
analyze data on slope stability and argue, with evidence, how one change to Earth’s surface, such as a wildfire, creates feedbacks that change other Earth systems.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Why can you build a steep sandcastle wall with damp sand but not with dry sand or with soupy wet sand? Write a one-sentence hypothesis.
A slope can fail during a storm even though its angle has not changed.
A human impact first. In one well-documented case, an intense burst of rain fell on steep slopes above a coastal town a few weeks after a wildfire had burned them. Mud, boulders and trees poured down the creeks as debris flows, destroying homes and closing the coastal highway. People died. Scientists study events like this so that warnings and evacuations save lives next time. (Reading: Earle, Physical Geology, chapter 15.)
Forces on a slope. Any mass on a slope feels gravity. Part of its weight pulls it downhill (the driving force, proportional to sin θ, where θ is the slope angle); part presses it into the slope (proportional to cos θ), and that pressing produces friction that resists sliding. Engineers compare them with a factor of safety: FS = resisting force / driving force. For simple friction with coefficient μ, FS = μ cos θ / sin θ. When FS > 1 the slope holds; when FS < 1 it fails.
Worked example 1. Soil with μ = 0.6 on a 25° slope: FS = 0.6 × cos 25° / sin 25° = 0.6 × 0.906 / 0.423 ≈ 1.29. Stable. Now saturate the soil. Water in the pores pushes the grains apart and carries some of the weight, lowering the pressing force. If pore water reduces it by 40%, FS = 1.29 × 0.6 ≈ 0.77, and the slope fails, though its angle never changed. The steepest stable angle for dry material with μ = 0.6 is the angle whose tangent is 0.6, about 31°.
Water does two opposite things. A little water makes sand stronger: thin films between grains pull them together by surface tension, a result of water’s polarity, which is why damp sand builds steep walls. A lot of water makes it weaker, because it fills the pores, adds weight and pushes grains apart until the mass flows like a liquid.
Lab: Angle of Repose: Dry, Damp and Saturated Sand. Question: how does the amount of water in sand change the steepest slope it can hold? Materials: about 1 L of dry play sand, a paper cup with the bottom cut out, a tray, a measuring cup, a spray bottle, a protractor, a ruler, paper towels, goggles.
| Sand condition | Water added (mL) | Height (mm) | Base radius (mm) | Angle = tan−1(h/r) (°) | Average angle (°) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dry | 0 | ||||
| Damp | 25 | ||||
| Saturated | 75 |
Feedbacks between systems. A feedback is a chain of cause and effect in which one change triggers changes elsewhere that come back to affect the first system. Wildfire shows several at once.
Worked example 2: a human technology in the system. After large fires, geological surveys publish debris-flow hazard assessments that estimate the rainfall intensity likely to trigger flows in each burned basin, and communities use them to time warnings. Technology can also add to the problem: a road cut steepens the toe of a slope and lowers its factor of safety.
Your argument. Were the debris flows caused by the rain, the fire or the slopes? A strong argument does not pick one; it shows how they interacted, with evidence for each link, and answers a counter-claim.
Use your cone data. Show calculations.
Finish the lab and argue it out.
Claim: how does water content affect the angle of repose? Use your average angles as evidence and explain the result with surface tension and pore pressure. Estimate μ for your dry sand (μ = tan of the angle). Then share your CER with a partner and respond to their strongest objection in writing or on a recording.
Water can hold a slope together or bring it down, and one change ripples through every sphere. Next phase we model how water breaks solid rock.
How confident are you that you can I can use slope-stability data to argue how a change to Earth's surface creates feedbacks in other systems.
Exit ticket: name one feedback in the post-fire hillside, say whether it is positive or negative, and give the evidence.
Timing: Poly ran this argumentation lab over two 50-minute periods. Day 1: forces, factor of safety and the cones; day 2: feedbacks, CER and partner responses.
Materials (per group): dry play sand, a bottomless cup or funnel, tray, measuring cup, spray bottle, protractor, ruler, paper towels, goggles.
Alternative: build cones at home with sand, sugar or dry rice, or analyze the teacher’s photos of cones with a printed protractor overlay.
Care note: the debris-flow case is kept generic and stated briefly and respectfully. Students may know people affected by fires or floods; allow a written rather than spoken response.
Listen for: single-cause answers; “wet sand is always weaker”; confusing positive feedback with ‘good’.
Support / stretch: give a sin/cos table and FS template. Stretch: find the pore-pressure reduction at which the 25° slope reaches exactly FS = 1.