
use the four stages of the Critical Response Process to critique my own work (with a family member or as a written self-dialogue) and to respond to the course’s exemplar works, and construct evaluations of a work from differing sets of criteria.
Instruction
All year you have critiqued with the four-step method (describe, analyze, interpret, judge) and tested with readers. The final critique uses a process designed for artists presenting finished or nearly finished work: the Critical Response Process, developed by the choreographer Liz Lerman. It puts the artist in charge of the conversation and delays opinion until it can be useful. It is usually run with a group, but its structure works just as well with one other person, or on paper with yourself.
The roles. The artist presents the work. The responder gives feedback. A facilitator keeps the stages in order. You will play these roles in two ways. On your own work: you are the artist and the facilitator; the responder is a family member or another adult if one is willing, or, if not, yourself, writing as a responder after at least a day away from the work. On an exemplar work: you are the responder to one of the course’s invented exemplars, such as Held Together or Three Arches, whose artist’s goals and test results are written out in the readings.
Stage 1: Statements of meaning. The responder says what was meaningful, striking, surprising or memorable in the work. Not “I liked it”, but “When my hand reached the stitched seam in the center, the whole piece felt like it was being held together.” This stage tells the artist what is already working.
Stage 2: The artist as questioner. The artist asks the responder questions about the work: “Did you find where the texture changes?” “What did the key in the box make you think of?” The responder answers honestly, and may give opinions only on what the artist asks. Write your questions before the session so you ask about what you actually need to know.
Stage 3: Neutral questions from the responder. The responder asks questions without opinions hidden inside. “Why did you make it so dark?” hides a judgment; “What guided your color choices?” does not. Neutral questions often lead the artist to discover something themselves.
Stage 4: Opinion time. The responder offers opinions, but first asks permission and names the topic: “I have an opinion about the edges; would you like to hear it?” The artist may say yes or no. This keeps feedback focused and respectful.
Running it as a self-dialogue. With no one to respond, write the session as a script with two voices. Put the work away for at least a day, then write as the responder, by touch first and then by sight, using only what the work shows; switch to the artist’s voice to ask your Stage 2 questions and answer the neutral questions. Keep to the stage order and the permission rule even on paper: it stops you from jumping straight to fixes.
Being useful. Constructive feedback is specific (it points to a place in the work), grounded in evidence, connected to the artist’s goal, and actionable. “The progressive rhythm stops two-thirds of the way across; if the last arches continued to grow, the build-up might land” is useful. “It’s great” and “it’s boring” are not.
Differing criteria. The Advanced standard asks you to construct evaluations based on differing sets of criteria. After the process, write two short evaluations of one exemplar work, each naming its criteria: for example, one by the artist’s own stated goals, and one by tactile readability, or by this course’s assessment criteria (originality, interpretation of the AI image, technical skill, composition, emotional impact, experimentation). Notice where they agree and disagree.
Receiving feedback. As the artist, listen and take notes without defending. Afterward, sort each comment: act on it, test it, or set it aside, with a reason. You are the author of your work; feedback informs your decisions rather than making them.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Which is a neutral question?
Stage 1
Tap to revealStatements of meaning: what was meaningful, striking or surprising.
Stage 2
Tap to revealThe artist asks the responder questions.
Stage 3
Tap to revealThe responder asks neutral questions.
Stage 4
Tap to revealOpinion time: the responder asks permission and names the topic first.
Upload your critique notes as the artist on your own work (your Stage 2 questions, what the responder said, whether the responder was a family member or your written self-dialogue) and as a responder to one of the course’s exemplar works (one statement of meaning, one neutral question, one permissioned opinion). Write two evaluations of that exemplar work from different named criteria. Then sort the feedback on your own work into act, test or set aside, with reasons.
How confident are you that you can critique my own work and an exemplar through the Critical Response Process and evaluate from different criteria?
The Structured Critique: The Critical Response Process Step by Step, With a Family Member or as a Self-Dialogue, a Worked Round, Two Evaluations and a Rubric
Steps paraphrased from Liz Lerman’s Critical Response Process one-page summary (lizlerman.com, 2020/2025), read 26 September 2026; worked round, self-dialogue, evaluations and rubric are SLS original, invented and illustrative · SLS original (worked round and rubric, illustrative), with a paraphrase and one short credited quotation of Liz Lerman’s published summary
Why this reading. The lesson describes the four stages of the Critical Response Process and asks you to run it on your own work (with a family member, or as a written self-dialogue), respond to one of the course’s exemplar works, write two evaluations from different criteria and sort feedback. It does not give the full protocol in one place, the criteria sets you would judge by, a worked example to copy, or a way to check your responses. This reading does. The process is Liz Lerman’s; the four steps below are paraphrased from her published one-page summary (lizlerman.com, read 26 September 2026), and the worked example and rubric are SLS original and invented.
The process
Roles: the artist, who presents a work and questions it; responders, who are committed to the artist’s aim of making excellent work; a facilitator, who starts each step and keeps the order. Lerman designed it for groups, but the roles can be shared by two people. In this course: on your own work you are the artist and facilitator, and the responder is a family member or another adult, or yourself writing after at least a day away; on an exemplar work you are the responder. Record the session on a phone, or write it down as you go. Lerman describes good feedback as “the kind that makes you want to go back to work.”
- Statements of meaning. Responders say what was meaningful, striking or memorable. Doubts and negative opinions wait.
- Artist as questioner. The artist asks questions about the work; responders answer the question asked, and may give opinions only in direct response to it.
- Neutral questions. Responders ask questions with no opinion hidden inside. “Why is the center so cluttered?” hides a judgment; “What led you to place the objects in the center?” does not. The artist answers.
- Permissioned opinions. Responders offer opinions only with the artist’s permission, in the form “I have an opinion about the edges; would you like to hear it?” The artist may say no. Lerman also notes that suggestions for changes (“fix-its”) work best if the artist says up front that they want them.
A worked round with two responders (SLS original, invented)
Work: Held Together, a shadow box on a mending theme (the exemplar in Portfolio Task 7), with the artist’s aunt as Responder A and a parent as Responder B. 1. Statements of meaning. Responder A: “When my hand reached the stitched seam in the center, the whole piece felt like it was being held together.” Responder B: “The soft cloth at the start made me feel welcome.” 2. Artist as questioner. Artist: “Did you find the line of beads?” A: “Not until I looked. My fingers went straight past them.” Artist: “What did the cracked pane make you think of?” B: “A plate. Or a bone.” 3. Neutral questions. A: “What guided your choice of a shallow box?” Artist: “I wanted a hand to reach in and find corners… I hadn’t thought that the corners are empty.” B: “What were you hoping the last thing a hand meets would be?” 4. Permissioned opinions. A: “I have an opinion about the beads; would you like to hear it?” Artist: “Yes.” A: “They are the same height as the frame, so they vanish under the fingers. Raising them might help.” B: “I have an opinion about the right edge; would you like to hear it?” Artist: “Not yet.”
The same process as a self-dialogue (SLS original, invented)
No responder available? Write the session as a script, two days after you last touched the work. 1. Meaning (as responder, touch first): “The soft cloth at the lower left is the first thing my hand meets, and it is welcoming. The seam in the center is the strongest moment.” 2. Artist’s questions (written before the two days away): “Can the beads be found by touch?” Responder: “Not easily; my fingers passed over them before I knew they were there.” 3. Neutral question (as responder): “What should the last thing a hand meets be?” Artist: “Repair, but right now it is the plain box edge.” 4. Opinion (as responder, after asking): “I have an opinion about the right edge; do I want to hear it? Yes: it needs a final, gentle texture.” The self-dialogue is weaker than a real second person, because you know your own intent, so keep to what the work itself shows and say so in your notes.
Sorting what the artist heard:
| Comment | Act, test or set aside | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Beads vanish under the fingers | Act | Two readers missed them; raise them on thread |
| Cracked pane felt like a plate or a bone | Set aside | Both fit my theme; nothing to change |
| Corners of the box are empty | Test | Put a bead in one corner and see whether a hand finds it |
Two evaluations from different criteria (worked)
By the artist’s stated goal (“a hand should feel something broken, then held”): strong. Both blind readers reported the broken-then-held story by touch. By tactile readability (could every planned element be found by hand?): fair. The seam and the pane were found; the beads were not. The two evaluations disagree because the artist’s goal did not mention the beads, and readability asks about every element. Notice where evaluations agree (the seam works) and where they split (the beads).
The course’s own criteria (rate each 1–4 with a reason): originality; interpretation of the AI image; technical skill; composition; emotional impact; experimentation.
Rubric for your critique notes
| 3 | 2 | 1 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Statement of meaning | Names a place in the work and what it did to you | A place, no effect | “I liked it” |
| Neutral question | No judgment hidden inside | Mostly neutral | A judgment as a question |
| Permissioned opinion | Asks, names the topic, specific and actionable | Asks, general | Does not ask |
| As artist | Asks questions, listens without defending, sorts every comment with a reason | Sorts some | Argues back |
Sources: Liz Lerman, Critical Response Process in Brief (lizlerman.com); Liz Lerman and John Borstel, Liz Lerman’s Critical Response Process (Dance Exchange, 2003) (archive.org)