
communicate a scientific explanation, supported by evidence and calculations, of how the atoms in a piece of gold came to exist, and present our tested exhibit station to the museum.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Reread the question board from 1.01. Put a check next to every question your team can now answer with evidence, and a star next to one you still find hard.
Which step in your gold biography could NOT have made the gold itself?
The question. How did the atoms in a flake of gold from a mountain stream come to exist, and how do we know? Your explanation connects everything in this unit, and it has to be built from evidence, not just a story. It becomes the text behind your museum station.
What a scientific explanation needs. It explains a phenomenon by a mechanism, supported by evidence, in order. For this task that means four chapters, each with a claim and evidence:
Worked example: one paragraph. Claim: “The universe began in a hot, dense state and has been expanding.” Evidence: “A galaxy whose hydrogen line appears at 671.0 nm instead of 656.3 nm has z ≈ 0.0224 and is receding at about 6,700 km/s; Hubble found that recession speed increases with distance.” Reasoning: “If all galaxies are moving apart at speeds proportional to distance, then in the past they were closer together, and running the expansion backward gives a beginning about 14 billion years ago.” Notice how the paragraph uses a number, names where it came from, and says why it matters.
Your timeline model. Build a labeled timeline from 13.8 billion years ago to today with at least six events, placed to scale. A useful scale: 1 cm = 250 million years puts the Big Bang 55 cm from today and the Sun’s birth 18 cm from today.
Sources and honesty. Cite OpenStax Astronomy 2e (chapters 3, 16, 21–23 and 29) or a space agency for any fact you did not measure. Where scientists disagree (the exact value of the Hubble constant; how much gold comes from mergers), say so. You may choose a different heavy element (silver, platinum, uranium) if you explain the same chain.
Gallery opening. Each team sets up its version 2 station. Visitors (the museum’s role-players, families or staff) use the station for five minutes, then each student gives a three-minute talk from the biography and answers one question about the evidence.
Planning and drafting checks. Work alone, then compare with your peer reviewer.
Finish and present.
Submit your final biography (1,000–1,300 words) with the timeline, two calculations, at least three cited sources and a paragraph on what is still uncertain. Then give your three-minute talk and record the question you were asked and your answer.
The museum asked for a station that answers “Where did the gold in a ring come from?” Deliver two products. (1) Your team’s tested exhibit station (version 2), which must meet the class criteria: at least 8 of 10 test visitors name where gold was made, every fact is accurate and cited, visitors do something hands-on, it includes a scale or math element, and it fits 2 m by 2 m and 40 sample museum points. (2) Your own written Cosmic Biography of a Gold Atom (1,000–1,300 words) in four chapters, with a to-scale timeline of at least six events, at least two calculations from this unit (for example, the Sun’s mass loss, a redshift and recession velocity, a Wien’s-law temperature or a Kepler’s-law period) and at least three cited sources. Hand-drawn timelines are fully acceptable.
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Origin of the universe and light elements (HS-ESS1-2) | Uses at least two lines of Big Bang evidence with specific data, names the technology that gathered it, and explains why it supports the claim. |
| Stellar energy (HS-ESS1-1) | Explains fusion as mass converted to energy with a correct calculation, compares it with chemical energy, and describes the Sun’s life span and changing core. |
| Element production (HS-ESS1-3) | Explains why fusion stops at iron, conserves nucleons in an example, and explains how supernovae and neutron-star mergers produce heavier elements, separating established from debated ideas. |
| Model, orbits and station (HS-ESS1-4, HS-ETS1-3) | Timeline is to scale and labeled; the station’s scale or orbit element is correct; visitor data show which criteria were met and what was traded off. |
| Sources and communication | Cites specific evidence from reliable sources; the explanation is clear in text and diagram; the talk answers a question about evidence accurately. |
The gallery is open, astronomers. Next class: the unit checkpoint. After that, your 3DX field trip.
Exit ticket: which question from the Wonder Board can you now answer? Write the question and your evidence-based answer.
How confident are you that you can I can communicate, with evidence and calculations, how the elements in a gold ring were made.
Timing: Poly ran this task over three sessions. Here it is one showcase period; assign Stages 1–3 as homework across the build phase, with the peer review in 1.08 or a short workshop, and use this period for the stations and talks.
Materials: version 2 stations, rubric copies for visitors, timer, a device for recorded talks.
Setup: invite staff or family members to play the museum director and visitors; a video call works. Visitors can score the station row. Keep everything generic: no real museum is the client.
Listen for: “the Sun made the gold”; certainty about debated shares; timelines not to scale.
Support / stretch: give a four-chapter outline with sentence starters and allow 700–900 words with the same evidence requirements. Stretch: add a fifth chapter on what will happen to the gold when the Sun becomes a red giant.