
construct and defend an evidence-based forecast, from real data and model results, of how carbon dioxide, temperature and sea level at a harbor city are likely to change by 2050.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. The planning office will give each team three minutes. Write the one sentence you most want them to remember about 2050.
Mauna Loa rose from 369.71 ppm in 2000 to 424.61 ppm in 2024. What was the average rate?
The question. By 2050, how much higher are carbon dioxide, global temperature and sea level at the harbor likely to be, how confident can we be, and how much depends on choices people make? A forecast is not a guess. It states a range, gives the evidence and the method, and says what would change it.
What to include.
Worked comparison 1: sea level. The sample harbor record rises about 2.0 mm per year when fitted from 1900, so a straight-line extrapolation adds 2.0 × 25 = 50 mm, about 5 cm, from 2025 to 2050. The 1993–2025 rate of about 2.4 mm per year gives about 6 cm. The recent global rate from the IPCC, 3.7 mm per year, would give about 9 cm. Climate models and the observed acceleration suggest the later decades will rise faster than any of these. A careful forecast therefore gives a range, for example 5–15 cm by 2050, and explains that extrapolation of a past rate is the low end. Sea-level scenarios published by national science agencies for coastal planning are worth citing; name the source and the scenario you use.
Worked comparison 2: carbon dioxide. A straight line through the Mauna Loa annual means for 2000–2024 has a slope of about 2.27 ppm per year and reaches about 482 ppm in 2050. A curve that allows the rate to keep increasing reaches about 506 ppm. Your class model gives about 470 ppm if emissions halve by 2050 and about 494 ppm if they grow 1% a year. The forecast depends on which assumptions you trust, and you must say why.
Uncertainty is not ignorance. Scientists are confident about the direction and approximate size of change and less certain about details, such as how fast ice sheets will melt late in the century. Separate the two clearly. Cite NOAA, NASA and the IPCC, and treat readers who hold different views with respect: let the evidence carry the argument.
Plan and check your work before drafting.
Draft the core sections.
Write the sea-level section of your forecast: give rates for two periods, the extrapolated rise to 2050 for each, and a forecast range with your confidence and one reason the real rise may be larger.
Write the carbon section: show the 2014–2024 carbon budget, explain where emitted carbon goes, and use your model to show how two emission scenarios change the 2050 concentration.
Write an evidence-based forecast of carbon dioxide, global temperature and sea level at the harbor in 2050 for the city’s planning office. Include (1) rates of change from at least two datasets for at least two periods each, with graphs; (2) the carbon-cycle and energy-balance mechanisms, with the carbon budget; (3) a comparison of a trend extrapolation with model scenarios, including the class model and the IPCC scenarios, and your hindcast test; (4) a forecast range for each quantity with your confidence and whether it is reversible; (5) how human choices change the outcome, and one design decision for the city; (6) a limits paragraph; (7) your Forecast Card V2 as a summary. Cite NOAA, NASA and the IPCC. Hand-drawn graphs are fully acceptable.
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Data analysis and forecast | Rates from real data for more than one period, correctly calculated and graphed, lead to a stated forecast range with confidence and a judgment of reversibility. |
| Computational representation | Uses model scenarios and a hindcast correctly and explains how human choices change the linked Earth systems. |
| Carbon-cycle mechanism | Explains where emitted carbon goes with a balanced budget, and why carbon dioxide rises; names model limits. |
| Uncertainty and limits | Names sources of uncertainty, including a data limitation or bias, and explains how each affects the range. |
| Argument and sources | Claims are supported by evidence; NOAA, NASA and IPCC sources are cited accurately; the defense answers a question with evidence. |
Your forecast gives the city something it can design to. Next: the unit checkpoint.
How confident are you that you can I can construct and defend an evidence-based forecast from data and model results.
Exit ticket: which question in your defense was hardest, and what evidence would make your answer stronger?
Timing: three 50-minute sessions: (1) plan and rate calculations; (2) drafting and partner recheck; (3) final edits and defenses. Allow the final write-up to be finished as homework if needed.
Setup: invite staff or family to play the planning office for the defenses; a video call works. The harbor gauge is sample data; students may instead use a real gauge the teacher names, with NOAA’s published trend.
Facts to keep careful: the 482 and 506 ppm figures and the 5–15 cm range come from Poly’s worked comparisons; the IPCC numbers are from AR6 WG1.
Listen for: single-number forecasts; “the model proves”; dismissing readers who disagree instead of answering with evidence.
Support / stretch: provide a section-by-section outline and allow 700–900 words. Stretch: add a heat-days panel using a local climate normal and explain how its uncertainty differs from the global one.