
A 2050 Forecast for a Harbor City
By 2050, how much higher are carbon dioxide, temperature and sea level likely to be at a harbor city, how confident can we be, and how much depends on the choices people make?
The mystery: Carbon dioxide measured on Mauna Loa has risen every year since 1958, from 315.98 ppm in 1959 to 424.61 ppm in 2024, ever faster, while a harbor’s tide gauge records a sea that keeps creeping up the pier.
Questions we will figure out together in this unit:
explain the harbor city’s problem, the driving question and our need-to-knows, and describe what each climate dataset measures and how it could help predict conditions at the waterfront in 2050.
Phase 1: Spark
Do Now. A new school building is expected to last at least 50 years. Write down three things about the climate its designers would want to know about the year it turns 25.
An engineer designs a harbor wall using only the highest tide recorded in the last 100 years. What is the main risk?
Our client. The waterfront planning office of a harbor city. The city is about to build a new waterfront park, a school on filled land near the harbor, and a storm-drain outfall that must work for at least 25 years. Engineers have asked the office one question: what should we design for in 2050? The office has asked our class for an evidence-based forecast of carbon dioxide, temperature and sea level, with an honest range and a statement of confidence.
The brief. The office’s letter asks for: a forecast for 2050 of carbon dioxide, global temperature and sea level at the harbor; a range for each, not a single number; the evidence and method behind each range; how much the answer depends on what people do about emissions; and a short list of what would make the office change its plans. The forecast must be checked against the past before anyone builds on it.
Driving question. By 2050, how much higher are carbon dioxide, temperature and sea level likely to be at a harbor city, how confident can we be, and how much depends on the choices people make?
Three datasets, three jobs. Each record measures something different. The Mauna Loa record measures the concentration of carbon dioxide in well-mixed air, in ppm: the cause side of the story. GISTEMP measures global surface temperature as an anomaly in °C: the planet’s response. A tide gauge measures the height of the sea at one harbor, in millimeters, relative to the land the gauge stands on: the local effect the city must design for. A forecast that uses all three can link cause, response and local effect.
Worked example 1: a need-to-know list. Diego’s team sorted their questions. Science: Why is carbon dioxide rising, and where does the rest go? Data: How fast is the sea rising at the harbor, and is it speeding up? Models: How do scientists forecast decades ahead, and how good are they? People: Which choices change the answer, and who is affected?
Worked example 2: a first, rough prediction. If the harbor’s sea level rose 2.0 mm a year for the next 25 years, it would rise 2.0 × 25 = 50 mm, or 5 cm, by 2050. Is that the right number to design for? Only if the rate stays the same, and Lesson 3.01 showed that carbon dioxide’s rate has not. Testing that assumption is the work of this unit.
Teams and roles. Teams of four rotate roles each week: Climate Scientist (keeps the mechanism accurate), Data Analyst (rates, graphs, model runs), Planning Liaison (keeps the client’s design questions in view) and Project Manager (timeline, sources and the final submission).
Use the client’s brief. Discuss each card before you answer.
Build the team’s need-to-know board.
Write at least eight need-to-knows, two in each group: science, data, models and people. Star the three your team thinks matter most for the client.
For each of the three datasets, write one sentence on what it measures, one on why it matters to the harbor city, and one prediction it could support for 2050.
Client, brief, driving question and teams are set. Next phase we follow the carbon: into the air, into the ocean, and out of the ground.
Exit ticket: restate the client's problem in one sentence that names what must be forecast, for what year, and why a range is needed.
Materials: printed client brief, role cards, chart paper for need-to-know boards, sticky notes for the Wonder Board.
Setup: the client and harbor are generic. If a local planning office or engineer can speak or send a short video about design life, use it, but keep the project city generic. The tide-gauge rates used in this unit are sample data; say so.
Listen for: “a forecast is a guess”; confusing the global temperature with the temperature at the harbor; need-to-know lists with no model or people questions.
Support / stretch: provide question stems for each group. Stretch: find the design life of one real piece of public infrastructure and bring the source to 3.04.