusal is the evidence (Boudinot B4; Ross R1 hoping for the General Government’s honor; Phoenix, H1).
- Conclusion: what the reading lets a reader see: the Phoenix kept publishing to an audience that had proved it could be convinced and could not be made to act.
A model conclusion (SLS original)
If the instruments were built to persuade a federal audience, the Nation’s next act after the ruling is the telling one: it went on publishing. The Phoenix kept addressing readers who had just shown they could be convinced and had not shown they would act. What the documents establish, then, is a claim that could not be answered in argument; what they could not secure is a remedy that argument does not supply.
Recording and process
After Stage 3, record a ninety-second defense (claim, strongest evidence, hardest objection) and reply to two classmates using the Lesson 2.3 structure. A typed transcript earns equal credit.
Sources
Cherokee Phoenix, vol. 1, nos. 1 and 2 (21 and 28 February 1828), Western Carolina University Hunter Library digital collections, retrieved 2026-09-26. Worcester v. Georgia, 31 U.S. 515 (1832), Project Gutenberg ebook #29513, retrieved 2026-09-26. Rubric, thesis, outline and conclusion SLS original. The essay may quote only these passages and the passages in the Lessons 2.1 and 2.3 readings.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you, and your teacher, whether the standard below has landed yet.
syllabary
Tap to revealA writing system in which each character stands for a syllable.
sovereignty
Tap to revealThe inherent authority of a nation to govern itself, separate from federal and state governments.
indefeasible
Tap to revealIncapable of being defeated or annulled.
counterclaim
Tap to revealAn opposing position stated fairly and supported with its own evidence.
constraint of position
Tap to revealWhat an office permitted a speaker to say.
Which conclusion satisfies W.9-10.1.e for this essay?
How confident are you that you can write a counterclaim paragraph that makes my own argument more convincing rather than less?
Submit: Sovereignty Argument Essay (1,000 words) + Socratic Defense
Prompt: What did the Cherokee documents of 1821-1832 establish, and what could they not secure? Argue a position on the relationship between the instruments and the outcome, and develop the opposing position fairly before answering it.
Stages open in sequence and are scored separately.
Submission workflow
- Stage 1 — Claim & counterclaim organizer. From Lesson 2.4. Scored on the precision of the claim and the fairness of the counterclaim.
- Stage 2 — Peer-reviewed rough draft (700+ words). Upload, complete the peer rubric for two classmates, then submit a revision note naming one specific change and the feedback that caused it.
- Stage 3 — Final revised essay (1,000 words) + Works Cited. MLA, PDF.
- Stage 4 — Recorded 90-second defense + two peer replies. Replies must summarize agreement, name the divergence, then qualify or justify. Transcript accepted for equal credit.
How it is scored
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Claim (W.9-10.1.a) | Precise and contestable; names a mechanism rather than a sentiment; holds across the essay. |
| Counterclaim (W.9-10.1.b) | Stated so its holders would recognize it, supported with its own evidence, then answered rather than dismissed. |
| Evidence range (RI.9-10.9) | Quotations from at least three of the unit’s documents, each analyzed, none dropped. |
| Conclusion (W.9-10.1.e) | Follows from the argument and names what the reading makes visible. |
| One nation, named (EU1, EU2) | Writes about the Cherokee Nation specifically and does not generalize to Native nations as a class; evaluates Ross and Boudinot as arguers rather than delivering verdicts on them. |
| Conventions & MLA (L.9-10.2.a, L.9-10.2.b) | Semicolons and colons correct; legal terms quoted exactly; citations name the document. |