
explain, with climate data and an energy-budget model, why two places have different climates, predict how a change in Earth’s energy flow would affect both, and recommend a tested schoolyard surface.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Write your central claim about Coastal Town and Inland City in one sentence. Underline the energy word in it.
Coastal Town's July high is 67 °F and Inland City's is 94 °F (sample data). What is the difference in °C?
The question. Why do two places, often only a few hours’ drive apart, have such different climates, how would a change in Earth’s energy balance affect each, and what does that mean for a hot schoolyard? Use Coastal Town and Inland City from the sample normals, or choose two real places with contrasting climates in your own region that your teacher approves and look up their NOAA normals.
What to include.
Three calculations. For example: an annual range from the normals (Valley Town 98 − 55 = 43 °F); a sun-angle intensity ratio (at 38.6° N, sin 74.8° / sin 28.0° ≈ 0.965 / 0.469 ≈ 2.1); a heat-capacity comparison from your lab (ΔTsand / ΔTwater); an energy-balance temperature for a changed albedo; or your tile’s rise as a percentage of the blacktop’s.
A worked paragraph. Claim: “Coastal Town’s summers are cool because its air is chilled by cold ocean water before it arrives.” Evidence: “The sample normals show Coastal Town’s July high is 67 °F, 27 °F cooler than Inland City’s 94 °F, although in January the two differ by only 2 °F; in our lab, 200 g of water warmed much less than 200 g of sand under the same lamp.” Reasoning: “Upwelling brings cold water to the surface off the coast in summer, and water’s high specific heat keeps it cold; air crossing it cools and forms the marine layer, which the heating valley then pulls inland through gaps in the coastal hills.”
Sources and limits. Cite NOAA or label sample data for every number you did not measure, and cite Earle’s Physical Geology, chapter 19, for background. Say what your explanation cannot settle, for example how climate change will affect coastal fog, which scientists are still studying and for which the evidence is mixed.
Plan and check before drafting.
Draft the core paragraphs.
Write the “energy budget” paragraph for one of your two places in claim-evidence-reasoning form, with one data value and one calculation.
Write the schoolyard recommendation paragraph: your V2 results against every criterion, and the energy-budget reason it works.
Write a scientific explanation of why two places have different climates, and recommend a schoolyard surface to the facilities department. Include (1) a data table of normals for both places; (2) an energy-flow diagram for each place in July; (3) at least three calculations; (4) a paragraph connecting the local climates to Earth’s global energy balance, the greenhouse effect and the drivers that change it; (5) a prediction of how both climates would change if less energy left Earth, with your confidence stated; (6) your tested schoolyard tile and recommendation; (7) a limits paragraph. Hand-drawn diagrams are fully acceptable.
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Energy-flow model | Explains each climate as a balance of energy in, moved, stored and out, and connects it to Earth’s global energy balance, the greenhouse effect and drivers on different time scales. |
| Properties of water | Uses specific heat and evaporation, with lab and tile evidence, to explain the difference in temperature range and the schoolyard result. |
| Data and calculations | Correct data in a clear table, sourced or labeled sample; three correct calculations with units; tile data compared with every criterion. |
| Explanation, prediction and presentation | Clear mechanism for each claim; prediction is reasoned and confidence is stated honestly; the presentation answers a question with evidence. |
You explained two climates and gave a client a tested design. Next: the unit checkpoint.
How confident are you that you can I can explain two climates with data and an energy-budget model and recommend a tested design.
Exit ticket: which part of your explanation are you least confident about, and what evidence would help?
Timing: three 50-minute sessions: (1) plan, data and calculations; (2) drafting and peer review; (3) final edits and presentations.
Setup: the sample places are the default. If students choose real places, they cite NOAA normals; check that both are in the same region and contrast clearly.
Listen for: explanations that list factors without a mechanism; predictions stated with false certainty; recommendations that ignore water use.
Support / stretch: provide a paragraph-by-paragraph outline and allow 700–900 words. Stretch: add a third place at a higher elevation and explain its climate with the same budget.