
revise one class model that links the Big Bang, the Sun’s fusion, orbits and element-making stars, write a CER from it, and brainstorm exhibit ideas grounded in that science.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Without notes, put these on a line from earliest to latest: the Sun forms; a neutron-star merger makes gold; the Big Bang; Earth forms; gold is mined from a stream. Then mark the one you are least sure about.
Which event had to happen BEFORE the Sun formed for a gold ring to exist on Earth?
Explore first: the gallery of first models. Each team posts the flow model from 1.05. Walk the room with sticky notes. On each poster, add one arrow you think is missing and one question. Then return and sort the notes into the revision table.
| Part of the model | What our first model showed | Evidence we now have | What we will change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Big Bang (H, He, Li) | |||
| Sun’s core and energy path | |||
| Massive star and supernova | |||
| Neutron-star merger (gold) | |||
| Solar system forms; orbits |
Why a revised model is stronger. A model is a tool for explaining and predicting, and scientists revise it when new evidence arrives. Our revised model has to do three jobs: show where matter comes from, show where energy comes from, and show how gravity organizes the solar system that captured the gold.
Worked example 1: the energy argument, in numbers. Jamal’s team added a box comparing energy sources. The Sun has emitted about 3.8 × 1026 W for 4.6 billion years (1.45 × 1017 s), a total of about 5.5 × 1043 J. If the whole Sun (2 × 1030 kg) were coal at 3 × 107 J/kg, it could supply only 6 × 1037 J, about one millionth of what was needed. Fusion of a tenth of its hydrogen supplies plenty. Their claim: only nuclear fusion fits the Sun’s age.
Worked example 2: gravity in the model. Priya’s team added the orbits. Gravity pulled the enriched gas cloud into a spinning disk, and the planets formed in it. Because the Sun’s pull falls as 1/r2, Mercury at 0.387 AU feels an acceleration about 1/0.3872 ≈ 6.7 times Earth’s, and it orbits fastest. By the second law, a body speeds up as it falls closer to the Sun along its ellipse.
Two formats, one explanation. A museum visitor reads text, looks at diagrams and touches objects. Scientists also communicate the same idea in more than one format: a diagram, a paragraph, a table of numbers. Today each team writes its explanation as a diagram and as a CER paragraph, and cites a source for each claim.
Ideate. Finally, teams brainstorm. Good brainstorming has rules: go for quantity, build on others’ ideas, defer judgment, and stay grounded in the science. Every exhibit idea must teach at least one link in the revised model.
Use your revised model. Discuss each card as a team before answering.
Finish the revised model in two formats.
Redraw your team's revised model as a labeled diagram with at least six arrows, then write a 150-word paragraph explaining the same story. Cite at least two sources (for example OpenStax Astronomy 2e or a space-agency fact sheet).
We have the science and a pile of ideas. Next phase, we design competing exhibit concepts and pick one with evidence.
Exit ticket: which link in the model do visitors most need help with, and which of your starred ideas teaches it?
How confident are you that you can I can communicate how stars produce elements in two formats, with sources.
Materials: team posters from 1.05, sticky notes in two colors, chart paper for the brainstorm, calculators.
Setup: 10 minutes gallery walk, 15 minutes revision and numbers, 15 minutes CER, 10 minutes brainstorm. Keep the brainstorm lists; 1.07 starts from them.
Listen for: models with matter arrows but no energy arrows; orbits drawn as perfect circles with the Sun at the center of every one; uncited facts.
Support / stretch: give a model skeleton with five empty boxes. Stretch: add the Sun’s future (red giant, white dwarf) and the matter it will return to space.