
specify criteria and constraints for a community’s hazard or impact, break it into smaller problems, and evaluate competing solutions with a cost-benefit ratio and trade-offs, defending my proposal before an audience.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. The council will ask you three hard questions. Write the three you most fear, and one piece of evidence you would use for each.
Weights: safety 5, cost 3, time 2. A solution scores safety 3, cost 4, time 5. What is its weighted total?
The challenge. For the client town (or your own community), choose one hazard or human impact it faces and propose an engineering solution that makes the community more resilient. Options include wildfire at the forest edge, earthquake shaking downtown, flooding and polluted runoff in the creek, drought, or the energy and mineral decision. You may work alone or in a team of up to three, with each member writing one section and all sharing the defense.
The engineering process you will follow.
A worked trade-off matrix (illustrative). A foothill town compares two wildfire solutions. Criteria and weights: lives protected (weight 5), cost (3), ecological harm (2), time to finish (2). Solution 1, a community fuel break, scores 4, 3, 2, 4; solution 2, a home-hardening grant program, scores 4, 2, 5, 2. Weighted totals: solution 1 = 5×4 + 3×3 + 2×2 + 2×4 = 20 + 9 + 4 + 8 = 41; solution 2 = 5×4 + 3×2 + 2×5 + 2×2 = 20 + 6 + 10 + 4 = 40. The totals are almost equal, which tells you something important: the choice depends on the weights, and on whether the two can be combined. State that honestly.
Equity and people. Hazards fall hardest on people with the fewest resources to prepare or recover. A strong proposal says who benefits, who pays, and how it will reach renters, older residents and people who do not speak English. Remember the human impact of the disasters you cite, and describe it accurately and with respect.
The defense. You will present to classmates acting as the town council, who will ask about cost, fairness and evidence. Prepare by anticipating the three hardest questions.
Plan and check your work before drafting.
Draft the core sections.
Draft your trade-off matrix: at least four weighted criteria and two solutions, with scores and totals. Then write three sentences explaining how your recommendation would change if the heaviest-weighted criterion were given half its weight.
Write the “causes and evidence” section: explain the Earth-science causes of your hazard or impact, cite at least two reliable sources, and say how technology has changed the community's relationship with it.
Write an engineering proposal for the client town (or your own community) and one hazard or human impact. Include (1) the Earth-science causes of the hazard, with evidence; (2) prioritized criteria and constraints, including societal needs and equity; (3) the problem broken into at least three smaller problems; (4) at least two solutions compared in a weighted trade-off matrix and with benefit-cost ratios; (5) evidence from a lab test or a simulation, with its limits; (6) a recommendation with its trade-offs, any negative consequences, and the parts of the problem it leaves unsolved. Cite Earle’s Physical Geology and national or local science agency sources. Label illustrative numbers.
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Criteria and constraints | Measurable, prioritized criteria and realistic constraints that account for societal needs, safety, cost and equity. |
| Problem decomposition | The problem is broken into at least three solvable sub-problems, each linked to part of the solution; residual problems are named. |
| Evaluation of solutions | Weighted trade-off matrix and benefit-cost ratios are correct, negative consequences are weighed, and the recommendation follows from them with trade-offs stated. |
| Hazard and impact science | Explains the Earth-science causes of the hazard or impact with evidence from reliable sources, how the solution reduces risk or human impact, and its effect on natural systems. |
| Evidence from testing | Uses lab or simulation evidence appropriately, compares it with expectations, and states its limits. |
| Communication | Clear, well-sourced proposal; the defense answers questions with evidence. |
Your proposal gives the town council something real to fund. Next: the unit checkpoint.
How confident are you that you can I can specify criteria and constraints, break down a hazard problem and evaluate solutions with trade-offs.
Exit ticket: which council question was hardest, and what evidence would make your answer stronger?
Timing: four 50-minute sessions: (1) plan and matrix; (2) drafting and partner recheck; (3) revision; (4) defenses. Allow the final write-up to be finished as homework if needed.
Setup: invite staff or family to sit on the mock council; a video call works. Students who choose their own community should use local sources but keep any personal disaster experience optional.
Listen for: matrices that hide a broken constraint; benefit-cost numbers without labels; equity mentioned only in the last sentence.
Support / stretch: provide a section-by-section outline and allow 800–1,000 words. Stretch: combine two solutions and show whether the combination beats either alone.