
show what I learned about Earth’s formation and age, radiometric dating, craters and the coevolution of life and Earth’s systems, using data questions, a scenario set and short constructed responses.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Back to the phenomenon: a stone that fell from the sky a few years ago is older than any rock on Earth’s surface. Explain how in three sentences.
A meteorite's age is the date it landed on Earth.
Geologists, this is the unit checkpoint. Part A is multiple choice with data and a scenario set. Part B is short constructed responses scored 0 to 3. Calculators and a powers-of-2 table are allowed.
How a 0–3 answer is scored. 3 points: a correct claim, accurate evidence or calculation, and reasoning that links them with science ideas. 2 points: claim and evidence correct, reasoning missing or partly wrong. 1 point: a correct claim with little support, or a partly correct answer. 0 points: incorrect or blank.
Worked example: from 1 point to 3. Question: “Why does Earth have fewer craters than the Moon?” “Because Earth is different” earns 1 point. Ava wrote: “Both were bombarded early on, but Earth’s plate tectonics, volcanism and erosion keep remaking its surface, so old craters are erased. The Moon’s highlands are 4.4–4.5 billion years old and still covered in craters.” Claim, evidence, reasoning: 3 points.
Age data for questions 1–3 (rounded published values).
| Sample | Age (billion years) | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Oldest meteorite grains | 4.567 | never melted or recycled |
| Lunar highland rocks | 4.4–4.5 | chemistry like Earth’s mantle |
| Oldest zircons on Earth | about 4.4 | grains in a younger sandstone |
| Oldest intact Earth rocks | about 4.0 | metamorphic gneiss |
Scenario set (sample data) for questions 6–9. A rock column, bottom to top: Layer 1 basalt with stromatolites; Layer 2 banded iron formation; an ash layer dated with potassium-argon (3 argon-40 atoms per potassium-40 atom, after correction); Layer 3 red sandstone with no river-rounded pyrite.
Part A: answer on your own.
Part B: constructed responses, each scored 0–3.
12. Use radiometric ages of meteorites, lunar rocks and Earth's oldest rocks, and crater patterns on the Moon and Earth, to explain when the solar system and Earth's crust formed and why most Earth rocks are younger. (0–3)
13. Make a claim that Earth's systems and life evolved together. Support it with at least two examples and the rock evidence for each. (0–3)
14. Ancient oxygen estimates have wide uncertainty. Explain how that uncertainty limits the evidence, and whether the data show cause and effect or only correlation between the rise of oxygen and the spread of large animals. (0–3)
15. Describe one feedback between the biosphere and another Earth system, naming each step in the loop and its evidence. (0–3)
Finished, geologists. Next: your 3DX field trip, and then Unit 3, where we find out what keeps remaking Earth’s surface.
Exit ticket: which question was hardest, and what will you review?
How confident are you that you can I can explain Earth's age, its early history and how life and Earth changed together, with evidence.
Materials: printed checkpoint with the age table and rock column, calculators, powers-of-2 table, scoring guide for items 12–15.
Setup: about 40 minutes for Parts A and B, then review. Item tags: 1 ESS1-6:1a; 2, 3 and 5 ESS1-6:2a; 4 ESS1-6:2a and 3a; 6 ESS1-6:3a; 12 ESS1-6:1a, 2a, 3a; 7, 8 and 10 ESS2-7:2a; 13 ESS2-7:1a; 9 and 14 ESS2-7:3a; 11 and 15 ESS2-7:4a.
Listen for: rock age equals Earth’s age; “uncertain means wrong”; correlations stated as causes.
Support / stretch: read items aloud on request. Stretch: redo item 5 assuming the zircon gained lead, and explain how concordant clocks would reveal it.