
construct and defend a report that uses population models, behavioral evidence and population genetics to explain the decline of Missouri’s greater prairie-chickens and what translocations can and cannot fix.
Instruction
The question. Why did Missouri’s greater prairie-chickens fall from hundreds of thousands to a few dozen birds, and what does that history mean for their future? You are writing for a hypothetical visitor center at a Missouri prairie that holds public lek-viewing mornings, whose staff want an accurate, readable explanation for the public.
What a strong report contains.
- The numbers. Model the decline with an exponential model, stating your starting and ending figures and citing MDC’s estimates (about 1,000 birds in 1998, 200 in 2006, fewer than 25 today). Explain why the recent record sits above a straight projection of the 1998–2006 rate (birds were added by translocation), and name factors, such as the amount of prairie and the weather in nesting season, that limit how many birds the land can support.
- Behavior (enrichment). Explain how lek displays, contests and hen choice affect which males reproduce, and evaluate the evidence about the costs and benefits of gathering on a lek. Use evidence from the pill bug lab or the group-behavior cases to show how group behavior can affect survival and reproduction.
- Genes (9-12.LS4.B.2). Use the Hardy-Weinberg model and your bead drift results to explain why a bottleneck and a mating system in which few males mate reduce genetic variation. Include at least one calculation, such as the fraction of heterozygosity kept per generation for a small breeding population.
- Risk and rescue. Explain why low genetic variation could matter if the birds meet a new disease or a changing climate, connecting to natural selection (9-12.LS4.B.1): selection can only act on variation that exists. Then use the Illinois record to explain what translocated birds added, and why, without enough prairie, the gain did not last.
- Accuracy. Label every figure as a published estimate (with its source) or illustrative. Where the evidence is uncertain or sources disagree, say so.
A worked example of one link. Claim: the crash left prairie-chickens with less genetic variation, and translocation restored some of it. Evidence: in the bead model, a scoop of about 10 beads from a bag with four colors often kept only two or three colors; and with 20 breeders, 0.97510 ≈ 0.78 of heterozygosity remains after 10 generations. DNA from Illinois museum specimens shows alleles present earlier in the century were lost after the crash, and after birds were brought in from other states the average number of alleles per gene rose from 4.7 to 5.5. Reasoning: only the alleles carried by the few survivors could be passed on, drift in the small population removed more, and only gene flow from other populations could bring lost alleles back quickly.
Presentation. In four minutes, recorded on a phone or computer, present your two key displays and answer one question about your evidence.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Why did Illinois’s prairie-chickens still have reduced genetic variation and poor egg hatching even while a few dozen birds survived?
With 20 breeding individuals, a population keeps about 97.5% of its heterozygosity each generation, on average, through drift alone.
Write the genetics section of your report as claim, evidence and reasoning, including one calculation and the source of any published figure.
How confident are you that you can explain a population’s recovery and genetic risk with growth models, behavior and population genetics?
Unit 4 checkpoint
Do this before you start the task. It covers the whole unit and tells you what to review first.
Which best explains why only a few male prairie-chickens mate each spring?
In 100 choice-chamber observations, 72 on the damp side and 28 on the dry side give χ2 = .
Group behavior always benefits every individual in the group.
Kin selection predicts that an alarm call is most likely when:
If 16% of a population shows a recessive trait, q = and the carrier frequency 2pq = .
A population in Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium has p = 0.8. What fraction is homozygous AA?
A population that is not in Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium is undergoing some evolutionary force, such as selection, drift, migration, mutation or non-random mating.
Genetic drift has the greatest effect in:
With 20 breeding individuals, the fraction of heterozygosity kept per generation by drift alone is 1 − 1/(2 × 20) = .
Why did Illinois’s prairie-chickens lose genetic variation when their numbers crashed?
A sample has 50 AA, 20 Aa and 30 aa. What is p?
Submit: The Prairie-Chicken Rescue Report (900-1,300 words with a population model and a genetics calculation) + four-minute presentation
Task: Write a report for a hypothetical Missouri prairie visitor center that explains the decline of the greater prairie-chicken and the effort to rescue it. Include a population model with stated assumptions, an explanation of how lek behavior affects which individuals reproduce, a population-genetics explanation of the bottleneck with at least one calculation, and a discussion of the risk posed by low genetic variation and of what translocations can and cannot fix. Use evidence from the pill bug lab, the group-behavior argument and the bead drift model, and label every figure as published (with source) or illustrative. Hand-drawn displays are fully acceptable.
Submission workflow
- Stage 1 — Plan. Draft population model and genetics calculation, and an outline linking each section to evidence.
- Stage 2 — Reviewed draft. Ask a parent, guardian or other adult reader to read the draft while you recompute your rate and genetics figures from scratch; check that each number is sourced or labeled illustrative, mark any sentence your reader could not follow or any claim without evidence, and submit your recomputation, their notes and your revision plan.
- Stage 3 — Final report. 900-1,300 words with revised displays, calculations, citations and a limitations paragraph.
- Stage 4 — Presentation and defense. Four minutes, recorded, ending with your answer to one question about your evidence.
How it is scored
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Population genetics (9-12.LS4.B.2, SEP.5) | Correct Hardy-Weinberg or drift calculation, used to explain why the bottleneck reduced variation. |
| Group behavior (enrichment) | Explains how the breeding system affects reproduction and evaluates costs and benefits with evidence. |
| Population change (9-12.LS2.A.1) | Decline model is correct with stated assumptions and a reasoned discussion of what limits the population. |
| Selection and risk (9-12.LS4.B.1, CCC.7) | Explains why low variation limits the population’s ability to respond to change, and what translocation adds. |
| Explanation (SEP.6) | Links behavior, numbers and genes into a coherent causal account. |
| Evidence and communication (RST.9-10.1) | Every figure sourced or labeled illustrative; clear for the public; presentation answers a question accurately. |
From Hundreds of Thousands to Fewer Than Twenty-Five: Missouri’s Prairie-Chickens on Record
Missouri Department of Conservation, Field Guide: Greater Prairie-Chicken (reviewed Dec. 9, 2025) and news releases of Aug. 30, 2011, May 3, 2012, Apr. 16 and July 29, 2015, Apr. 22, 2016, Mar. 18 and Apr. 25, 2019; Missouri Conservationist, Mar. 1998, Feb. 2004 and Mar. 2008; Westemeier et al., Science 282:1695-1698 (1998), abstract; Bouzat et al., American Naturalist 152:1-6 (1998), abstract; Westemeier and Simpson (1991) via Conservation Evidence; Illinois Natural History Survey (Dec. 21, 2015); University of Illinois News Bureau (Feb. 27, 2017); Mussmann et al., Royal Society Open Science 4:160736 (2017), CC BY 4.0; retrieved Nov. 5, 2026 · SLS original, citing Missouri Department of Conservation and University of Illinois publications and quoting short passages with attribution; figures from Mussmann et al. (2017) used under CC BY 4.0
Why this reading. Your timeline, your decline model and your rescue report all need published figures with sources, and the task tells you to label every number as published or illustrative. Here are the published ones: the Missouri Department of Conservation’s (MDC) estimates of the state’s prairie-chickens from the 1800s to today, its counts on the spring leks and its record of birds moved in from Kansas and Nebraska, and the genetic record from neighboring Illinois, where scientists have measured what a crash does to a prairie-chicken population’s genes and eggs. MDC’s own publications do not always agree; this reading shows where, so you can say which figure you are using.
1. The decline, as MDC states it
| Date | Missouri prairie-chickens | Source |
|---|---|---|
| As the 1800s began | “in the hundreds of thousands across open prairies” | MDC news release, Mar. 18, 2019 |
| 1907 | Hunting stopped, with about 12,500 birds left in the state | Missouri Conservationist, Feb. 2004 |
| 1944 (World War II era) | Estimates “ranged only from 5,000 to 13,000 birds in scattered flocks”; biologist Charles Schwartz estimated 13,000 | MDC, Mar. 18, 2019; Missouri Conservationist, Feb. 2004 |
| 1998 | About 1,000 birds | MDC, Mar. 18, 2019 |
| 2006 | About 200 birds | MDC, Mar. 18, 2019 |
| Spring 2011 | “about 100 prairie chickens sighted on mating grounds” | MDC news release, Aug. 30, 2011 |
| Spring 2019 | “less than 50 birds confirmed this spring in two isolated populations” | MDC news release, Apr. 25, 2019 |
| Today | “Fewer than 25 birds remain in isolated populations in northwest and west-central Missouri” | MDC Field Guide, Greater Prairie-Chicken (reviewed Dec. 9, 2025) |
Where MDC’s figures disagree. A March 1998 Missouri Conservationist article put the population “at only 2,000 birds,” while MDC’s 2019 release gives about 1,000 for 1998. A February 2004 article said “only about 500” remained and a March 2008 article said “fewer than 500,” while the 2019 release gives 200 for 2006. Prairie-chickens are counted mainly as males booming on leks, so every total is an estimate. The table uses the 2019 release because it gives one consistent series; in your report, say which figure you use and where it came from.
Why they declined. MDC’s field guide names the cause: “Loss of suitable habitat from agricultural conversion and nonnative grass establishment and grazing.” MDC’s 2019 releases report that less than one-tenth of one percent of Missouri’s original native prairie remains and that biologists estimate a core of at least 10,000 acres is needed to sustain a flock; its 2011 release adds that adults live only two to three years on average, so a few bad nesting seasons in a row can empty a lek.
2. The leks and the translocations
- Upper Osage Grasslands (west-central Missouri). The flock at Wah’Kon-Tah Prairie near El Dorado Springs “vanished by 2004,” while a small flock survived about 10 miles away at Taberville Prairie. From 2008 to 2012 MDC trapped birds in the Smoky Hills of Kansas, where they are plentiful, and released them at Wah’Kon-Tah with leg bands and radio transmitters (MDC, May 3, 2012). In summer 2011 crews found 29 nests at Wah’Kon-Tah and Taberville; hens in 23 of them hatched broods, “almost 80 percent,” against about 50 percent in most stable populations (MDC, Aug. 30, 2011). In spring 2012 the birds used three leks. By 2018 biologists counted six males on the lek at Taberville and only two birds on a lek at Wah’Kon-Tah; in 2019, four males and three hens at Taberville, and MDC reported that the birds “have failed to establish a sustained population at Wah’Kon-Tah.”
- Grand River Grasslands (Harrison County, northwest Missouri). The flock at The Nature Conservancy’s Dunn Ranch and MDC’s Pawnee Prairie fell to three males on leks in 2012 after extreme nesting-season weather. MDC released birds trapped in Nebraska from 2013 to 2017: 19 males and 20 hens in 2015, and in 2016, 100 birds trapped in Nebraska, of which 60 were released at Dunn Ranch and 40 in neighboring Iowa. Spring lek counts: 40 birds on five leks (2015), 47 birds on seven leks (2016), 33 birds in 2018 and again in 2019 (16 males and 8 hens on the Dunn Ranch lek, 6 males and 3 hens on a lek on private land).
3. Who mates on a lek
MDC’s field guide describes the system: “Cocks visit booming grounds (leks), where they dance, call, and fight among themselves. Hens visit the lek and select the most fit mate; mating occurs on the lek.” The breeding season runs from March through mid-April, and chicks stay with the hen for 8–10 weeks. Charles Schwartz, MDC’s first prairie-chicken biologist, found that a booming ground averages about 12 males, and some were used for 40 years (Missouri Conservationist, Feb. 2004). The Illinois Natural History Survey (Dec. 21, 2015) reports that “typically only 10-30% of male Greater Prairie-Chickens get to mate,” so the number of birds that pass on genes each year is much smaller than the number on the leks. That gap is what the term effective population size is for; a 2017 genetic study of Illinois leks estimated an effective size per lek averaging 15.9 birds.
4. What the crash did to the genes: the Illinois record
Missouri’s flocks have not been studied genetically in the same depth, but the population across the state line in Illinois has, and it is the standard example.
- Numbers and eggs fell together. Westemeier and colleagues (Science, 1998) followed one remnant population for 35 years: it “decreased from 2000 individuals in 1962 to fewer than 50 by 1994. Concurrently, both fitness, as measured by fertility and hatching rates of eggs, and genetic diversity declined significantly.”
- Alleles were lost. DNA from Illinois museum specimens (Bouzat and colleagues, American Naturalist, 1998) revealed “the loss of specific alleles (known to have been present earlier in this century) following a demographic contraction,” including alleles found in every other population sampled.
- Outside genes helped the eggs. In a small 1991 test, eggs were swapped between nests in two isolated Illinois flocks: 20 of 24 exchanged eggs hatched (83 percent), against 45 percent of 112 eggs that were not exchanged (Westemeier and Simpson 1991, summarized by Conservation Evidence).
- Translocation. Between 1992 and 1998 “teams imported more than 200 prairie chickens from other states,” from North Dakota, Minnesota, Kansas and Nebraska (University of Illinois, Feb. 27, 2017), and the 1998 study reports that translocations from “large, genetically diverse populations restored egg viability.”
- What came back, and what did not last. Mussmann and colleagues (Royal Society Open Science, 2017, CC BY 4.0) compared six DNA markers before and after the translocations. Average allelic richness (the number of alleles per gene, corrected for sample size) rose from 4.7 before to 5.5 after, a significant gain; observed heterozygosity changed little (0.525 to 0.611, not significant). That is the textbook pattern: a short bottleneck removes rare alleles first and heterozygosity more slowly. Twenty years on, the males counted on the leks of the two remaining counties fell from 63 (2010) to 46, 33 and 27 (2013), and the authors conclude that without enough habitat the birds depend on repeated translocations.
5. Worked calculations
- The lesson’s rate. About 1,000 birds in 1998 to 200 in 2006: r = ln(200 ÷ 1,000) ÷ 8 = −1.609 ÷ 8 = −0.20 per year; halving time 0.693 ÷ 0.201 = 3.4 years (3.5 if you round r to 0.20 first).
- The slower decline before. 13,000 (1944) to 1,000 (1998): r = ln(1,000 ÷ 13,000) ÷ 54 = −0.047 per year, halving every 14.6 years. From the low end of the wartime range, 5,000: r = −0.030, halving every 23 years. The decline sped up as the flocks shrank.
- Projection against the record. If the 1998–2006 rate had simply continued, 200 × e−0.201 × 13 ≈ 15 birds would have been left by 2019. MDC confirmed more than that in 2019 (33 birds in the Grand River Grasslands alone) because birds from Kansas and Nebraska had been added; a model of a managed population has to include the birds people move.
- The Illinois lek count. 63 males (2010) to 27 (2013): 27 ÷ 63 = 0.43 of the males left after three years, r = ln(0.43) ÷ 3 = −0.28 per year.
- Allelic richness. (5.5 − 4.7) ÷ 4.7 = 0.17: a 17 percent gain in alleles per gene after translocation.
- Heterozygosity kept by drift. With N = 20 breeders, 1 − 1 ÷ (2 × 20) = 0.975 per generation; after ten generations 0.97510 = 0.78.
6. A timeline you can source
| Date | Event | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Early 1800s | Hundreds of thousands of prairie-chickens on Missouri’s prairies | MDC 2019 |
| 1907 | Hunting stopped (about 12,500 birds) | Missouri Conservationist 2004 |
| 1944 | About 13,000 birds (estimates 5,000–13,000) | MDC 2019; Missouri Conservationist 2004 |
| 1962–1994 | Illinois remnant falls from 2,000 to fewer than 50; eggs and genetic diversity decline | Westemeier et al. 1998 |
| 1992–1998 | More than 200 birds moved into Illinois from other states | University of Illinois 2017 |
| 1998 | About 1,000 birds in Missouri | MDC 2019 |
| 2004 | Wah’Kon-Tah flock vanishes | MDC 2012 |
| 2006 | About 200 birds | MDC 2019 |
| 2008–2012 | Kansas birds released at Wah’Kon-Tah | MDC 2011, 2012 |
| 2012 | Three males left on Grand River leks | MDC 2019 |
| 2013–2017 | Nebraska birds released at Dunn Ranch | MDC 2015, 2016, 2019 |
| 2019 | Fewer than 50 birds confirmed in two isolated populations | MDC 2019 |
| Today | Fewer than 25 birds remain | MDC Field Guide (reviewed 2025) |
Sources: Missouri Department of Conservation, Field Guide: Greater Prairie-Chicken (reviewed 2025-12-09) (mdc.mo.gov); MDC, MDC finding fewer endangered prairie chickens despite conservation efforts (Mar. 18, 2019) (mdc.mo.gov); MDC, MDC finds endangered prairie-chicken numbers low on spring mating grounds (Apr. 25, 2019) (mdc.mo.gov); MDC, Weather gives endangered prairie chickens a nesting boost (Aug. 30, 2011) (mdc.mo.gov); MDC, New hope arrives for endangered prairie chickens (May 3, 2012) (mdc.mo.gov); MDC, MDC tracking Grand River Grassland prairie chickens (Apr. 16, 2015) (mdc.mo.gov); MDC, MDC biologists manage habitat to help prairie chickens through wet weather (July 29, 2015) (mdc.mo.gov); MDC, MDC finds prairie chicken numbers up at Dunn Ranch (Apr. 22, 2016) (mdc.mo.gov); Missouri Conservationist, Bringing the Boom Back to Missouri (Mar. 1998) (mdc.mo.gov); Missouri Conservationist, Save the Last Dance (Feb. 2004) (mdc.mo.gov); Missouri Conservationist, Spirit of the Prairie (Mar. 2008) (mdc.mo.gov); Westemeier, R. L., et al., Tracking the long-term decline and recovery of an isolated population, Science 282 (1998), abstract (PubMed 9831558) (pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov); Bouzat, J. L., et al., The ghost of genetic diversity past: historical DNA analysis of the greater prairie chicken, American Naturalist (1998), abstract (PubMed 18811397) (pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov); Conservation Evidence, Successful exchange of prairie-chicken eggs between nests in two remnant populations (Westemeier and Simpson 1991) (conservationevidence.com); Illinois Natural History Survey, Ornithologist receives grant to determine ‘Who’s the father?’ for hatchling Greater Prairie-Chickens (Dec. 21, 2015) (blogs.illinois.edu); University of Illinois News Bureau, Greater prairie chickens cannot persist in Illinois without help, researchers report (Feb. 27, 2017) (news.illinois.edu); Mussmann, S. M., et al., Genetic rescue, the greater prairie chicken and the problem of conservation reliance in the Anthropocene, Royal Society Open Science 4:160736 (2017), CC BY 4.0 (ncbi.nlm.nih.gov)