write a claim, evidence and reasoning response that weighs population estimates from different sources.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Find the question on our Wonder Board: “Was Cahokia really bigger than London?” You may see this claim in books and on websites. Before looking at numbers, what would we need to know to test it?
What do you think the evidence will show?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Claim, evidence, reasoning. A claim answers the question. Evidence is the facts from sources. Reasoning explains why the evidence supports the claim.
| Source | What it says |
|---|---|
| National Park Service, World Heritage article | Cahokia itself: 10,000 to 20,000, equal to many European cities then. Greater Cahokia: perhaps 40,000 to 50,000. |
| National Park Service, Midwest Region article | Cahokia at its height (1050–1200): 10,000 to 20,000, roughly the number in London toward the end of that period. |
| Illinois State Archaeological Survey | Central city: about 20,000. Region: more than 50,000. |
| Research Framework for London Archaeology | City of London: about 25,000 in 1100, rising to perhaps 60,000 to 80,000 by 1300. |
Compare like with like. A fair test compares a city with a city and the same years with the same years. Comparing all of Greater Cahokia with only the City of London would be unfair. The London source says no similar estimate exists for London’s wider region at that time.
Worked example 1: a weak answer. Bella writes, “Cahokia was bigger because 50,000 is more than 25,000.” She compared a whole region with one city. Her numbers are real, but her comparison is not fair.
Worked example 2: a stronger answer. Andre writes, “Claim: Cahokia was a major city, similar in scale to many European cities, but the evidence does not show it was larger than London. Evidence: experts estimate 10,000 to 20,000 people in Cahokia and about 25,000 in London in 1100. Reasoning: these are the same kind of place, and London’s estimate is as high or higher.”
The story is still amazing. Cahokia does not need to beat London to matter. A city of many thousands, built by Native people, is remarkable on its own. All these numbers are estimates, so we say “about.”
Use the table and the reading. Check every number before you answer.
Write your own response.
Write a claim, evidence and reasoning paragraph answering: Should our exhibit say that Cahokia was larger than London? Use at least two sources, and write the sentence you think our exhibit should say instead.
We tested a popular claim and let the evidence decide. Next we compare two pictures of the same Native towns and ask who was doing the showing.
Exit ticket: how did checking sources change what you think, or make you more sure?
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 8, mini lesson 10, practice 7, writing 10.
Sources checked: nps.gov Cahokia World Heritage article; nps.gov Midwest Region article; isas.illinois.edu Cahokia page; Research Framework for London Archaeology, Medieval (researchframeworks.org/rfla/?p=84), citing Keene 2000.
Accuracy: the defensible statement is that Cahokia was comparable to many European cities of its day. “Roughly the size of London” has NPS support, but London specialists give a higher figure. “Larger than London” is not supported. London estimates also vary among historians. Mound counts: the survey’s 200 appears to cover all three precincts of the greater city, while the 120 in other lessons is the National Park Service count for the Cahokia site (see 1.24).
Supports: highlight the like-for-like rows; provide a CER frame. Stretch: explain how the answer changes if we compare Greater Cahokia, and what missing data would be needed.
Answer guide: accept well-reasoned wording such as “about as large as many European cities of its time.” Responses should use numbers accurately, name sources and address fair comparison.
Illinois State Archaeological Survey, University of Illinois, Cahokia · Copyright University of Illinois Board of Trustees; summarized in our own words with a link
Nearly 1,000 years ago, Cahokia grew along the Mississippi River near present-day St. Louis. The Illinois State Archaeological Survey calls it America’s first city. It had about 200 earthen pyramids across three connected districts called precincts, and hundreds of rural settlements on the floodplain and nearby uplands.
At its peak, the survey estimates about 20,000 people in a central area of 6 square miles. Counting the wider region, it estimates more than 50,000.
Researchers keep asking how so many people came together. They study buried soils and find no sign that Cahokians badly harmed nearby waterways or farmland. They connect the city’s growth with a warmer, wetter climate and with corn farming. Droughts may be linked to its decline.
New tools help too. One method senses what lies under the ground, so scientists can study a mound’s structure without digging into it.
Source: Illinois State Archaeological Survey, University of Illinois, Cahokia (isas.illinois.edu)