
Engineering Resilience for One Foothill Town
How can a community use Earth science and engineering to reduce its risk from hazards and use its resources wisely?
The mystery: A foothill town sits between a forested slope where wind-driven wildfires have destroyed neighboring towns, an active fault under an old downtown, and a paved creek that turns brown with every storm, while it decides where its energy and minerals should come from.
Questions we will figure out together in this unit:
explain the town council’s problem, the driving question and our need-to-knows, define criteria and constraints for a hazard solution, and choose reliable sources of evidence.
Phase 1: Spark
Do Now. The town council has $2 million and four problems: wildfire, earthquake shaking, a polluted creek and an energy decision. Which would you fund first? Write your choice and the one fact you would want before deciding.
Which kind of source is MOST reliable for the town's earthquake hazard?
Our client. The town council of a foothill town (a made-up town drawn from many real ones). Its east side climbs into forested hills, and homes now reach well into the trees. A mapped active fault runs a few kilometers to the west, and the old downtown is full of brick storefronts and apartments built over open ground-floor garages. The creek through town was paved over decades ago, so its first autumn storm sends muddy, oily water downstream. The council must also choose a new source of electricity and answer a company that wants to develop a mineral deposit in the hills. It has asked our class for engineering proposals it can act on.
The brief. The council’s letter asks each team to choose ONE hazard or impact (wildfire at the forest edge, shaking in the old downtown, polluted runoff in the creek, or the energy and mineral decision), explain its Earth-science causes, and propose a solution that is tested, priced and fair. The council wants to see at least two competing solutions compared before it spends any money.
Driving question. How can a community use Earth science and engineering to reduce its risk from hazards and use its resources wisely?
Criteria and constraints. Engineers define a problem before solving it. Criteria are what a good solution must achieve, stated so they can be measured. Constraints are limits it must respect. Worked example 1. For downtown shaking, Priya’s team wrote: criteria — C1 no building collapse in the design earthquake; C2 cut expected annual loss by at least half; C3 finished within five years. Constraints — K1 cost under $2 million in public money; K2 ground-floor shops and parking stay open; K3 renters are not pushed out by higher rents. Then they ranked them: a life-safety criterion comes first.
Worked example 2: judging sources. Evidence for a proposal can come from scientific theories, simulations, peer-reviewed studies and your own investigations. Ask four questions of each source: Who made it, and do they have the expertise? What data is it based on? Has anyone else checked it? Does it have a reason to exaggerate? A hazard map from a geological survey passes all four; a brochure selling homes near the forest may fail the last.
Teams and roles. Teams of four rotate roles each week: Hazard Scientist (keeps the Earth science accurate), Test Engineer (labs, simulations and data), Community Advocate (keeps every resident’s needs in view, including renters and older residents) and Project Manager (timeline, sources and the final submission).
Use the client’s brief. Discuss each card before you answer.
Choose a focus and build the need-to-know board.
Choose your team's hazard or impact. Write at least three ranked criteria and two constraints, including one about cost and one about fairness or culture.
Write eight need-to-knows (science, data, design and people) and name one reliable source you could use to answer each science or data question.
Client, brief, criteria and teams are set. Next phase we test the first solution with our own hands: a pavement that drinks the rain.
Exit ticket: restate the town's problem for your chosen hazard in one sentence that names who is affected and what the solution must achieve.
Materials: printed client brief and town map (made-up town), role cards, criteria-and-constraints organizer, sticky notes for the Wonder Board.
Setup: the town is generic. If a local emergency manager, city engineer or utility planner can visit or send a short video, use it, but keep the project town generic. Balance team choices so all four hazards are covered.
Listen for: criteria that cannot be measured; constraints left out entirely; treating any website as a source.
Support / stretch: give criterion stems (“reduce ___ from ___ to ___ by ___”). Stretch: assign weights to your criteria and justify the heaviest one.