state a precise claim, distinguish it from a fairly stated opposing claim, and write a concession paragraph that strengthens rather than weakens my own argument.
Instruction
Unit 1 asked for analysis: here is what the text does, here is the effect. Unit 2 asks for argument, and the difference is that an argument has an opponent. An argumentative essay that never states the opposing position is not an argument; it is a position paper written in the hope that nobody was listening.
This unit has just given you a model of exactly that failure and its opposite. Ross and Boudinot each had to state the other’s position to argue against it, and one of them lost his platform for insisting it be printed.
A precise claim. Precision means narrow enough that evidence could settle it:
- The Cherokee documents show the Nation was sovereign. Not a claim — the documents say so and nobody in this class disputes it.
- Legal victory was not enough. A claim, but vague — not enough for what, and by what measure?
- The Cherokee instruments of 1827-1832 were designed to be read by a federal audience and succeeded with that audience completely, which is precisely why they could not protect the Nation from a state that had stopped caring what the federal audience thought. Precise. It names a mechanism and points at evidence.
A counterclaim is not a strawman. This is where ninth-grade arguments fail: the writer states the other side in its weakest form, defeats it in a sentence, and moves on. A reader who holds that position is not persuaded; they are insulted. W.9-10.1.b asks you to supply evidence for the counterclaim and name what is genuinely strong in it.
The test is uncomfortable and simple: would someone who actually holds this view recognize it as their view?
The shape of a concession paragraph. Four moves, in order:
- State it fairly. The strongest case for reading the documents as successful is Worcester itself: the Nation took its claim to the highest court of the United States and won, on the merits, in an opinion that affirmed its sovereignty in terms that are still cited.
- Concede what is true. That victory was real, it was not narrow, and it remains foundational in federal Indian law two centuries later.
- Turn. But a right that is affirmed and not enforced tests something other than the right.
- Re-anchor. The instruments were built to persuade, and they persuaded; what they could not do was compel, and the Nation had no way to make them.
The concession did not weaken the argument. It made it look like the product of someone who had read the other side, which is the only version a reader trusts.
What you submit today is not an essay: a claim, a fairly stated counterclaim with its own evidence, and the four-move plan. If you find yourself half-convinced while writing the counterclaim, say so in the organizer — switching sides at Stage 1 is a success.
Reading: A mentor concession, a model paragraph and the Stage 1 criteria
Elias Boudinot, Cherokee Phoenix, 11 August 1832; Worcester v. Georgia (1832); SLS original models | Text: Western Carolina University Hunter Library, Cherokee Phoenix digital collection (wcu.edu/library/DigitalCollections/CherokeePhoenix), vol. 4 no. 52 (11 Aug 1832); PG #29513 (the Gutenberg ebook) [not machine-checkable: includes text only on non-scriptable hosts; checked by hand] · SLS original; quoted passages are public domain (Cherokee Phoenix, 1832; U.S. Supreme Court opinion, 1832)
Your claim must be about the documents of 1821-1832, not about the model above.
Stage 1 of the Sovereignty Argument Essay is a claim, a fairly stated counterclaim with its own evidence, and a four-move plan for the concession paragraph. The reading gives you a mentor concession from a Cherokee writer, a model concession paragraph built on the unit’s documents, and the criteria Stage 1 is scored against. The documents you can cite are the Cherokee Constitution (Lesson 2.1), the Boudinot and Ross passages (Lesson 2.3, labeled B and R) and the Worcester passages (Lesson 2.5, labeled W).
A mentor concession, from Elias Boudinot (1832)
Boudinot on the Phoenix, “A few further explanations”
When I say that the continuation of the Phoenix has answered all the purposes that it can be expected to answer hereafter, I mean the purposes intended to be affected out of the Nation. The political rights of the Cherokees cannot be restored or secured by a continued investigation, or a repetition of the numerous and aggravated grievances which they have already laid before the American people. That the circulation of the paper has been ‘greatly instrumental in the diffusion of General knowledge among the Cherokees,’ there can be no doubt.
Cherokee Phoenix, 11 August 1832
Watch the four moves. Boudinot first states the other side’s claim as the other side would (the paper has been “greatly instrumental in the diffusion of General knowledge among the Cherokees”). He then concedes it plainly (“there can be no doubt”). The sentences before it turn: the paper’s purposes “out of the Nation” are exhausted. And he re-anchors by returning to his own claim, that political rights “cannot be restored or secured” by more argument. A reader who held the opposing view would recognize their own position in the concession, and that is the test.
A precise claim, and three that are not
| Sentence | Verdict |
|---|---|
| The Cherokee documents show the Nation was sovereign. | Not a claim: the documents say so, and no one in the class disputes it. |
| Legal victory was not enough. | Vague: not enough for what, by what measure? |
| The Nation’s instruments were written to persuade a federal audience and did, which is exactly why they could not protect it from a state that no longer cared what that audience thought. | Precise: names a mechanism (audience and enforcement) and points at evidence. |
A model concession paragraph (SLS original)
“The strongest case against my claim is Worcester v. Georgia itself. The Nation took its claim to the highest court of the United States and won: Marshall wrote that the Georgia law under which Worcester was convicted was, in his word, ‘void,’ and that the judgment was ‘a nullity’ (Worcester, W3). That victory was real, and it was not narrow. But a right that is affirmed and not enforced tests something other than the right, and Boudinot’s question in the Phoenix is the test: whether President Jackson would ‘obey the Supreme Court, and execute the treaties’ (Boudinot, B4). The instruments were built to persuade and they persuaded; what they could not do was compel.”
The two passages the model draws on, so you can check every quotation:
W3 (Worcester v. Georgia, 1832)
The act of the State of Georgia, under which the plaintiff in error was prosecuted, is consequently void, and the judgment a nullity.
Marshall for the Court, 31 U.S. 515
B4 (Boudinot, Cherokee Phoenix, 11 August 1832)
And has not an Hon. Judge of the Supreme Court made a similar communication, stating that the operation of the late decision of the Supreme Court cannot extend to our relief, unless the executive felt itself bound to enforce the treaties? And does President Jackson feel himself bound to obey the Supreme Court, and execute the treaties?
The four-move plan, as notes
- State it fairly: the strongest reading of Worcester as a success, in the terms its holders would use.
- Concede what is true: the ruling affirmed sovereignty on the merits and remains cited in federal Indian law.
- Turn: “But affirmed” is not “enforced,” and B4 shows the question was already asked in 1832.
- Re-anchor: the instruments succeeded with the audience they were written for and could not compel the one that mattered.
Criteria for the Stage 1 organizer (four levels)
| Criterion | Advanced (4) | Proficient (3) | Approaching (2) | Beginning (1) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Claim | Precise, contestable, names a mechanism, and anticipates the strongest reply. | Precise and contestable, names a mechanism. | A sentiment or a vague claim. | A fact everyone accepts. |
| Counterclaim | A holder of the view would recognize it; it has its own evidence and is answered on the merits. | Stated fairly with one quotation. | Stated briefly and in its weakest form. | A strawman. |
| Concession plan | Four moves, each specific to the documents. | Four moves in note form. | Two or three moves. | No plan. |
| Evidence | Four quotations from at least three documents, each with a label and a note. | Four quotations from at least three documents. | Four from one or two documents. | Fewer than four. |
Sources
Boudinot passage: Cherokee Phoenix, vol. 4, no. 52 (11 August 1832), Western Carolina University digital collections, retrieved 2026-09-26. Worcester v. Georgia, 31 U.S. 515 (1832), Marshall for the Court; Project Gutenberg ebook #29513, retrieved 2026-09-26. Models and criteria SLS original.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you, and your teacher, whether the standard below has landed yet.
Which of these is a precise claim suitable for the Unit 2 essay?
The safest way to handle the opposing view is to state it briefly in its weakest form so it is easy to refute.
The Worcester ruling affirmed the Nation’s sovereignty on the merits however, a right that is affirmed and not enforced tests something other than the right.
Submit your Stage 1 organizer: (1) your precise claim in one sentence; (2) the counterclaim, stated so someone holding it would recognize it, with one quotation supporting it; (3) the four moves of your concession paragraph in note form; (4) four quotations for your own case drawn from at least three of the unit’s documents, with citations.
How confident are you that you can state an opposing view so fairly that someone who holds it would recognize it as their own?