
break the burned-slope problem into parts, define measurable criteria and constraints, choose a protection design with a weighted decision matrix, and plan a storm test that will measure how well it works.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. The district’s problem is big: a whole burned hillside, a creek and a road. Break it into three smaller problems that could each be solved and tested on its own.
Which criterion is measurable enough to test in a model storm?
Breaking the problem down. Following HS-ETS1-2, the class splits the district’s problem into three sub-problems that match the weak links from 4.06: (1) keep rain from striking and loosening bare soil; (2) slow runoff on the slope so it soaks in instead of gathering speed; (3) catch the sediment that still moves before it reaches the creek and the road.
Class criteria and constraints. Criteria: (1) in the storm test, sediment reaching the model creek falls by at least 60% compared with a bare control; (2) runoff volume falls by at least 30%; (3) the measure causes no major unintended effect; (4) crews can install it on the real slope before the rainy season. Constraints: a budget of 50 sample “district points” per tray; only materials that are safe for the creek; nothing that blocks the road ditch.
Three concepts. Teams sketch all three before choosing.
Worked example 1: a weighted decision matrix (sample scores). Score each concept 1–5 on each criterion, multiply by the weight, and add.
| Criterion (weight) | A Mulch | B Contour barriers | C Sediment basin |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cuts sediment to the creek (3) | 4 | 3 | 4 |
| Cuts runoff (2) | 4 | 3 | 1 |
| Fits budget (2) | 4 | 3 | 2 |
| Installed before the rains (2) | 5 | 3 | 2 |
| Few unintended effects (1) | 4 | 4 | 2 |
| Weighted total |
Totals: A = 12 + 8 + 8 + 10 + 4 = 42; B = 9 + 6 + 6 + 6 + 4 = 31; C = 12 + 2 + 4 + 4 + 2 = 24. A wins clearly. C scores low on unintended effects because a basin must be dug out after every storm and, once full, passes clear water that can scour the channel below (4.06). A smart team might still add a few contour barriers on the steepest part of the slope.
Worked example 2: planning the storm test. Ava’s team writes its plan before building.
| Plan item | Ava’s team | Your team |
|---|---|---|
| Question | Does a mulch blanket reduce the sediment and runoff leaving a 25° slope in a model storm? | |
| Independent variable | Treatment: bare control or mulch | |
| Dependent variables | Dry mass of sediment collected (g); runoff volume (mL) | |
| Controlled variables | Same soil and packing, 25° angle, 1.0 L of ‘rain’ in 60 s from 30 cm, same collection time | |
| Trials | 3 per treatment | |
| How water’s properties show up | Raindrop impact (kinetic energy), infiltration, runoff carrying grains | |
| Individual or group | Group of four: one pours, one times, one collects, one records | |
| Accuracy check | Measure the rain can’s output in a graduated cylinder before each run; dry sediment before weighing |
The storm tray. Version 1 goes on a shallow plastic box (about 40 cm × 25 cm) packed with 3 cm of garden soil, propped at 25°, with a notch at the low end draining into a cup: the ‘creek’. A watering can or a bottle with pin holes in the cap is the storm.
Complete your team’s decision matrix and test plan, then check these cards.
Plan and build version 1.
Fill in the ‘your team’ column of the test plan: question, variables, at least four controlled variables, trials, how water's properties will show up in your measurements, whether you work individually or as a group, and how you will check accuracy. Then build version 1 on your storm tray, list its materials and their cost in district points, and predict the percent reduction in sediment.
Version 1 and the test plan are ready. Next class the storm comes.
Exit ticket: which part of your test plan is most likely to give imprecise results, and how could you improve it before the test?
Materials (per team): a shallow plastic box, garden soil, blocks or books to set 25°, a protractor, a watering can or pierced bottle, a graduated cylinder, collection cups, straw or shredded paper, paper-towel rolls or coir for barriers, a kitchen balance, goggles, and a “district points” price list (sample: 10 g of mulch 5, one barrier roll 8, a basin cup 10, rocks 2).
Setup: the class fixes the criteria and constraints at the start; 4.08 and 4.09 test against these exact values. Set up a shared ‘rain rack’ if possible so every team pours from the same height. This lesson follows HS-ETS1-1, HS-ETS1-2 and HS-ETS1-3.
Listen for: no control tray; changing angle and treatment at once; ignoring unintended effects.
Support / stretch: give a half-filled plan. Stretch: add a second independent variable (slope angle) and explain how many trays the test would then need.