
construct and defend an evidence-based account of Earth’s formation and early history, including a radiometric age calculation and a to-scale timeline, and present our tested trail plan to the parks department.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Reread the Wonder Board from 2.02. Check every question you can now answer with evidence, and star one that is still hard.
A mineral has 1 daughter atom for every 3 parent atoms. How many half-lives have passed?
The question. How did Earth form, what was it like in its first billion years, and how do we know its age? Your account uses evidence from the whole unit, and it must be an argument: every claim needs evidence and reasoning. It also becomes the text behind your trail’s stations.
What to include.
A worked calculation you can model yours on. A zircon grain contains 0.979 atoms of lead-206 for each atom of uranium-238. Assume it began with no lead. The number of half-lives is log2(1 + 0.979) = log2(1.979) ≈ 0.985. With a half-life of 4.468 billion years, the age is 0.985 × 4.468 ≈ 4.40 billion years, like the oldest known zircons. State the assumption (a closed system with no starting lead) and why zircon makes it reasonable: it rejects lead when it crystallizes.
Using sources well. Earle’s Physical Geology (chapter 8, Measuring Geological Time) and OpenStax Astronomy 2e (chapters 13–14) are your reference texts. When you cite a number, say where it came from. When sources disagree on a detail, such as the timing of the first life, give the range and explain why the evidence is harder to read for older events: older rocks have usually been heated, deformed and partly erased.
Defending your account. You will get one question about the limits of your evidence. Good answers name the assumption, explain why scientists accept it, and say what would change their minds. For example: “If the zircon had gained lead from outside, the age would be too old. Geologists check this by comparing two uranium-lead clocks (uranium-238 and uranium-235) in the same grain; if they agree, the grain was closed.”
Trail Plan Night. Teams set up their version 2 hallway models and present to role-players from the parks department, then each student gives a three-minute defense of the account.
Planning and drafting checks.
Finish and defend.
Submit your final account (1,000–1,300 words) with the timeline, calculation, sources and limits paragraph. Give your three-minute defense and record the question you were asked and your answer.
The county parks department asked for a to-scale Deep Time Trail on a 460 m loop. Deliver two products. (1) Your team’s tested trail plan (version 2), which must meet the class criteria: every station within 1 m of its true position at 1 m = 10 million years; at least 8 stations, with 3 on how we know Earth’s age and 2 on Earth and life changing together; at least 8 of 10 test visitors can say how old Earth is and how we know; every fact accurate and cited; within 60 sample sign points; accessible and weatherproof. (2) Your own written account, How Do We Know Earth’s Age? (1,000–1,300 words), with at least three independent lines of evidence, one radiometric calculation with its assumption stated, an explanation of why Earth’s oldest rocks are younger than Earth, a to-scale timeline of at least eight events including two coevolution examples, and a limits paragraph.
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Evidence for Earth’s age (HS-ESS1-6) | Uses at least three independent lines of evidence with specific numbers and sources, explains why meteorites date Earth’s formation, and explains the rock-age gap and missing craters with surface processes. |
| Radiometric reasoning | Calculation correct from D/P and half-life, with assumptions stated and justified (closed system, concordant clocks). |
| Coevolution (HS-ESS2-7) | Two examples explained as two-way cause and effect between life and Earth’s systems, with rock evidence, a feedback, and an honest call on causation versus correlation. |
| Scale and trail design (HS-ETS1-3) | Timeline and trail positions are accurate to scale; visitor data show which criteria were met; trade-offs are named. |
| Argument and sources | Claims supported by evidence and reasoning; a counter-claim is answered; limits are honest; sources cited accurately. |
The trail plan is in the parks department’s hands, geologists. Next class: the unit checkpoint. After that, your 3DX field trip.
Exit ticket: what is the strongest single piece of evidence for Earth's age, and why?
How confident are you that you can I can construct and defend an evidence-based account of Earth's formation and early history.
Timing: Poly ran this task over three sessions. Here it is one showcase period; assign Stages 1–3 across the build phase and use this period for the trail models and defenses.
Materials: version 2 hallway models, rubric copies for visitors, timer, recording device.
Setup: invite staff or family members to role-play the parks department. Keep the client generic: no real park is named.
Listen for: rock age treated as Earth’s age; over-precise dates; coevolution described one way only.
Support / stretch: give a five-section outline with sentence starters and allow 700–900 words with the same evidence. Stretch: add the uranium-235 clock to your calculation and show the two ages agree.