
construct an account of Earth’s formation and early history from meteorites, lunar samples, ancient zircons and planetary surfaces, and evaluate how the scientific estimate of Earth’s age changed.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. A friend says, “The oldest rock ever found is about 4 billion years old, so Earth is 4 billion years old.” Write one reason that argument might be wrong.
Which would you expect to be older: the oldest rocks on the Moon or the oldest rocks on Earth?
Explore first: the evidence stations. Rotate through four stations (meteorites, Moon rocks, ancient zircons, cratered surfaces). At each, record the age, the dating method and why the material was not recycled. (Readings: Earle, Physical Geology, chapter 22; OpenStax Astronomy 2e, chapters 13 and 14.)
| Evidence | Age (billion years) | Method | Why it survived | What it tells us |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Meteorites | ||||
| Lunar highland rocks | ||||
| Oldest zircons | ||||
| Crater records |
The problem. Earth recycles its surface. Plate tectonics carries crust down into the mantle, erosion grinds rocks into sediment, and heat and pressure remake them. So no rock on Earth has survived from the planet’s first days. To date Earth’s birth, scientists use materials that were not recycled.
Evidence 1: meteorites. Most meteorites are pieces of asteroids that formed with the planets and never melted or were remade. In 1956 the geochemist Clair Patterson measured lead isotopes in meteorites, including the iron meteorite that made Meteor Crater in Arizona, and calculated an age of about 4.55 billion years. Modern uranium-lead dates on the oldest meteorite grains, calcium-aluminum-rich inclusions, give 4.567 billion years: the start of the solar system. Earth is taken to be about 4.54 billion years old, a little younger because it took time to assemble.
Evidence 2: the Moon. Apollo astronauts returned 382 kg of lunar rock. The Moon has no plate tectonics and almost no erosion, so its oldest rocks survive: some highland samples are about 4.4–4.5 billion years old. The Moon’s chemistry is very similar to Earth’s mantle. Together with computer models, this supports the giant impact hypothesis: a Mars-sized body struck the young Earth, and the Moon formed from the debris.
Evidence 3: ancient zircons. Tiny zircon crystals from the Jack Hills of Western Australia give uranium-lead ages up to about 4.4 billion years, although the sandstone that holds them is much younger. Their oxygen isotopes suggest they formed from magma that had interacted with liquid water, which implies oceans within about 150 million years of Earth’s formation. The oldest intact rocks, the Acasta Gneiss in Canada, are about 4.0 billion years old.
Evidence 4: planetary surfaces. The Moon, Mercury and Mars are covered with craters. Dated lunar samples let scientists calibrate crater counts: heavily cratered surfaces are old, smooth ones young. The record shows many large impacts early in solar system history, falling off after about 3.8 billion years. Earth must have been hit just as hard, but its craters have been erased.
A historical argument. In 1862 Lord Kelvin calculated Earth’s age from how fast a molten ball would cool and got between 20 and 400 million years. His physics was careful, but two things were unknown in his time: radioactive decay keeps heating Earth’s interior, and the mantle carries heat by convection, not only by conduction. His data were reliable; his model’s missing pieces limited what they could show. Science corrected him when new evidence appeared.
Worked example: weighing uncertainty. Meteorite ages carry uncertainties of about 1 million years or less; the giant impact’s exact timing is debated by tens of millions of years. Both are useful, but a strong argument says which numbers are firm and which are estimates.
Use your station table.
Partner exchange.
Share your argument with a partner, and respond to their strongest objection in writing or on a recording. Then explain one way the uncertainty in a piece of evidence (for example, the timing of the giant impact) limits how useful it is for your claim.
Earth is about 4.54 billion years old, and we know it from rocks that are not from Earth. Next phase, we look at what happened after Earth formed.
How confident are you that you can I can argue for Earth's age from meteorites, lunar samples, zircons and planetary surfaces.
Exit ticket: why are Earth's oldest rocks younger than Earth? Use two processes in your answer.
Materials: four station cards with images from public space-agency and geological-survey libraries, a world map to locate Western Australia, Canada and Arizona.
Setup: 15 minutes of stations, 15 minutes of reading and discussion, 20 minutes of CER and partner exchange.
Listen for: “meteorites are from other planets” (most are from asteroids); “Kelvin was bad at math”; treating every number as equally certain.
Support / stretch: give a CER frame and a station summary sheet. Stretch: explain how comparing the uranium-238 and uranium-235 clocks in one zircon tests whether it stayed a closed system.