
evaluate the evidence that human activities are the main cause of recent warming, and analyze land-ice, sea-ice and tide-gauge data to argue about the rate of sea-level rise.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. An ice cube floats in a glass of water filled to the brim. When it melts, does the glass overflow? Write your prediction and your reason.
Which melting ice raises global sea level?
A question of evidence. Scientists concluded that human activity is the main cause of recent warming not from one graph but from many independent lines of evidence that point the same way. The IPCC’s 2021 assessment stated that it is unequivocal that human influence has warmed the atmosphere, ocean and land.
1. The carbon is from fossil fuels. Fossil fuels formed from plants and plankton millions of years ago, so they contain no carbon-14 (its half-life is 5,730 years) and, like all plant carbon, they are slightly low in carbon-13. As carbon dioxide has risen, the proportion of carbon-13 in the air has fallen, and carbon-14 was diluted even before nuclear-bomb testing added more. Oxygen in the air is also declining slightly, as expected when carbon fuels burn. Volcanoes cannot explain the rise: they emit well under 1 GtC per year, and their carbon has a different isotopic signature.
2. Physics and fingerprints. Carbon dioxide absorbs infrared energy (Unit 2). Satellites measure less infrared escaping at exactly the wavelengths carbon dioxide absorbs, the lower atmosphere is warming while the stratosphere cools, and Earth is now gaining energy, most of it stored in the ocean. Natural drivers, the Sun and volcanoes, would have produced slight cooling since the mid-1900s.
3. Sea level rises for two reasons. Seawater expands as it warms (thermal expansion), and water from melting glaciers and ice sheets on land flows into the ocean. The IPCC reports that global mean sea level rose about 0.20 m between 1901 and 2018; the average rate was about 1.3 mm per year from 1901 to 1971 and about 3.7 mm per year from 2006 to 2018. The rise is accelerating, and much of it is effectively irreversible for centuries: the deep ocean keeps expanding as heat mixes down, and ice sheets take a very long time to regrow.
Worked example: a harbor tide gauge (sample data).
| Harbor tide gauge (sample data) | Rate of sea-level rise |
|---|---|
| Whole record, 1880–2025 | 1.6 mm per year |
| 1900–2025 | 2.0 mm per year |
| 1993–2025 | 2.4 mm per year |
Sample data for a model harbor, shaped like a long real tide-gauge record. It is not a measurement of any real station.
At 2.0 mm per year, the sea at this harbor rose about 0.0020 × 125 ≈ 0.25 m, about 25 cm, between 1900 and 2025. Why is the harbor’s rate slower than the recent global rate? Local sea level also depends on whether the land is rising or sinking, on winds and currents, and on natural cycles such as El Niño, which can raise sea level along a coast for months at a time. Choosing the period matters, and a strong argument says which period it used and why. A gauge’s record can also be biased by changes such as moving the gauge or land sinking under the pier, which is why its data are checked against nearby stations and satellites.
Lab: Land ice, sea ice and sea level. Question: does melting ice raise the water level when the ice floats in the water, when it rests on land, or both?
| Cup | Ice position | Level before ice (mm) | Level with ice (mm) | Level after melting (mm) | Rise from start (mm) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | On land (clay) | ||||
| B | Floating (sea ice) |
Arguing well. A strong argument about causes weighs alternative explanations with evidence, not by who makes them. When you rebut a claim such as “The climate has always changed, so this is natural,” agree with what is true (it has changed before, for reasons you studied in Unit 2) and then show with evidence why those causes do not fit the present change.
Reading: Earle, Physical Geology, chapter 19.
Answer during and after the lab.
Write an argument and share it.
Write a CER argument rebutting one claim: (a) “The climate has always changed, so current warming is natural”; (b) “The extra CO₂ comes from volcanoes”; or (c) “Melting Arctic sea ice will flood the harbor.” Use at least two pieces of evidence from this lesson, including one calculation or your lab data. Respond in writing to a partner's strongest question.
Using the sample harbor rates, describe the harbor's sea level today compared with 1900, and state whether its rise is likely to be reversible by 2100. Give a reason.
The carbon is ours, the energy is building up, and the sea is rising faster. Next phase: how do models turn that evidence into a forecast?
How confident are you that you can I can evaluate the evidence for human-caused warming and analyze sea-level rates for different periods.
Exit ticket: name the two main causes of sea-level rise and one piece of evidence that the extra carbon dioxide comes from fossil fuels.
Timing: this lesson spans two 50-minute periods: day 1 the evidence lines and the ice lab (start it early, since melting takes 30–40 minutes); day 2 the tide-gauge analysis and the CER.
Materials (per team): two identical clear cups, modeling clay or a flat rock, four equal ice cubes, room-temperature water, a fine marker, a ruler with mm marks, goggles, paper towels.
Facts to keep careful: the harbor rates are sample data. The IPCC rates and the 0.20 m rise are from AR6 Working Group I.
Listen for: “sea ice melting floods coasts”; dismissing a counterclaim without evidence; mixing up global and local rates.
Support / stretch: provide CER sentence starters. Stretch: explain why a station’s 95% confidence interval narrows as its record gets longer.