write a four-sentence rhetorical precis that separates what a speaker claims from how the claim is developed, and use it as the skeleton of a longer critique.
Instruction
The rhetorical precis is four sentences and each has a fixed job. The constraint is the instruction: you cannot pad, so you discover immediately whether you understood the text or only agreed with it.
Sentence 1 — speaker, genre, occasion, and the claim. In Life Among the Piutes (1883), written and sold on a lecture tour to fund a petition to Congress, Sarah Winnemucca Hopkins contends that the suffering of the Northern Paiute was produced by the conduct of named federal agents rather than by circumstance.
The verb is load-bearing. Talks about and discusses are verbs of avoidance. Use asserts, contends, concedes, refutes, warns, demonstrates, questions — and mean it.
Sentence 2 — how the claim is developed. The method, in order, not the topics. She develops the claim by first establishing her own position as interpreter and witness, then narrating specific events with names, dates and numbers, and only then addressing her readers directly. This is where RI.9-10.5 lives: the order is part of the argument.
Sentence 3 — purpose, with “in order to.” Her purpose is to convert a general sympathy into a specific obligation in order to secure signatures on a petition that names a remedy. Purpose is what the writer wants to happen.
Sentence 4 — the relationship established with the audience. She addresses eastern readers as people with the power to act and no excuse for not knowing, a stance that converts their sympathy from a feeling into a debt.
That fourth sentence is the one students waste on “her tone is emotional.” It is the most valuable of the four, because it is where occasion, audience and power meet — and it usually hands you the thesis of the longer critique.
From precis to critique. Your 750-word critique is the precis with evidence in it. Sentence 2 becomes your body paragraphs, one per method. Sentence 4 becomes your thesis. Sentence 3 becomes your conclusion.
One discipline carried from Units 1 and 2: every claim about a technique must be anchored to a quoted phrase, and the analysis must say what the technique does here, to this audience. “Winnemucca uses vivid detail” fails. “Winnemucca names the agent and quotes his refusal, so a reader who wants to dismiss the account has to dismiss a named official’s reported words” passes.
Reading: A mentor text, a model precis, a revision and the Stage 1 criteria
William Apess (Pequot), Indian Nullification of the Unconstitutional Laws of Massachusetts Relative to the Marshpee Tribe (Boston, 1835), Project Gutenberg 12486; SLS original models | Text: Project Gutenberg 12486 · SLS original; quoted passages are public domain (Apess, 1835)
Write your own precis of your chosen text before you compare it with the model.
Stage 1 of the Key Assignment asks for four things: a four-sentence rhetorical precis, a thesis drawn from sentence 4, three topic sentences drawn from sentence 2, and one quoted phrase for each paragraph. This reading gives you a mentor text to practice on, a model precis of it, a weak precis and its revision, and the criteria Stage 1 is scored against. The mentor is William Apess (Pequot), writing about the Marshpee of Massachusetts in 1835. You will do the same steps on the text you choose from the unit.
The mentor paragraphs
A1: how the overseers handled Marshpee wages
At one time, it was the practice of the Overseers, when the Indians hired themselves to their neighbors, to receive their wages, and dispose of them at their own discretion. Sometimes an Indian bound on a whaling voyage would earn four or five hundred dollars, and the shipmaster would account to the overseers for the whole sum. The Indian would get some small part of his due, in order to encourage him to go again, and gain more for his white masters, to support themselves and educate their children with. And this is but a specimen of the systematic course taken to degrade the tribe from generation to generation. I could tell of one of our masters who has not only supported himself and family out of the proceeds of our lands and labors, but has educated a son at College, at our expense. It is true that if any Indian elected to leave the plantation, he might settle and accumulate property elsewhere, and be free; but if he dared to return home with his property, it was taken out of his hands by the Board of Overseers, according to the unjust law. His property had no more protection from their rapacity than the rest of the plantation. In the name of Heaven, (with due reverence,) I ask, what people could improve under laws which gave such temptation and facility to plunder?
William Apess, Indian Nullification of the Unconstitutional Laws of Massachusetts Relative to the Marshpee Tribe (1835)
A2: the test, and the general claim
I think such experiments as our government have made ought to be seldom tried. If the government of Massachusetts do not see fit to believe me, I would fain propose to them a test of the soundness of my reasoning. Let them put our white neighbors in Barnstable County under the guardianship of a Board of Overseers, and give them no privileges other than have been allowed to the poor, despised Indians. Let them inflict upon the said whites a preacher whom they neither love nor respect, and do not wish to hear. Let them, in short, be treated just as the Marshpee tribe have been, I think there will soon be a declension of morals and population. We shall see if they will be able to build up a town in such circumstances. Any enterprising men who may be among them will soon seek another home and society, which it is not in the power of the Indians to do, on account of their color. Could they have been received and treated by the world as other people are, there would not be so many living in Marshpee as there are by half. The laws were calculated to drive the tribe from their possessions, and annihilate them, as a people; and I presume they would work the same effect upon any other people; for human nature is the same under skins of all colors. Degradation is degradation, all the world over.
Same pamphlet
A model rhetorical precis of A1 and A2 (SLS original)
- Speaker, occasion, verb, claim. In Indian Nullification (1835), a pamphlet addressed to the white people of Massachusetts after a dispute over the Marshpee tribe’s right to choose its own preacher, William Apess argues that the poverty of the Marshpee was produced by the law that placed them under a board of overseers, and not by anything in the people themselves.
- Method, in order. He develops the claim by first describing a specific practice, the overseers collecting an Indian whaler’s wages, then calling it a “specimen” of a system, and finally proposing that Massachusetts test his reasoning by placing its own white citizens under the same law.
- Purpose, with “in order to.” His purpose is to remove the excuse that the Marshpee failed because of their race, in order to make the guardianship law, and not the tribe, the thing his readers hold to account.
- Relationship with the audience. He addresses his white readers as the people who made the law and are able to change it, and he asks them to imagine themselves under it, so that the argument reads as a demand from an equal and not a plea from a ward.
From the precis to Stage 1 (SLS original)
| Stage 1 part | Derived from | Model |
|---|---|---|
| Thesis | Sentence 4 | Apess makes his white readers the subjects of his argument, and the reversal in A2 does more than the evidence in A1 to move the guilt from the tribe to the law. |
| Topic sentence 1 | Sentence 2, first method | Apess begins with one concrete practice, the collection of a whaler’s wages, so that a reader who wants to dismiss the claim must answer a specific example. |
| Topic sentence 2 | Sentence 2, second method | He then names that example a “specimen,” which turns a single case into evidence about a whole system. |
| Topic sentence 3 | Sentence 2, third method | His last move is a test that reverses the roles of the Marshpee and their white neighbors, which makes the reader’s own position the evidence. |
| Quoted phrases, one per paragraph | The mentor text | “this is but a specimen of the systematic course”; “Let them put our white neighbors”; “human nature is the same under skins of all colors” |
Check: each topic sentence names a method (a concrete example, a generalization, a reversal), not a topic. Each quoted phrase is exact and short, and each will be followed by a sentence that says what the phrase does in this text.
A weak precis, and its revision (SLS original)
| Sentence | Weak version | What is wrong | Revised version |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | In this passage Apess talks about how the Marshpee were treated badly by the overseers. | “Talks about” names no argumentative action, and “treated badly” is not a claim someone could deny. | William Apess argues that the law placing the Marshpee under overseers, and not the tribe, produced their poverty. |
| 2 | He discusses the law and gives an example. | It lists topics and does not give the order of the moves. | He moves from one specific practice to the system it represents, and then to a test that reverses the roles. |
| 3 | He wants people to know. | Purpose is left empty. It says what he wants people to have, and not what he wants to happen. | He wants the readers to hold the law, and not the tribe, to account. |
| 4 | His tone is angry. | It names a feeling. The fourth sentence has to name the stance toward the audience. | He treats his white readers as the authors of the law, and as able to change it. |
Criteria for Stage 1 (four levels)
| Criterion | Advanced (4) | Proficient (3) | Approaching (2) | Beginning (1) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Precis, sentence 1 | Speaker, occasion, an accurate verb and a claim that could be denied. | Speaker, occasion and verb; the claim is stated but general. | A verb like “talks about”; claim left out. | A topic only. |
| Precis, sentence 2 | Method described in order, one clause per move. | Method described; order is loose. | A list of topics. | Missing. |
| Precis, sentences 3 and 4 | Purpose uses “in order to” and names an outcome; the audience relationship names who holds power. | Both present; one is vague. | Purpose is a wish; audience is a feeling. | Missing. |
| Thesis and topic sentences | The thesis comes from sentence 4; each topic sentence names a method, not a topic. | Thesis comes from the precis; topic sentences mix methods and topics. | A thesis that is a fact; topic sentences are topics. | No thesis. |
| Quoted phrases | One exact, short phrase per paragraph, chosen to show the method. | One phrase per paragraph; some long. | Some paragraphs without a phrase. | No quotation. |
Sources
William Apess, Indian Nullification of the Unconstitutional Laws of Massachusetts Relative to the Marshpee Tribe: or, The Pretended Riot Explained (Boston, 1835), Project Gutenberg ebook 12486, retrieved 2026-09-26. The model precis, derivation, revision and criteria are SLS original.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you, and your teacher, whether the standard below has landed yet.
Which opening sentence of a rhetorical precis is strongest?
The second sentence of a rhetorical precis should list the topics the writer covers.
The third sentence of a rhetorical precis names the writer’s purpose using the phrase “in order “, and the fourth describes the the writer establishes with the audience.
Submit Stage 1: (1) the full four-sentence rhetorical precis of your chosen text; (2) the thesis for your critique, derived from sentence 4; (3) three body-paragraph topic sentences derived from sentence 2, each naming a method rather than a topic; (4) one quoted phrase per paragraph.
How confident are you that you can write the second precis sentence as a description of method and order rather than a list of topics?