
show what I learned about rocks, internal and surface processes, feedbacks between Earth’s systems and the effects of water, using data questions, a scenario set and short constructed responses.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Back to the phenomenon: granite that crystallized kilometers underground now forms cliffs that shed blocks every year, and a coastal hillside slid into the sea. In three sentences, explain how both are possible.
Granite cliffs are exposed today because uplift raised the granite and erosion removed the rock that once covered it.
Geoscientists, this is the unit checkpoint. Part A is multiple choice with data and a scenario set, where several questions share one situation. Part B is short constructed responses scored 0 to 3. Calculators are allowed. Read each question twice and show your reasoning.
How a 0–3 answer is scored. 3 points: a correct claim, accurate evidence or calculation, and reasoning that links them with science ideas. 2 points: correct claim and evidence, but reasoning missing or partly wrong. 1 point: a correct claim with little or no support, or a partly correct answer. 0 points: incorrect or blank.
Worked example: from 1 point to 3. Question: “Why can a slope fail in a storm without getting steeper?” “Because of the rain” earns 1 point. Jamal wrote: “Water filling the pores raises pore pressure and reduces the force pressing grains together. For μ = 0.6 on a 25° slope, FS drops from 1.29 to about 0.77 if that force falls by 40%. Below 1, driving force beats friction, so the slope fails.” Claim, numbers and reasoning: 3 points.
Scenario set data (sample data). Mei planned an investigation of frost wedging. She cut a 2 mm slit into each of three plaster blocks, filled the slits with water, and froze and thawed the blocks in a freezer, measuring each slit’s width with a ruler marked in millimeters. She worked alone. Use this table for questions 14–17.
| Freeze-thaw cycles | Block 1 width (mm) | Block 2 width (mm) | Block 3 width (mm) | Mean (mm) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | 2.0 | 2.0 | 2.0 | 2.0 |
| 5 | 2.5 | 3.0 | 2.0 | |
| 10 | 3.5 | 4.0 | 2.5 |
Part A: answer on your own. Your teacher reviews answers after everyone finishes.
Part B: constructed responses, each scored 0–3.
18. Draw and explain a model of a glacier-carved granite valley that shows one internal process and three surface processes, each with its time scale, from a single storm to tens of millions of years. (0–3)
19. Using the post-fire data from this unit (plant cover, infiltration, sediment yield), describe one feedback between two Earth systems, say whether it is positive or negative, and support each link with data. (0–3)
20. Complete the mean column of Mei's table, describe what the data show about the effect of freezing water on the blocks, and explain which property of water causes it. (0–3)
21. Revise Mei's plan to improve the accuracy and precision of her data. Give at least two changes and explain how each helps. (0–3)
Finished, geoscientists. That completes Earth Science I. Next: your 3DX field trip.
Exit ticket: which question was hardest, and which idea do you want to practice next?
How confident are you that you can I can explain how rocks, water and feedbacks shape Earth's surface, and judge the quality of my own data.
Materials: printed checkpoint with the scenario table, calculators, scoring guide for items 18–21.
Setup: about 40 minutes for Parts A and B, then a short review. Item tags: 1 ESS2-1:1a; 2 ESS2-1:2a; 18 ESS2-1:3a; 3 ESS2-2:1a; 4 ESS2-2:1b; 5 ESS2-2:2a; 6 ESS2-2:2b; 7 and 19 ESS2-2:3a; 8 ESS2-2:3b; 9 ESS2-2:3c; 10 ESS2-5:1a; 11 ESS2-5:2a; 12 ESS2-5:2b; 13 ESS2-5:3a; 14 ESS2-5:3b; 20 ESS2-5:4a; 15 and 16 ESS2-5:5a; 17 ESS2-5:5b; 21 ESS2-5:5c.
Answer notes: 20: means 2.0, 2.5 and 3.3 mm; widths grow with cycles because water expands about 9% as it freezes. 21: use a caliper, more blocks, the same fill level each cycle, and measure at marked points.
Listen for: “positive feedback is good”; precision confused with accuracy; one-way cause chains.
Support / stretch: read items aloud on request and give a formula card (Q = wdv, FS = μ cos θ / sin θ, density = m/V, percent change). Stretch: for item 15, compute the percent increase in width per cycle.