THE VR SCHOOL
  • Schools & Districts
    • License the academy
    • Free program for your students
    • Request a demo
  • Catalog
    • AI & Data
    • Cybersecurity & Web
    • Programming
    • Health Science
    • All Guilds
    • All courses
  • Families
  • Accreditation
  • Log In
  • Request a demo
  • Home
  • Courses

English 9A — The Written Word and the Rights of Nations

Curriculum

  • 4 Sections
  • 28 Lessons
  • 10 Weeks
Expand all sectionsCollapse all sections
  • Unit 1: The Native Public Voice, 1768–1836
    7
    • 1.1
      Introduction
      2 mins
    • 1.2
      Samson Occom and the Account That Was Not Printed
      45 mins
    • 1.3
      Language Lab — Semicolons, Conjunctive Adverbs and the Analytical Sentence
      40 mins
    • 1.4
      Seminar — Apess’s Looking-Glass: Who Is the Argument For?
      50 mins
    • 1.5
      Writing Workshop — Thesis, Topic Sentence and the Embedded Quotation
      50 mins
    • 1.6
      Key Assignment — Rhetorical Authority Analytical Essay
      150 mins
    • 1.7
      Occom’s Voice: A Mohegan Minister Writes His Own Record
      15 mins
  • Unit 2: Literacy as a Sovereign Act
    7
    • 2.1
      Introduction
      2 mins
    • 2.2
      A Nation Invents a Writing System
      45 mins
    • 2.3
      Language Lab — The Language of Law
      45 mins
    • 2.4
      Listening Lab — Boudinot, Ross, and the Editor Who Was Removed
      50 mins
    • 2.5
      Writing Workshop — Claim, Counterclaim and the Concession Paragraph
      50 mins
    • 2.6
      Key Assignment — Sovereignty Argument Essay
      150 mins
    • 2.7
      A Nation Writes Itself: Sequoyah, New Echota and the Constitution
      15 mins
  • Unit 3: Testimony, Evidence and the Courts
    7
    • 3.1
      Introduction
      2 mins
    • 3.2
      Sarah Winnemucca and the Book as Evidence
      45 mins
    • 3.3
      Language Lab — Parallel Structure, Antithesis and Public Cadence
      45 mins
    • 3.4
      Listening Lab — Standing Bear Before the Court
      50 mins
    • 3.5
      Writing Workshop — The Four-Sentence Rhetorical Precis
      50 mins
    • 3.6
      Key Assignment — Rhetorical Analysis and Audience Rewrite
      150 mins
    • 3.7
      The Book as Evidence: Winnemucca in the Great Basin and the Courtroom
      15 mins
  • Unit 4: Synthesis — Satire, the Report and the Record
    7
    • 4.1
      Introduction
      2 mins
    • 4.2
      Satire and the Record — Posey’s Fus Fixico Letters
      45 mins
    • 4.3
      Research Lab — Sources, Signal Phrases and Citing Community Knowledge
      50 mins
    • 4.4
      Media Lab — One Policy, Different Records
      50 mins
    • 4.5
      Writing Workshop — Synthesis as Braiding, Not Reporting
      50 mins
    • 4.6
      Key Assignment — Synthesis Research Paper and Digital Presentation
      200 mins
    • 4.7
      The Fire Circle and the Federal Record: Satire, Reports and Photographs
      15 mins

Key Assignment — Rhetorical Analysis and Audience Rewrite

Unit 3  ·  Culminating Unit Assessment  ·  Lesson 15 of 20

Key Assignment — Rhetorical Analysis and Audience Rewrite

W.9-10.4ENG9A-BIE
By the end of this lesson I can…

produce a 750-word rhetorical critique anchored in quoted evidence, rewrite a passage for a contemporary audience while preserving its argument, and deliver the rewrite aloud in appropriate formal English.

Instruction

A group of high school students sitting at desks in a classroom, each looking at a different printed book or facsimile manuscript representing early Native American rhetoricians

This is the unit’s summative assessment and the third of the semester’s four formal essays. Four parts, and the fourth is where SL.9-10.6 is assessed.

Choose your text. Sarah Winnemucca Hopkins, Life Among the Piutes; Standing Bear’s address; William Apess, “An Indian’s Looking-Glass” or the Eulogy; a Cherokee Phoenix editorial; or Samson Occom’s narrative. All are public domain. You may not choose a text you have already written about this year.

Part 1 — Rhetorical precis. Four sentences, the structure from Lesson 3.4. Submitted at Stage 1.

Part 2 — Rhetorical critique, 750 words. A thesis drawn from precis sentence 4. Three to four body paragraphs, each on a method — the sourcing of evidence, a structural choice, the naming of individuals, a device — not on a topic. Every claim anchored to a quoted phrase and analyzed for what it does in this text, to this audience. At least one paragraph must address a choice that works against the writer’s apparent interest, or a moment where the argument is exposed.

Part 3 — Audience rewrite, about 150 words, plus annotations. Rewrite one passage for contemporary ninth-grade students. The argument must survive intact — this is a translation of register, not a change of position. Annotate three choices: a word replaced and why, a sentence restructured and what was preserved, and a reference updated and what was lost in the update. That third clause is the criterion. A rewrite without annotations cannot be assessed.

A caution specific to these texts. If you rewrite Winnemucca or Standing Bear, you are handling accounts of deaths and of a family separation. The rewrite must not make them easier to read by making them vaguer — the specificity is the argument. If you find the only way to lower the register is to blur what happened, say so in an annotation; that is a real finding and it will be credited.

Part 4 — Recorded delivery, two minutes. Deliver the rewritten passage aloud. You are assessed on adapting speech to context — pacing, emphasis where your own structure puts it, formal English appropriate to an academic audience — not on performance or confidence. A student who prefers not to record may submit an annotated script and deliver in a scheduled session; both routes earn full credit.

One requirement carried through the semester. Name the nation. “A Native speaker” is not who Standing Bear was; he was Ponca, and the removal he describes was the removal of the Ponca. The rubric line on this is not decorative.

Academic honesty. The critique and rewrite must be yours. The chosen text is the only one you may reproduce, marked and cited.

Reading: The prompt, an archive passage from each text, the rubric and a worked exemplar

A student at a wooden desk, writing notes on lined notebook paper while referencing a printed excerpt from a 19th-century Native American speech

Sarah Winnemucca Hopkins (Northern Paiute), Life Among the Piutes (1883); Standing Bear (Ponca), speech of 1879, in The New York Times, 27 May 1906; William Apess (Pequot), Eulogy on King Philip (1836); Samson Occom (Mohegan), A Short Narrative of My Life (1768); SLS original rubric and exemplar | Text: https://archive.org/download/lifeamongpiutes00manngoog/lifeamongpiutes00manngoog_djvu.txt; https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/The_New_York_Times/1906/5/27/One_Case_Where_Carl_Schurz_Was_Not_on_the_Side_of_Human_Liberty; https://archive.org/download/eulogyonking00apesrich/eulogyonking00apesrich_djvu.txt; https://teachingamericanhistory.org/document/a-short-narrative-of-my-life/ · SLS original; quoted passages are public domain (Winnemucca Hopkins, 1883; Standing Bear via Tibbles, 1906; Apess, 1836; Occom, 1768)

Choose one text. Your rewrite must keep the specifics that carry the argument.

This is the reading for the Rhetorical Analysis Project: the full prompt, a short passage from each text you may choose, the rubric for all four parts at four levels, and a worked exemplar (a precis, a thesis and outline, a model paragraph, and an audience rewrite with three annotations). Every task can be done from this page and from the reading for the lesson on your chosen text. Choose one text, complete the four parts, and cite your text by passage label.

The prompt

A student standing confidently in front of a small group, holding a printed script with annotated markings, and delivering a passage aloud Select one text from the unit archive. (1) Write a four-sentence rhetorical precis naming the speaker and occasion, the claim, the method by which the claim is developed, and the relationship the speaker establishes with the audience. (2) Write a 750-word rhetorical critique that explains how specific choices advance the speaker’s purpose: the sourcing of evidence, the naming of individuals, structural order, parallel construction, and the management of a reader or listener who has power over the outcome. Every claim is anchored to a quoted phrase, and at least one paragraph addresses a choice that works against the writer’s interest or a point where the argument is exposed. (3) Rewrite a passage of about 150 words for contemporary ninth-grade students, keeping the argument and changing the register, and annotate three choices, including what each one cost. (4) Record two minutes of the rewritten passage, or submit an annotated script and deliver it in a scheduled session; both routes earn full credit.

The archive: one passage from each text

Each passage is a place to start, not a limit. The whole text you choose is available in the course; if you choose the Cherokee Phoenix option, use the passages labeled B1 to B5 in the Lesson 2.3 reading.

Option 1, Winnemucca A: the officer’s order

Sarah, an order is issued that your people are to be taken to Yakima Reservation, across the Columbia River.” I said, “All of my people?” “No, not your father’s, but all that are here.” I asked, “What for?” He said he did not know.

Sarah Winnemucca Hopkins (Northern Paiute), Life Among the Piutes (1883), chapter 8

Option 1, Winnemucca B: her answer

It was just a little before Christmas. My people were only given one week to get ready in. I said, “What! In this cold winter and in all this snow, and my people have so many little children? Why, they will all die. Oh, what can the President be thinking about? Oh, tell me, what is he? Is he man or beast? Yes, he must be a beast; if he has no feeling for my people, surely he ought to have some for the soldiers.” “I have never seen a president in my life and I want to know whether he is made of wood or rock, for I cannot for once think that he can be a human being. No human being would do such a thing as that, — send people across a fearful mountain in midwinter.”

Same, chapter 8

Option 2, Standing Bear A: the hand

That hand is not the color of yours, but if I prick it, the blood will flow and I shall feel pain. The blood is of the same color as yours. God made me, and I am a man. I never committed a crime. If I had, I would not stand here to make a defense. I would suffer the punishment and make no complaint.

Standing Bear (Ponca), Omaha, 1879, as reported by Thomas H. Tibbles (The New York Times, 27 May 1906)

Option 2, Standing Bear B: the river

I seem to be standing on the high bank of a great river, with my wife and little girl by my side. I cannot cross the river, and impassable cliffs arise behind me.

Same report

Option 3, Apess: the laws

Look at the disgraceful laws, disfranchising us as citizens. Look at the treaties made by Congress, all broken. Look at the deep-rooted plans laid, when a territory becomes a State, that after so many years, the laws shall be extended over the Indians that live within their boundaries.

William Apess (Pequot), Eulogy on King Philip (1836)

Option 5, Occom: the pay

Now you see what difference they made between me and other missionaries; they gave me £180 for 12 years’ service, which they gave for one year’s services in another mission. In my service (I speak like a fool, but I am constrained) I was my own interpreter. I was both a schoolmaster and minister to the Indians, yea, I was their ear, eye, and hand, as well as mouth. I leave it with the world, as wicked as it is, to judge whether I ought not to have had half as much, they gave a young man just mentioned which would have been but £50 a year; and if they ought to have given me that, I am not under obligations to them, I owe them nothing at all; what can be the reason that they used me after this manner?

Samson Occom (Mohegan), A Short Narrative of My Life (1768)

Rubric (four levels)

Part and criterionAdvanced (4)Proficient (3)Approaching (2)Beginning (1)
1. Precis accuracySentence 1 has an accurate verb and a deniable claim; sentence 2 gives method in order; sentence 3 gives purpose with “in order to”; sentence 4 names who holds power.All four sentences present and accurate; one is general.One or two sentences name topics or feelings.Missing sentences, or a summary.
2. Method (critique)Each paragraph analyzes a choice for what it does in this text, for this audience, anchored to a quoted phrase.Most paragraphs do; one names a device without saying what it does.Devices named and not analyzed.Summary in place of analysis.
2. Vulnerability paragraphFinds a choice that works against the writer’s interest, or an exposed point, and explains the cost.Identifies one and explains it briefly.Names a weakness with no evidence.Missing.
2. Nation namedNames the speaker’s nation throughout and does not substitute a general category.Names it, with a lapse.Names it once.Uses a general category.
3. Rewrite fidelityRegister changes and the argument does not; specificity is kept; three annotations name a word, a structure and a reference, and say what was lost.Argument kept; one annotation is thin.Some specificity blurred; annotations name changes and not costs.Meaning changed or annotations missing.
4. DeliveryFormal English adapted to an academic audience; emphasis falls where the writer’s own structure places it.Formal and clear; emphasis sometimes off.Uneven pacing or register.Not delivered.

A worked exemplar on Standing Bear (SLS original)

Precis. (1) In a short speech at the close of his habeas corpus hearing in Omaha in 1879, Standing Bear, a Ponca chief held by the army, asserts that he is a man and so is a person a court must hear. (2) He develops the claim by first granting the visible difference between his hand and the judge’s, then offering the shared fact of blood and pain, then describing a river and a man standing in the path. (3) His purpose is to have the court hear his case, in order to be released to bury his son in the homeland. (4) He addresses the judge as the one person in the room able to decide, and he makes that decision the last sentence of the speech.

Model thesis (from sentence 4). Standing Bear speaks to a judge who holds all the power in the room, and he builds each part of the speech so that the judge, and not the speaker, becomes the subject of the final decision.

Outline. (a) Concession first: “That hand is not the color of yours,” then the shared fact. (b) The move from body to story: the river and the cliffs. (c) Parallel structure and the direct address. (d) The exposed point: a claim about a hand is not a claim about law, so the speech cannot make the legal argument and depends on the lawyers who came before him.

One model paragraph. Standing Bear concedes before he claims. He begins, “That hand is not the color of yours,” and only then turns to the shared fact, “The blood is of the same color as yours.” A court that had been told Standing Bear was outside a category would expect an argument about the category. He gives the judge a difference he cannot deny and puts the claim he needs in the same grammatical frame. The concession costs him nothing, and it earns the second sentence a hearing.

Audience rewrite (about 100 words here; yours is about 150). “Judge Dundy, my hand is not the same color as yours. But if someone cut it, it would bleed, and it would hurt me the way your hand would hurt you. The blood is the same color as yours. God made me. I am a man. I have never committed a crime. If I had, I would not stand here defending myself. I would take the punishment and not complain. Picture me standing on the high bank of a great river with my wife and my little girl beside me. I cannot cross the river, and cliffs I cannot climb rise behind me.”

Three annotations. Word replaced: “prick” became “cut” because “prick” is unfamiliar to many ninth graders; the cost is the picture of a small point, which is the gentlest pain a listener can imagine. Sentence restructured: the long first sentence became three shorter ones; what was kept is the order, the concession before the claim. Reference updated: “the judge” became “Judge Dundy,” because a reader outside the courtroom does not know who “you” is; the cost is that the direct address is now spoken to a named man and reads less like a look across the room.

Sources

Winnemucca: Internet Archive copy lifeamongpiutes00manngoog of the 1883 edition, retrieved 2026-09-26 (spacing before punctuation closed up). Standing Bear: The New York Times, 27 May 1906, on Wikisource, quoting Tibbles. Apess: Internet Archive copy eulogyonking00apesrich of the 1836 edition. Occom: Dartmouth Occom Circle modernized transcription, teachingamericanhistory.org, retrieved 2026-09-26. Precis, thesis, outline, model paragraph, rewrite, annotations and rubric SLS original.

Formative check

Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you, and your teacher, whether the standard below has landed yet.

Flashcard

ethos / pathos / logos

Tap to reveal
Answer

Appeals from credibility, from values and feeling, and from reasoning.

Flashcard

antithesis

Tap to reveal
Answer

Opposed ideas in parallel grammatical form, so the structure performs the contrast.

Flashcard

sufficiency

Tap to reveal
Answer

Whether the evidence offered is enough, in quantity and kind, to carry the claim.

Flashcard

habeas corpus

Tap to reveal
Answer

The protection requiring a government to justify holding a person before a court.

Flashcard

category argument

Tap to reveal
Answer

An argument that a case falls outside a rule entirely, rather than about its merits.

+50 XP

In the audience rewrite, a student renders Winnemucca’s account of the January 1879 removal as “the government moved her people a long way in bad conditions.” What is the problem?

Register changes; the argument does not. Here the particulars are not decoration — they are the whole rhetorical strategy of the book.
Quick self-check

How confident are you that you can change a passage’s register for a new audience without blurring the specificity that carries its argument?

Not yetVery confident

Submit: Rhetorical Analysis Project (4 parts)

Task: Select one text from the unit archive and complete a four-part rhetorical analysis: precis, 750-word critique, 150-word audience rewrite with annotations, and a two-minute recorded delivery.

Stages open in sequence and are scored separately.

Submission workflow

  1. Stage 1 — Precis & critique outline. The four-sentence precis, the derived thesis, three method-based topic sentences and one quoted phrase each.
  2. Stage 2 — Peer-reviewed rough draft of the critique (550+ words). Upload, peer-review two classmates, then submit a revision note naming one specific change and the feedback behind it.
  3. Stage 3 — Final critique (750 words) + audience rewrite (about 150 words) + three annotations. MLA, PDF.
  4. Stage 4 — Recorded delivery (2 minutes) of the rewritten passage. Annotated script plus a scheduled one-to-one delivery is an equal-credit alternative.

How it is scored

CriterionWhat proficient looks like
Precis accuracy (W.9-10.2.b, RI.9-10.2)Sentence 1 uses a rhetorically accurate verb; sentence 2 describes method and order; sentence 4 names the stance toward the audience.
Analysis of method (RI.9-10.6)Each paragraph analyses a choice for what it does in this text to this audience; no claim floats free of a quoted phrase.
Vulnerability paragraph (RI.9-10.8)Addresses a choice working against the writer’s interest, or a point where the argument is exposed.
Rewrite fidelity (L.9-10.3.a, W.9-10.4)Register changes; the argument does not; specificity is not blurred. Annotations name a word, a structure and a reference, and say what was lost.
Nation named (EU1)Names the speaker’s nation throughout and does not substitute a general category for it.
Delivery (SL.9-10.6)Formal English adapted to an academic audience; emphasis falls where the writer’s own structure places it.

CCSS addressed in this lesson: W.9-10.4, RI.9-10.6, L.9-10.3.a, SL.9-10.6, W.9-10.5

Essential Understandings addressed: EU1, EU6

Instructional pillar: Analytical writing with demonstrated command of register

Up NextComplete & Continue →

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Writing Workshop — The Four-Sentence Rhetorical Precis
Prev
The Book as Evidence: Winnemucca in the Great Basin and the Courtroom
Next

© 2026 The VR School | Career content by Wiley | Powered by Sejal Learning Systems.

Join free · Accreditation · Privacy Policy · Terms of Service

Modal title

Main Content