
estimate population size by mark-recapture, calculate Simpson’s diversity index from quadrat samples, and use a computer model to explain how predator and prey populations affect each other.
Instruction
Why sample? Nobody can count every elk in the Ozarks or every plant in a meadow. Ecologists count a sample carefully and use mathematics to estimate the whole. 9-12.LS2.A.1 asks you to use these mathematical representations to explain what affects populations and biodiversity.
Mark-recapture. Capture a sample of animals, mark them harmlessly and release them. Later, capture a second sample and count how many are marked. If the marked animals have mixed evenly back into the population, the fraction marked in the second sample should equal the fraction of the whole population that is marked. The Lincoln-Petersen estimate is N ≈ MC/R, where M is the number marked in the first sample, C the size of the second sample and R the number of recaptures. Worked example: biologists mark 40 lizards; later they catch 50, of which 8 are marked. N ≈ 40 × 50 ÷ 8 = 250 lizards. The method assumes no births, deaths or migration between samples and that marks do not change an animal’s chance of being caught.
Measuring biodiversity. Biodiversity has two parts: richness (how many species) and evenness (how equally individuals are spread among them). Simpson’s diversity index combines both: D = 1 − Σn(n − 1) / [N(N − 1)], where n is the number of individuals of each species and N the total. D is the probability that two individuals picked at random belong to different species, from 0 (one species) toward 1 (very diverse). Worked example: quadrat A has four species with 10 plants each (N = 40). Σn(n − 1) = 4 × 90 = 360; N(N − 1) = 1,560; D = 1 − 360/1,560 ≈ 0.77. Quadrat B also has four species but 37, 1, 1 and 1 plants: Σ = 1,332 + 0 + 0 + 0; D = 1 − 1,332/1,560 ≈ 0.15. Same richness, very different diversity, because B is dominated by one species.
Why diversity matters. A diverse ecosystem usually has more pathways for energy and matter, so the loss of one species is less likely to cause a collapse. Unit 2 tests that idea on real Missouri ecosystems.
Predators and prey in a model. Populations are linked. More prey means more food for predators, so predators increase; more predators eat more prey, so prey decrease; then predators starve and decrease, and prey recover. The Wolf Sheep Predation model in NetLogo Web runs this with simple rules for each animal, and with the grass option on it adds a resource that limits the sheep. By changing one parameter at a time and watching the populations, you can test what makes the system stable and what makes it collapse.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Lab: Backyard quadrats and bean mark-recapture
Question. How diverse are two contrasting outdoor areas near you, and how accurately does mark-recapture estimate a population of known size?
Materials
- Quadrat frames (1 m × 1 m, from meter sticks or string and tent pegs)
- Clipboards, plant identification sheets (or photos to sort into morphospecies) and tally sheets
- A paper bag with a known number of white beans (hidden from the sampler) and a marker or a cup of colored beans for marking
- Tell a parent or guardian where you will work and stay within sight of an adult; wear closed shoes and sun protection outdoors.
- Do not pick or taste plants; some plants (such as poison ivy) can cause skin reactions. Wash hands after fieldwork.
- Move away from any stinging insects, ticks or other hazards, and tell the adult with you.
Procedure
- Choose two contrasting areas (for example a mowed lawn and an unmowed edge). Place a quadrat at random in each area three times by tossing a marker over your shoulder.
- In each quadrat, count the individuals of each plant type. Where you cannot name a plant, give it a code (species A, B, C) and photograph it.
- Calculate Simpson’s index for each area from the pooled counts.
- Mark-recapture model: take a scoop of beans from the bag, count them and replace them with the same number of colored beans (the “marked” animals). Shake the bag well.
- Take a second scoop, count the total and the colored beans, and calculate N = MC/R. Repeat three times and average.
- Count every bean in the bag and compare the true size with your estimates.
Data
| Area | Species (codes) | Counts per species | Total N | Simpson’s D |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Area 1 | ||||
| Area 2 |
| Trial | Marked (M) | Second sample (C) | Recaptured (R) | Estimate N = MC/R |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ||||
| 2 | ||||
| 3 |
Illustrative field data (Option B). Three 1 m × 1 m quadrats pooled in each of two areas of one neighborhood lot, and a bean model whose true answer is known. These are constructed teaching data, not a real survey.
| Area 1: mowed lawn | Count | Area 2: unmowed fence line | Count |
|---|---|---|---|
| Perennial ryegrass | 142 | Tall fescue | 34 |
| White clover | 31 | Queen Anne’s lace | 21 |
| Annual bluegrass | 18 | Chicory | 19 |
| Dandelion | 9 | Red clover | 17 |
| — | — | Yarrow | 12 |
| — | — | Common milkweed | 11 |
| — | — | Broadleaf plantain | 9 |
| — | — | Orchardgrass | 8 |
| — | — | Black-eyed Susan | 4 |
| Total N | 200 | Total N | 135 |
Bean model, true population 250 beans (hidden from the sampler): 40 beans were scooped, counted and replaced with 40 colored beans, so M = 40. Second scoops: 50 beans of which 8 were colored; 60 beans of which 11 were colored; 45 beans of which 6 were colored.
Work out Simpson’s D for each area and N = MC/R for each trial yourself. As a check, Area 1 comes out near 0.46 and Area 2 near 0.86, and the mean of the three estimates lands close to, but not exactly on, 250.
Analysis
- Which area is more diverse? Is the difference due to richness, evenness or both? Cite your indexes and counts.
- How close was your mark-recapture estimate to the true count? Which assumption of the method would most often fail for real animals, and how would that bias the estimate?
- Explain why the average of three trials is more reliable than one trial.
- Propose one human action that would change the diversity of Area 1 and predict the effect on Simpson’s index.
If you cannot do this lab in person: Choose one. All three earn full credit and end in the same two Simpson’s indexes, the same three mark-recapture estimates and the same answers to every analysis question. Option A — sample real ground. The procedure above. You do not need a large field: two contrasting patches of any park, yard, sidewalk strip or vacant lot will do, and a 1 m square of string with four sticks is a quadrat. Sort plants you cannot name into species A, B, C and photograph them. Run the bean model with any two kinds of dried beans, pasta shapes or buttons in a paper bag. Option B — the illustrative field data in the data section above. No internet and nothing to collect. Compute both indexes and all three mark-recapture estimates from the numbers given, then answer every analysis question, including which assumption of mark-recapture the bean model quietly satisfies that real animals would not. Option C — the hosted iNaturalist snapshot. This lesson’s second reading hosts a dated record for two contrasting Missouri places, Forest Park in St. Louis and Shaw Nature Reserve near Gray Summit: the eleven most-observed plant species in each in 2025, with Simpson’s D already worked for both (0.911 and 0.901). Use those two indexes directly, then work the mark-recapture part from the same reading’s American black elderberry counts in Forest Park, 10 observations in the first half of the year and 7 in the second, and try to find R, the number recaptured. You cannot: an observation records a species at a place and time, not an individual, and that is the same assumption question the other two options ask. Explain why in your analysis. Cite the reading and its retrieval date.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Ecologists mark 60 newts, then catch 45, of which 9 are marked. The estimated population is newts.
Two meadows each have five plant species. Meadow 1 has 12, 8, 5, 3 and 2 plants; meadow 2 has 26, 1, 1, 1 and 1. Which has the higher Simpson’s index?
Simulation & tools
Test predator-prey stability
Open the Wolf Sheep Predation model in NetLogo Web. (1) Choose the sheep-wolves-grass version, press setup and go, and let it run for 500 ticks. Sketch the three population curves. (2) Reset and change only wolf-gain-from-food from 20 to 10. Run 500 ticks and record what happens to the wolves and sheep. (3) Reset and turn the grass off (the sheep-wolves version). Record whether the system stays stable. Write three sentences explaining how a resource (grass) and a predator each limit the sheep population. Choose one. All three earn full credit and answer the same three questions. Option A is the model above. Option B, for no internet, is the record of three runs below: a constructed summary of how the model behaves, not a measurement. Option C is to play the model by hand.
| Run | Setting | What happened over 500 ticks |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | sheep-wolves-grass, default settings | All three cycle. Sheep rise to about 180, wolves peak near 70 about 25 ticks later, and grass falls as the sheep peak and recovers as they crash. The swings get smaller with each cycle and all three are still present at tick 500. |
| 2 | sheep-wolves-grass, wolf-gain-from-food lowered from 20 to 10 | Wolves gain too little from each sheep. Their numbers fall steadily and they die out near tick 120. The sheep then rise until grass, not wolves, limits them, and settle near 400 with the grass cropped short. |
| 3 | sheep-wolves, grass turned off | Nothing limits the sheep but wolves. The first cycle overshoots badly: sheep climb past 1,000, wolves boom, the sheep crash almost to zero, and one population or the other is usually extinct before tick 300. |
Option C — play it by hand. You need about 60 small objects in two colors (sheep and wolves), a pile of a third thing for grass, and one die. Start with 20 sheep, 4 wolves and 30 grass. Each round: every sheep eats one grass, and sheep that find none are removed; every wolf eats one sheep, and wolves that find none are removed; each surviving sheep has a lamb on a roll of 1-3 and each surviving wolf a pup on a roll of 6; then add 10 grass back. Run 20 rounds and graph all three counts. Play it twice more, once with wolves eating only on even-numbered rounds (the low wolf-gain case) and once with unlimited grass, and answer the same three questions from your own graphs.
Open NetLogo Web ↗ · NetLogo Web, Northwestern University CCL · GPL open source
Two communities with the same number of species always have the same biodiversity index.
How confident are you that you can estimate a population by mark-recapture and calculate a diversity index from sample data?
Practice
Work these on paper or in your notebook, then open Check your answer. Aim for all of Fluency and Application; try at least one Challenge.
Printable version: this unit’s practice workbook (PDF)
Fluency
Build speed and accuracy with the core skill.
- Biologists mark 60 fence lizards and later catch 45, of which 9 are marked. Estimate the population.
Check your answer
Answer: 300N = MC/R = 60 × 45 ÷ 9 = 300. - 25 three-toed box turtles are marked; a second sample of 30 includes 6 marked. Estimate the population.
Check your answer
Answer: 12525 × 30 ÷ 6 = 125. - 120 trout are tagged; a later catch of 100 includes 16 tagged. Estimate the population.
Check your answer
Answer: 750120 × 100 ÷ 16 = 750.
Application
Use the skill in context. Show your reasoning.
- A quadrat has four species with 20, 5, 3 and 2 individuals. Calculate Simpson’s diversity index.
Check your answer
Answer: D ≈ 0.53Σn(n − 1) = 380 + 20 + 6 + 2 = 408; N(N − 1) = 30 × 29 = 870; D = 1 − 408/870 = 0.531. - A second quadrat has five species with 12, 8, 5, 3 and 2 individuals (D ≈ 0.75). Explain why it is more diverse than the first, using richness and evenness.
Check your answer
Answer: It has one more species (higher richness) and individuals are spread more evenly, whereas the first is dominated by one species with 20 of 30 individuals.Simpson’s index rises with both richness and evenness. - In a mark-recapture study, marked squirrels learn to avoid the traps. Will the estimate be too high or too low? Explain.
Check your answer
Answer: Too high: fewer marked animals are recaptured (R is too small), and dividing by a smaller R gives a larger N.N = MC/R; a smaller R inflates N.
Challenge
Stretch problems. Expect to think before you write.
- In the Wolf Sheep Predation model with grass, reducing wolf-gain-from-food from 20 to 10 often makes the wolves die out, after which the sheep level off. Explain both results in terms of energy and carrying capacity.
Check your answer
Answer: Wolves get less energy per sheep eaten, so they cannot reproduce fast enough to replace losses and die out. Without predators, the sheep grow until the grass limits them, leveling off near the carrying capacity set by grass regrowth.Connect energy transfer between levels to population size, and resource limits to K.
Review
Keep earlier skills sharp.
- For the data 12, 15, 17, 20, 21, 23, 23, 23, 39: find the mean, median, range and interquartile range. (Find the quartiles as the medians of the lower and upper halves, leaving out the overall median when the count is odd.)
Check your answer
Answer: mean = 21.44; median = 21.0; range = 27; IQR = 7.0 (Q1 = 16.0, Q3 = 23.0)
Two Missouri Places, Eleven Species Each: A Dated iNaturalist Snapshot for Simpson’s Index
iNaturalist API, research-grade plant observations in 2025 for Forest Park, St. Louis (place 117643) and Shaw Nature Reserve (place 143935), species counts and American black elderberry counts by half-year; retrieved November 5, 2026 · SLS original, with aggregated observation counts from iNaturalist (the counts are facts about the public record; individual observations carry their observers’ own licenses)
Why this reading. Option C of the lab sends you to the public record. The record is hosted here, dated, so the option works with no internet and so that everyone comparing answers is using the same numbers. Two contrasting Missouri places were chosen: Forest Park, a large city park in St. Louis, and Shaw Nature Reserve, a reserve of prairie, woodland and glade near Gray Summit run by the Missouri Botanical Garden. The filters were plants only, the year 2025, and research-grade records (identified and agreed by more than one person). Each list is cut after the eleventh species because three species tie for ninth place in Forest Park and four tie for eighth at Shaw; eleven is where both ties end.
Forest Park, St. Louis (358 plant species recorded)
| Rank | Species | Observations |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Mayapple (Podophyllum peltatum) | 25 |
| 2 | Virginia springbeauty (Claytonia virginica) | 22 |
| 3 | River oats (Chasmanthium latifolium) | 19 |
| 4 | Blue phlox (Phlox divaricata) | 17 |
| 5 | Golden Alexanders (Zizia aurea) | 17 |
| 6 | American black elderberry (Sambucus canadensis) | 17 |
| 7 | Red columbine (Aquilegia canadensis) | 16 |
| 8 | White snakeroot (Ageratina altissima) | 16 |
| 9 | Baldcypress (Taxodium distichum) | 15 |
| 10 | Partridge pea (Chamaecrista fasciculata) | 15 |
| 11 | Tall bellflower (Campanulastrum americanum) | 15 |
| Total, top eleven | 194 |
iNaturalist flags ten of these eleven as native at this place. The exception is baldcypress, a swamp tree of southeast Missouri that grows in the park where it was planted. Of the park’s 358 species recorded in 2025, iNaturalist counts 279 as native, about 78 percent.
Shaw Nature Reserve, Gray Summit (448 plant species recorded)
| Rank | Species | Observations |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Painted-cup paintbrush (Castilleja coccinea) | 43 |
| 2 | Canadian lousewort (Pedicularis canadensis) | 33 |
| 3 | Blue phlox (Phlox divaricata) | 23 |
| 4 | American persimmon (Diospyros virginiana) | 21 |
| 5 | American columbo (Frasera caroliniensis) | 20 |
| 6 | Eastern beebalm (Monarda bradburyana) | 19 |
| 7 | Grey-headed coneflower (Ratibida pinnata) | 18 |
| 8 | Butterfly milkweed (Asclepias tuberosa) | 17 |
| 9 | Eastern gamagrass (Tripsacum dactyloides) | 17 |
| 10 | Yellow crownbeard (Verbesina helianthoides) | 17 |
| 11 | Leadplant (Amorpha canescens) | 17 |
| Total, top eleven | 245 |
All eleven are flagged as native. Of the reserve’s 448 species recorded in 2025, iNaturalist counts 406 as native, about 91 percent.
Worked: Simpson’s D for the two top-eleven lists
D = 1 − Σn(n − 1) ÷ [N(N − 1)].
- Forest Park. Σn(n − 1) = 25×24 + 22×21 + 19×18 + 17×16 + 17×16 + 17×16 + 16×15 + 16×15 + 15×14 + 15×14 + 15×14 = 3,330. N(N − 1) = 194 × 193 = 37,442. D = 1 − 0.0889 = 0.911.
- Shaw Nature Reserve. Σn(n − 1) = 43×42 + 33×32 + 23×22 + 21×20 + 20×19 + 19×18 + 18×17 + 17×16 + 17×16 + 17×16 + 17×16 = 5,904. N(N − 1) = 245 × 244 = 59,780. D = 1 − 0.0988 = 0.901.
Both indexes are high because the top eleven species are fairly even in both places. Forest Park’s is slightly higher because its list has no dominant species: its top species is 1.7 times its eleventh (25 against 15), while Shaw’s painted-cup paintbrush is 2.5 times its eleventh (43 against 17). Richness tells a different story from the index here: 448 species recorded at the reserve against 358 in the park, and a larger share of them native. A higher index for the top of a list does not mean a more diverse place.
Worked: the checks in the lesson
- Meadow 1 (12, 8, 5, 3, 2): Σ = 132 + 56 + 20 + 6 + 2 = 216; 30 × 29 = 870; D = 1 − 0.248 = 0.75. Meadow 2 (26, 1, 1, 1, 1): Σ = 650; D = 0.25. Same richness, three times the diversity.
- Option B, Area 1 (142, 31, 18, 9): Σ = 21,330; 200 × 199 = 39,800; D = 0.46. Area 2 (nine species, N = 135): Σ = 2,538; 135 × 134 = 18,090; D = 0.86.
- Option B beans: 40 × 50 ÷ 8 = 250; 40 × 60 ÷ 11 = 218; 40 × 45 ÷ 6 = 300; mean 256, against a true 250. Newts: 60 × 45 ÷ 9 = 300.
The mark-recapture part, and why it fails on purpose
American black elderberry in Forest Park in 2025, research grade: 10 observations from January through June and 7 from July through December (17 for the year). Treat the first half as the marking period, M = 10, and the second as the recapture sample, C = 7. Now try to find R, the number of elderberry shrubs photographed in the second half that had also been photographed in the first. You cannot: an observation records a species at a place and time, not an individual, so nothing is marked and no recapture can be recognized. Lincoln-Petersen also assumes every individual is equally likely to be caught; observation counts are highest where people walk, on weekends, in flowering or fruiting season, and for showy plants. (Several species in these lists were observed almost only in spring: painted-cup paintbrush at Shaw had 43 observations from January through June and none from July through December.) That is the assumption question all three options ask. The bean model quietly satisfies it, because a shaken bag has no trails or weekends; real animals and real observers do not.
Your turn
- Compute D for the top five species in each place and compare with the top-eleven value. (Check: Forest Park 0.80, Shaw 0.79.) What does dropping species do to the index, and why?
- Which place is more diverse, and is the difference richness, evenness or both? Cite the indexes, the species totals and the counts.
- Name one human action that would change the park’s diversity and predict its effect on D.
- Explain in two sentences why observation counts are not counts of plants, and what a quadrat survey does that this record cannot.
Sources: iNaturalist API, observations/species_counts (place_id 117643 and 143935, iconic_taxa Plantae, quality_grade research, year 2025) (api.inaturalist.org); iNaturalist API, observations (American black elderberry, taxon 84300, Forest Park, 2025, by month range) (api.inaturalist.org); iNaturalist API, observations/species_counts with native=true (same filters), for the native-species totals (api.inaturalist.org); iNaturalist API documentation (api.inaturalist.org)