THE VR SCHOOL
  • Schools & Districts
    • License the academy
    • Free program for your students
    • Request a demo
  • Catalog
    • AI & Data
    • Cybersecurity & Web
    • Programming
    • Health Science
    • All Guilds
    • All courses
  • Families
  • Accreditation
  • Log In
  • Request a demo
  • Home
  • Courses

RLP Biology B — Ecosystems, Evolution and Human Impact

Curriculum

  • 5 Sections
  • 23 Lessons
  • 10 Weeks
Expand all sectionsCollapse all sections
  • Unit 1: Ecosystems: Carrying Capacity, Energy and Matter
    5
    • 1.1
      Phenomenon: The Elk Return to the Missouri Ozarks
      50 mins
    • 1.2
      Duckweed in a Cup: Measuring Population Growth
      50 mins
    • 1.3
      Why So Few Bobcats? The Energy Pyramid Argument
      100 mins
    • 1.4
      Counting the Uncountable: Sampling Biodiversity and Populations
      100 mins
    • 1.5
      Performance Task — What Limits the Ozark Elk?
      150 mins
  • Unit 2: Stability, Change and Human Impact: Engineering for Missouri Ecosystems
    5
    • 2.1
      Phenomenon: From Open Glade to Cedar Thicket
      50 mins
    • 2.2
      Salt and Survival: Brine Shrimp Hatching Across Salinities
      50 mins
    • 2.3
      The Pallid Sturgeon Debate: Causes, Criteria and Constraints
      100 mins
    • 2.4
      Fire in the Forest: Testing Solutions With Prototypes and Simulations
      100 mins
    • 2.5
      Performance Task — Design Brief: Protecting a Missouri Ecosystem
      200 mins
  • Unit 3: Evolution: Evidence and Mechanisms
    5
    • 3.1
      Phenomenon: Pale Fish in Missouri’s Caves
      50 mins
    • 3.2
      Hunting the Dots: A Natural Selection Investigation
      100 mins
    • 3.3
      Many Lines, One Conclusion: The Evidence for Common Ancestry
      100 mins
    • 3.4
      Adaptation in Action: Modeling Selection and Resistance
      100 mins
    • 3.5
      Performance Task — Explaining the Grotto Sculpin
      150 mins
  • Unit 4: Behavior, Populations and Population Genetics
    5
    • 4.1
      Phenomenon: The Booming Grounds of Missouri’s Prairie-Chickens
      50 mins
    • 4.2
      Pill Bug Choices: Investigating Behavior
      100 mins
    • 4.3
      Alarm Calls and Helpers: When Does Group Behavior Pay?
      100 mins
    • 4.4
      Hardy-Weinberg and Genetic Drift: Is This Population Evolving?
      100 mins
    • 4.5
      Performance Task — The Prairie-Chicken Rescue Report
      150 mins
  • Unit 5: Missouri Biology Supplement
    3
    • 5.1
      Two Ways to Make Offspring, and What Embryos Reveal
      50 mins
    • 5.2
      Life and Earth Change Each Other
      50 mins
    • 5.3
      Resources, Hazards and Sustainability in Missouri
      50 mins

Performance Task — Explaining the Grotto Sculpin

Unit 3  ·  Culminating Performance Task  ·  Lesson 15 of 23

Performance Task — Explaining the Grotto Sculpin

9-12.LS4.B.1RLP-BIOB
Cross-section showing mottled surface sculpins and pale, small-eyed grotto sculpins isolated in a cave stream
By the end of this lesson I can…

construct and defend an evidence-based explanation, with a labeled map or model, of how natural selection and isolation could have produced the differences between Missouri’s grotto sculpin and its surface relative, the banded sculpin.

Instruction

The question. How could a population of sculpins living in Perry County’s caves have come to differ so much from the banded sculpins of Ozark streams that biologists now treat it as a separate species?

What a strong explanation contains.

  1. The four factors (9-12.LS4.B.1). Apply each factor to the cave sculpins: sculpins produce more young than survive (a single nest in Mystery Cave held about 200 eggs); individuals vary in eye size, color and sensory pores, partly heritably; food is scarce in caves, and adults even eat young sculpins, so not all survive; and those whose traits suit their environment leave more offspring. Use your predation-lab data to show how an advantage changes a trait’s proportion.
  2. Adaptation to local environments (9-12.LS4.C.1). Explain why a mottled, camouflaged pattern could be favored in sunlit streams, where predators hunt by sight, and why that advantage disappears in total darkness. Then explain the cave traits: smaller eyes and larger sensory pores could be favored because building eyes costs energy in a food-poor cave and other senses find food in the dark. Present these as hypotheses supported by evidence (for example, cave fish grow and burn energy more slowly, and live at about one-sixth the density of fish at the resurgences), and say what evidence would test them.
  3. Isolation and speciation (9-12.LS4.C.2). Explain how life in separate cave systems and drainages limits gene flow: no other sculpin species lives within the grotto sculpin’s range, each drainage studied carries its own DNA lineage, and cave water may reach spawning temperature months before surface streams. Explain how differences accumulated until the cave population became a separate lineage.
  4. Evidence of common ancestry (9-12.LS4.A.1). Explain what evidence shows that grotto and banded sculpins share a common ancestor (shared features such as a complete lateral line found in no other Missouri sculpin; DNA comparisons among populations) and how it is interpreted.
  5. Honest uncertainty. Scientists agree that cave fish descend from surface ancestors and have diverged through evolution. They debate details: how much eye loss comes from natural selection and how much from harmless-in-the-dark mutations piling up once eyes no longer matter (a 2023 review concludes that both most likely contribute), how many times cavefish moved underground, and how many species to recognize. Say what is well supported and what is debated.

A worked example of one link. Claim: in sunlit Ozark streams, the mottled pattern of banded sculpins is maintained because it reduces predation by animals that hunt by sight. Evidence: in the predation lab, the color matching the background rose from a proportion of 0.50 to about 0.89 in four generations, while the control habitat, where neither color was hidden, showed no steady trend. Reasoning: if sight-hunting predators find camouflaged sculpins less often, camouflaged individuals survive and reproduce more, and because the pattern is heritable its proportion stays high. In a cave there is no light, so, like the control habitat, color no longer affects who is caught, and the trait is no longer protected by selection. Note the limit: the lab is a model, so field data would be needed to confirm the mechanism.

Presentation. Record a four-minute presentation of your map or model, and finish by answering one of the evidence questions listed in the task.

📖 Read for this lesson

The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.

  • Into the Dark: What Has Actually Been Measured on Missouri’s Cave FishU.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, grotto sculpin proposed rule 77 FR 59488 (2012) and final rule 78 FR 58938 (2013), public domain; Missouri Department of Conservation Field Guide entries for the banded sculpin, grotto sculpin, Ozark cavefish, Salem Plateau cavefish and Shawnee Hills cavefish; Adams, Burr and Starkey, Zootaxa 3609 (2013), Niemiller et al., Evolution 67 (2013), Hart et al., Proc. R. Soc. B 292 (2025), Brownstein et al., Mol. Biol. Evol. 42 (2025) and Culver, Kowalko and Pipan, Front. Ecol. Evol. 11 (2023), abstracts; retrieved Nov. 5, 2026 · about 8 min

    Your explanation needs the measured facts about life in the cave (6,265 captures of 4,218 grotto sculpins, densities of 0.037 per m² in caves against 0.225 at resurgences, slower growth and metabolism underground) and the current state of the debate over why eyes shrink, so your labeled map and your account of what is settled and what is still debated can cite real findings rather than the phenomenon lesson’s summary.

Vocabulary in context

  • troglomorphic — Having the traits typical of animals adapted to constant darkness, such as reduced eyes, little pigment and enhanced non-visual senses.
  • gene flow — The transfer of alleles between populations when individuals move and interbreed.
  • hypothesis — A testable, evidence-based explanation for an observation.
  • relaxed selection — A weakening of natural selection on a trait once it no longer affects survival or reproduction, so mutations that damage it are no longer removed.

Formative check

Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.

+50 XP

What limits gene flow between Perry County’s grotto sculpins and banded sculpins elsewhere in the Ozarks?

Banded sculpins live in neighboring watersheds and do enter caves elsewhere, but not in the grotto sculpin’s range; separation, not inability to swim, keeps the populations apart.
Myth or Fact?

Grotto sculpins have small eyes because each fish’s eyes shrank from disuse during its life, and the shrinking was passed on to its young.

Heritable variation already present was selected or drifted over many generations; individuals do not pass on changes made during their lives.

Write one link of your explanation as claim, evidence and reasoning, and add one sentence stating its main limitation.

0 words
Quick self-check

How confident are you that you can build and defend an explanation of adaptation and speciation using evidence?

Not yetVery confident

Unit 3 checkpoint

Do this before you start the task. It covers the whole unit and tells you what to review first.

+50 XP

What usually starts the process of speciation?

Isolated populations change independently.
Myth or Fact?

A cave population that stops exchanging genes with surface populations can accumulate heritable differences until it becomes a separate species.

Without gene flow, differences accumulate; Missouri’s grotto sculpin split from the banded sculpin this way.
+50 XP

Which is required for natural selection?

Selection acts on existing heritable variation.
Fill in the blank

20 green and 40 brown dots survive; scaled to 100, the proportion of brown is about .

+50 XP

Which is a pair of homologous structures?

Same bones from a common mammal ancestor.
+50 XP

Whales have small pelvic bones embedded in their bodies. These are best described as:

Reduced remnants of structures that were functional in ancestors.
Fill in the blank

Two 20-base sequences that differ at 4 positions are % identical.

Myth or Fact?

Independent lines of evidence, such as fossils and DNA comparisons, give largely matching pictures of evolutionary relationships.

Agreement among independent lines is what makes common ancestry so strongly supported.
+50 XP

An antibiotic is used and resistant bacteria become common. What caused the resistance mutations?

Selection acts on variation that arises independently of need.
Fill in the blank

If 10 of 1,000 bacteria are resistant and an antibiotic kills 90% of the rest, about % of survivors are resistant (one decimal).

+50 XP

Which species is most at risk of extinction from rapid environmental change?

Slow reproduction, low variation and no refuge limit adaptation.

Submit: Explaining the Grotto Sculpin (900-1,300 words with a labeled map or model) + recorded four-minute presentation

Task: Write an evidence-based explanation of how natural selection and geographic isolation could have produced the differences between the grotto sculpins of Perry County’s caves and the banded sculpins of Ozark streams. Apply the four factors of natural selection, explain at least two local adaptations as hypotheses with evidence, explain how isolation leads to a separate lineage and reproductive isolation, describe evidence that shows common ancestry, and state what is still debated. Use evidence from the predation lab, the evidence gallery and the Natural Selection simulation. Hand-drawn maps and models are fully acceptable.

Evidence questions for the presentation (answer one): (1) Which piece of your evidence is strongest, and why? (2) What result would make you change your explanation? (3) How does the control habitat in the predation lab help explain what happens to color in a dark cave?

Submission workflow

  1. Stage 1 — Plan. A draft map or model and a table linking each part of your explanation to evidence.
  2. Stage 2 — Checklist-reviewed draft. Check your draft against the rubric: are all four factors applied correctly, are hypotheses labeled as hypotheses, and does every claim cite evidence? You may also ask a parent, guardian or other adult to read it with the rubric. Submit the completed checklist and your revision plan.
  3. Stage 3 — Final explanation. 900-1,300 words with the revised map or model, data displays, citations and an uncertainty paragraph.
  4. Stage 4 — Presentation and defense. A recorded four-minute presentation that ends by answering one of the evidence questions in the task.

How it is scored

CriterionWhat proficient looks like
Natural selection (9-12.LS4.B.1)Applies all four factors accurately to the cave sculpins, with lab data showing how an advantage changes a trait’s proportion.
Adaptation (9-12.LS4.C.1)Explains local adaptations as evidence-based hypotheses and names evidence that would test them.
Speciation (9-12.LS4.C.2, CCC.2)Explains how separate caves and drainages limit gene flow and lead to a separate lineage and reproductive isolation.
Common ancestry (9-12.LS4.A.1)Describes appropriate evidence for common ancestry and how it would be interpreted.
Explanation and uncertainty (SEP.6)Distinguishes well-supported conclusions from open questions accurately.
Evidence and communication (RST.9-10.1)Claims tied to data and cited sources; presentation answers a question accurately.

Missouri Learning Standards — Science addressed: 9-12.LS4.B.1, 9-12.LS4.C.1, 9-12.LS4.C.2, 9-12.LS4.A.1, SEP.6, CCC.2, RST.9-10.1

Instructional focus: Evidence-based explanation of adaptation and speciation in a Missouri species

Reading

Into the Dark: What Has Actually Been Measured on Missouri’s Cave Fish

U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, grotto sculpin proposed rule 77 FR 59488 (2012) and final rule 78 FR 58938 (2013), public domain; Missouri Department of Conservation Field Guide entries for the banded sculpin, grotto sculpin, Ozark cavefish, Salem Plateau cavefish and Shawnee Hills cavefish; Adams, Burr and Starkey, Zootaxa 3609 (2013), Niemiller et al., Evolution 67 (2013), Hart et al., Proc. R. Soc. B 292 (2025), Brownstein et al., Mol. Biol. Evol. 42 (2025) and Culver, Kowalko and Pipan, Front. Ecol. Evol. 11 (2023), abstracts; retrieved Nov. 5, 2026 · SLS original, summarizing public-domain U.S. government documents and citing the Missouri Department of Conservation and published studies for their findings

Why this reading. The phenomenon lesson asks you to map Missouri’s cave fishes and write testable questions; the performance task asks you to explain how a cave population became a separate species and to say honestly what is debated. That needs the actual findings: where the fish live, how they differ, what the DNA shows, what life in a cave is like by the numbers, and what scientists still argue about. This reading gathers them from the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service listing documents, the Missouri Department of Conservation (MDC) field guide and the published studies, with the numbers those sources report.

The surface fish: the banded sculpin

Sculpins are small, bottom-dwelling fish with broad, flat heads, large fan-shaped side fins and no swim bladder. MDC describes the banded sculpin (Cottus carolinae) as the most widely distributed sculpin in Missouri, found in all the major Ozark stream systems. Its back and sides are reddish brown with 4 or 5 dark saddle bars, its overall color tends to match the stream bottom where it lives, and MDC calls it well camouflaged by its pattern of light and dark among the rocks. It hides under rocks by day and feeds mostly at night on crayfish, insect larvae, snails and small fish. Adults are commonly 2½ to 5 inches long and may live 6 years or more. One more detail matters for this unit: unlike Missouri’s other stream sculpins, banded sculpins turn up rather commonly in caves, often far from any likely entrance.

The cave fish: the grotto sculpin

In 1991 biologists documented sculpins in the caves of Perry County, in southeast Missouri, that did not look like surface fish. The Fish and Wildlife Service summarizes what set them apart: greatly reduced eyes and skin pigment (the traits biologists call troglomorphic, typical of animals adapted to constant darkness), enlarged sensory pores on the head, and brains with reduced optic and olfactory lobes and enlarged regions linked to other senses. MDC describes the living fish as light tan to bleached tan with unpigmented undersides and smaller eyes than the banded sculpin, which it otherwise closely resembles.

To find out how widespread the cave form was, Burr and colleagues searched caves in five states with large karst areas. By the time of the 2012 listing proposal, more than 153 caves in Arkansas, Illinois, Indiana, Missouri and Tennessee had been searched. Banded sculpins were found in 25 of them, but only the fish in two karst areas of Perry County, the Central Perryville and Mystery-Rimstone karsts, showed the cave traits. Those two areas cover about 222 km2 (89 mi2). Within them the fish live in five cave systems (Moore, Crevice, Mystery, Rimstone River and Running Bull caves), the springs and “resurgences” where cave streams flow out, and two surface streams, Cinque Hommes Creek and Blue Spring Branch. No other sculpin species overlaps this range; banded sculpins live in the neighboring watersheds.

In 2013 Adams, Burr and Starkey named the cave fish a new species, Cottus specus, the grotto sculpin, distinguishable from every other Cottus by both genetic and physical characters, including eye size and the size of the head pores. It was the first cave species described in its genus. The Fish and Wildlife Service listed it as endangered the same year.

What the DNA shows

Adams and colleagues compared sculpins from three southeast Missouri drainages: the Bois Brule drainage in Perry County, Greasy Creek in Madison County and the Current River in Ripley County. Each area held its own evolutionary lineage, marked by a distinct nuclear DNA haplotype. One haplotype was shared by fish throughout the Bois Brule drainage, in Mystery, Running Bull, Rimstone River, Crevice and Moore caves and in Cinque Hommes Creek. The 2013 listing adds that the same study found genetic isolation even within the grotto sculpin’s small range, between northern sample sites (Moore, Crevice and Mertz caves, Blue Spring Branch, Cinque Hommes Creek) and southern ones (Mystery, Running Bull and Rimstone River caves, Thunderhole Resurgence). The fish of Running Bull Cave show the most extreme cave features and are the only ones in the Cinque Hommes drainage to carry a rare haplotype.

Life in the cave, by the numbers

From August 2005 to October 2008, researchers tagged and recaptured grotto sculpins at Mystery Cave, Running Bull Cave and their two resurgences. The Fish and Wildlife Service reports their results:

MeasureIn cavesAt resurgencesTotal
Captures2,684 (43%)3,581 (57%)6,265
Different individuals1,6422,5764,218
Mean recapture rate46%18%
Density (fish per m2)0.0370.225

Fish were about six times less dense in the caves (0.225 ÷ 0.037 ≈ 6.1). Growth rate and metabolism were lower in caves than at resurgences, yet fish in both places reached similar lengths, which suggests cave fish live longer. Caves have no light for plants, so nearly all food washes in from the surface; the fish do best where invertebrate prey such as isopods and amphipods are plentiful. Five nests of about 200 eggs each were found within 100 m of cave stream in Mystery Cave in December 1998. Water in the caves may reach spawning temperature 2 to 3 months before surface streams do, which could explain why spawning was not seen at the same time in both habitats. Young fish grow up in the resurgences, where adults, which are cannibalistic, are fewer; surface fish such as green sunfish, bluegill and channel catfish can enter caves through sinkholes and prey on eggs and young.

Missouri’s three cavefishes

A second group of Missouri cave fish, the cavefish family, shows the same pattern. MDC’s field guide describes three cavefishes (family Amblyopsidae) whose ranges do not overlap:

SpeciesWhere in MissouriEyes and colorLife history
Shawnee Hills cavefish (Forbesichthys papilliferus)A single spring at the base of a limestone bluff in Scott CountyVery small eyes that only tell light from dark; dark brown back, yellowish brown sidesStays underground by day, comes out into surface water at dusk; finds food by taste; most live about 2 years. MDC calls it intermediate between cave-only fish and surface fish.
Salem Plateau cavefish (Typhlichthys eigenmanni)Underground waters of the central and southern OzarksNo eyes; unpigmented, whitish pinkUp to 50 eggs per female, carried in the gill chamber 4 to 5 months; a low metabolic rate lets it go without food for long periods; believed to live more than 10 years
Ozark cavefish (Troglichthys rosae)Springfield Plateau of southwest Missouri; 13 known sites in Newton, Jasper, Lawrence, Greene, Stone and Barry countiesNo eyes; small and colorlessAbout 20 eggs per female, and only about 20 percent of mature females spawn in a year; finds food with sense organs on the head, body and tail; lives 10 years or more. Federally threatened, endangered in Missouri.

Genetic studies keep revising this list. MDC notes that Missouri’s Salem Plateau cavefish was split from the wider-ranging southern cavefish, which turned out to be several nearly identical (“cryptic”) species, and that the Shawnee Hills cavefish was split from the spring cavefish of neighboring states.

How many times did fish move into caves?

The cavefish family includes surface fish, part-time cave dwellers and blind cave-only species, so it is a natural test of whether cave traits evolved once or several times. Niemiller and colleagues (2013) found that at least three cave lineages independently picked up their own disabling mutations in rhodopsin, the light-sensing protein of the eye, over the last 10.3 million years. Hart and colleagues (2025), using more than a thousand genes and fossils, identified three independent cave colonizations, dated to about 18.5, 10.0 and 3.0 million years ago, and found more of the cave-related genes under relaxed selection than under strengthened selection. Brownstein and colleagues (2025), using whole genomes, concluded that the family colonized caves and lost its eyes independently at least four times. The studies agree that cave traits evolved repeatedly; they do not yet agree on the exact count.

What is settled and what is debated

  • Settled: Missouri’s cave fish descend from surface ancestors; the differences between cave and surface forms are heritable and have a genetic signature; the grotto sculpin is a distinct lineage closely related to the banded sculpin; and eyes and pigment have been reduced independently in more than one cave lineage.
  • Debated: why eyes and pigment shrink. One family of hypotheses is natural selection: in food-poor caves, an animal that does not build costly eyes saves energy, and genes that shrink eyes may also strengthen other senses. The other is neutral mutation: once eyes no longer affect survival, mutations that damage them are no longer removed and slowly pile up (relaxed selection). In a 2023 review, Culver, Kowalko and Pipan argue that the two are a false choice and that both most likely contribute. Scientists also continue to debate how many cavefish species to recognize; a further southern cavefish species was described in 2026. The debate is about how and how fast, not about whether these fish evolved.

Your turn

  1. On an outline map of Missouri, mark Perry County and its two karst areas, the Ozark streams where banded sculpins live, and the ranges of the three cavefishes.
  2. Use the density table to write one sentence about how much food a cave provides compared with a resurgence (0.037 against 0.225 fish per m2, about 6 times fewer).
  3. State the energy-saving hypothesis for small eyes as a claim, cite the lower growth and metabolism of cave fish as evidence, and name one observation or experiment that would test it further.
  4. Write two testable questions the cave fish raise, each naming what would be measured.

Sources: U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Endangered Status for Grotto Sculpin and Designation of Critical Habitat, proposed rule, 77 FR 59488 (Sept. 27, 2012), public domain (federalregister.gov); U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Determination of Endangered Species Status for the Grotto Sculpin (Cottus specus) Throughout Its Range, final rule, 78 FR 58938 (Sept. 25, 2013), public domain (federalregister.gov); Missouri Department of Conservation, Field Guide: Banded Sculpin (mdc.mo.gov); Missouri Department of Conservation, Field Guide: Grotto Sculpin (mdc.mo.gov); Missouri Department of Conservation, Field Guide: Ozark Cavefish (mdc.mo.gov); Missouri Department of Conservation, Field Guide: Salem Plateau Cavefish (mdc.mo.gov); Missouri Department of Conservation, Field Guide: Shawnee Hills Cavefish (formerly Spring Cavefish) (mdc.mo.gov); Adams, G. L., B. M. Burr and D. E. Starkey, Cottus specus, a new troglomorphic species of sculpin (Cottidae) from southeastern Missouri, Zootaxa 3609:484-494 (2013), abstract (PubMed 24699612) (doi.org); Niemiller, M. L., et al., Evidence for repeated loss of selective constraint in rhodopsin of amblyopsid cavefishes (Teleostei: Amblyopsidae), Evolution 67:732-748 (2013), abstract (PubMed 23461324) (doi.org); Hart, P. B., et al., Ancient climate changes and relaxed selection shape cave colonization in North American cavefishes, Proceedings of the Royal Society B 292:20242516 (2025), abstract (PubMed 40669076) (doi.org); Brownstein, C. D., et al., Convergent Evolution in Amblyopsid Cavefishes and the Age of Eastern North American Subterranean Ecosystems, Molecular Biology and Evolution 42:msaf185 (2025), CC BY, abstract (doi.org); Culver, D. C., J. E. Kowalko and T. Pipan, Natural selection versus neutral mutation in the evolution of subterranean life: A false dichotomy? Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution 11:1080503 (2023), CC BY, abstract (doi.org)

Up NextComplete & Continue →

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Adaptation in Action: Modeling Selection and Resistance
Prev
Phenomenon: The Booming Grounds of Missouri’s Prairie-Chickens
Next

© 2026 The VR School | Career content by Wiley | Powered by Sejal Learning Systems.

Join free · Accreditation · Privacy Policy · Terms of Service

Modal title

Main Content