produce a 1,200-1,500 word MLA synthesis research paper that reaches a position on the semester’s essential question, publish it digitally, and present the findings in four to five minutes using visual media that carries information my narration does not.
Instruction
This is the semester’s culminating assessment and the fourth formal essay.
The essential question. When a policy is described by the government that made it and by the people it was made about, what can each account see that the other cannot? Answer it. A paper that reports what various sources said and concludes the matter is complex has not answered it.
Requirements. 1,200-1,500 words. Evidence from at least one literary text, the Meriam Report, and at least two vetted open-access secondary sources. A governing claim stated in the introduction and defended, not surveyed. Braided paragraphs in which your analysis outweighs the borrowing. Signal phrases and MLA citation throughout, with a Works Cited page and the annotated bibliography attached. At least one paragraph in which you disagree with a secondary source, having represented it fairly.
Two requirements specific to this course. Name nations precisely. Posey was Muscogee (Creek) and wrote about what allotment did in the Creek Nation; the Meriam Report surveyed conditions across many nations and treated them as one administrative problem, which is itself a finding your paper can make. A paper that writes “the Indians” where a nation belongs has not met the first Essential Understanding, and the rubric says so. And keep the tense honest: the nations in this paper exist now. Writing about them entirely in the past tense is a claim, and not one you mean to make.
The digital publication requirement (W.9-10.6). Submit as a formatted PDF and publish to your course portfolio page where classmates can read it.
The presentation (SL.9-10.4, SL.9-10.5). Four to five minutes, with slides, an infographic or a concept diagram. At least one visual must carry information your narration does not. A slide reproducing your spoken sentences fails. A matrix of what each kind of record can and cannot establish, a to-scale map, a timeline of the policy periods against the texts — these pass. Do not use boarding-school photographs of identifiable children as illustration.
Peer evaluation. Each student evaluates two classmates’ presentations, naming one persuasive element and one specific, actionable improvement. Scored on specificity.
Accessibility and alternatives. Every recording needs a transcript or captions, which is part of the submission. A student who prefers not to record may deliver live in a scheduled session with the annotated visual and script; both routes earn full credit.
Academic honesty. Every borrowed idea is cited whether quoted or paraphrased, and community knowledge is cited under the rules from Lesson 4.2. Text generated by a language model is not a source and may not appear in the paper — and is specifically unreliable about tribal history.
Reading: The prompt, key passages, the rubric and a worked exemplar for the synthesis paper
The Dawes Act (24 Stat. 388, 1887); Lewis Meriam and staff, The Problem of Indian Administration (1928); Alexander Posey (Muscogee Creek), Fus Fixico letters (1903), see the reading for Lesson 4.1; SLS original rubric and exemplar | Text: https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Dawes_Act; https://archive.org/download/ldpd_11418459_000/ldpd_11418459_000_djvu.txt · SLS original; quoted passages are public domain (federal statute, 1887; Meriam et al., 1928)
Answer the essential question; do not survey.
This reading gives you the full prompt, the key passages the paper draws on and where each comes from, the rubric at four levels, a model thesis and outline, and a worked exemplar of a braided paragraph and a disagreement paragraph. The Posey letters are in the reading for Lesson 4.1 (passages F1 to F4, from the Vinita Daily Chieftain of 16 June and 9 November 1903); the Meriam Report and the Dawes Act passages are here.
The prompt
Essential question. When a policy is described by the government that made it and by the people it was made about, what can each account see that the other cannot? Answer it in a paper of 1,200 to 1,500 words that synthesizes evidence from at least one literary text, the Meriam Report and at least two open-access secondary sources you have vetted, and that reaches a position. Introduce each source with a signal phrase, cite in MLA form, and give an annotated working bibliography with two sentences per entry. Then record a presentation of four to five minutes with a visual that carries information your narration does not, and evaluate two classmates’ presentations.
Key passages and where they come from
| Text | Where to find it | Used for |
|---|---|---|
| Posey, the Fus Fixico letters (1903) | Lesson 4.1 reading, F1 to F4; Vinita Daily Chieftain, 16 June 1903, p. 2, and 9 November 1903, p. 1 | The literary account: people subject to the policy, talking about it |
| The Meriam Report (1928) | Below, R1, R2 and R5; the page numbers are counted from the running heads of the printing | The government’s own audit |
| The Dawes Act (1887) | Below, L2, section 5 | What the government promised |
L2: the promise (section 5 of the Dawes Act)
Sec. 5. That upon the approval of the allotments provided for in this act by the Secretary of the Interior, he shall cause patents to issue therefor in the name of the allottees, which patents shall be of the legal effect, and declare that the United States does and will hold the land thus allotted, for the period of twenty-five years, in trust for the sole use and benefit of the Indian to whom such allotment shall have been made, or, in case of his decease, of his heirs according to the laws of the State or Territory where such land is located, and that at the expiration of said period the United States will convey the same by patent to said Indian, or his heirs as aforesaid, in fee, discharged of said trust and free of all charge or incumbrance whatsoever:
An Act to provide for the allotment of lands in severalty to Indians (24 Stat. 388), approved 8 February 1887
R1: the general condition (Meriam, page 3)
An overwhelming majority of the Indians are poor, even extremely poor, and they are not adjusted to the economic and social system of the dominant white civilization.
Lewis Meriam and staff, The Problem of Indian Administration (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins Press, 1928)
R2: allotment (Meriam, page 41)
The policy of individual allotment should be followed with extreme conservatism. Not accompanied by adequate instruction in the use of property, it has largely failed in the accomplishment of what was expected of it. It has resulted in much loss of land and an enormous increase in the details of administration without a compensating advance in the economic ability of the Indians.
Same report
R5: boarding schools (Meriam, page 11)
The survey staff finds itself obliged to say frankly and unequivocally that the provisions for the care of the Indian children in boarding schools are grossly inadequate.
Same report
R5 concerns the care of children. Cite it as a finding of the Report and do not use images from the boarding schools; the photographs of identifiable children are institutional records, not illustration.
Rubric (four levels)
| Criterion | Advanced (4) | Proficient (3) | Approaching (2) | Beginning (1) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Governing claim | States a position on the essential question in the introduction and defends it in every section. | States a position; one section drifts. | A survey of sources, with a claim at the end. | No claim. |
| Synthesis | Sources are braided into paragraphs the writer’s claim governs; the writer’s analysis outweighs borrowed material. | Mostly braided; some paragraphs in sequence. | Reports source by source. | Copies sources. |
| Range and use of evidence | A literary text, the Meriam Report and two vetted secondary sources; one paragraph disagrees with a source after representing it fairly. | All sources used; disagreement is thin. | Missing a source type. | One source. |
| Nations named, tense honest | Names specific nations where a nation belongs; does not write “the Indians”; does not put living nations wholly in the past. | A lapse or two. | Frequent general terms. | Uses “the Indians” throughout. |
| Research integrity | Signal phrases, accurate MLA, names spelled correctly, an annotated bibliography that matches what was read, community knowledge cited under the Lesson 4.2 rules. | Two or three slips. | Uneven citation. | Uncited borrowing. |
| Presentation | Four to five minutes; a visual that carries information the narration does not; a transcript; two structured peer evaluations that name one persuasive element and one actionable improvement. | All present; the visual partly repeats the narration. | Visual repeats the narration. | No visual. |
A model thesis and outline (SLS original)
Thesis. Each account sees what its maker was built to see: the government’s audit can count what allotment did to land and administration, and Posey’s letters can register how the people subject to the policy talked about the men who ran it, so neither account is complete, and each leaves out what the other holds.
- Introduction: the question, the thesis, and the two Nations and the policy named (Muscogee (Creek) Nation and allotment in Indian Territory).
- What the Act promised (L2) and what the audit found (R2): scale and verdict.
- What the letters register (Lesson 4.1, F3 and F4): who lines up for the offices statehood created.
- A paragraph that disagrees with a source after stating it fairly (see below).
- What a photograph, a roll or a form can and cannot establish; the matrix.
- Conclusion: what a reader must hold in mind when using either account.
A braided paragraph (SLS original)
The Act and the Report fail at opposite ends of the same question. Section 5 of the Act pledges that the United States “does and will hold the land thus allotted, for the period of twenty-five years, in trust for the sole use and benefit of the Indian” (L2), and the survey staff found forty-one years later that allotment “has resulted in much loss of land” (Meriam 41). The Report can establish that the loss was general because a survey is built to count. It cannot say what the process sounded like to anyone inside it, and the letters can. Neither account is incomplete by accident: each is limited by the thing that makes it useful.
A disagreement paragraph (SLS original)
The Report attributes the failure of allotment to a lack of teaching: allotment was “not accompanied by adequate instruction in the use of property” (Meriam 41). That is a fair reading of what the survey staff could count, and it deserves credit for naming a remedy. But the letters raise a different question. F4 lists the offices statehood created and the men waiting to fill them, which is evidence that the change had winners, and the sentence in the Report does not ask who they were. The Report may be right about the missing teaching and still leave that question open.
A visual that passes the eyes-shut test (SLS original)
| Kind of record | Can establish | Cannot establish |
|---|---|---|
| Statute (Dawes Act) | What the government promised and authorized | What the promise did in practice |
| Audit (Meriam Report) | Scale, pattern, verdict | A voice; what the fields left out |
| Satirical letter (Fus Fixico) | How the policy was talked about by people subject to it | How many people, and how much land |
| Enrollment card or roll | Who was counted, and in which category | How any person understood themselves |
The eyes-shut test: if you read the slide aloud, the audience should learn nothing new from the narration alone, and if you close your eyes, you should not be able to reproduce the matrix from the narration. A matrix with cells you do not read aloud passes; a slide listing your four points fails.
Sources
The Dawes Act: Wikisource transcription of the act of 8 February 1887. The Meriam Report: Internet Archive copy ldpd_11418459_000. Retrieved 2026-09-26. Prompt, rubric, thesis, outline, model paragraphs and matrix SLS original.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you, and your teacher, whether the standard below has landed yet.
synthesis
Tap to revealWriting in which the author’s claim governs and sources are brought in to serve it.
allotment
Tap to revealFederal policy dividing communally held tribal land into individual parcels.
institutional record
Tap to revealA document made by an institution for its own purposes — evidence of intent before evidence of fact.
knowledge holder
Tap to revealA person who holds community knowledge, attributed by name and nation with permission.
convention vs. choice
Tap to revealWhat a genre supplied, against what the author did with it.
Which visual satisfies the requirement that at least one visual carry information the narration does not?
How confident are you that you can write a research paper that reaches a position on the essential question instead of surveying what others have said?
Submit: Synthesis Research Paper (1,200-1,500 words) + Digital Presentation
Essential question: When a policy is described by the government that made it and by the people it was made about, what can each account see that the other cannot? Synthesize evidence from a literary text, the Meriam Report and at least two vetted secondary sources, and reach a position.
Stages open in sequence and are scored separately.
Submission workflow
- Stage 1 — Research question, annotated bibliography and one braided paragraph. From Lesson 4.4. The annotations, the permissions recorded for any community source, and the statement of how the question changed are all scored.
- Stage 2 — Peer-reviewed rough draft (900+ words). Upload, peer-review two classmates, then submit a revision note naming one specific change and the feedback behind it.
- Stage 3 — Final paper (1,200-1,500 words) + Works Cited + annotated bibliography. PDF, and published to your course portfolio page.
- Stage 4 — Recorded presentation (4-5 minutes) with visual media and transcript, plus two structured peer evaluations. Live delivery in a scheduled session is an equal-credit alternative.
How it is scored
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Governing claim (W.9-10.2, W.9-10.7) | States a position on the essential question and defends it; does not survey sources and declare complexity. |
| Synthesis (W.9-10.7) | Sources braided into paragraphs the writer’s claim governs; the writer’s analysis outweighs borrowed material. |
| Range and use of evidence (W.9-10.8) | A literary text, the Meriam Report and two vetted secondary sources; one paragraph disagrees with a source after representing it fairly. |
| Nations named, tense honest (EU1, EU3) | Names specific nations where a nation belongs and does not write ‘the Indians’; does not place living nations entirely in the past tense. |
| Research integrity (W.9-10.8, L.9-10.2.c) | Signal phrases, accurate MLA, correctly spelled names, annotated bibliography matching what was read, community knowledge cited under the Lesson 4.2 rules. |
| Presentation (SL.9-10.4, SL.9-10.5) | Four to five minutes; at least one visual carries information the narration does not; transcript supplied; no photographs of identifiable children used as illustration. |