
revise one model that links mantle convection, the ages of crustal rocks and the motion of the fault, defend it with a claim-evidence-reasoning paragraph, and brainstorm crossing designs grounded in that science.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Lay out your notebook models from 3.01, 3.03 and 3.05 side by side. Circle one place where two of them disagree or leave a gap. Write it as a question.
Which energy source drives mantle convection?
Why revise? So far we have three separate models: the sea floor and crustal ages (3.01), the layered, convecting interior (3.03) and the margin’s history (3.05). The client’s public explanation needs one model that shows how they connect: energy inside Earth moves matter, moving plates make and destroy crust, and the fault is where two plates slide past each other today.
The data to explain (sample data). A survey line runs from a mid-ocean ridge across the ocean floor to a continent. Use the table for the worked examples and your model.
| Distance from ridge (km) | Sea-floor age (million years, sample) | Heat flow (mW/m², sample) | Sediment thickness (m, sample) | Your note |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | 0 | 250 | 0 | |
| 500 | 10 | 130 | 60 | |
| 1,500 | 30 | 85 | 170 | |
| 3,000 | 60 | 65 | 330 | |
| 4,500 (trench at the continent) | 90 | 55 | 500 | |
| Continent interior | rocks up to 2,700 | — | — |
Worked example 1: reading the pattern. Age rises steadily with distance: 4,500 km in 90 million years is 450,000,000 cm / 90,000,000 yr = 5 cm/yr. Heat flow is highest at the ridge, where hot mantle rises and new crust is still cooling, and falls as the plate ages and cools. Sediment piles up slowly on older floor. Every column points the same way: crust forms hot at the ridge and moves away as it cools, then sinks at the trench. The continent’s interior holds rocks far older than any sea floor because buoyant continental crust is not recycled.
Worked example 2: a revised model, in words. Malik’s first model showed plates ‘riding on’ convection cells like boxes on a conveyor belt. His revision: heat from radioactive decay and Earth’s formation keeps the mantle convecting; hot, less dense rock rises beneath ridges, melts partly as pressure drops, and makes new crust; the plate cools, thickens and becomes denser as it moves away; at the trench, cold dense slab sinks and pulls the plate behind it, returning matter to the mantle. The strike-slip fault forms where two plates moving in different directions meet side by side. The revision adds the slab’s pull and the cycling of matter, and it explains the heat-flow data.
CER starters. Claim: “The ages of crustal rocks are explained by…” Evidence: “The sample survey shows…; the S-wave shadow zone shows…; the stream channel offset shows…” Reasoning: “Because hot mantle is less dense…, and because ocean crust is denser than continental crust…”
Across scales. Your model must also show the surface: convection moves plates centimeters a year for tens of millions of years; uplift at the fault bend builds a range over millions of years; rivers erode it over thousands; one earthquake moves the ground meters in seconds.
Ideate. Now turn the science toward the client. The fault moves about 35 mm/yr but is locked, so it stores slip and releases it in jumps of several meters. The crossing must survive a sudden sideways jump, not slow creep. Brainstorm at least five crossing ideas without judging them. Quantity first; we judge with criteria next phase.
Use the sample survey table. Check your reasoning with a partner.
Revise and ideate.
Draw your revised model as one cross-section from the inner core to the fault. Show the heat sources, convection, a ridge, a sinking slab, the strike-slip fault and one surface process. Label one process at each time scale: seconds, thousands of years and millions of years. Write two sentences on what you changed from your first models and why.
Ideate: list at least five crossing ideas for the water main (a sketch and one sentence each). For each, name the fault behavior it answers: sudden sideways slip, shaking, or the stored slip since the last earthquake.
One model now links the core to the creek. Next phase we turn the best ideas into designs and test them.
Exit ticket: in one sentence, explain how energy from radioactive decay ends up moving the two sides of the fault.
How confident are you that you can I can use one model to explain how mantle convection moves plates, sets crustal ages and shapes the surface.
Materials: the sample survey table, students’ models from 3.01, 3.03 and 3.05, large paper, colored pencils, sticky notes for ideation.
Setup: the survey numbers are sample data shaped like real sea-floor patterns (heat flow highest at ridges, sediment thickening with age). Run the ideation as a timed silent brainstorm (4 minutes) then a share-out.
Listen for: “plates ride on convection cells” with no role for slab pull; “the mantle is liquid”; the Sun as an energy source for plate motion.
Support / stretch: give a cross-section outline with blank labels. Stretch: graph heat flow against age and describe the shape of the curve.