
construct and defend a scientific explanation, with calculations from data, of why a major strike-slip fault crosses the region and what its motion means for people, and present our tested crossing design to the utility.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Reread the question board from 3.01. Put a check next to every question your team can now answer with evidence, and a star next to one you still find hard.
Which statement best links steady plate motion to sudden fault slip?
The question. Why does a plate boundary run through this region, how does it move, and what does that mean for the people who live on it and the pipe that serves them? Your explanation ties together the whole unit, and every part must rest on evidence. It becomes the public explanation the utility will share with residents.
What to include.
Three calculations. Choose three, and show every step:
A worked paragraph. Claim: “The plates on either side of the fault move past each other at a steady rate, but the fault releases that motion in sudden earthquakes.” Evidence: “The stream channel has been offset 130 m in about 3,700 years, a rate of 35 mm per year that matches GPS measurements; yet trenches show past earthquakes that each slipped several meters at once.” Reasoning: “Because the fault is locked by friction, the steady motion of the plates bends the rocks near the fault until the stored strain overcomes friction, and the fault slips all at once.”
Care with people. When you write about earthquakes that killed and injured people, name the human cost accurately and without drama. Your explanation is part of how communities prepare.
Limits. Say what is uncertain: exact recurrence intervals, which fault segment will rupture next, how small counts of large earthquakes make the upper end of the Gutenberg-Richter line uncertain, and how well a sand-box test stands for a real pipe.
Crossing day. Each team sets up its version 2 fault box. The ‘utility panel’ (staff, family or invited guests) watches one live offset test, then each student gives a three-minute defense of the explanation and answers one question about the limits of the evidence.
Planning and drafting checks. Work alone, then compare with your peer reviewer.
Finish and defend.
Submit your final explanation (1,000–1,300 words) with the plate-boundary model, three calculations, sources cited and a limits paragraph. Then give your three-minute defense and record the question you were asked and your answer.
The water utility asked for a crossing that survives the fault’s next large earthquake and a public explanation of why the fault is there. Deliver two products. (1) Your team’s tested crossing (version 2) in the fault box, which must meet the class criteria: it survives a 7 cm (7 m at scale) offset with no leak and no more than double the flow time, shows where valves allow service to be restored within 24 hours, stays clear of the stream channel, can be inspected, and fits 100 sample utility points and the 200 m right-of-way. (2) Your own written explanation, Why the Region Has a Major Strike-Slip Fault (1,000–1,300 words), including (a) evidence that plates move and why ocean crust is younger than continental crust; (b) a model of Earth’s interior and mantle convection built from seismic evidence; (c) a labeled model of the boundary’s history, from subduction to transform, with processes at different time scales; (d) at least three calculations from this unit; (e) what a probability forecast means for residents, and its limits. Hand-drawn models are fully acceptable. Cite Earle’s Physical Geology and any USGS sources you use.
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Evidence for plate motion and crustal ages (HS-ESS1-5) | Uses sea-floor and GPS evidence with specific numbers, evaluates its reliability, and explains why ocean crust is young and continental crust old. |
| Interior and convection (HS-ESS2-3) | Explains the layered interior from seismic and density evidence and models convection, driven by internal heat, as the cycling of matter that moves the plates. |
| Plate-boundary model across scales (HS-ESS2-1) | Model shows subduction changing to transform, with landforms and processes at scales from seconds to tens of millions of years. |
| Quantitative reasoning | Three calculations correct, with units and assumptions stated. |
| Crossing design (HS-ETS1-3) | Test data show which criteria were met; the design offset is justified from fault evidence; trade-offs are named. |
| Explanation and sources | Clear mechanism linking steady plate motion to sudden fault slip; limits and human impact handled accurately; specific evidence cited from Earle and USGS data. |
The crossing is presented, geoscientists. Next class: the unit checkpoint. After that, your 3DX field trip.
Exit ticket: which question from the Wonder Board can you now answer? Write the question and your evidence-based answer.
How confident are you that you can I can construct and defend an explanation of a plate boundary with calculations from data.
Timing: Poly ran this task over three sessions. Here it is one showcase period; assign Stages 1–3 as homework across the build phase, with the peer review in a short workshop, and use this period for the live offset tests and defenses.
Materials: version 2 fault boxes, water, a stopwatch, rubric copies for the panel, a device for recorded defenses.
Setup: invite staff or family members to play the utility’s engineers; a video call works. Keep everything generic: no real utility or named fault is the client.
Listen for: “the fault is overdue”; certainty about dates; models that skip the energy source; claims that the sand-box test proves the real pipe is safe.
Support / stretch: give a five-section outline with sentence starters and allow 700–900 words with the same evidence requirements. Stretch: add a section comparing a creeping stretch of fault with a locked one and what each means for the pipe.