
use parent-to-daughter ratios and half-lives to date ancient materials, choose the right radiometric clock for a sample, and explain the assumptions behind carbon-14, uranium-lead and potassium-argon dating.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. From your candy lab: when the daughter pile was three times the parent pile, how many shakes had passed? Write how you could tell the time just by counting the two piles, even if no one had watched the clock.
Carbon-14 has a half-life of 5,730 years. Why can't it date a 66-million-year-old dinosaur bone?
The idea. Your candy lab showed that the ratio of daughter to parent grows in a predictable way: 1 after one half-life, 3 after two, 7 after three. Measure that ratio in a sample, and you can count backward to the moment the clock started. In general, the fraction of parent left is P ÷ (P + D), and the number of half-lives is n = log((P + D) ÷ P) ÷ log 2. Laboratories count the atoms with a mass spectrometer, which sorts ions by mass and can tell lead-206 from lead-207 one atom at a time.
Three clocks for the exhibit.
Worked example 1: the zircon. Priya’s data sheet (a ratio consistent with the published age) reports that the 4.4-billion-year zircon contains 0.979 atoms of lead-206 for every atom of uranium-238. Parent fraction = 1 ÷ (1 + 0.979) = 0.505, just over one half, so slightly less than one half-life has passed. n = log(1.979) ÷ log 2 = 0.985; age = 0.985 × 4.47 billion years = 4.40 billion years. Nearly half the uranium-238 in that grain has become lead since it crystallized.
Worked example 2: a hearth. Charcoal from an ancient campfire has 12.5% of the carbon-14 found in living wood. 12.5% = 1/8 = (1/2)3, so n = 3 and the age is 3 × 5,730 = 17,190 years, which we report as about 17,200 years. Notice carbon-14 dating compares with a living standard, not with a daughter count, because nitrogen-14 is everywhere in the air and cannot be measured as a daughter.
The assumptions behind every clock. (1) Closed system: no parent or daughter atoms entered or left since the clock started; a cracked zircon that lost lead would look too young. (2) Known start: we know how much daughter was present at the start (zero lead in zircon, zero argon in fresh lava). (3) Constant half-life: decay rates do not change with heat, pressure or chemistry, which experiments and observations of distant supernovae both support. Geochronologists test these by dating the same rock with two different clocks; when uranium-238 and uranium-235 give the same age, the sample is called concordant and trusted.
Choosing the right clock. A clock works best when the sample’s age is between about a tenth of a half-life and several half-lives. Too young, and too little daughter has formed to measure; too old, and too little parent is left. That is why carbon-14 dates a mammoth tusk but potassium–argon or uranium–lead dates the volcanic ash above and below a dinosaur.
Reading. OpenStax Chemistry 2e, section 21.3 (radiometric dating), CC BY 4.0. Ages are rounded published values.
Work in teams. For every sample, write the parent fraction, n and the age, and name the clock.
The dating puzzle. The museum sent six specimen cards. The ratios are rounded from published measurements of real kinds of samples. Use n = log(1 + D/P) ÷ log 2 for the rock clocks.
| Card | Specimen | Data | Clock and half-life | n | Age |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | Cave bear bone | 25% of living carbon-14 | |||
| B | Ash layer just above the last dinosaur fossils | corrected D/P (K-40) = 0.0373 | |||
| C | Zircon from one of Earth’s oldest rock bodies | Pb-206/U-238 = 0.86 | |||
| D | Stony meteorite | Pb-206/U-238 = 1.03 | |||
| E | Moon basalt | corrected D/P (K-40) = 7 | |||
| F | Cloth from an ancient burial | 50% of living carbon-14 |
Solve all six cards. Then put the specimens in order from oldest to youngest and write one sentence on what the order says about the meteorite compared with the oldest Earth rock.
Pick one card and name the assumption that would make its age wrong if it failed. Describe how a scientist could test that assumption.
We can read three clocks. Next phase, we look inside the nucleus to see why some nuclei decay at all, and why stars made the uranium in the first place.
Exit ticket: in two sentences a museum visitor would understand, explain why a zircon crystal works as a clock.
Materials: printed specimen cards (one set per team), calculators with a log key, the candy-lab graphs from 4.03, a timeline strip from 0 to 4.6 billion years.
Answers: A 2 half-lives, 11,460 years. B n = 0.0528, about 66 million years. C n = 0.895, about 4.0 billion years. D n = 1.022, about 4.57 billion years. E 3 half-lives, 3.75 billion years. F 1 half-life, 5,730 years. Order: D, C, E, B, A, F. The meteorite is older than any Earth rock.
Note: real potassium–argon ages correct for the fact that only about 11% of potassium-40 decays produce argon-40; the cards give the corrected ratio so students can use the simple formula. Carbon-14 ages are also calibrated in practice against tree rings; mention it if students ask.
Listen for: “carbon dating shows the Earth is old” (it cannot reach that far); “the rock’s atoms are 4 billion years old” (the clock dates crystallization or cooling, not when atoms were made).
Support / stretch: let students use a halving ladder for the whole-number cards and a worked log template for B, C and D. Stretch: use the uranium-235 clock (704 million years) to predict the Pb-207/U-235 ratio for card C’s 4.0-billion-year age (about 50) and explain why a second clock is a strong check.