
evaluate the compositions of AI-generated images, my own sculpture and the course’s worked example sculpture using compositional principles, and construct evaluations from more than one set of criteria.
Instruction
Image generators learn from what is common in their training data, and composition is no exception. Many AI images share recognizable habits: the subject sits in the center, often symmetrically; lighting is dramatic and even; the background is softly blurred; the view is at eye level or a sweeping wide angle. These are not errors. They are the average of millions of photographs and illustrations — and the average is rarely the most interesting choice.
Critique by principle. In this lab you critique AI images and sculptures (your own, and the worked example in the image-cards reading) one principle at a time, rather than all at once. For each principle, answer three questions: What is here? How does it affect the viewer? What would change it?
- Balance: symmetrical, asymmetrical or radial? Where is the visual weight?
- Rhythm: what repeats, at what interval, and where does it lead?
- Proportion: which part is largest, and is that the most important part?
- Spatial arrangement: where is the negative space? What overlaps? From how many viewpoints does it work?
- Emphasis: where does the eye, or the hand, go first?
A worked example. An AI image shows a lighthouse dead center, with symmetrical cliffs on each side and a sunset behind. Balance: symmetrical, very stable. Rhythm: almost none — the waves are uniform. Proportion: the lighthouse fills a third of the height. Negative space: evenly distributed, so nothing feels open or crowded. Emphasis: clear but static. A recomposition might move the lighthouse to the right third, let a curve of rocks lead in from the lower left in a progressive rhythm, and leave a large empty sky — asymmetrical balance with a path for the eye. Compare Hokusai, whose Great Wave puts the mountain low and small and lets the wave take over.
Different criteria, different judgments. The Advanced-level standard for this lesson asks you to construct evaluations from differing sets of criteria. Judge the lighthouse image three ways: by formal criteria (does the composition create movement and emphasis?), by purpose (would it work as a calm poster? then symmetry is a strength), and by tactile criteria (could a hand read it? the symmetrical cliffs would feel identical). One work can be weak by one set of criteria and strong by another. Say which set you are using.
Critiquing sculptures. Apply the same principles to your own armature sculpture from Lesson 1.2. Put it away for at least a day first, so you meet it with fresh eyes, then turn it a quarter turn at a time. Name the weakest viewpoint and suggest one change, and check your critique against the worked example of the Leaning Figure in the reading. If a family member is willing, ask them which view they find least interesting, and compare their answer with yours. A sculpture has no single frame, so its composition is really a sequence of compositions, one for each position of the viewer.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
An AI image centers a single tree symmetrically in a flat field. If you move the tree to the right third and add a path curving in from the lower left, what happens to the composition?
A symmetrical, centered composition is judged weak for a dramatic print but strong for a calm poster. This shows that:
Critique one AI image by principle (balance, rhythm, proportion, spatial arrangement, emphasis). Evaluate it by formal, purpose and tactile criteria, stating each. Sketch a recomposition. Then, after at least a day away, critique your own armature sculpture from Lesson 1.2: name its weakest viewpoint and one change.
How confident are you that you can critique a composition by principle and evaluate it with different criteria?
Four Machine Image Cards and the Critique Kit: Method, a Worked Critique, a Sculpture Example and a Rubric
Constructed and illustrative: written for this course to stand in for AI-generated images; not real model output and not attributed to any tool, artist or museum · SLS original (constructed teaching material, illustrative)
Why this reading. The critique lab asks you to critique “an AI image” by principle and to recompose it. You cannot critique what you cannot see, and text alone must therefore carry the image. Below are four image cards: each describes, in measured positions, an image of the kind a text-to-image tool typically produces. They are SLS original, written for this course. They are not copies of any real output and are not attributed to any tool, person or museum. If you have your own AI image, use it instead and describe it the same way. The same four cards serve as sources in Lessons 1.4, 1.5, 2.4, 3.4 and 3.5. Positions are (% across from the left, % down from the top).
The four image cards (illustrative)
Card A — Lighthouse at sunset. Illustrative prompt: “a lighthouse on a cliff at sunset, dramatic sky, cinematic”. A white lighthouse stands at (50%, 50%) and fills a third of the picture height. Cliffs on both sides are near mirror images of each other, each about 30% wide. The sun sits exactly behind the tower at (50%, 60%). The horizon is at 65% down. The waves are evenly spaced, near-identical bands. The light is even, the far cliffs are softly blurred and the point of view is at eye level.
Card B — Dune field at dusk. Illustrative prompt: “sand dunes at dusk, golden hour, ultra detailed”. Three ridgelines curve across the picture like slow S-shapes: one runs from the lower left corner (0%, 95%) up to about (70%, 45%), a second lies behind it about 10% higher, and a third is a thin line at the horizon, 40% down. The sky is a smooth gradient and fills the top 40%. A small dark shrub sits at (52%, 60%). Sand ripples repeat across the foreground at equal spacing, about 6% apart.
Card C — Greenhouse at dawn. Illustrative prompt: “abandoned greenhouse at dawn, light through broken glass”. One-point perspective, vanishing point at (50%, 45%). Six iron roof arches march away from the viewer, each smaller than the last, at equal steps in perspective. About one pane in five is broken, in no pattern. A center aisle runs down the middle; plant benches line both sides in matching pairs. A shaft of pale light falls from the upper left across the right benches.
Card D — Terraced hillside at midday. Illustrative prompt: “terraced hillside village, midday sun, photorealistic”. Five terrace bands climb from the bottom edge to the top. Their heights get smaller as they rise: about 30%, 24%, 19%, 15% and 12% of the picture height from bottom to top. A white farmhouse sits at (72%, 40%) on the third band up from the bottom. A zigzag path links the bands, left to right to left. Shadows are short and the whole picture is sharp.
The critique method
Critique one principle at a time. For each of balance, rhythm, proportion, spatial arrangement and emphasis, answer three questions in a sentence each: What is here? (a fact you can point to, with a position or a count) How does it affect a viewer or a hand? What would change it? Then judge the image three ways and name the criteria each time: formal (does it create movement and emphasis?), purpose (what is it for: a calm poster, a dramatic print, a relief for touch?) and tactile (could a hand read it?).
The habits to watch for in machine compositions: a centered subject, near-symmetry, even light, blurred background, a horizon near the middle. These are averages, not errors. A recomposition changes at least one of them on purpose.
Worked critique, Card B (SLS original)
| Principle | What is here | Effect | What would change it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Balance | Asymmetrical. The long ridge sweeps from the lower left to the right; the tiny shrub sits near center. | The sweep pulls the eye right; the shrub is too small to answer it, so the picture leans. | Move the shrub to (75%, 50%) so it sits where the ridge ends. |
| Rhythm | Flowing: three curved ridges and ripples repeating about 6% apart, all alike. | Calm, but the equal spacing never speeds up or slows down. | Make the ripples progressive: 8%, 6%, 4%, 2%, so the eye accelerates toward the horizon. |
| Proportion | Sky 40%, dunes 60%; the shrub is about 2% of the height. | The shrub is too small to be the emphasis, so the sky is the largest thing. | Lower the horizon to 30% for less sky, or enlarge the shrub to about 8%. |
| Space | Deep space by overlapping ridges; the whole lower left is empty. | Open and quiet, with no place to stop. | Keep the empty left corner but add one overlap in front of the shrub. |
| Emphasis | No single strongest point; the eye lands on the sun-lit ridge edge. | Static, atmospheric. | Give the shrub the darkest dark and the sharpest edge. |
Three sets of criteria. Formal: weak to fair; it has flowing rhythm but no emphasis. Purpose (a calm poster): strong, because the even ripples and open sky are restful. Tactile: weak. Under a hand, three identical ripple ridges feel like one, and a 2% shrub disappears. To make it readable, raise the ridges to three different heights and make the shrub a distinct raised knot. One picture, three verdicts, and each verdict names its criteria. Recomposition (words): horizon at 35%; ridge from (0%, 95%) to (75%, 45%); shrub enlarged to about 8% at (75%, 50%); ripples progressive, 8% to 2%.
Critiquing a sculpture: a worked example (SLS original, invented)
Leaning Figure, an invented student sculpture for practice: 18 cm high; wire and foil armature under 6 mm of air-dry clay; a 6 × 6 cm wood base. Front: the figure leans forward about 25 degrees and reaches left; the head is the biggest, roughest form. Side: a clear diagonal from the base to the hand. Back: a flat clay slab, smooth and unmodeled. Balance test: it stays put when nudged from the back and sides, and tips forward when nudged from the front.
Responder’s critique. Balance: the physical balance fails forward because the center of gravity is outside the base at the front; visually the heavy head adds to the forward pull. Rhythm: the ridges on the sleeve repeat at equal spacing and then stop at the elbow. Space: the gap between the arm and the body reads well from the side. Weakest viewpoint: the back, a plain slab with nothing to find. One change: add a counterweight behind, such as a lump of clay for a cloak, widening the base to the rear; the same lump adds a form to the back view. Notice that the critique names a place, gives the reason and offers one action.
Rubric for your critique record
| 3 | 2 | 1 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Specific | Every claim points to a place, position or count | Some claims point | General words such as “nice” |
| By principle | All five principles, three questions each | Three or four principles | One or two |
| Criteria named | Formal, purpose and tactile, each judged and named | Two sets | One set, unnamed |
| Actionable | A recomposition with positions, or a sculpture change with a reason | A change, no reason | No change offered |