
construct and critique an argument that the universe began in a hot, dense state about 13.8 billion years ago, using redshift data, the cosmic microwave background and the composition of matter.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Draw dots on a balloon, then blow it up a little more. If you lived on one dot, what would you see the other dots doing? Does any dot get to be the center?
Galaxy A is 50 Mpc away and galaxy B is 200 Mpc away. If Hubble's law holds, how does B's recession speed compare with A's?
Explore first: the evidence cards. Each team gets three evidence cards: a galaxy spectrum table, a microwave-sky map and a chart of the composition of old stars. Fill in the table before you read on. (Reading: OpenStax Astronomy 2e, chapter 29, “The Big Bang.”)
| Galaxy | Observed H line (nm) | z = Δλ/λ | v = zc (km/s) | d = v/H0 (Mpc) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | 658.5 | |||
| B | 664.0 | |||
| C | 671.0 | |||
| D | 678.2 |
Galaxies A, B and D are sample data for practice; galaxy C is worked below.
The claim. The Big Bang theory says the universe was once extremely hot and dense and has been expanding and cooling for about 13.8 billion years. It is not an explosion at a point in space; space itself stretches everywhere. A theory is accepted because several independent lines of evidence point the same way.
Evidence 1: redshift and Hubble’s law. Every element absorbs and emits light at fixed wavelengths. Hydrogen’s red line is at 656.3 nm in the lab. In the light of distant galaxies the same pattern appears shifted to longer wavelengths: a redshift. The fractional shift is z = Δλ/λ, and for nearby galaxies the recession speed is v ≈ zc.
Worked example 1. A galaxy’s hydrogen line is observed at 671.0 nm. z = (671.0 − 656.3)/656.3 ≈ 0.0224, so v ≈ 0.0224 × 299,792 km/s ≈ 6,700 km/s. In 1929 Edwin Hubble showed that more distant galaxies recede faster: v = H0d. With H0 ≈ 70 km/s per megaparsec, this galaxy is about 6,700/70 ≈ 96 Mpc away (about 310 million light-years).
Worked example 2. If everything is moving apart, running time backward brings everything together. The time since then is roughly 1/H0: 1 Mpc = 3.086 × 1019 km, so 1/H0 = 3.086 × 1019/70 s ≈ 4.4 × 1017 s ≈ 14 billion years. (Current measurements of H0 range from about 67 to 73; the disagreement is an active research question, but every value gives an age of 13 to 15 billion years.)
Evidence 2: the cosmic microwave background (CMB). A hot, dense early universe would have glowed. As space expanded, that glow would be stretched into microwaves. In 1965 Arno Penzias and Robert Wilson found a faint microwave signal coming equally from every direction. Satellites (COBE, WMAP, Planck) have measured it as a nearly perfect thermal spectrum at 2.725 K, the same in every direction to about 1 part in 100,000.
Evidence 3: the composition of matter. Big Bang models predict that the first few minutes produced mostly hydrogen and about 25% helium by mass, with a trace of lithium, before the universe cooled too much for fusion. The oldest stars and gas clouds show almost exactly this mix. Stars since then have not had time to make that much helium.
Where the evidence comes from. Spectrometers on telescopes spread starlight into spectra to measure redshift; radio antennas and microwave satellites map the CMB; spectra of old stars and gas clouds give their composition.
Building a strong argument. A claim-evidence-reasoning (CER) argument states the claim, gives specific data with numbers and sources, and explains why the data support the claim. A strong argument also answers a counter-claim. “Maybe galaxies are flying away from us because we are at the center” fails, because observers in any galaxy would see the same pattern. Critique by asking: Is the evidence specific? Does the reasoning connect it to the claim? Is an alternative ruled out? Is the source reliable?
Finish the evidence table first, then work through the cards.
Peer critique and rebuttal.
Read a partner's argument and write a two-sentence critique: name the strongest piece of evidence they used and one place where their reasoning needs to say more. Then record your rebuttal or respond live to their critique of yours.
Graph v against d for galaxies A to D from your table. Is the graph a straight line through the origin? Explain what its slope means.
The Big Bang made hydrogen and helium, but not gold. Next phase, we find the factories that made everything else.
How confident are you that you can I can argue for the Big Bang from redshift, the cosmic microwave background and the composition of matter.
Exit ticket: which of the three lines of evidence would you put first on the museum wall, and why?
Materials: evidence cards (spectrum table, CMB map image from a space agency, old-star composition chart), balloons for the warm-up (check latex allergies; use a stretchy fabric band instead), calculators.
Answer key (sample galaxies): A z ≈ 0.0034, v ≈ 1,000 km/s, d ≈ 14 Mpc; B z ≈ 0.0117, v ≈ 3,500 km/s, d ≈ 50 Mpc; C about 6,700 km/s and 96 Mpc; D about 10,000 km/s and 143 Mpc.
Listen for: “the Big Bang was an explosion into empty space”; “we are at the center”; evidence quoted with no numbers.
Support / stretch: give a CER frame (I claim… The data show… This matters because… Someone might argue… but…). Stretch: research the current disagreement about H0 and explain why it does not threaten the Big Bang.