
measure heat released by respiring seeds, calculate energy transfer between trophic levels, and argue from evidence why ecosystems support few top predators while matter is recycled.
Instruction
The puzzle. A Missouri oak-hickory woodland supports millions of grass plants and acorns, thousands of mice and chipmunks, dozens of hawks and snakes, and only a few bobcats. Why do the numbers shrink so sharply as you move up a food chain? The answer is about energy, and you can measure part of it with a thermometer.
Trophic levels and the ten percent rule. Producers capture light energy by photosynthesis. Primary consumers (herbivores) eat producers, secondary consumers eat herbivores, and so on. At each step, most of the energy in the food is not stored in the consumer’s body. Some food is not eaten or not digested, and most of what is absorbed is used in cellular respiration to power movement, growth and body heat, and leaves the organism as heat. On average only about 10% of the energy at one level becomes biomass at the next level; the real figure varies from roughly 5% to 20%. Worked example (illustrative): if the producers in a patch of woodland store 20,000 kJ per square meter per year, herbivores store about 2,000 kJ, secondary consumers about 200 kJ and tertiary consumers about 20 kJ. The top level receives only 0.1% of the energy the producers captured. A bobcat needs a lot of energy each year, so it needs a very large area of producers beneath it.
Where does the energy go? A measurement. Germinating seeds are alive and respiring rapidly, breaking down stored starch to fuel growth: C6H12O6 + 6O2 → 6CO2 + 6H2O + energy. Part of that energy is captured as ATP, and all of it eventually ends up as heat. In today’s lab you put soaked, germinating peas in an insulated cup and dry peas in another, with thermometers, and record temperatures for two days. In one illustrative run, the germinating peas warmed from 22.0 °C to 27.8 °C, a rise of 5.8 °C, while the dry peas rose by only 0.4 °C. That heat is energy leaving the food chain.
Matter cycles, energy does not. Energy enters an ecosystem as light and leaves as heat, a one-way flow. Matter is different: the carbon, nitrogen and phosphorus atoms in a dead oak or a bobcat are returned to the soil and air by decomposers, bacteria and fungi, and are used again by producers. Decomposition can be aerobic, releasing CO2, or anaerobic, in waterlogged soils, where it is slower and can release methane. Missouri’s fens show the slow side of the process. These spring-fed wetlands stay soaked with cool, low-oxygen groundwater, and MDC notes that some fens grow more plant material than their water allows to decay, so half-decayed plants pile up as peat. Drain such a soil and the balance flips: oxygen reaches the peat, aerobic microbes decompose it much faster, and the carbon it stored returns to the air as CO2.
Building the argument. Claim: ecosystems support few top predators because energy is lost as heat at every trophic level. Evidence: your seed data, the pyramid calculation, and counts of organisms at each level. A strong argument also addresses a counter-claim, such as there are few predators because people hunt them. Missouri has a real case of people removing a predator: MDC lists the mountain lion as extirpated since the 1920s, with no breeding population, and genetic samples suggest that many of the few confirmed each year wander in from western states. People explain why lions are missing. They cannot explain why, where predators are protected, the top level of every pyramid is still small.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Lab: Heat from germinating seeds
Question. Do respiring seeds release energy as heat, and how does this help explain energy loss between trophic levels?
Materials
- Dried peas or mung beans (about 1 cup), half soaked in water for 24 hours beforehand
- Two insulated foam cups with lids (or small vacuum flasks) and two thermometers or temperature probes
- Cotton wool, paper towels and a marker
- Work with a parent or guardian’s permission. Wear safety glasses when pouring water; wipe spills to prevent slips.
- Use a digital or alcohol (red-liquid) thermometer, never a mercury one; if a glass thermometer breaks, tell an adult at once and do not touch the pieces.
- Do not eat or taste the seeds; wash hands after the lab and compost the seeds afterward.
Procedure
- Drain the soaked (germinating) seeds and rinse them. Fill one cup two-thirds full with them and the other with the same volume of dry seeds.
- Push a thermometer into the center of each cup and seal around it with cotton wool and a lid. Label the cups.
- Record the starting temperature of each cup and the room temperature.
- Record all three temperatures every few hours during the day and first thing the next two mornings (a probe logger can record overnight).
- Graph temperature against time for both cups and the room.
- Calculate the temperature rise in each cup over 48 hours.
Data
| Time (h) | Germinating seeds (°C) | Dry seeds (°C) | Room (°C) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | |||
| 4 | |||
| 24 | |||
| 28 | |||
| 48 |
Analysis
- Compare the temperature rise in the two cups. What process explains the difference? Cite your data.
- Why were the dry seeds included? What alternative explanations does the control rule out?
- Write your argument about why few top predators exist, using your seed data and a pyramid calculation as evidence, and rebut one counter-claim.
- Name two sources of error (heat leaking out, uneven cup filling) and their likely effect on your results.
If you cannot do this lab in person: Use the illustrative data (germinating seeds 22.0 °C to 27.8 °C over 48 hours; dry seeds 22.0 °C to 22.4 °C) and the full 48-hour record in this lesson’s reading to complete the graph and analysis.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
If producers store 20,000 kJ/m2 per year, about kJ reach the secondary consumers.
Where does most of the energy a herbivore takes in from food go?
Draining a peat wetland speeds up decomposition because oxygen can reach the buried organic matter.
Write the rebuttal paragraph of your argument: state a counter-claim about why top predators are rare, and use evidence to explain why energy flow is still the better explanation.
How confident are you that you can use data and the ten percent rule to argue why ecosystems support few top predators?
Practice
Work these on paper or in your notebook, then open Check your answer. Aim for all of Fluency and Application; try at least one Challenge.
Printable version: this unit’s practice workbook (PDF)
Fluency
Build speed and accuracy with the core skill.
- Producers in an ecosystem capture 25,000 kJ of energy. Using the 10% rule, about how much energy reaches the primary consumers?
Check your answer
Answer: ≈ 2,500 kJAbout 10% of the energy at one level is passed to the next; the rest is used or lost as heat. - Producers in an ecosystem capture 50,000 kJ of energy. Using the 10% rule, about how much energy reaches the secondary consumers?
Check your answer
Answer: ≈ 500 kJAbout 10% of the energy at one level is passed to the next; the rest is used or lost as heat. - Producers in an ecosystem capture 50,000 kJ of energy. Using the 10% rule, about how much energy reaches the tertiary consumers?
Check your answer
Answer: ≈ 50 kJAbout 10% of the energy at one level is passed to the next; the rest is used or lost as heat. - Put these in order of trophic level, lowest first: red-tailed hawk, acorns, eastern chipmunk.
Check your answer
Answer: acorns (producer), chipmunk (primary consumer), hawk (secondary consumer)Energy flows from producers to herbivores to carnivores.
Application
Use the skill in context. Show your reasoning.
- Grass in a pasture stores 20,000 kJ/m2 in a year and the deer grazing it store 1,500 kJ/m2. What is the transfer efficiency, and how does it compare with the 10% rule?
Check your answer
Answer: 7.5%, a little below 10% but within the typical 5-20% range1,500 ÷ 20,000 = 0.075. - A hawk population (third trophic level: grass, mice, hawks) needs 5,000 kJ a year. Using the 10% rule, how much energy must producers store to support it?
Check your answer
Answer: About 500,000 kJ5,000 ÷ 0.1 ÷ 0.1 = 500,000. - Germinating seeds warmed from 22.0 °C to 27.8 °C in 48 hours, while dry seeds warmed by 0.4 °C. Explain the difference and connect it to energy loss in food chains.
Check your answer
Answer: The germinating seeds were respiring rapidly and releasing energy as heat (a 5.8 °C rise versus 0.4 °C). Every organism releases most of the energy it takes in as heat, which is why only a small fraction passes to the next trophic level.Cellular respiration transfers energy from food to ATP and heat.
Challenge
Stretch problems. Expect to think before you write.
- A field produces crops storing 10,000 kJ. Using the 10% rule, compare the energy people get by eating the crops directly with the energy they get by eating cattle fed the crops. What does this imply about how many people an area can feed?
Check your answer
Answer: About 1,000 kJ directly versus about 100 kJ through cattle, 10 times less. Eating lower on the food chain lets the same land feed more people.Direct: 10,000 × 0.1 = 1,000. Via cattle: 10,000 × 0.1 × 0.1 = 100.
Review
Keep earlier skills sharp.
- (Biology A) How many grams of CO2 are released when 36 g of glucose is completely respired aerobically? (glucose 180.16 g/mol, CO2 44.01 g/mol)
Check your answer
Answer: About 52.8 g36 ÷ 180.16 = 0.1998 mol glucose; × 6 = 1.199 mol CO2; × 44.01 = 52.8 g.
Where the Energy Goes: A Measured Pyramid, a Seed-Heat Record and Missouri’s Peat Fens
Odum (1957), Silver Springs energy budget, as reproduced by Kemp and Boynton (2004); Missouri Department of Conservation, Wetlands (fens and seeps) and Field Guide, Mountain Lion; SLS illustrative seed-heat record; retrieved November 5, 2026 · SLS original, citing published figures from Odum (1957) and public information from the Missouri Department of Conservation
Why this reading. Your argument needs three kinds of evidence the lesson names but does not print: a measured energy pyramid (the ten percent rule is a rule of thumb, and someone had to measure it), a complete temperature record from the seed investigation, and what Missouri’s peat-building fens show about decomposition. All three are here.
1. A pyramid that was actually measured
The classic measurement is Howard T. Odum’s 1957 study of Silver Springs, a large spring-fed river in Florida whose constant flow and clear water let him measure the energy captured and used at every feeding level over a year. His published energy-flow figures give these values for energy entering each trophic level, in kilocalories per square meter per year:
| Trophic level | Energy (kcal/m2/yr) | Fraction passed from the level below |
|---|---|---|
| Producers (aquatic plants and algae) | 20,810 | — |
| Herbivores (snails, turtles, insect larvae, some fish) | 3,368 | 3,368 ÷ 20,810 = 16.2% |
| Carnivores (fish, invertebrates) | 383 | 383 ÷ 3,368 = 11.4% |
| Top carnivores (gar, bass) | 21 | 21 ÷ 383 = 5.5% |
Three things to notice. The transfer fractions are not all 10 percent; they run from about 5 to 16 percent, which is the “roughly 5 to 20 percent” range the lesson gives, and the ten percent rule is their rough average. The top level receives 21 ÷ 20,810 = 0.1 percent of what the producers captured, exactly the fraction in the lesson’s worked example. And the numbers were reached by measuring oxygen production and consumption and the respiration of the organisms, not by counting animals: the pyramid is a pyramid of energy, and where the energy is not passed on, it has left as heat.
Apply the same arithmetic to the lesson’s Missouri oak-hickory woodland: producers 20,000 kJ/m2/yr, herbivores about 2,000, secondary consumers about 200, tertiary consumers about 20. A bobcat, fed from the third or fourth level, therefore stands on a very large area of grass, acorns and brush.
2. The seed-heat record (illustrative)
These are constructed teaching data, not measurements, written to the endpoints the lesson quotes: germinating peas from 22.0 to 27.8 °C in 48 hours, dry peas from 22.0 to 22.4 °C. Two insulated cups two-thirds full, a thermometer in the center of each, cotton wool and a lid sealing the top; room temperature read beside them.
| Time (h) | Germinating peas (°C) | Dry peas (°C) | Room (°C) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | 22.0 | 22.0 | 22.0 |
| 4 | 23.1 | 22.1 | 22.4 |
| 8 | 24.0 | 22.1 | 22.2 |
| 24 | 26.2 | 22.3 | 21.8 |
| 28 | 26.6 | 22.3 | 22.0 |
| 32 | 27.0 | 22.4 | 22.3 |
| 48 | 27.8 | 22.4 | 21.9 |
Rise over 48 hours: germinating +5.8 °C, dry +0.4 °C, room −0.1 °C. The dry cup is the control: it has the same insulation, the same mass of seed and the same room, so the 0.4 °C it gained is the most that insulation, handling or the room can explain. The other 5.4 °C came from the seeds themselves. Germinating seeds respire stored starch, and the energy not captured as ATP, and eventually all of it, leaves as heat. The curve also flattens: 2.0 °C in the first 8 hours, 2.2 °C in the next 16, 1.6 °C in the last 20. Heat is leaking out of the cup faster as the cup warms, which is your first source of error and the reason a vacuum flask gives a larger rise than a foam cup.
3. Missouri’s fens, from MDC
The Missouri Department of Conservation describes fens as spring-fed wetlands, “very diffuse springs,” whose ground stays saturated with cool groundwater. It explains that some fens produce more vegetation than their “cool, low-oxygen, fairly acidic water allows to decay,” and that this buildup of half-decayed plant material eventually becomes peat; Missourians have called these quaking or soggy patches bogs or shaking springs. Fens also hold muck, an organically rich, little-oxygenated soil. That is the slow, anaerobic side of decomposition: carbon stays stored in the soil because oxygen is scarce. Drain such a soil and the balance flips. Oxygen reaches the peat, aerobic microbes decompose it far faster, and carbon that had been stored for centuries leaves as CO2 while the peat shrinks. MDC notes that drainage “improvements” are already eliminating some Missouri wetland habitat. Matter cycles either way; the rate depends on oxygen.
Building the argument
Claim: ecosystems support few top predators because energy is lost as heat at every trophic level. Evidence: at Silver Springs only 5.5 to 16.2 percent of energy passed each step, and 0.1 percent reached the top; in the seed cup, respiring tissue warmed its surroundings by 5.4 °C more than the control, a direct measurement of energy leaving as heat. Reasoning: if most of what an animal eats is respired and leaves as heat, only a small fraction is available to whatever eats it, so each level up can support far less biomass. Rebuttal: a counter-claim says predators are rare because people hunt them. Silver Springs had no hunting of its gar and bass, and the pyramid still shrank by 90 percent or more at every step; hunting can make a rare predator rarer, but it does not explain a pattern that holds where predators are protected. Missouri’s mountain lions make the distinction clear. MDC lists them as extirpated since the 1920s, with no breeding population; it has confirmed an average of about 8 a year since the mid-2000s, and genetic samples suggest many come from western states. People explain why lions are missing from Missouri. They do not explain why bobcats, which are protected outside a regulated season and found statewide, are still far fewer than the rabbits and mice they eat.
Sources: Kemp, W. M., and W. R. Boynton, Productivity, trophic structure, and energy flow in the steady-state ecosystems of Silver Springs, Florida (Ecological Modelling 178, 2004), reproducing Odum’s 1957 energy-flow diagram (emergysociety.com); Missouri Department of Conservation, Wetlands (Groundwater Seepages: Fens and Seeps) (mdc.mo.gov); Missouri Department of Conservation, Field Guide: Mountain Lion (mdc.mo.gov); Missouri Department of Conservation, Field Guide: Bobcat (mdc.mo.gov)