THE VR SCHOOL
  • Schools & Districts
    • License the academy
    • Free program for your students
    • Request a demo
  • Catalog
    • AI & Data
    • Cybersecurity & Web
    • Programming
    • Health Science
    • All Guilds
    • All courses
  • Families
  • Accreditation
  • Log In
  • Request a demo
  • Home
  • Courses

English 9A — The Written Word and the Rights of Nations

Curriculum

  • 4 Sections
  • 28 Lessons
  • 10 Weeks
Expand all sectionsCollapse all sections
  • Unit 1: The Native Public Voice, 1768–1836
    7
    • 1.1
      Introduction
      2 mins
    • 1.2
      Samson Occom and the Account That Was Not Printed
      45 mins
    • 1.3
      Language Lab — Semicolons, Conjunctive Adverbs and the Analytical Sentence
      40 mins
    • 1.4
      Seminar — Apess’s Looking-Glass: Who Is the Argument For?
      50 mins
    • 1.5
      Writing Workshop — Thesis, Topic Sentence and the Embedded Quotation
      50 mins
    • 1.6
      Key Assignment — Rhetorical Authority Analytical Essay
      150 mins
    • 1.7
      Occom’s Voice: A Mohegan Minister Writes His Own Record
      15 mins
  • Unit 2: Literacy as a Sovereign Act
    7
    • 2.1
      Introduction
      2 mins
    • 2.2
      A Nation Invents a Writing System
      45 mins
    • 2.3
      Language Lab — The Language of Law
      45 mins
    • 2.4
      Listening Lab — Boudinot, Ross, and the Editor Who Was Removed
      50 mins
    • 2.5
      Writing Workshop — Claim, Counterclaim and the Concession Paragraph
      50 mins
    • 2.6
      Key Assignment — Sovereignty Argument Essay
      150 mins
    • 2.7
      A Nation Writes Itself: Sequoyah, New Echota and the Constitution
      15 mins
  • Unit 3: Testimony, Evidence and the Courts
    7
    • 3.1
      Introduction
      2 mins
    • 3.2
      Sarah Winnemucca and the Book as Evidence
      45 mins
    • 3.3
      Language Lab — Parallel Structure, Antithesis and Public Cadence
      45 mins
    • 3.4
      Listening Lab — Standing Bear Before the Court
      50 mins
    • 3.5
      Writing Workshop — The Four-Sentence Rhetorical Precis
      50 mins
    • 3.6
      Key Assignment — Rhetorical Analysis and Audience Rewrite
      150 mins
    • 3.7
      The Book as Evidence: Winnemucca in the Great Basin and the Courtroom
      15 mins
  • Unit 4: Synthesis — Satire, the Report and the Record
    7
    • 4.1
      Introduction
      2 mins
    • 4.2
      Satire and the Record — Posey’s Fus Fixico Letters
      45 mins
    • 4.3
      Research Lab — Sources, Signal Phrases and Citing Community Knowledge
      50 mins
    • 4.4
      Media Lab — One Policy, Different Records
      50 mins
    • 4.5
      Writing Workshop — Synthesis as Braiding, Not Reporting
      50 mins
    • 4.6
      Key Assignment — Synthesis Research Paper and Digital Presentation
      200 mins
    • 4.7
      The Fire Circle and the Federal Record: Satire, Reports and Photographs
      15 mins

Samson Occom and the Account That Was Not Printed

Unit 1  ·  Anchor Text & Close Reading  ·  Lesson 1 of 20

Samson Occom and the Account That Was Not Printed

RI.9-10.6ENG9A-BIE
By the end of this lesson I can…

explain how Occom builds a case about his own treatment without ever stating a grievance directly, and cite the exact sentences that do that work.

Instruction

Samson Occom, a Mohegan man in mid-18th-century attire, stands outside a small, mat-covered wigwam constructed with bent wood poles, set in a wooded glade representing Connecticut

Samson Occom was Mohegan, born in 1723 in what is now Connecticut. He became a Presbyterian minister, ran a school, and in 1765 sailed to England and Scotland on a fundraising tour. Over two years he preached more than three hundred sermons and raised roughly £12,000 — an enormous sum, and the largest amount ever raised for Native education to that point.

The money was used to found Dartmouth College, which educated almost no Native students. Occom returned to find his own family in poverty and his school effectively abandoned.

In 1768 he wrote an account of his own life. It was not published until the twentieth century. He wrote it, as far as scholars can tell, because rumors were circulating about his background and his competence, and he wanted a record in his own words.

That is the rhetorical situation, and everything about the prose follows from it.

What the narrative does. It is short, plain and almost entirely factual. He gives his birth, his upbringing, his conversion, his schooling, his ordination, the years of teaching and preaching, and — in careful detail — what he was paid. He records that he taught, preached, served as a judge among his people, wrote letters for them, and was paid a fraction of what white missionaries doing less work received.

He does not editorialise. He itemizes. And then, at the very end, the restraint breaks into a single passage that is one of the sharpest in eighteenth-century American writing: he tells a short story about an Indian who was accused of being lazy, and concludes that he supposes the reason he was paid so little was “I am a poor Indian.”

Why the restraint is a technique and not a temperament. Consider who could read this. Occom’s livelihood depended on white church societies. A document of open complaint could be dismissed as ingratitude — the charge that was, in fact, made against him. So he does what a lawyer does: he establishes the facts, in order, from a source nobody will dispute (himself, on matters of his own labor and pay), and lets the conclusion form in the reader.

The analytical question for this lesson. Not “was he treated unfairly?” — the account settles that. The question is: what does a writer do when the grievance cannot be stated, and where in the prose can you see the cost of not stating it?

Keep a two-column chart as you read. Left: the fact, quoted. Right: what a reader concludes from it that Occom never says.

Reading: A Short Narrative of My Life: the work, the pay and the ending

Samson Occom rides a horse at night, carrying a travel bag and a book, along a winding dirt path bordered by sparse moonlit trees

Samson Occom (Mohegan), A Short Narrative of My Life, manuscript of 1768; Dartmouth Occom Circle modernized transcription; retrieved 2026-09-26 | Text: https://teachingamericanhistory.org/document/a-short-narrative-of-my-life/ · Public domain (Occom, 1768); framing, chart and note SLS original

Read passages 4 to 7 twice. On the first read, list what he did and what he was paid. On the second, mark the one sentence in which he says the conclusion out loud.

Samson Occom (Mohegan) wrote this account in 1768 to answer rumors about his character and his competence. It was not printed in his lifetime. The passages below are numbered so you can cite them (for example, Occom, passage 6). The first three describe his work at Montauk on Long Island and how he lived; the last four are the accounting of his pay and the short story that ends the narrative. Spelling and capitalization are the modernized text of the Dartmouth Occom Circle transcription as reprinted by Teaching American History; the words are Occom’s.

The passages

Passage 1

I am now to give an account of my circumstances and manner of living. I dwelt in a wigwam, a small hut with small poles and covered with mats made of flags, and I was obliged to remove twice a year, about 2 miles distance, by reason of the scarcity of wood, for in one neck of land they planted their corn, and in another, they had their wood, and I was obliged to have my corn carted and my hay also, and I got my ground plowed every year, which cost me about 12 shillings an acre;

Passage 2

I was obliged to contrive every way to support my family; I took all opportunities to get something to feed my family daily. I planted my own corn, potatoes, and beans; I used to be out hoeing my corn sometimes before sunrise and after my school is dismissed, and by this means I was able to raise my own pork, for I was allowed to keep 5 swine. Some mornings and evenings I would be out with my hook and line to catch fish and in the fall of year and in the spring, I used my gun, and fed my family with fowls. I could more than pay for my powder and shot with feathers.

Passage 3

And I kept on in my service as usual, yea, I had additional service; I kept school as I did before and carried on the religious meetings as often as ever, and attended sick and their funerals, and did what writings they wanted, and often sat as a judge to reconcile and decide their matters between them, and had visitors of Indians from all quarters; and, as our custom is, we freely entertain all visitors. And was fetched often from my tribe and from others to see into their affairs both religious, and temporal, besides my domestic concerns. And it pleased the Lord to increase my family fast—and soon after I was married, Mr. Horton left these Indians and the Shenecock and after this I was (alone) and then I had the whole care of these Indians at Montauk, and visited the Shenecock Indians often. Used to set out Saturdays toward night and come back again Mondays. I have been obliged to set out from home after sunset, and ride 30 miles in the night, to preach to these Indians. And some Indians at Shenecock sent their children to my school at Montauk, I kept one of them some time, and had a young man a half year from Mohegan, a lad from Nahantuck, who was with me almost a year; and had little or nothing for keeping them.

Passage 4

In the whole I lost 5 horse kind; all these losses helped to pull me down; and by this time I got greatly in debt and acquainted my circumstances to some of my friends, and they represented my case to the commissioners of Boston, and interceded with them for me, and they were pleased to vote £15 for my help, and soon after sent a letter to my good friend at New London, acquainting him that they had superseded their vote; and my friends were so good as to represent my needy circumstances still to them, and they were so good at last, as to vote £15 and sent it, for which I am very thankful; and the Reverend Mr. Buell was so kind as to write in my behalf to the gentlemen of Boston; and he told me they were much displeased with him, and heard also once again that they blamed me for being extravagant; I can’t conceive how these gentlemen would have me live. I am ready to (forgive) their ignorance, and I would wish they had changed circumstances with me but one month, that they may know, by experience what my case really was; but I am now fully convinced that it was not ignorance, for I believe it can be proved to the world that these same gentlemen gave a young missionary, a single man, 100 pounds for one year, and £50 for an interpreter, and £30 for an introducer; so it cost them £180 in one single year, and they sent too where there was no need of a missionary.

Passage 5

Now you see what difference they made between me and other missionaries; they gave me £180 for 12 years’ service, which they gave for one year’s services in another mission. In my service (I speak like a fool, but I am constrained) I was my own interpreter. I was both a schoolmaster and minister to the Indians, yea, I was their ear, eye, and hand, as well as mouth. I leave it with the world, as wicked as it is, to judge whether I ought not to have had half as much, they gave a young man just mentioned which would have been but £50 a year; and if they ought to have given me that, I am not under obligations to them, I owe them nothing at all; what can be the reason that they used me after this manner?

Passage 6

and he used to drive plow for a young man, and he whipt and beat him almost every day, and the young man found fault with him, and complained of him to his master and the poor boy was called to answer for himself before his master, and he was asked, what it was he did, that he was so complained of and beat almost every day. He said, he did not know, but he supposed it was because he could not drive any better; but says he, I drive as well as I know how; and at other times he beats me, because he is of a mind to beat me; but says he believes he beats me for the most of the time “because I am an Indian.”

Passage 7

So I am ready to say, they have used me thus, because I can’t influence the Indians so well as other missionaries; but I can assure them I have endeavored to teach them as well as I know how; but I must say, “I believe it is because I am a poor Indian.” I can’t help that God has made me so; I did not make myself so.

How to read it as evidence

Occom never writes the word “unfair” in these passages. He lists what he did (kept school, read Scripture, visited the sick, sat as a judge, rode thirty miles at night), what it cost him (a wigwam, a cow and a horse, five lost horses), and what he was paid, and he puts the pay of a young missionary beside it. Each item is a fact he can be checked on. The conclusion he reaches is left for the reader to reach first.

A worked chart row (SLS original)

Fact, quotedWhat a reader concludes that Occom does not say
“they gave me £180 for 12 years’ service, which they gave for one year’s services in another mission” (passage 5)The commissioners valued one year of another missionary’s work at twelve years of his. He states the two sums and does not say what the ratio means. The reader does the division.
“I was both a schoolmaster and minister to the Indians” (passage 5)He did two jobs and was paid for one, and the other man had “an interpreter” and “an introducer” paid separately (passage 4). Occom served as his own.

Use the same two columns for four facts of your own from passages 1 to 7. For the question about the final paragraph, compare passage 7 with passage 5: passage 5 is a list of numbers, and passage 7 is the only place he writes the words “I believe it is because I am a poor Indian.” Look at what he writes next, and at the sentence he puts in quotation marks.

Source

Samson Occom, “A Short Narrative of My Life,” manuscript of September 1768, Dartmouth College Rauner Library; modernized transcription, The Occom Circle (collections.dartmouth.edu/occom, document 768517); excerpt as reproduced at teachingamericanhistory.org/document/a-short-narrative-of-my-life/, retrieved 2026-09-26. The words are Occom’s (1768). The excerpt shows his 1768 narrative after the section on his conversion; the earlier part, about his birth and schooling, is not reproduced here.

Vocabulary in context

  • restraint — Deliberate withholding of the expected intensity, so the reader supplies the judgment — a technique, not an absence of feeling.
  • rhetorical situation — The speaker, audience, purpose and occasion that together determine what a text is doing.
  • itemize — To set out facts in an enumerated list rather than as argument; Occom’s principal method.
  • ethos — The appeal from the writer’s credibility, constructed within the text rather than brought to it.
  • patron — A funder on whom a writer depends, and whose expectations shape what can be said.
Local knowledge  ·  completed by your school

Who kept the record here, and in what language

Occom wrote in English, for English readers, because that was the only record that would count where he needed it to count. Every nation has its own answer to the question of who kept its record, in what form, and what happened to it.

This slot asks who kept the record of this nation, in what form and in what language, and what happened to it. Your nation’s own account is the best answer there is, and your school may bring it to you. Until then, work the slot yourself by one of the three routes below — all three earn full credit. Two rules hold on every route. Write about the nation as what it is today: a sovereign government with citizens, offices and a press of its own. And if the nation has not published something, that is your answer and you record it; you do not go hunting for it somewhere else.

Your route — choose one. All three earn full credit.

  1. Route A — What the nation publishes about itself now — Open the Tribal Leaders Directory at bia.gov/service/tribal-leaders-directory, find the nation whose homeland your school stands on, and follow the link to the nation’s own website. Read, in this order, its history or heritage pages, its language program, its archive or museum if it has one, and its newspaper or newsroom. Write 200 words on who keeps this nation’s record today — which office, in what language or languages, and for whom. Quote only what the nation itself has published, and cite it the way you would cite any government’s own website. If the nation publishes nothing on one of these, say so plainly and name the pages you checked: a documented silence is a finding, and it is not an invitation to look elsewhere.
  2. Route B — The Native press, in the nation’s own type — The Cherokee Phoenix, first published in 1828, was the first newspaper published by a Native nation, and it printed in English and in the Cherokee syllabary in parallel columns. Read one issue at the Library of Congress (loc.gov/item/sn83020866 for the 1828–1829 run, loc.gov/item/sn83020874 for Cherokee Phoenix, and Indians’ Advocate, 1829–1834). Then open the Library of Congress research guide Native American Newspapers (guides.loc.gov/native-american-newspapers), which lists papers written by and for Native peoples by region, state and city, and search Chronicling America (loc.gov/collections/chronicling-america) for papers from your own state or region. Write 200 words on what a nation printing its own paper controls that it cannot control when someone else writes about it.
  3. Route C — The federal record, and who was holding the pen — Open the National Archives research page Native American Heritage at archives.gov/research/native-americans and read the topic sections: Treaties, Census Records, Tribal Rolls, Allotment Records, School Records, Correspondence Files. Then search the National Archives Catalog (catalog.archives.gov) for the name of the nation, or of the Indian agency that administered it, and open one digitized record. Write 200 words answering three questions about that document: who wrote it, in what language, and who were they writing for. Then name one thing about this nation that a federal clerk’s file would never contain, and say how you know it is missing rather than absent.

For the school — how this slot gets filled

Who holds this: A tribal historian, archivist, language program or cultural department of the nation this school serves.

  1. Ask the tribal historic preservation office, cultural department, tribal college or language program before the unit is scheduled, not during it. A request made in week three becomes a request for a favor under deadline.
  2. Ask what may be shared with students and what may be published in a course that other schools can see. Those are two different permissions and the second is the one that catches people out.
  3. Agree attribution in writing — the person, the office, the nation — and agree who may revise the material later.
  4. If the answer is that this material is not for a course, that answer is the end of the matter. Teach the slot as it stands, with the explanation that the knowledge exists and is held by the community.

Formative check

Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you, and your teacher, whether the standard below has landed yet.

Make a prediction

Occom spends most of his narrative listing duties and sums of money rather than describing how he felt. Before reading on — why?

The second, and the charge of ingratitude was in fact made against him. The itemizing is a lawyer’s method: establish facts from a source nobody disputes, and let the conclusion form in the reader. Note that the restraint does break, once, at the very end.
+50 XP

Occom writes: “I would wish you had Learning enough to spell my name right.” What is this sentence doing?

Ask who in this relationship was assumed to be the learner. The sentence is one of the few places the restraint breaks, and it breaks precisely on that assumption.
Myth or Fact?

Because Occom’s narrative was never published in his lifetime, it tells us nothing about how he wrote for an audience.

Myth. He wrote it because rumors were circulating and he wanted a record in his own words — so it is addressed to a reader throughout, and the caution in its prose is evidence of exactly who he expected that reader to be.
Fill in the blank

Withholding the expected intensity so that a reader supplies the judgment is ; the speaker, audience, purpose and occasion that determine what a text is doing are its rhetorical .

Build the two-column chart: quote four facts Occom reports, and for each write in one sentence what a reader concludes that he never states. Then answer: the restraint breaks in the final paragraph. What changes in the prose at that moment — name a specific feature, not a feeling — and what does the break cost him?

0 words
Quick self-check

How confident are you that you can explain what a writer’s restraint is accomplishing, using the exact sentences rather than the general situation?

Not yetVery confident

CCSS addressed in this lesson: RI.9-10.6, RI.9-10.1, RI.9-10.5, L.9-10.4.a

Essential Understandings addressed: EU1, EU5, EU6

Instructional pillar: Extensive reading of full-length literary non-fiction

Up NextComplete & Continue →

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Introduction
Prev
Language Lab — Semicolons, Conjunctive Adverbs and the Analytical Sentence
Next

© 2026 The VR School | Career content by Wiley | Powered by Sejal Learning Systems.

Join free · Accreditation · Privacy Policy · Terms of Service

Modal title

Main Content