
construct and defend a water plan for an overdrawn groundwater basin, using a computational model, stated criteria and constraints, and evidence of feedbacks between Earth’s systems.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. The district board will give each team three minutes. Write the one sentence you most want them to remember.
Recharge is 400,000 acre-feet a year and pumping is 550,000. What percentage cut in pumping balances the budget?
The question. How should an overdrawn groundwater basin be managed so that it can supply people, farms and ecosystems for the long term? You may use the model basin from 1.05 or research a real overdrawn basin with U.S. Geological Survey and state or local water-agency sources. Either way, your plan must be built on evidence and tested with a model.
What to include.
A worked comparison (sample basin). A 27% pumping cut balances the budget at once. Managed recharge of 100,000 acre-feet in wet years, alone, does not: with two wet years in every five it adds an average of only 40,000 a year against a 150,000 overdraft, so storage keeps falling by about 110,000 a year. Combining a 15% cut (overdraft 67,500) with that recharge leaves a deficit of about 27,500 a year: close, but not yet sustainable. Our class’s Plan C, a 20% cut with 100,000 acre-feet of wet-year recharge, balances. Numbers like these let decision-makers see the trade-off between cuts that fall on farms now and projects that cost money to build.
Sources and respect. Cite Earle’s Physical Geology and any agency sources for facts you did not measure. Groundwater decisions affect real communities, including farmworkers and rural households whose wells go dry; write about them accurately and with respect.
Limits. Name what your model leaves out, such as differences within the basin, a warming climate shifting snow to rain, and uncertainty in recharge estimates, and how each could change your recommendation.
Plan and check your work before drafting.
Draft the core sections.
Write the “criteria and constraints” section of your plan: at least two measurable criteria and three constraints, ranked, with one sentence each explaining why it matters.
Write the “how water shaped the valley” paragraph: use evidence to explain how water availability and technology changed where people live and farm, and one unintended effect.
Write an evidence-based management plan for the district’s overdrawn groundwater basin. Include (1) the basin’s water budget as a system; (2) evidence of overdraft and at least one feedback; (3) how water availability and technology shaped the valley; (4) prioritized criteria and constraints; (5) a computational model, in a spreadsheet, JupyterLite or on paper, comparing at least two strategies over 20 years, with a graph and the creek’s habitat score; (6) your recharge-pond bed results; (7) a recommendation with trade-offs and a limits paragraph. Cite sources for facts you did not measure.
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Computational model | The model follows storage = storage + recharge − pumping correctly for at least two strategies over 20 years, with user-set inputs, a clear graph and a habitat score; results are compared with real basins and limits are named. |
| Feedbacks and data | At least one feedback is explained with evidence and classified as reinforcing or balancing; uncertainty in the data is stated. |
| Water and society | Explains with evidence how water availability and technology shaped settlement and farming, including one unintended effect. |
| Criteria and constraints | States and prioritizes measurable criteria and realistic constraints, including societal and ecosystem needs. |
| Recommendation and defense | Recommends a strategy supported by model and bed results; trade-offs and who bears them are stated honestly; the defense answers a question with evidence. |
Your plan gives the district something real to weigh. Next: the unit checkpoint.
How confident are you that you can I can construct and defend a groundwater plan built on a computational model and stated criteria and constraints.
Exit ticket: what question from the board was hardest to answer, and what evidence would make your answer stronger?
Timing: three 50-minute sessions: (1) plan and model runs; (2) drafting and peer rerun; (3) final edits and defenses. Allow the final write-up to be finished as homework if needed.
Setup: invite staff or family to play the district board for the defenses; a video call works. Real-basin research is optional; the model basin is the default and is sample data.
Listen for: plans that skip the creek or household wells; “the model proves” language; trade-offs that blame one group.
Support / stretch: provide a section-by-section outline and allow 700–900 words with a fully worked model. Stretch: add a climate scenario where wet years bring 20% less recharge and test whether the plan still meets C1.