compare accounts of the same policy in two mediums, determine which details each emphasizes and which it must omit, and evaluate the credibility of each for a specific purpose.
Instruction
Every medium is a set of constraints, and constraints decide what gets emphasized. That is the whole of RI.9-10.7, and this unit gives you an unusually clean case because the same policy period was recorded in radically different forms.
What each medium must do.
- A satirical letter must have a speaker and a scene. It can carry irony, timing and what people actually said to each other; it cannot establish how many people were affected.
- A statistical audit must have categories and totals. It can establish scale and compare across regions; it cannot carry a voice, and its categories decide in advance what can be counted.
- A photograph must show a moment and a face. The boarding-school before-and-after photographs of the period were made as institutional publicity — evidence of what the schools intended, which is not the same as evidence of what they were.
- A government form — an allotment roll, an enrollment card — must fit a person into fields. What it cannot record is everything the fields did not ask, and the fields were designed by one party.
The analytical move. Not which is better. Three questions, in order: what does this medium emphasize; what did it have to add that the source left open; what did it have to drop? The second is where the interesting answer usually is, because an addition is always an interpretation.
Run it on the enrollment card, which is the sharpest example in the unit. To enroll a person the Dawes Commission needed a name in a fixed format, a degree of blood, and a category. Every one of those is an addition — a decision imposed by the form — and the categories on that card went on to govern who was recognized, who received land, and, through descendancy rules, who is a citizen of some nations today. A form is not a neutral record; it is an argument with boxes.
Credibility, the SL.9-10.2 half. Say what a record is evidence of. A school photograph is strong evidence of what the school wanted to demonstrate. An audit is strong evidence of what its categories were built to count. A satirical letter is strong evidence of how the policy was being talked about by people subject to it — which is something no federal record contains.
This lesson’s work. From the open-access material in the course archive, choose two records of the same policy in different mediums. Build the three-question chart, then add the fourth question this unit needs: who made this record, and for whom? Record a ninety-second finding naming the single most consequential difference. Reply to two classmates using the Unit 3 structure — summarize the agreement, name the divergence, qualify or justify. A typed transcript earns equal credit.
A note on the photographs. The boarding-school images are of identifiable children, many of whom did not survive, and descendants of those children may be in this room. Look at them as institutional records that had a purpose. Do not use them as illustration.
Reading: Four records of allotment in three mediums, a blank chart, worked comparisons and a model finding
The Dawes Act (24 Stat. 388, 1887); Lewis Meriam and staff, The Problem of Indian Administration (1928); National Archives, Dawes Records of the Five Civilized Tribes; SLS original charts and models | Text: https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Dawes_Act; https://archive.org/download/ldpd_11418459_000/ldpd_11418459_000_djvu.txt; https://www.archives.gov/research/native-americans/dawes · SLS original; quoted passages are public domain (federal statute, 1887; Meriam et al., 1928) or US federal government works (National Archives)
Choose two records, fill in the chart, and then answer who made each and for whom.
The lesson asks you to compare two records of one policy in different mediums and to say what each medium emphasizes, what it had to add, what it had to drop, and who made it for whom. The policy is allotment. This reading supplies four records of it in three mediums: the statute that created it (L1 to L3), a federal audit of its results (A1), and the form the Dawes Commission used to enroll people (C1 and C2), plus a pointer to the satirical letters in Lesson 4.1 as a fourth medium (Fus Fixico, F3 and F4). It also gives a blank chart, two worked comparisons, and a model finding and reply. Photographs are not reproduced: the boarding-school images are of identifiable children, and they are institutional records to be read as such, not used as illustration.
The statute: the Dawes Act, 1887
L1: section 1, the allotment
That in all cases where any tribe or band of Indians has been, or shall hereafter be, located upon any reservation created for their use, either by treaty stipulation or by virtue of an act of Congress or executive order setting apart the same for their use, the President of the United States be, and he hereby is, authorized, whenever in his opinion any reservation or any part thereof of such Indians is advantageous for agricultural and grazing purposes, to cause said reservation, or any part thereof, to be surveyed, or resurveyed if necessary, and to allot the lands in said reservation in severalty to any Indian located thereon in quantities as follows: To each head of a family, one-quarter of a section; To each single person over eighteen years of age, one-eighth of a section; To each orphan child under eighteen years of age, one-eighth of a section; and To each other single person under eighteen years now living, or who may be born prior to the date of the order of the President directing an allotment of the lands embraced in any reservation, one-sixteenth of a section:
An Act to provide for the allotment of lands in severalty to Indians (24 Stat. 388), approved 8 February 1887
L2: section 5, the trust period
Sec. 5. That upon the approval of the allotments provided for in this act by the Secretary of the Interior, he shall cause patents to issue therefor in the name of the allottees, which patents shall be of the legal effect, and declare that the United States does and will hold the land thus allotted, for the period of twenty-five years, in trust for the sole use and benefit of the Indian to whom such allotment shall have been made, or, in case of his decease, of his heirs according to the laws of the State or Territory where such land is located, and that at the expiration of said period the United States will convey the same by patent to said Indian, or his heirs as aforesaid, in fee, discharged of said trust and free of all charge or incumbrance whatsoever:
Same act
L3: the sale of what was not allotted
it shall be lawful for the Secretary of the Interior to negotiate with such Indian tribe for the purchase and release by said tribe, in conformity with the treaty or statute under which such reservation is held, of such portions of its reservation not allotted as such tribe shall, from time to time, consent to sell,
Same act, proviso in section 5
The audit: the Meriam Report, 1928
A1: allotment, page 41
The policy of individual allotment should be followed with extreme conservatism. Not accompanied by adequate instruction in the use of property, it has largely failed in the accomplishment of what was expected of it. It has resulted in much loss of land and an enormous increase in the details of administration without a compensating advance in the economic ability of the Indians.
Lewis Meriam and staff, The Problem of Indian Administration (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins Press for the Institute for Government Research, 1928)
The form: the Dawes Commission enrollment records
C1: what the Final Dawes Rolls record
The rolls provide the following information about enrollees: Roll number (enrollment number) Name Age Sex Blood degree Census card number
National Archives, “Dawes Records of the Five Civilized Tribes,” archives.gov/research/native-americans/dawes
C2: what a Dawes census (enrollment) card records
The Dawes census cards typically contain the following information about each applicant: Enlarge Dawes Enrollment Card for William P. Rogers, Cherokee Citizen by Blood, Census Card No. 4747 View in National Archives Catalog Dawes Roll number (if enrolled) Tribe and enrollment category Census card number Name Relationship to the head of the family group Age Sex Blood degree Parents’ names
Same page
The blank chart
| Question | Record 1: ______ | Record 2: ______ |
|---|---|---|
| What does this medium emphasize? | ||
| What did it have to add that its source left open? | ||
| What did it have to drop? | ||
| Who made this record, and for whom? | ||
| What is it strong evidence of? |
Worked comparison 1: the statute and the audit (SLS original)
| Question | L1 to L3 (the Dawes Act) | A1 (the Meriam Report) |
|---|---|---|
| Emphasizes | How much land goes to whom: a quarter section to the head of a family, an eighth to a single person over eighteen (L1). | A result and a verdict: the policy “has largely failed.” |
| Had to add | A schedule, a length of time (twenty-five years, L2) and a mechanism for the tribe’s remaining land (L3). | A cause, “Not accompanied by adequate instruction in the use of property,” and a remedy. |
| Had to drop | Any account of what the person who receives the parcel wants or thinks. | The voices of those who lived it; the counts stand in for them. |
| Made by, for | Congress, for the executive branch that would carry it out. | The Institute for Government Research, for the Secretary of the Interior. |
| Strong evidence of | What the government intended and authorized in 1887. | What a federal survey concluded in 1928 about the effect of that intention. |
Worked comparison 2: the enrollment record (SLS original)
The fields in C1 and C2 are name, age, sex, blood degree, roll number, tribe and category, and, for the card, relationship to the head of the family and the parents’ names. Each field was chosen by the Commission. To enroll a person, the form needed a category and a fraction, and it had no place for anything else. That is an addition: the form turns a person into entries that the allotment could then use to decide who received land. The category on the card is an argument with boxes. The dropped material is everything the boxes did not ask. The record is strong evidence of how the Commission organized the question of who counted, and it is weak evidence of how any enrolled person understood themselves.
A model 90-second finding (SLS original)
The most consequential difference between the Act and the Report is what each one can see. The Act sees parcels: L1 says how many acres go to whom, and L2 says the land will be held in trust for twenty-five years. The Report sees results: A1 says allotment “has resulted in much loss of land” and “an enormous increase in the details of administration.” So the Act can tell us what the government meant to do, and the Report can tell us what a federal survey found it had done. Neither one can tell us what the person holding the parcel would have said. That gap is what the satirical letters in Lesson 4.1 partly fill, and it is why my research question needs a third kind of record.
A model reply, and stems (SLS original)
I agree that the Act sees parcels and the Report sees results. I would add that L3 shows the Act was also about the land left over after allotment, which the Report’s sentence does not mention. Where I part from you is on “strong evidence”: I would say the Act is strong evidence of intent, and not of effect.
- The record I chose was … and the difference that matters most is …
- I agree with you that … and I would add …
- Where I part from you is … because passage … says …
- I would qualify what I said, since …
Sources
The Dawes Act: Wikisource transcription of the act of 8 February 1887 (24 Stat. 388), retrieved 2026-09-26. The Meriam Report: Internet Archive copy ldpd_11418459_000, retrieved 2026-09-26. The enrollment fields: the National Archives page “Dawes Records of the Five Civilized Tribes”, retrieved 2026-09-26. Charts, worked comparisons, the model finding and the reply are SLS original.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you, and your teacher, whether the standard below has landed yet.
A Dawes Commission enrollment card records a name, a category and a degree of blood. What is the best analytical statement about that record?
A boarding-school before-and-after photograph is good evidence of what the boarding schools were like.
For your two chosen records, complete the chart: what each medium emphasizes, what each had to add, what each had to drop — and then the fourth question, who made this record and for whom. Draft your ninety-second finding: the single most consequential difference and what it changed about what can be known.
How confident are you that you can explain what a record’s format had to add, and why that addition is an interpretation rather than a neutral fact?