
revise a model of the burned landscape that links processes across time scales, classify feedbacks as positive or negative using data, judge the uncertainty in those data, and brainstorm protection ideas grounded in the science.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. A thermostat turns a heater off when a room gets warm and on when it gets cool. Does that loop push the room’s temperature further from where it started, or back toward it? Write one sentence.
Snow and ice reflect most sunlight. If warming melts snow and exposes dark ground, what happens next?
Why revise? We now hold four pieces: the rock cycle (4.01), running water (4.03), slope failure and feedbacks (4.04) and water’s properties (4.05). The district needs one model that shows how they connect on the burned slope and how fast each process acts.
Two kinds of feedback. A positive feedback amplifies the original change; a negative feedback reduces it and pushes the system back toward balance. A climate example: the ice-albedo feedback is positive, because melting snow exposes darker ground that absorbs more sunlight and warms further. On the burned slope, bare soil → more erosion → thinner soil → slower regrowth is positive. But as the loose ash and soil are stripped away, less easily moved material remains, so sediment loss falls even before plants return: a negative feedback that limits the change.
The data (sample data from a burned watershed).
| Years after fire | Plant cover (%) | Sediment yield (t/ha per year) | Uncertainty (± t/ha) | Rain gauges used |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before fire | 85 | 0.5 | 0.2 | 3 |
| 1 | 10 | 40 | 15 | 1 |
| 2 | 35 | 18 | 6 | 2 |
| 3 | 60 | 6 | 3 | 3 |
| 5 | 75 | 1.5 | 0.6 | 3 |
Worked example 1: reading a trend with its uncertainty. Sediment yield in year 1 was 40 ± 15 t/ha, so the true value probably lies between 25 and 55. Even the low end is 50 times the pre-fire 0.5 t/ha, so the jump is real. Between years 1 and 2 the ranges are 25–55 and 12–24; they do not overlap, so the drop is also real. Notice why year 1 is so uncertain: only one rain gauge worked after the fire, and one storm can dominate a single year. Limits like these, plus possible bias (gauges placed only near the road), must be stated before we draw conclusions.
Worked example 2: an unintended effect of a technology. Suppose the district had once built a concrete check dam in the creek to trap sediment. It fills quickly after the fire; downstream, the water released over it carries less sediment and has spare energy to erode the creek bed and banks below the dam. A technology built to protect the creek can cause erosion somewhere else. Large river dams do the same at a bigger scale, starving beaches of sand.
Across scales. Your revised model must place every process on a time scale: a debris flow in minutes, a storm in hours, regrowth in years, frost wedging and soil formation over centuries, carving of the valley by glaciers over tens of thousands of years, and uplift and exhumation of the granite over tens of millions.
CER starters. Claim: “After the fire, the slope’s sediment loss…” Evidence: “The sample data show… with an uncertainty of…” Reasoning: “Because plant cover…, this is a positive/negative feedback…”
Ideate. Now turn the science toward the client. The slope’s weakest links are bare soil, fast runoff and loose sediment heading for the creek. Brainstorm at least five protection ideas without judging them (covering the soil, slowing runoff on the slope, catching sediment in the channel, helping plants return, warning the road crew). Quantity first; we judge with criteria next phase.
Use the sample watershed data. Check your reasoning with a partner.
Revise and ideate.
Draw your revised landscape model as one annotated cross-section from the granite ridge to the creek and road. Show at least one internal process, three surface processes, one positive and one negative feedback, and a time scale on every arrow (minutes to tens of millions of years). Write two sentences on what you changed from earlier models and why.
Ideate: list at least five slope or creek protection ideas (a sketch and one sentence each). For each, name the weak link it targets and one unintended effect it might have.
One model now runs from tens of millions of years to minutes. Next phase we turn the best ideas into designs and test them in a storm.
Exit ticket: give one positive and one negative feedback on the burned slope, and one reason the data about them are uncertain.
How confident are you that you can I can model a landscape across time scales and judge feedbacks and data uncertainty.
Materials: the sample watershed table, students’ models from 4.01, 4.04 and 4.05, large paper, sticky notes for ideation.
Setup: the watershed data are sample data shaped like typical post-fire recovery (a sharp first-year spike that falls as plants return); they are not from a specific fire. The check dam is a hypothetical example of a common engineering trade-off. Run ideation as a 4-minute silent brainstorm, then share.
Listen for: “positive feedback means a good effect”; ignoring error bars; treating any uncertainty as ‘we know nothing.’
Support / stretch: give a feedback-loop template with + and − arrows. Stretch: graph sediment yield with error bars on a log scale and describe the shape of the recovery.