
explain how water’s unusual properties, expansion on freezing, its power as a solvent and its high heat capacity, break down rock, and measure how surface area and acidity change the rate of chemical weathering.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. A full glass bottle of water left in a freezer overnight cracks. Write a claim about what happened to the water and one way the same thing could happen to rock.
Because ice has a density of 0.917 g/cm³, water expands by about % when it freezes, so 50 cm³ of water in a crack becomes about cm³ of ice.
An unusual molecule. Water is so common that its strangeness is easy to miss. A water molecule is bent, with a slightly negative oxygen end and slightly positive hydrogen ends: it is polar. Neighboring molecules attract each other through hydrogen bonds. Those two facts explain nearly every property that makes water the planet’s main agent of weathering. (Reading: Earle, Physical Geology, chapters 5 and 16.)
1. Water expands when it freezes. Most substances shrink as they solidify. Water does the opposite: hydrogen bonds lock the molecules into an open crystal. Ice has a density of 0.917 g/cm3, so a given mass of water takes up 1 / 0.917 ≈ 1.09 times as much space as ice, about 9% more. Worked example 1. A crack in granite holds 50 cm3 of water. When it freezes, it needs about 50 × 1.09 ≈ 54.5 cm3. Confined in rock, that expansion pushes the crack wider. Repeat it on hundreds of freezing nights and the rock splits. This is frost wedging, and it is why high mountain slopes are littered with angular blocks and why the talus slopes below granite cliffs keep growing.
2. Water dissolves minerals. Because it is polar, water pulls ions out of crystals. Rainwater dissolves carbon dioxide from the air and soil, forming weak carbonic acid (H2O + CO2 → H2CO3). This acid dissolves calcite: CaCO3 + H2CO3 → Ca2+ + 2HCO3−. That is how caves form in limestone and how marble gravestones lose their lettering. Feldspar, the most common mineral in granite, reacts slowly with the same acid to form clay, loosening the quartz grains so the granite crumbles into coarse sand called grus. Chemical weathering is faster where it is warm and wet and where rock has more surface exposed.
Worked example 2: surface area. Breaking rock exposes more surface to attack. A 1 cm cube has 6 cm2 of surface. Cut it into 1 mm cubes and you have 1,000 cubes with 6 mm2 each: 6,000 mm2 = 60 cm2, ten times as much. Physical weathering (frost wedging, root growth, rock falls) and chemical weathering speed each other up.
3. Water stores heat. Water’s specific heat is about 4,184 J per kilogram per degree Celsius, roughly five times that of granite (about 790). Water warms and cools slowly, which moderates temperatures near coasts and in wet soil, and drives the sea breezes and land breezes that move air along a coast. Where rock is dry and bare, as in a desert, daily heating and cooling are larger.
4. Water flows and carries. Liquid water moves under gravity, so it carries away weathered material and exposes fresh rock (4.03). Frozen, it becomes a glacier. Glaciers pluck and grind rock, and during ice ages they turned V-shaped river canyons into U-shaped valleys like the granite valley of our phenomenon.
Lab: Chalk and Vinegar: What Speeds Chemical Weathering? Question: how do surface area and acidity affect the rate at which calcite rock dissolves? Materials: white chalk labeled calcium carbonate (many classroom chalks are calcium sulfate and will not fizz), white vinegar, tap water, four clear cups, a balance (0.01 or 0.1 g), a spoon and plastic bag for crushing, paper towels, a stopwatch, goggles.
| Cup | Chalk form | Liquid | Start mass (g) | Final dry mass (g) | Mass lost (%) | Observations |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | Whole | Water | ||||
| B | Whole | Vinegar | ||||
| C | Crushed | Vinegar | ||||
| D | Crushed | Water |
Illustrative run (Option B, sample data). Start and final masses: A 5.02 g → 4.98 g; B 5.05 g → 3.91 g; C 5.01 g → 2.12 g; D 4.99 g → 4.90 g. Cup C fizzed hardest and turned cloudy within a minute.
Accuracy and precision. Accuracy is how close a measurement is to the true value; precision is how close repeated measurements are to each other. A balance that reads 0.01 g is precise, but if wet chalk is weighed, every result is inaccurate in the same direction. Crushed chalk lost while pouring makes cup D look like it dissolved when it did not.
Use your cup data or the illustrative run.
Analyze the weathering data.
Claim: which factor, acidity or surface area, had the larger effect on the weathering rate? Compare cups A with B and B with C as evidence, and explain using the reaction of acid with calcite. Then judge your data: how accurate and how precise were your masses, and can the results be used to infer how rainwater weathers limestone over hundreds of years? Explain why or why not.
Water freezes, dissolves, stores heat and flows, and each property breaks rock in its own way. Next class we pull the unit together into one model.
How confident are you that you can I can explain how water's properties break down rock and what controls the rate of chemical weathering.
Exit ticket: name one property of water and one effect it has on rock, and explain the link in one sentence.
Timing: Poly ran this workshop over two 50-minute periods. Day 1: properties of water and setting up the cups; day 2: weighing the dried chalk, analysis and the outcrop model.
Materials (per group): calcium carbonate chalk (check the label), white vinegar, four clear cups, balance, plastic bag, spoon, paper towels, stopwatch, goggles.
Data note: the illustrative run is sample data. Expected percent losses: A 0.8%, B 22.6%, C 57.7%, D 1.8%.
Listen for: “ice is denser than water”; “rain is not acidic”; confusing accuracy with precision.
Support / stretch: give a percent-change template. Stretch: estimate how much energy 1 kg of water releases as it cools from 10 °C to 0 °C and compare with granite.