
use a carbon budget to show that carbon is conserved as it cycles, revise the class model with evidence, name its limits, and brainstorm forecast products for the client.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. A bank account receives $11 a week. Its balance grows by only $5.50 a week. Write two places the rest could be going, and how you would check.
When fossil carbon is burned, some of it is destroyed, which is why only half stays in the air.
A carbon budget. Like a bank account, a reservoir’s change equals what comes in minus what goes out. For the whole Earth over one year: emissions = gain in the atmosphere + uptake by the ocean + uptake by land. Worked example 1. For 2014–2024, about 11 GtC was emitted each year. The atmosphere gained about 5.5 GtC (2.58 ppm × 2.13). If ocean and land took the rest in about equal shares, each took about 2.75 GtC: 5.5 + 2.75 + 2.75 = 11. The books balance, because carbon is conserved. Scientists who build the yearly global carbon budget also report a small “imbalance” term when independent estimates do not quite add up, and that term is a measure of their uncertainty.
Worked example 2: revising the model with evidence. Run the class model from 2014 (398.81 ppm) with 11 GtC a year and an airborne fraction of 0.45: it adds 2.32 ppm a year and reaches 398.81 + 23.2 ≈ 422.0 ppm in 2024. Observed: 424.61. The model is 2.6 ppm low. With an airborne fraction of 0.50 it adds 0.50 × 11 / 2.13 ≈ 2.58 ppm a year and reaches 424.6 ppm, matching the record. A model revised this way is better for the recent past, but the revision is itself a claim: it assumes the ocean and land will keep taking up half, and the warm-seltzer lab suggests a warming ocean may take less.
One chain, many systems. Put the unit together as one causal model. Burning fossil fuels moves carbon from the geosphere to the atmosphere. About half stays there and strengthens the greenhouse effect, so the surface warms. About a quarter dissolves in the ocean and lowers its pH, stressing shell-builders. About a quarter is taken up by plants and soils, helped by extra CO2 but limited by heat, drought and fire. Warming expands seawater and melts land ice, so the sea rises; a warmer ocean holds less CO2, a reinforcing feedback.
Limits of our models. The class model treats the whole ocean as one fixed share, ignores the deep ocean’s slow mixing, counts only CO2, and has no rocks at all, because the slow cycle is too slow to matter by 2050. Each omission is a reason to state a range, not a single number.
Ideate. The client needs something it can use. Brainstorm at least five possible forecast products before judging any: a one-page forecast card, a three-scenario chart, a spreadsheet the office can rerun, a list of “signposts” that would trigger a redesign, a short video for the public. Use “yes, and” rules: build on ideas, judge later.
CER sentence starters. Claim: The airborne fraction … Evidence: In 2014–2024 the atmosphere gained … while emissions were … Reasoning: Because carbon is conserved, the remainder must …
Work in your team. Check every number against conservation.
Write the synthesis CER.
CER: where did the carbon emitted from 2014 to 2024 go? Use the budget numbers as evidence, show that the parts add up, and explain with conservation of matter. Then name two limitations of your carbon model and how each affects a 2050 forecast.
Revise your 3.05 system diagram: add the airborne fraction as a changeable link, mark the reinforcing feedback, and write two sentences on how human activity is changing the relationship between the atmosphere and the ocean.
Every gigaton is accounted for, and our model is better and more honest. Next phase: compete forecast methods and build the first forecast card.
How confident are you that you can I can show that carbon is conserved in my model and explain its limits.
Exit ticket: which forecast product from today's brainstorm would you hand the client, and why?
Materials: chart paper, the 3.05 diagrams, calculators, sticky notes for the Ideate round.
Facts to keep careful: the equal ocean/land split is a rounded teaching value; real yearly budgets differ, and land uptake swings a lot from year to year.
Listen for: “carbon is used up”; revisions made with no evidence or with no stated assumption; Ideate rounds that judge too early.
Support / stretch: give a budget table with one blank per row. Stretch: find the airborne fraction that would match 2000–2014 and compare it with 0.50.