write a synthesis paragraph in which my own claim governs and the sources serve it, and revise a report-style paragraph into a braided one.
Instruction
Most first research papers are not arguments. They are reports: a paragraph on what the first source says, a paragraph on the second, a conclusion announcing the topic is complex. The outline is the giveaway — if your outline is a list of sources, you are reporting.
Synthesis means your claim governs and the sources are brought in because the claim needs them. The test is mechanical: look at your topic sentences. If a source’s name is the subject, the paragraph belongs to the source.
Compare.
Reporting: “The Meriam Report found that allotment had failed. It said the boarding schools were inadequate. Posey also criticized allotment in his letters. This shows that allotment was a problem.”
Braided: “The two records fail at opposite ends of the same question. The Meriam Report can establish that allotment ‘has largely failed in the accomplishment of what was expected of it’ (41) across the whole system, because a survey is built to count — and it cannot say what the failure sounded like to anyone inside it. Posey’s letters can: Tookpafka Micco’s complaint that an Indian ‘was had a hard time to find out what he was owned and where it was at’ registers the specific experience of a process that produced paperwork faster than it produced understanding. Neither account is incomplete by accident. Each is limited by the thing that makes it useful.”
The second has the claim in the first sentence, sources arriving mid-sentence inside the writer’s syntax, analysis outweighing borrowing, and a final sentence that is the writer’s own.
Three moves that produce braiding.
- Put sources in conversation, not in sequence. Where the Report counts, Posey listens; this is the point at which the two records diverge.
- Let a source be wrong. You may disagree with a secondary source, and doing it well is the strongest evidence of understanding. Represent it fairly first.
- Keep the ratio. Your sentences must outnumber borrowed material in every paragraph. If they do not, cut the borrowing.
The annotated bibliography, due today. Each entry: full MLA citation, then exactly two sentences — what it contributes, and where its authority, purpose or currency limits it. “There are no limitations” is never correct. For any community source, the entry also records the permission that was given.
One more discipline. Your research question has probably moved. Restate it at the top of Stage 1 in its current form and say in one sentence how it changed. Narrowing a question in response to evidence is what W.9-10.7 names explicitly, and it is scored.
Reading: A mentor paragraph, two source passages, a report-to-braided revision and Stage 1 criteria
William Apess (Pequot), Indian Nullification (Boston, 1835), Project Gutenberg 12486; The Dawes Act (24 Stat. 388, 1887); Lewis Meriam and staff, The Problem of Indian Administration (1928); SLS original models | Text: Project Gutenberg 12486; https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Dawes_Act; https://archive.org/download/ldpd_11418459_000/ldpd_11418459_000_djvu.txt · SLS original; quoted passages are public domain (Apess, 1835; federal statute, 1887; Meriam et al., 1928)
Write the topic sentence first, and check whose sentence it is.
Stage 1 of the Key Assignment has three parts: your research question with a note on how it changed, an annotated bibliography, and one fully drafted braided paragraph. This reading gives you a mentor paragraph in which a writer’s claim governs his evidence, two source passages to practice on (L2 from the Dawes Act and R2 from the Meriam Report), a report-style paragraph rewritten as a braided one, models of the bibliography entries, and the criteria Stage 1 is scored against.
A mentor paragraph: the claim governs the evidence
A3: William Apess (Pequot), on legislation and Indian lands
It is a sorrowful truth that, heretofore, all legislation regarding the affairs of Indians, has had a direct tendency to degrade them, to drive them from their homes, and the graves of their fathers, and to give their lands as a spoil to the general government, or to the several States. In New England, especially, it can be proved that Indian lands have been taken to support schools for the whites, and the preaching of the gospel to them. Had the property so taken been applied to the benefit of its true owners, they would not and could not have been so ignorant and degraded a race as they now are; only forty-four of whom, out of four or five hundred, can write their names. From what I have been able to learn from the public prints and other sources, the amount annually derived to the American people, from Indian lands is not far from six millions, a tax of which they have almost the sole benefit.
William Apess, Indian Nullification of the Unconstitutional Laws of Massachusetts Relative to the Marshpee Tribe (1835)
Look at the order. The first sentence is the claim: all legislation about Indians has had a direct tendency to degrade them. The numbers come after it as support: only forty-four of four or five hundred can write their names. The source, “the public prints and other sources,” arrives in the middle of his own sentence. His paragraph is about the claim, and the evidence serves it. One thing he does not do is name the sources, which is exactly what your paper must do.
Two passages to work with
L2: the promise, section 5 of the Dawes Act (1887)
Sec. 5. That upon the approval of the allotments provided for in this act by the Secretary of the Interior, he shall cause patents to issue therefor in the name of the allottees, which patents shall be of the legal effect, and declare that the United States does and will hold the land thus allotted, for the period of twenty-five years, in trust for the sole use and benefit of the Indian to whom such allotment shall have been made, or, in case of his decease, of his heirs according to the laws of the State or Territory where such land is located, and that at the expiration of said period the United States will convey the same by patent to said Indian, or his heirs as aforesaid, in fee, discharged of said trust and free of all charge or incumbrance whatsoever:
An Act to provide for the allotment of lands in severalty to Indians (24 Stat. 388)
R2: the finding, page 41 of the Meriam Report (1928)
The policy of individual allotment should be followed with extreme conservatism. Not accompanied by adequate instruction in the use of property, it has largely failed in the accomplishment of what was expected of it. It has resulted in much loss of land and an enormous increase in the details of administration without a compensating advance in the economic ability of the Indians.
Lewis Meriam and staff, The Problem of Indian Administration (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins Press, 1928)
The test for a report paragraph and a braided one (SLS original)
Look at the topic sentence. If a source’s name is the subject, the paragraph belongs to the source. If your claim is the subject, the paragraph belongs to you.
| Report paragraph | Braided paragraph | |
|---|---|---|
| Text | The Dawes Act said the United States would hold allotted land in trust for twenty-five years. The Meriam Report said allotment had largely failed. These are two documents about allotment, and they show it was important. | The Act promised protection and the Report found loss, and the distance between the two is where the policy failed. Section 5 pledged that the United States “does and will hold the land thus allotted, for the period of twenty-five years, in trust for the sole use and benefit of the Indian” (L2), and forty-one years after the Act a federal survey found allotment “has resulted in much loss of land” (Meriam et al. 41). The Act speaks of what the United States would hold and for how long, and the Report speaks of what happened to the land. Those are different questions, so the promise cannot answer the finding. |
| Topic sentence | Names the two documents as the subject. | Makes a claim: the distance between promise and finding is where the policy failed. |
| Sources | Summarized in turn. | Arrive inside the writer’s own sentences, with a signal phrase or a parenthesis. |
| Last sentence | A restatement. | The writer’s own conclusion. |
The ratio check. Count the sentences in each paragraph that are yours and the words that are borrowed. In the braided model, most of the words are the writer’s own, and two short quotations carry the evidence. If your sentences do not outnumber the borrowed words, cut the borrowing.
Three moves that produce braiding. (1) Put sources in conversation, not in sequence: L2 and R2 answer each other. (2) Let a source be wrong, after you have represented it fairly. (3) Keep the ratio.
Annotated bibliography: model entries (SLS original)
Each entry has the full MLA citation, then exactly two sentences: what the source contributes and where its authority, purpose or currency limits it. For a community source, the entry also records the permission that was given.
| MLA citation | Two-sentence annotation |
|---|---|
| Meriam, Lewis, and Associates. The Problem of Indian Administration. Johns Hopkins P, 1928. | This report gives a survey-based finding on allotment, that it “has largely failed,” and on boarding schools. It was made at the request of the Secretary of the Interior and speaks for 1928 only, so it cannot show what a nation thinks now. |
| United States, Congress. An Act to Provide for the Allotment of Lands in Severalty to Indians. 24 Stat. 388, 8 Feb. 1887. | The Act states the promise, a twenty-five-year trust, in the government’s own words. It says what Congress intended and authorized, and it is silent on what allottees experienced. |
| Fus Fixico [Alexander Posey]. “Fus Fixico on Statehood.” Vinita Daily Chieftain, 16 June 1903, p. 2. Chronicling America, Library of Congress. | The letter shows how people subject to the statehood campaign talked about the politicians who ran it. It is satire, so it is strong evidence of attitude and weak evidence of fact, and the scanned text has errors. |
| [Last name, First name.] [Nation]. Interview. [Date]. Used with permission for this paper. | [Two sentences: what the person shared, and where the knowledge is limited to what they chose to share.] The permission given, in the form the person chose, is recorded here. |
Criteria for Stage 1 (four levels)
| Criterion | Advanced (4) | Proficient (3) | Approaching (2) | Beginning (1) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Research question | Narrow, arguable, answerable from both kinds of text, with one sentence on how it changed and why. | Narrow and answerable; the change is stated. | Too broad or answerable by fact. | A topic. |
| Annotated bibliography | A literary text, the Meriam Report and two vetted sources; exactly two sentences each; limits named; permission recorded for any community source. | All required sources; one annotation is thin. | Missing a required source or annotations too long. | Missing. |
| Braided paragraph | The writer’s claim is the topic sentence; at least two sources arrive in the writer’s syntax; the writer’s sentences outnumber the borrowing. | Claim is clear; sources appear in sequence. | A source is the subject of most sentences. | Report only. |
| Citation accuracy | Signal phrases, correct MLA, names spelled exactly. | One or two slips. | Frequent slips. | No citation. |
Sources
Apess: Indian Nullification (Boston, 1835), Project Gutenberg ebook 12486. The Dawes Act: Wikisource transcription of the act of 8 February 1887. The Meriam Report: Internet Archive copy ldpd_11418459_000. Retrieved 2026-09-26. Models, tables and criteria SLS original.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you, and your teacher, whether the standard below has landed yet.
Which topic sentence indicates a synthesis paragraph rather than a report paragraph?
Changing your research question partway through is a sign the research was poorly planned.
Submit Stage 1: (1) your research question in its current form, with one sentence on how it changed; (2) your annotated bibliography — a literary text, the Meriam Report and at least two vetted secondary sources, each with the two-sentence annotation and, for any community source, the permission recorded; (3) one fully drafted braided paragraph in which your claim governs, at least two sources appear, and your own sentences outnumber the borrowed material.
How confident are you that you can look at my own topic sentences and tell whether the paragraph belongs to me or to my source?