
deliver a complete exhibit package for the museum: five panels with balanced nuclear equations and correct half-life math, an evidence-based argument for the age of Earth, a tested half-life interactive, and a defense of our choices to a review panel.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. List the three strongest pieces of evidence you have collected this unit (a candy-lab graph, a dating-puzzle age, the evidence table, a version 2 test result). Next to each, write the panel it belongs on and the claim it supports.
Which set of evidence best supports an age of about 4.5–4.6 billion years for Earth and the solar system?
The context. The museum’s review panel (the exhibits director, a geologist, an educator and a visitor-services lead) will decide which team’s package goes into the gallery. Your package must be accurate enough for the geologist, clear enough for a 12-year-old and sturdy enough for thousands of visitors.
Panel 1: Carbon-14 (HS-PS1-8). How carbon-14 forms in the atmosphere, enters living things and decays after death; the beta-minus equation 146C → 147N + 0−1e with both sums checked; one worked age; and the 50,000-year limit.
Panel 2: Uranium–lead in zircon and Panel 3: Potassium–argon. For uranium–lead: why zircon traps uranium but not lead, the first alpha step of the chain with sums checked, the 8-alpha, 6-beta path to lead-206, and the 4.4-billion-year grain’s ratio worked into an age. Note that each alpha step is a lopsided kind of fission and each beta step is not. For potassium–argon: why the clock starts when lava cools and how ash layers bracket the age of fossils.
Panel 4: Earth’s Age (HS-ESS1-6). A claim, evidence and reasoning argument: meteorites (4.567 and 4.56 billion years), Earth’s age from lead (4.54 billion years), lunar highlands (about 4.4–4.5), zircons (4.4) and Earth’s oldest rocks (about 4.0); a comparison of compositions (primitive meteorites, a differentiated Earth, an iron-poor Moon); and crater evidence: why the cratered Moon tells us Earth was also heavily bombarded, and why erosion, volcanism and plate tectonics left Earth with about 200 known craters.
Panel 5: The same physics helps people. Technetium-99m: its production from molybdenum-99 and its gamma emission, both equations balanced; why its half-life and gamma ray suit imaging; one dose comparison in millisieverts with a cited source; and a link to the smoke detector’s alpha source. Contrast one nuclear change with one chemical change in energy, and explain in two sentences how fission and fusion each release energy (E = mc2) and what each needs to start.
The interactive. Version 2 of your model with its test data against every criterion and the decision matrix that chose it.
Worked example: a strong panel sentence. “When this zircon crystallized, it trapped uranium but no lead; since then almost half of its uranium-238 has decayed to lead-206, and because uranium-238’s half-life is 4.47 billion years, that ratio means the crystal is about 4.4 billion years old.” Claim, evidence, mechanism and number in one sentence, in words a visitor can follow.
Quality bar. Every nuclear equation balances in mass number and charge. Every age shows its half-life math. Every published value has a source; every invented value is labeled sample. No panel says carbon-14 dates rocks or that a patient stays radioactive for long.
Stages. Plan, draft, peer review, revise, and defend in five minutes (live or recorded), demonstrating the interactive and answering one question from the review panel.
Plan and peer-review checks.
Write and revise the exhibit across the work sessions.
Write Panels 1–3 (150–200 words each) with their equations and worked ages.
Write Panels 4 and 5 and a one-page interactive summary with your decision matrix and version 2 data, with sources cited.
Task: For the museum’s review panel, deliver five panels: carbon-14; uranium–lead in zircon; potassium–argon; Earth’s age from meteorites, Moon rocks, zircons and crater patterns; and technetium-99m with the smoke detector’s americium-241. Each panel carries at least one balanced nuclear equation and a worked number. Include your version 2 half-life interactive with its test data and decision matrix, and a comparison of nuclear and chemical energy with fission and fusion explained. Cite at least three sources.
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Nuclear model (HS-PS1-8) | Balanced equations for alpha, beta and gamma processes; correct changes in protons and neutrons; fission, fusion and their energy explained with E = mc2 and compared with chemical energy. |
| Half-life and dating math | Correct fractions, numbers of half-lives and ages, with the right clock for each material and its assumptions stated. |
| Earth’s early history (HS-ESS1-6) | Uses ages of meteorites, Moon rocks and Earth’s oldest minerals and rocks, compares compositions, and explains crater scarcity with erosion, volcanism and plate tectonics. |
| Interactive design (HS-ETS1-3) | Version 2 meets the criteria with test data; the decision matrix and trade-offs are explained. |
| Sources and communication | Clear panels for a 12-year-old, published values cited, sample values labeled; a defense that answers a question with evidence. |
Your exhibit turns a unit of evidence into something the public can use. Next: the unit checkpoint.
Exit ticket: what question did the review panel ask your team, and how did you answer it with evidence?
Timing: the exhibit runs across about three sessions: this lesson launches it and covers planning and peer review; drafting, final assembly and the defenses need further work time.
Materials: peer-review checklist, teams’ candy-lab graphs, dating-puzzle cards and version 2 interactives, the evidence table from 4.06, rubric copies for visiting “review panel” members (staff or community volunteers).
Listen for: “carbon dating shows Earth’s age”; “Earth has few craters because it was hit less”; nuclear equations balanced in mass but not charge; scan doses given with no source.
Support / stretch: provide a panel frame (question, answer, evidence, equation, try it). Stretch: add a sixth panel explaining how scientists know decay rates did not change in the past (supernova light curves, the natural fission reactor evidence, agreement among clocks with different decay modes).