
construct an evidence-based argument that Earth’s systems and life have changed each other over time, using Missouri’s limestone, the history of oxygen and Missouri’s prairie soils, and predict how human nutrient use links Missouri’s land and rivers to the Gulf hypoxic zone.
Instruction
Missouri is built of life. Pick up a piece of gray limestone from a Missouri road cut or a creek bed and you may be holding a fossil seabed. The Missouri Geological Survey’s fact sheet on the state fossil explains that crinoids, relatives of starfish often called “sea lilies,” are Missouri’s most common fossil. They are marine animals that thrived during the Paleozoic Era, from about 490 to 250 million years ago, and reached their peak in the Mississippian Period, about 360 to 320 million years ago. The Mississippian-age Burlington Limestone, “a rock formation found throughout Missouri,” is renowned for its crinoid fossils, which weather out of the rock as small stone discs. Limestone is calcium carbonate, much of it made from the shells and skeletons of sea animals. Much of the Ozarks rests on dolomite, a close chemical cousin of limestone that also formed on ancient sea floors. The ground under Missouri is a record of life changing Earth.
Coevolution: each changes the other. Earth’s systems are the geosphere (rock and soil), hydrosphere (water), atmosphere (air) and biosphere (life). Coevolution means that changes in one system drive changes in another, which then feed back on the first. Shallow, warm seas that covered Missouri gave crinoids and corals a place to live; that was the geosphere and hydrosphere shaping life. The animals pulled dissolved calcium and carbon out of seawater to build skeletons, and their remains piled up into rock layers that now form much of Missouri’s land surface; that was life reshaping the geosphere. Carbon locked in limestone is carbon removed from the ocean and air, so life changed the atmosphere too.
The oxygen story. The largest example of coevolution is the air you breathe. Earth’s early atmosphere had almost no free oxygen. Roughly 2.4 billion years ago, atmospheric oxygen levels rose for the first time because of the photosynthesis of cyanobacteria, an event called the Great Oxidation Event. That change by life altered the rest of the planet: oxygen reacted with rocks and changed how they weathered, and it formed the ozone layer that screens ultraviolet light. In turn it allowed new life, because animals depend on aerobic respiration. The oxygen-breathing crinoids in Missouri’s limestone could exist only because microbes had changed the atmosphere more than two billion years earlier.
Prairie and soil. MDC records that roughly 15 million acres of tallgrass prairie, about a third of Missouri, existed before European settlement, and that fewer than 70,000 acres remain today, less than one percent (0.47 percent). Prairie plants with deep, dense roots added organic matter to the soil year after year, building the dark, fertile soils of northern and western Missouri; fire and climate kept trees out and the grasses in. Those soils then shaped human life, because they were exactly what farmers wanted to plow, and MDC notes that suppressing fire let trees take over much of what was not plowed.
Predicting human effects: from Missouri fields to the Gulf. Every river in Missouri drains to the Mississippi, and the Mississippi carries nutrients from farms and cities across the basin to the Gulf of America (formerly the Gulf of Mexico). NOAA explains the chain: excess nutrients stimulate an overgrowth of algae; when the algae die and decompose they use up oxygen as they sink; the low-oxygen water, called a hypoxic or “dead” zone, drives fish and shrimp away. NOAA-supported scientists measured the 2025 zone at about 4,402 square miles. The Hypoxia Task Force’s goal is a five-year average below 1,900 square miles by 2035; the five-year average in 2025 was 4,755 square miles, 2.5 times the goal, so reaching it means shrinking the average by about 60 percent. The record is 8,776 square miles, set in 2017.
Predictions are about causes, not certainty. In June 2026 NOAA forecast a larger-than-average zone of about 7,027 square miles, based mainly on river flow and nutrient data from the U.S. Geological Survey. The July survey measured only about 1,332 square miles (19 percent of the forecast), because Tropical Storm Bertha crossed the northern Gulf on the eve of the cruise and its winds and waves mixed oxygen-rich surface water down to the seabed. The nutrients had not gone away; weather broke up the zone that year. That is why the goal is set as a five-year average and why a good prediction names its cause and its uncertainty.
Human activity can push either way. Adding more fertilizer than crops can use, or draining wetlands, sends more nitrogen and phosphorus downstream: a negative effect that links the geosphere, hydrosphere and biosphere. Reconnecting floodplains, restoring wetlands and planting cover crops hold nutrients on the land; a Missouri River levee-setback fact sheet notes that floodplains improve water quality by retaining nutrients deposited during floods. When you predict, write an if-then-because chain that passes through each Earth system the effect crosses.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Missouri standard: 9-12.ESS2.E.1
Missouri’s Burlington Limestone is packed with fossil crinoids, marine animals. Which statement best describes the coevolution this rock records?
Missouri standard: 9-12.ESS2.E.1
Earth’s atmosphere has held its present oxygen since the planet formed, before any life existed.
Missouri standard: 9-12.ESS3.D.2
The five-year average Gulf hypoxic zone was 4,755 square miles in 2025 and the goal is 1,900 square miles, so reaching the goal means shrinking the average by about percent.
Missouri standard: 9-12.ESS3.D.2
In June 2026 NOAA forecast a Gulf hypoxic zone of about 7,027 square miles; in late July scientists measured about 1,332. What best explains the difference?
Missouri standard: 9-12.ESS2.E.1, 9-12.ESS3.D.2
Part A (argument): Claim that Earth’s systems and life have changed each other over time. Support the claim with three pieces of evidence from the lesson and its reading (Missouri limestone, atmospheric oxygen, prairie soils), and for each say which system changed which, and how the change fed back. Part B (prediction): Write an if-then-because prediction for each of two human choices: (1) reconnecting floodplain along the Missouri River, and (2) applying more fertilizer than crops can use before a wet spring. Each prediction must pass through at least three Earth systems on the way to the Gulf hypoxic zone and say whether the effect is positive or negative.
Practice
Work these on paper or in your notebook, then open Check your answer. Aim for all of Fluency and Application; try at least one Challenge.
Printable version: this unit’s practice workbook (PDF)
Fluency
Build speed and accuracy with the core skill.
- List Earth’s four systems.
Check your answer
Answer: Geosphere, hydrosphere, atmosphere and biosphere.Rock and soil, water, air and life. - About how long ago did oxygen first build up in Earth’s atmosphere, and what caused it?
Check your answer
Answer: Roughly 2.4 billion years ago, from photosynthesis by cyanobacteria.This is the Great Oxidation Event. - What is Missouri’s state fossil, and in what kind of rock is it usually found?
Check your answer
Answer: The crinoid; usually in limestone, such as the Burlington Limestone.Crinoids were marine animals, so the rock records an ancient sea.
Application
Use the skill in context. Show your reasoning.
- MDC estimates about 15 million acres of Missouri prairie before settlement and fewer than 70,000 acres today. What percentage remains?
Check your answer
Answer: About 0.47 percent (less than 1 percent).70,000 ÷ 15,000,000 × 100 ≈ 0.47. - NOAA’s 2026 forecast was 7,027 square miles and the measured zone was 1,332 square miles. What percentage of the forecast was measured?
Check your answer
Answer: About 19 percent.1,332 ÷ 7,027 × 100 ≈ 19.0. - Trace the chain from a Missouri cornfield to a fish leaving the Gulf floor, naming each Earth system the nutrients pass through.
Check your answer
Answer: Fertilizer on soil (geosphere) washes into streams and the Mississippi (hydrosphere), feeds an algal bloom in the Gulf (biosphere), and decomposition uses up dissolved oxygen in bottom water (hydrosphere), so fish and shrimp leave (biosphere).Each arrow is a cause-and-effect link between systems.
Challenge
Stretch problems. Expect to think before you write.
- Explain how the rise of atmospheric oxygen is an example of feedback between life and Earth’s systems, not just a one-way effect.
Check your answer
Answer: Life (cyanobacteria) changed the atmosphere by releasing oxygen; the oxygen then changed the geosphere (rock weathering) and the atmosphere (ozone layer), and those changes made aerobic, animal life possible, which changed the biosphere again.Coevolution: each system’s change becomes the next system’s cause. - The 2025 five-year average was 4,755 square miles and the 2035 goal is 1,900. If the average fell by the same number of square miles each year from 2025 to 2035, how much would it need to fall per year?
Check your answer
Answer: About 285.5 square miles per year (2,855 over 10 years).4,755 − 1,900 = 2,855; 2,855 ÷ 10 = 285.5.
Review
Keep earlier skills sharp.
- (Unit 1) Why does decomposition of a large algal bloom lower oxygen in water?
Check your answer
Answer: Decomposers break down the dead algae by aerobic cellular respiration, which consumes dissolved oxygen.Respiration uses O2 and releases CO2. - (Unit 2) Name one way restoring a wetland can increase biodiversity.
Check your answer
Answer: It provides habitat (food, shelter, breeding sites) for species that cannot live on drained land, such as wetland plants, amphibians, waterfowl and fish.Habitat restoration adds niches.
Life Changes Earth, Earth Changes Life: Missouri Rock, Oxygen, Prairie and the Gulf Dead Zone
Missouri Geological Survey fact sheet PUB0660, Crinoid: Missouri’s Official State Fossil; MDC, The Tallgrass Prairie: An American Original Landscape; Science News on the Great Oxidation Event; NOAA NCCOS releases on the 2025 measured hypoxic zone and the 2026 forecast; NOAA release of August 5, 2026 on the measured 2026 zone (as posted by the Gulf hypoxia program); all retrieved November 5, 2026 · SLS original, citing U.S. government data (public domain) and Missouri state agency facts
Why this reading. Your argument needs evidence you can cite, and your prediction needs numbers. This card collects the Missouri rock, oxygen and prairie facts and NOAA’s hypoxic-zone measurements, with every calculation worked.
Evidence 1: a sea floor under Missouri
- Crinoids, Missouri’s state fossil (since June 16, 1989), are marine echinoderms related to starfish. They thrived in the Paleozoic Era (about 490 to 250 million years ago) and peaked in the Mississippian Period (about 360 to 320 million years ago). Missouri Geological Survey fact sheet PUB0660.
- The Mississippian-age Burlington Limestone, found throughout Missouri, is renowned for abundant crinoid fossils; crinoid pieces usually occur in limestone. PUB0660.
- System links: sea (hydrosphere) and sea floor (geosphere) → habitat for crinoids (biosphere) → skeletons of calcium carbonate accumulate into limestone (geosphere), locking away carbon that came from water and air.
Evidence 2: oxygen
- Roughly 2.4 billion years ago, atmospheric oxygen rose for the first time because of photosynthesis by cyanobacteria: the Great Oxidation Event. Science News.
- System links: biosphere → atmosphere (oxygen) → geosphere (oxidized rocks, changed weathering) and atmosphere (ozone) → biosphere (aerobic and, later, animal life).
Evidence 3: prairie soils
- About 15 million acres, a third of Missouri, was tallgrass prairie before European settlement; fewer than 70,000 acres remain. MDC. Share remaining: 70,000 ÷ 15,000,000 × 100 = 0.47 percent.
- Fire maintained the prairie; suppressing fire let trees take over. MDC. Deep prairie roots built organic-rich soils that later drew farmers to plow them.
The Gulf hypoxic zone: NOAA’s numbers
| Measure | Square miles | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Record size (2017) | 8,776 | NOAA, June 2026 forecast release |
| Average measured size, 39 years | 5,223 | NOAA, June 2026 forecast release |
| Measured 2025 | 4,402 | NOAA, July 2025 release |
| Five-year average, 2025 | 4,755 | NOAA, July 2025 release |
| Hypoxia Task Force goal (five-year average, by 2035) | 1,900 | NOAA |
| Forecast 2026 (June) | 7,027 | NOAA, June 2026 |
| Measured 2026 (July 24-30 cruise) | 1,332 | NOAA release of August 5, 2026 |
Worked numbers. Distance to the goal: 4,755 − 1,900 = 2,855 square miles, which is 2,855 ÷ 4,755 × 100 ≈ 60 percent of the current average; equivalently, the average is 4,755 ÷ 1,900 ≈ 2.5 times the goal. In 2026 the measured zone was 1,332 ÷ 7,027 × 100 ≈ 19 percent of the forecast.
Why 2026 came in small. NOAA reports that Tropical Storm Bertha crossed the northern Gulf on the eve of the survey cruise, and its winds and high waves mixed oxygen-rich surface water down to the seabed. The forecast models assume typical weather. The nutrient load that drives the forecast was still there.
The cause chain (NOAA). Excess nutrients from the Mississippi-Atchafalaya River Basin → overgrowth of algae → algae die, sink and decompose, using up oxygen → hypoxic bottom water → fish and shrimp leave. The basin includes all of Missouri.
Writing a prediction
Template: If [human action], then [change in the hypoxic zone], because [system 1 → system 2 → system 3 → Gulf]. Add one sentence on uncertainty (weather, river flow) and say whether the effect is positive or negative.
Sources: Missouri Geological Survey, Crinoid: Missouri’s Official State Fossil (PUB0660) (dnr.mo.gov); MDC Discover Nature Notes, The Tallgrass Prairie: An American Original Landscape (mdc.mo.gov); Science News, Before altering the air, microbes oxygenated large swaths of the sea (sciencenews.org); NOAA NCCOS, 2025 measured Gulf dead zone (4,402 square miles) (coastalscience.noaa.gov); NOAA NCCOS, 2026 Gulf dead zone forecast (7,027 square miles) (coastalscience.noaa.gov); NOAA and partners find smaller-than-anticipated hypoxic zone in Gulf of America (August 5, 2026), Gulf hypoxia program posting (gulfhypoxia.net)