
explain with evidence how rivers, fertile bottomlands, lead ore, earthquakes and floods have shaped where and how Missourians live; build a step-by-step computational simulation linking a deer harvest to the herd, the people who depend on it and forest biodiversity; and evaluate and refine the L-536 levee setback as a solution that reduces human impact on the Missouri River floodplain.
Instruction
Why Missourians live where they do. Look at a map of Missouri’s largest cities and nearly all of them sit on a river: St. Louis near the meeting of the Missouri and Mississippi, Kansas City where the Missouri bends east, Jefferson City, St. Charles and Cape Girardeau along the big rivers. Rivers offered water, transport and, in their bottomlands, deep soils laid down by floods. Underground resources pulled people too. The Missouri Geological Survey records that lead ore was discovered near Mine La Motte in Madison County and that galena (lead sulfide) has been important to Missouri since 1720. Missouri became the nation’s top lead producer in 1907 and has held that place every year since except 1962, when a strike cut production. Mining towns grew in the Old Lead Belt around Flat River and Bonne Terre until its last mine closed in 1972, and production moved to the Viburnum Trend, a 35-mile-long ore district in southeast Missouri. In 1992 nine Missouri mines produced 330,000 tons of lead, 75 percent of the U.S. total.
Hazards shape choices too. The U.S. Geological Survey lists three principal New Madrid earthquakes: M7.5 on December 16, 1811, in northeast Arkansas; M7.3 on January 23, 1812, in Missouri; and M7.5 on February 7, 1812, along the Reelfoot fault in Missouri and Tennessee. Southeast Missouri still plans buildings and bridges around that risk. Floods are the hazard Missourians meet most often. In the Great Flood of 1993 the Mississippi at St. Louis crested at a record 49.58 feet on August 1, nearly 20 feet above flood stage, and the city’s 52-foot floodwall held with 2.42 feet to spare. Across the flooded region, the National Weather Service reports, 18 percent of federal levees and 78 percent of non-federal levees failed or were overtopped, because most federal levees are designed for a 100- to 500-year flood and most farm levees for a 50-year flood or less. After the flood, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service bought flood-damaged land from willing sellers, much of it buried under several feet of sand, and created the Big Muddy National Fish and Wildlife Refuge in September 1994; it has grown to almost 20,000 acres. A hazard changed how people used the floodplain.
A resource you can model: Missouri’s deer. White-tailed deer are a renewable resource that Missourians eat, hunt and manage. MDC reported a preliminary harvest of 301,954 deer in the 2025-2026 season (145,222 antlered bucks, 25,129 button bucks and 131,603 does), up from 275,656 the season before. Too few deer and hunters lose a food source; too many and deer damage crops, collide with cars and browse away forest wildflowers and young trees. Smithsonian researchers who fenced deer out of six of twelve forest study areas found that deer reshape the forest understory and the animals that use it. Managing the harvest means balancing people’s needs, the herd and biodiversity at once, and a simulation lets you test choices before making them.
Building the simulation. Use a simple, illustrative model of one region (the numbers are chosen for teaching, not measured). The herd starts at N = 20,000 deer. Each year it grows by rN(1 − N/K), with growth rate r = 0.4 and carrying capacity K = 30,000, and hunters remove a fraction h of the herd. So next year’s herd is N + rN(1 − N/K) − hN. Track biodiversity with an understory index W = 100 − 2 × (N ÷ 1,000): 100 means a forest floor full of wildflowers and seedlings, lower means heavier browsing. Year 1 with h = 0.20: growth = 0.4 × 20,000 × (1 − 20,000/30,000) ≈ 2,667; harvest = 0.20 × 20,000 = 4,000; next herd = 20,000 + 2,667 − 4,000 = 18,667. Put these columns in a spreadsheet (year, N, growth, harvest, next N, W) and fill down for ten years; on paper, a ten-row table does the same job.
What the model shows. Run long enough, each harvest rate settles where growth equals harvest, at N = K(1 − h/r). With no harvest the herd climbs toward 30,000 and the understory index falls to 40. At h = 0.10 the herd settles at 22,500, hunters take 2,250 a year and W = 55. At h = 0.20 it settles at 15,000, the harvest peaks at 3,000 a year and W = 70. At h = 0.30 the herd falls to 7,500, the harvest drops back to 2,250 and W = 85. At h = 0.40 or more the herd is harvested to zero. No single rate maximizes everything; the model makes the trade-off visible and tells you which data (r, K, the browsing effect) are worth measuring.
Evaluating a technological solution: the L-536 levee setback. In 2019 Missouri River flooding breached or overtopped more than 100 levees and inundated 1.2 million acres. Levee L-536 in Atchison and Holt counties was breached in 7 places. Rather than rebuild it in the same spot, the levee district and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers moved it inland: a 5-mile setback, finished in 2021, that reconnected 1,040 acres of floodplain to the river, lowers the 100-year flood surface by up to 0.83 feet, and protects 20 square miles (12,800 acres) behind a levee with gentler, erosion-resistant slopes. It cost about $103.5 million, and the Corps found it cheaper than repairing the old line. The project fact sheet lists benefits beyond flood control: slower floodwater and less scour, habitat and spawning areas for fish, groundwater recharge, and nutrient retention. To evaluate it, list criteria (people and property protected, cost, biodiversity restored, recurrence prevented) and constraints (farmland given up, money, landowner consent), weigh the evidence for each, and then propose a refinement, such as planting native floodplain forest on the reconnected land or monitoring fish use, that would make it better.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Missouri standard: 9-12.ESS3.A.1
Why did towns such as Bonne Terre and Flat River grow up in southeast Missouri, and why did mining later move south?
Missouri standard: 9-12.ESS3.A.1
In the 1993 flood, federal and non-federal levees failed or were overtopped at about the same rate.
Missouri standard: 9-12.ESS3.C.1
In the deer model (N = 20,000, r = 0.4, K = 30,000), a harvest rate of h = 0.10 gives a herd of deer after one year (round to the nearest deer).
Missouri standard: 9-12.ESS3.C.1
Build the simulation. In a spreadsheet (or a paper table), make columns for year, herd N, growth rN(1 − N/K), harvest hN, next year’s N and understory index W = 100 − 2 × (N ÷ 1,000). Run ten years from N = 20,000 for h = 0.10, 0.20 and 0.30 (check your h = 0.20 run against the table in the reading). Report the year-10 herd, harvest and W for each rate, then recommend one rate for this region in three sentences that weigh the hunters and farmers who depend on the herd against forest biodiversity, and name one measurement that would make the model more trustworthy.
Missouri standard: 9-12.ESS3.C.2
Evaluate the L-536 levee setback. Make a table with four criteria (people and property protected, cost, biodiversity restored, future flood damage prevented) and two constraints (farmland given up, landowner consent). For each, cite one fact from the lesson or reading and rate the setback strong, mixed or weak. Then propose one refinement to the design or its management, explain how it would further reduce human impact on the river or restore biodiversity, and say what evidence you would collect to know whether it worked.
Practice
Work these on paper or in your notebook, then open Check your answer. Aim for all of Fluency and Application; try at least one Challenge.
Printable version: this unit’s practice workbook (PDF)
Fluency
Build speed and accuracy with the core skill.
- Name one natural resource and one natural hazard that have shaped where Missourians live.
Check your answer
Answer: Sample: resource — rivers, fertile bottomland soils or lead ore; hazard — floods or New Madrid earthquakes.Resources attract settlement; hazards change how and where people build. - What is the formula for next year’s herd in the lesson’s deer model?
Check your answer
Answer: N + rN(1 − N/K) − hN.Logistic growth minus a harvest that is a fraction h of the herd. - How many acres of floodplain did the L-536 setback reconnect to the Missouri River?
Check your answer
Answer: 1,040 acres.From the project fact sheet.
Application
Use the skill in context. Show your reasoning.
- St. Louis’s floodwall is 52 feet and the 1993 crest was 49.58 feet. How much room was left?
Check your answer
Answer: 2.42 feet.52 − 49.58 = 2.42. - Run the deer model for one year with h = 0.30 from N = 20,000 (r = 0.4, K = 30,000). Give the growth, harvest and new herd.
Check your answer
Answer: Growth ≈ 2,667; harvest = 6,000; new herd ≈ 16,667.0.4 × 20,000 × (1/3) ≈ 2,667; 0.3 × 20,000 = 6,000; 20,000 + 2,667 − 6,000. - Continue the model for ten years. What herd sizes do h = 0.10, 0.20 and 0.30 reach in year 10?
Check your answer
Answer: About 22,417, 15,386 and 9,367 deer.Each run approaches its long-run level K(1 − h/r): 22,500, 15,000 and 7,500.
Challenge
Stretch problems. Expect to think before you write.
- Use N = K(1 − h/r) to find the long-run harvest hN and understory index W for h = 0.15. Compare it with h = 0.20.
Check your answer
Answer: N = 30,000 × (1 − 0.375) = 18,750; harvest = 0.15 × 18,750 ≈ 2,813 a year; W = 100 − 37.5 = 62.5. h = 0.20 gives a larger harvest (3,000) and a healthier understory (70).Up to h = r/2 = 0.20, harvesting more raises both the yield and W in this model. - A critic says the L-536 setback “wasted” 1,040 acres of farmland. Write a two-sentence response that weighs this constraint against the evidence.
Check your answer
Answer: Sample: The reconnected land is no longer farmed, but the fact sheet reports the setback lowers the 100-year flood surface by up to 0.83 feet, protects 20 square miles behind a stronger levee and was cheaper than rebuilding the breached line. The floodplain also adds fish habitat, recharges groundwater and retains nutrients, so the trade gives up a little farmland to reduce repeated damage and restore part of the river’s natural function.A good evaluation names the cost and then compares it with measured benefits.
Review
Keep earlier skills sharp.
- (Unit 1) In the logistic model, at what herd size is growth rN(1 − N/K) largest when K = 30,000?
Check your answer
Answer: At N = K/2 = 15,000.rN(1 − N/K) peaks halfway to carrying capacity. - (5.2) Name one way the L-536 setback could help the Gulf hypoxic zone.
Check your answer
Answer: Floodplains retain nutrients deposited during floods, so less nitrogen and phosphorus reaches the Gulf.Less nutrient load means less algal overgrowth and less oxygen depletion.
Missouri’s Resources and Hazards, a Deer-Harvest Model and the L-536 Levee Setback
Missouri Geological Survey fact sheet PUB0658 (galena); USGS Summary of 1811-1812 New Madrid Earthquakes Sequence; NWS St. Louis, The Great Flood of 1993; USFWS Big Muddy National Fish and Wildlife Refuge pages; MDC news release, final deer harvest 2025-2026 (Jan. 16, 2026); Large-Scale Levee Setback on the Missouri River (L-536 case study, Sept. 2021); Smithsonian, White-tailed Deer in Eastern Forests; all retrieved November 5, 2026; deer model parameters illustrative · SLS original, citing U.S. government data (public domain) and Missouri state agency and project facts
Why this reading. The lesson gives you three jobs: explain, simulate and evaluate. This card puts the Missouri resource and hazard facts in one place, gives the full model with a ten-year check run, and lays out the L-536 levee setback’s numbers for your evaluation table.
Resources that placed people
| Resource | Evidence | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Lead ore (galena, PbS) | Important in Missouri since 1720; first found near Mine La Motte (Madison County). Missouri has been the top U.S. lead producer since 1907, except 1962. Old Lead Belt (Flat River–Bonne Terre) mined until 1972; all production now from the 35-mile Viburnum Trend. In 1992, nine mines produced 330,000 tons, 75 percent of the U.S. total. | Missouri Geological Survey fact sheet PUB0658 |
| Rivers and bottomlands | Water, transport and flood-built soils drew cities and farms to the Missouri and Mississippi. | General geography |
| Prairie soils | About 15 million acres of tallgrass prairie, mostly plowed for farmland. | MDC |
Hazards that changed choices
- New Madrid earthquakes (USGS preferred magnitudes): M7.5, December 16, 1811 (northeast Arkansas); M7.3, January 23, 1812 (Missouri); M7.5, February 7, 1812 (Reelfoot fault, Missouri and Tennessee).
- Great Flood of 1993 (National Weather Service): St. Louis crest 49.58 feet on August 1, 1993, nearly 20 feet above flood stage; the 52-foot floodwall held with 52 − 49.58 = 2.42 feet to spare. 18 percent of federal and 78 percent of non-federal levees failed or were overtopped.
- Response: Big Muddy National Fish and Wildlife Refuge, created September 1994 on flood-damaged land bought from willing sellers (much of it buried under several feet of sand); now almost 20,000 acres. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service.
The deer harvest: real anchor numbers
MDC’s preliminary 2025-2026 harvest: 301,954 deer (145,222 antlered bucks, 25,129 button bucks, 131,603 does); 2024-2025: 275,656. Does were 131,603 ÷ 301,954 ≈ 43.6 percent of the 2025-2026 harvest.
The simulation (illustrative region)
Rules: next N = N + rN(1 − N/K) − hN, with r = 0.4, K = 30,000, starting N = 20,000. Understory index W = 100 − 2 × (N ÷ 1,000). These parameters are chosen for teaching, not measured for any Missouri county. Spreadsheet tip: if N is in B2, put =0.4*B2*(1-B2/30000) in C2 (growth), =0.2*B2 in D2 (harvest), =B2+C2-D2 in B3, and =100-2*B3/1000 for W; fill down.
Check run, h = 0.20 (rounded; W uses the end-of-year herd):
| Year | Growth rN(1 − N/K) | Harvest hN | Herd N at end of year | Understory index W |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2,667 | 4,000 | 18,667 | 62.7 |
| 2 | 2,821 | 3,733 | 17,754 | 64.5 |
| 3 | 2,899 | 3,551 | 17,102 | 65.8 |
| 4 | 2,941 | 3,420 | 16,623 | 66.8 |
| 5 | 2,965 | 3,325 | 16,263 | 67.5 |
| 6 | 2,979 | 3,253 | 15,989 | 68.0 |
| 7 | 2,987 | 3,198 | 15,778 | 68.4 |
| 8 | 2,992 | 3,156 | 15,615 | 68.8 |
| 9 | 2,995 | 3,123 | 15,487 | 69.0 |
| 10 | 2,997 | 3,097 | 15,386 | 69.2 |
Long-run levels (where growth equals harvest, N = K(1 − h/r)):
| Harvest rate h | Long-run herd | Deer harvested per year | Understory index W |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | 30,000 | 0 | 40 |
| 0.10 | 22,500 | 2,250 | 55 |
| 0.20 | 15,000 | 3,000 | 70 |
| 0.30 | 7,500 | 2,250 | 85 |
| 0.40 | 0 | 0 | 100 (no deer left) |
Limits to discuss: real r and K change with weather, disease and habitat; hunters harvest bucks and does differently; the browsing rule W is a stand-in for real vegetation surveys such as fenced-plot (exclosure) studies.
The L-536 levee setback (Atchison and Holt counties)
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| 2019 flood on the Missouri River | More than 100 levees breached or overtopped; 1.2 million acres inundated; L-536 breached in 7 places |
| Project | Levee moved inland; 5 miles long; built August 2020 to summer 2021 |
| Floodplain reconnected | 1,040 acres |
| Flood reduction | Up to 0.83 feet lower water surface in the 100-year flood |
| Area protected | 20 square miles (12,800 acres) |
| Cost | About $103.5 million (about $100 million construction, about $3.5 million real estate); the Corps’ analysis found the setback the least-cost option compared with repairing the levee in place |
| Listed benefits | Lower flood velocities, less erosion and scour; floodplain habitat and fish spawning and nursery areas; groundwater recharge; nutrient retention |
| Partners | Atchison County Levee District, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, NRCS, Missouri DNR, MDC, State Emergency Management Agency, The Nature Conservancy and others |
Sources: Missouri Geological Survey, Galena: Missouri’s Official State Mineral (PUB0658) (dnr.mo.gov); USGS, Summary of 1811-1812 New Madrid Earthquakes Sequence (usgs.gov); NWS St. Louis, The Great Flood of 1993 (weather.gov); USFWS, Big Muddy National Fish and Wildlife Refuge: About Us (fws.gov); USFWS, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service to begin expansion of Big Muddy National Fish and Wildlife Refuge (2001) (fws.gov); MDC, MDC reports final deer harvest for season at 301,954 (mdc.mo.gov); Large-Scale Levee Setback on the Missouri River (L-536 – A Case Study), Sept. 2021 (nature.org); Smithsonian’s National Zoo and Conservation Biology Institute, White-tailed Deer in Eastern Forests (nationalzoo.si.edu)