audit our showcase for accuracy, omissions and respect, then make final fixes.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. A friend says, “I went to the store.” They leave out that they broke the door. Every word was true. Was the story honest?
What is an omission?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Junior historians, today you are your own toughest reviewers. Every exhibit chooses what to include. Honest exhibits check what their choices leave out.
Audit step 1: accuracy. Does each label have a source? Is sample information marked as sample? Are disputed stories described as disputed?
Audit step 2: omissions. Who did the work? Who profited? Who resisted? Which Native nation lived there? Whose voice is missing?
Audit step 3: respect. Are all people described as people? Are there any cargo labels, tokens, prices or game pieces that represent people? If so, remove them now.
Worked example 1: Tessa’s stall. Tessa’s West Indies stall listed sugar, rum and molasses. It was accurate but incomplete. She added, “Enslaved people were forced to produce these goods. See the Human Story Panel.”
Worked example 2: Luis’s map. Luis noticed that western Pennsylvania looked empty on his map. He added the Forks of the Ohio and a note: “Seneca leader Alliquippa and her people lived near here.” An empty space on a map can tell a false story.
| Showcase criterion | What it looks like | Our evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Accurate | Every label names a source. Sample data says sample. | |
| Complete | Regions, goods, routes, and why places traded. | |
| Honest about people | Slavery is told directly. Resistance and named Native nations are included. | |
| Respectful | People are never goods: no cargo labels, tokens, prices or game pieces. | |
| Clear | A neighbor can understand it without help. |
Audit a partner team’s section, then your own.
Complete the final audit.
Score your work on each criterion. Give one piece of evidence for each score.
Make your final fixes. Explain the most important one.
Tomorrow, the community sees your work.
Exit ticket: what is the most important thing your exhibit no longer leaves out?
Note: the source is a grade 6-8 lesson plan. The reading gives its ideas at grade 5 level.
Pacing: warm-up 4, reading 6, lecture 5, audit 15, fixes 10 minutes.
Check personally: walk every display before the showcase. Remove any item that represents people as goods or pieces.
Misconceptions: true means complete; more text means more honest.
Answer guide: students may note that many enslaved and Native people left few written records, and they can state that gap plainly.
National Park Service, Quest for Omitted History: Part 1 · U.S. government work, public domain
The National Park Service worked with teachers at Salem Maritime to create lessons about omitted history. An omission is something left out. The lesson asks whether leaving out people or facts can give readers a false impression, even when each sentence is true.
Students compare two kinds of sources. One is a primary source from Salem’s past. The other is part of an earlier park brochure called “Valuable Cargoes.” That brochure described merchants seeking profit and ships carrying fish, lumber, rum, molasses, tea, coffee, sugar and pepper.
Then students ask sharp questions. What impression does each text leave? What is in the primary source but missing from the secondary source? What happens when many people read only the shorter story? What can be done to fix it?
Those questions matter for any exhibit. A list of valuable goods can sound exciting. It becomes more honest when visitors also learn who was forced to produce them.
Source: National Park Service, Quest for Omitted History: Part 1 (nps.gov)