explain the advantages and disadvantages of money compared with barter, using evidence from colonial times and a classroom trial.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. You have an extra pencil and want a snack. Your classmate has a snack but already has plenty of pencils. What is the problem?
Colonies often had too few coins. What do you predict people used instead?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Barter. Barter means trading goods or services directly, with no money. It can work well between neighbors. But both people must want what the other has, at the same time.
Money. Money is anything people widely accept in exchange. It lets you sell to one person and buy from another. It also gives everyone a shared way to compare prices, and it can be saved.
A colonial scarcity. Coins were scarce in the colonies. Colonists had to pay for British goods with gold and silver, and Britain did not let them mint their own coins. So people found other ways to pay.
Pennsylvania’s paper money. Pennsylvania first issued paper money in 1723, the same year a 17-year-old named Benjamin Franklin arrived in Philadelphia. Franklin later printed money and designed notes that were hard to copy. He argued that too little money slowed trade, and too much made it lose value.
Worked example 1: a barter problem. Ruby has flour and wants nails. The blacksmith has nails but wants cloth. Ruby must first find someone who will trade cloth for flour. Barter took her two trades and extra time.
Worked example 2: money’s weakness. Samir learns that a colony prints many more notes while goods stay the same. He reasons, “Each note may buy less, so people may trust it less.” Money works only when people trust its value.
Trading trial (sample data). Round 1: use paper cards for flour, nails, cloth and fish, and barter for the card on your list. Round 2: use paper tokens as money. Count completed trades in each round.
Write in your Investigator’s Log.
Claim: was money better than barter for colonial trade? Give one piece of evidence and one disadvantage of the side you chose.
How confident are you that you can I can use evidence to support an economic claim.
Money made distant trade easier. Next we will sort the goods themselves and see what each place brought in and sent out.
Exit ticket: name one advantage of money and one advantage of barter.
Materials: goods cards, paper tokens, tally chart. Pacing: warm-up 4, reading 7, mini lecture 7, trial and practice 16, log and exit 6. Results are classroom sample data. This goods-only trial stays in this lesson and is not part of the showcase, where lessons 2.15 and 2.17 rule out play money and market games.
Sources: coin limits and Franklin come from Federal Reserve Education, “Benjamin Franklin and the Birth of the Paper Money Economy.”
Care: do not make wampum tokens or treat wampum as play money. For many Native nations it carries diplomatic and ceremonial meaning beyond trade. Do not make cards for people or for tobacco fields worked by enslaved people.
Answer guide: money usually allows faster trades and easier price comparison, though it can lose value. Barter needs no currency and can suit neighbors, but requires matching wants.
EH.Net Encyclopedia (Economic History Association), “Money in the American Colonies” by Ron Michener · Copyright Economic History Association; summarized in our own words, nothing copied
Colonial buyers and sellers often did not hand over coins at all. Many purchases were written in an account book as a debt. Later, the debt might be paid with goods or work. One historian called this “bookkeeping barter.” Even rich Boston merchants often did business this way.
Different places used different goods as money. Tobacco served in the Chesapeake, rice in South Carolina and sugar in the British Caribbean. Beaver skins were used too, along with wampum, which is strings of shell beads made by Native people. Farm goods such as corn, beef and pork were called “country pay.”
Goods had problems. In Massachusetts in the late 1600s, three pounds in country pay counted as only two pounds in cash.
Coins from many countries also moved around, especially the Spanish dollar. Its value differed from colony to colony. In 1690, Massachusetts became the first colony to print paper money, to pay soldiers. Pennsylvania began in 1723.
Source: EH.Net Encyclopedia (Economic History Association), “Money in the American Colonies” by Ron Michener (eh.net)